Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Earbrass on November 18, 2011, 11:15:28 AM

Title: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Earbrass on November 18, 2011, 11:15:28 AM
In our morris side, there are usually two melodeons playing. Our leader plays a Lilly, and I have a Pokerwork. I think this combination works really well. For most tunes, the Lilly starts off alone with the introduction, and its clear clarion call is ideal for grabbing attention and cutting through any background noise. Then I come in with the Pokerwork, along with the drums, and its wet tuning fills out the sound nicely (when I hit the right notes!).

Any other thoughts on combinations of boxes that work well, or don't work well, together, in Morris or other contexts? 
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2011, 11:38:44 AM
My favourite combination is a box of any kind with a fiddle.   Loads of great examples,  Wood & Cutting, Spiers and Bowden, Phil Cunningham and Ally Bain for starters.  I recently heard this couple at the French dance weekend in Otley Naragonia (http://www.naragonia.com/)  who make a glorious sound playing two Castagnari Morys together.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 18, 2011, 06:00:27 PM
Since moving away from the UK I don't get a lot of opportunity to play for my old morris side any more, but when I do it's usually a combination of a Pokerwork, a Tommy and my Saltarelle, and that generally sounds pretty good to me.  There are also often one or more from another Pokerwork, another Saltarelle, a fiddle or two and (sorry about this!) a PA in attendance.  I don't know that it's so much a combination of boxes that sounds right or wrong as a combination of playing approaches.

Graham
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Tufty on November 18, 2011, 07:46:40 PM
Our morris band includes my Erica and a banjo. What combination could possibly match it for wistfulness and subtlety  >:E
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Anahata on November 18, 2011, 08:01:42 PM
The Pig Dyke Molly lineup typically includes my Oakwood, Mary's wooden ended EC and Tom Sennett's Loffet. The concertina is surprisingly loud for a wooden ended box, and the Oakwood's brightness complements the EC's slightly more mellow tone and that of the Loffet with it's LM tuning.

Add a drum and expertly played Sousaphone and - magic! (http://www.pigdyke.co.uk/mp3/currentcd/moral.mp3)


Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Ollie on November 18, 2011, 08:12:43 PM
My favourite combination is a box of any kind with a fiddle.   Loads of great examples,  Wood & Cutting, Spiers and Bowden, Phil Cunningham and Ally Bain for starters.  I recently heard this couple at the French dance weekend in Otley Naragonia (http://www.naragonia.com/)  who make a glorious sound playing two Castagnari Morys together.

Or indeed Boden...  ::)
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Lester on November 18, 2011, 08:32:27 PM
On good days my morris band comprises a treble, baritone and bass Wheatstone Aeola Englsh Concertinas. (I play inexpert baritone).

On a bad day three melodeons, a piano accordion, English concertina, bodhran, mouth organ.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: jonm on November 18, 2011, 09:37:54 PM
My favourite combination is a box of any kind with a fiddle.   Loads of great examples,  Wood & Cutting, Spiers and Bowden, Phil Cunningham and Ally Bain for starters.  I recently heard this couple at the French dance weekend in Otley Naragonia (http://www.naragonia.com/)  who make a glorious sound playing two Castagnari Morys together.

Or indeed Boden...  ::)

Ollie, you suffer with pedanticness!
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Anahata on November 18, 2011, 09:52:40 PM
Ollie, you suffer with pedanticness!

That should be....

oh, never mind.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 18, 2011, 09:56:46 PM
 ;D

Q still chuckling!
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 18, 2011, 10:45:16 PM
Pedanticity?
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 19, 2011, 12:03:39 AM
One combination I particularly like is an anglo (Lachenal) with a Hohner four-stop.  Plenty of grunt from the Hohner and the anglo fills in all the missing harmonies.

Rob.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Noodle on November 19, 2011, 04:32:16 AM
Well I can confirm that a piano accordion, a severely out of tune Hohner Erica and a Baffetti Binci competing for volume among other instruments does not make for a sound that soothes the ears.

I actually haven't found 2 boxes playing alongside each other to be all that pleasing. Unless played with a band or in a session, I find it to be an instrument best played on its own.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 19, 2011, 10:20:08 AM
Our morris has the combintion of my daughter's English concertina and an oboe..... very reedy and nice.
I suspect a single voiced melodeon plus oboe combination might be similar.
Q
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Anahata on November 19, 2011, 10:58:36 AM
Our morris has the combintion of my daughter's English concertina and an oboe..... very reedy and nice.
I suspect a single voiced melodeon plus oboe combination might be similar.

Did you ever hear those 1970s recordings of John Kirkpatrick and Sue Harris?
Oboe + concertina, melodeon or button accordion.

(Edit: typo)
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 19, 2011, 11:01:22 AM
I'd say one melodeon plus "other instruments of your choice" too. While Milleret/Pignol combine boxes very well, they seem to have a strict rule of one playing, one comping right hand chords.

Which is to treat their melodeons as very different instruments.  Here's a bit of both in a youtubeBreton plinn (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wI23hAq1bVI)
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 19, 2011, 11:28:21 AM
Anahata: Yes - of course! I'd forgotten......
that brings back memories of the Beach Store at Sidmouth, when I'd no idea why everyone was getting excited at the next guests!
( and red coloured toes in my sandals from the red sand always used on the floor..... )
Q
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on November 19, 2011, 12:14:42 PM
My favourite combination is a box of any kind with a fiddle. 

My favorite as well ... Lisa Ornstein with Normand Miron = heavenly sound.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: pbsalt on November 19, 2011, 03:23:47 PM
I play at lot with a friend at home.
Between us we play a range of boxes - he mainly plays English Concertina and I play a range of melodeons and anglo concertina. 

My Saltarelle (Nuage) goes well with his English Concertina but the Anglo and Pokerwork don't go so well. 
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on November 19, 2011, 05:30:19 PM
I can think of one or two morris sides that would benefit by actually thinking about this question.

I'm not sure cotswold morris and big bands are a good combination anyway.
Other traditions such as north west and border are different and thrive on a well-balanced 'wall of sound'.

Andy
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on November 19, 2011, 07:35:31 PM
3 gabbanellis  4 voice, 2 paolo sopranis four voice, and a beltrami 4 voice with stradella bass.  ;D

big and BOOMY!
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Nick Hudis on November 19, 2011, 07:39:53 PM
an unusual but extraordinary combination is box with double bass.  There is some great bass playing on Stephane Delicq's albums, Markku Lepisto has released a box (melodeon and CBA) and bass album and Andy Cutting has done some brilliant stuff with Tim Harries.  Its a shame that Danny Thompson never got together with a box player.

I really like box and clarinet too.... Delicq again and also Mark Perrone.  
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: **DTN** on November 19, 2011, 09:23:21 PM
Loffet AD Graet e Briezh played with Castagnari Mory in DG.... lovely harmonic mix

i.e ... me and Jimbo .. we must record a track! ;D ;D
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Ollie on November 19, 2011, 10:26:09 PM
I can think of one or two morris sides that would benefit by actually thinking about this question.

I'm not sure cotswold morris and big bands are a good combination anyway.
Other traditions such as north west and border are different and thrive on a well-balanced 'wall of sound'.

Andy

Cotswold bands do not work. They either go two ways; the group doesn't play together, and the emphasis is all over the place, or you can get a group of musicians working together to put emphasis in the correct place, but then it sounds very robotic and militaristic. Cotswold music should be organic, and it's very difficult to do that with more than two players.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on November 19, 2011, 10:34:10 PM
I can think of one or two morris sides that would benefit by actually thinking about this question.

I'm not sure cotswold morris and big bands are a good combination anyway.
Other traditions such as north west and border are different and thrive on a well-balanced 'wall of sound'.

Andy

Cotswold bands do not work. They either go two ways; the group doesn't play together, and the emphasis is all over the place, or you can get a group of musicians working together to put emphasis in the correct place, but then it sounds very robotic and militaristic. Cotswold music should be organic, and it's very difficult to do that with more than two players.
Agreed!  (:)
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Ollie on November 19, 2011, 11:23:39 PM
It's not about performance - I have no trouble sitting and listening to a group of Cotswold musicians play Cotswold tunes. However, playing said tunes doesn't aid the dance. Playing for Cotswold Morris is entirely different to anything else; you have to watch the every footfall, and be completely sympathetic to the dancers (usually follow no.1 or who you consider to be the best dancer in the set). When I play for Morris, I spend all my time looking at the ground, watching the dancers' feet. It's not simply a case of 'just playing the tune', you really have to add emphasis in certain places, and it varies every time.  So, I'm not saying it shouldn't be done because it sounds bad to listen to, I'm saying it shouldn't be done because

Yes, admittedly, one musician doesn't make for an organic performance (there are a lot of, quite frankly, crap Morris musicians out there {there are a lot of crap dancers/sides too, mind...}), but I've never seen a Cotswold band work.
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 20, 2011, 10:22:25 AM
Ollie is exactly right.
There are so many variables. As Ollie says, who do you follow?
In a set of 6 you will often find subtle variations between each dancer, timing for one will be out for another.
....then who do the rest of the band follow, because if they try and follow the main musician they'll be slightly out.
Build into this the venue or occasion. If it's the end of the day following a long day's dancing you imperceptably speed it up cos the dancers are tired. If it's a high pressure ceilidh spot at a prestigeous festival, the dancer's adrenaline will be squirting out their ears and will dance higher, so musicians need to dance slower to accommodate this.
For Border or North West, the nature of the dance is far more figure based ( and militaristic for NW ) so big bands work easier, but the stepping in Cotswold is difficult to play for.
Q
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: baz parkes on November 20, 2011, 12:42:49 PM
Before I get lured into the "How many musicians for Cotswold" debate (and I could...) in reply to the OPs question...Katie Howson's Martin and Jeannie Harris' HA114 (I think) on Veteran's Unbuttoned....

And for a bit of shameless self promotion, I think our Lisa and I make a nice noise...Salterelle something or other and a Castagnari whotsit...(though we both play Hohners if it's in C/F.. :||: :|||: :|||:)

Tried to insert image, but failed miserably...try www.allblackedup.co.uk

And of course, Jason Rice and Mark Bazeley...

Baz
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 20, 2011, 01:19:37 PM
Code: [Select]
Images done like this .. [img]http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/melodeonnet.gif[/img]Or just use the site's (http://forum.melodeon.net/Themes/melodeonnet/images/bbc/img.gif) button (2nd along)
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: baz parkes on November 20, 2011, 01:29:13 PM
Code: [Select]
Images done like this .. [img]http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/melodeonnet.gif[/img]Or just use the site's (http://forum.melodeon.net/Themes/melodeonnet/images/bbc/img.gif) button (2nd along)

Did that...then couldn't work out what to do next :|bl....

As Dicky Three would have it..."I am too childish foolish for this world..."

Mind you, most children of my acquaintance could probably work it out...

Baz
Title: Re: Box combinations - what boxes sound good together?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 20, 2011, 01:50:26 PM
Baz: Well resisted. One for the bar after methinks.....  :|glug
... and I agree both you and Lisa do make a nice sound too.

I'll leave the rest of the comments hanging there  ;)
take care
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal