Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Roland Carson on November 16, 2011, 10:43:44 PM
-
Hello,
Does anyone have any comments or experience on this keyboard layout?
It is Milleret/Pignol but has one incorrect note on the 3rd row of the bass.
Any comments would be appreciated.
Thanks
Roland
-
I've had its C/G bass incarnation for 3 years and it is 'liberating' as it immediately abolishes the problem of having bass in wrong direction when playing in say Gm (something we did a lot of at the Playford weekend)! Frans v d Aa is presently commissioned to make me a D/G one. So take that as a positive recommendation
However those F#, C# unisonorics are what a C/G would have. Manifestly wrong here as it breaks the 'every bass in both directions' parameter - B is absent on the chart - it contains C# twice. Someone hasn't changed the C# to B when laying out for C/F. The others appear OK
On a quick look the right end looks 'right structure' with rows in C, Dmharmonic plus accidentals. Emphasise that I've not checked all the notes - not my personal territory.
-
Thanks for those comments Chris.
Roland
-
Can someone please tell me what 'octave tuned' means ?
Incidentally Chris, the layout is from a Castagnari Mas.
Thank you
-
Two sets of reeds an octave apart.
-
Two sets of reeds an octave apart.
AKA Bandoneon tuning
-
Thanks ;)
Roland
-
Ahha - I played a Mas at Ch.d'Ars festival this summer. Sandro was very proud of it. It was excellent and not over expensive for what you got.
-
Do you know what the price new is Chris?
Roland
-
Do you know what the price new is Chris?
The price of a Mas, direct from Castagnari and before VAT, is 2,680 euros. (This info from a very recent Castagnari price list.)
-Andy
-
Thank you Andy in Vermont ;o)
Roland
-
Hello, If someone could tell me how to add a photo of my Evo layout. I will gladly
submit it to you Roland.
Larry :-\
-
Hi Larry,
I have sent you a personal message.
Thanks
Roland
-
Hello,
Does anyone have a three row castagnari weighing about 4.6 kg and preferably living in the Cambridge area?
I am considering buying a new instrument and I would like to hold something similar to see how I feel about the extra weight.
At 4.6 Kg it is not as heavy as a Mory (5.4) but a bit heavier than the Hascys I am used to at 3.9 Kg.
Help would be appreciated and I wouldn't mind travelling a bit further if necessary.
Thanks
Roland
-
Hello Roland, The Castagnari Rik is probably easier to find in
your area. They are 4.6 kilo and measurements are the same.
there is a almost new Evo at this site 2850.euro's
All the best in your hunt (:)
Larry
-
for Roland,
http://www.diatonie.de/shop/sonderposten.html
OOpsss ;D Larry
-
The Evo appears to be a Rik with extra basses, or am I missing something?
-
Hi Theo, You could say it is a Rik with 18 neutral basses/no 3rds.
No arguement there But the diatonie site has a GC# for sale
secondhand on the the above mentioned link for Roland. The weight and the dimensions are the same as the Rik if
someone wants to know what 4.6 kilo feels and handles like should there no Evo's in his area.
all the best, larry
-
Thanks for that Larry.
Theo, I think you are correct.
The one I am looking at is a prototype and is between an Evo and a Mas. It is a year old. It is octave tuned and has two registers to control the voices which are switches on the grille. It has 18 bass which are neutral tuned (I think that means no thirds) The basses are arranged like the Evo (square) and not angled like the Mas.
I would just have liked to get hold of something of similar weight to see how I feel about that ;o)
So, if anyone is anywhere near me with a Rik that would do fine.
Thanks
Roland
-
Just a thought about weights - I suppose the important statistic for a box is not so much its overall weight as the weight of the LH end plus say half the weight of the bellows, because that's roughly the bits you have to throw around.
Or perhaps the work done is what's tiring (ie the force times distance moved in that direction)? I suppose if it's that, the number and type of voices is also relevant, and the quality/responsiveness of the reeds?
-
Now your getting all scientific with me Chris and you know how easy I am to confuse ;D.....
Seriously though, I find a Mory a bit heavy and I think that I can manage 4.6 Kg but I would like to make sure just to help me make the decision.
But thanks for your input anyway ;)
Roland
-
Sure, and I understand your concern, Roland - you've tried my Saltarelle boxes, haven't you? - the lighter one is 4.9kg, the heavier 5.4, if that helps, and you're very welcome to have another go, any time - just give me a call. The lighter one certainly has the edge on speedy playing, but I find that's mainly due to more responsive reeds. I imagine the Castagnari would have more responsiveness than either of them.
(Also, if it's any help, I actually didn't find that the extra weight was the issue I imagined it was going to be when I first bought them, possibly because the significant increase in fingering possibilities meant that I no longer had to play the difficult passages with lots of bellows reversals.)
-
HI again Roland,
the Evo [and probably the Mas] is like a pussy cat, never fear!
the left hand has no problem. It, they will only answer your every wish >:E
balanced and lively.
"JUST DO IT"....... ;D
a friend in need is a friend indeed!!
You play well, you will manage......
Larry
-
Thanks Chris and Larry ;) I value your input.
chris, I may well take you up on that before I finally decide but I guess I would get used to it and, after all it is only .7 Kg heavier than the Hascys !
Roland