Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Badger on November 23, 2011, 01:35:57 PM
-
I own a Hohner Pokerwork approximately 2 years old. Whilst playing yesterday, the spring for the G/A on the G row has broken. I live in the Southampton area, and would appreciate if any one can assist as to where I can get the instrument repaired, preferably local, and what the cost is likely to be. Thanking readers in anticipation. :-\
-
You could try doing it for yourself. It's not too difficult. See this thread and subsequent replies.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1101.msg103045.html#msg103045
You will need a Hohner spring, available from Theo
http://www.theboxplace.co.uk/
or Charlie Marshall.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#7
As it is on the inside G-row you will need a spring made from 0.5 mm dia wire (the outside row springs are 0.55 mm dia as they need to be a fraction stronger)
-
broken spring? over here winter hasnt even started yet ::)
W
-
You might find one of the local morris musos can fix it for you, or you can give me a call. I live in Basingstoke but am often in Southampton (the petrol's cheaper there). I've sent a PM with my phone numbers.
Rob.
-
I live in Basingstoke but am often in Southampton (the petrol's cheaper there).
Rob.
Sufficiently cheaper to make it worth burning the extra fuel to get there and back? ;D
(I know someone here in Cyprus who drives from a village near Limassol to Larnaca and back - a round trip of about 100 miles - to save €1.85 on a tray of 24 tins of catfood....)
Graham
-
I may be daft, but not that daft... No, my boat is in Southampton - well, Hamble. I could always drop in to show how to do the repair and still go and get frozen and wet on the boat.
Rob.
-
Thanks to all of you who replied. I purchased a spring and followed the instructions. With a dose of patience: Success, spring replaced and box now working perfectly. What a terrific resource Melnet is. ;D
-
Glad to hear you got it fixed OK. It's a great sense of achievement doing your first one. My Pokerwork (Chinese) broke three in quick succession early on, but has been fine ever since. I find the only real difficulty is to find the two sizes of screwdriver to fit really well and a crochet hook to save one's fingertips when detaching the springs. I also have an old woooden breadboard that I screw the action to whilst working on it.
Have fun.
Rob.
-
I also have an old woooden breadboard that I screw the action to whilst working on it.
That is an excellent plan - the last thing you need is the action jumping about all over the place while you're trying to do things to it, and little parts absenting themselves without trace.
-
I think I've broken a spring on the bass side of my pokerwork - the C chord button is loose, and the C chord sounds all the time. I've never had it open before, and am not particularly good with fiddly stuff. Is this harder/easier to fix than a treble spring? Any advice /guidance appreciated.
-
It is the same process as for a treble spring, though it is more difficult to get the mechanism out - you either have to remove the buttons from the ends of the pushrods, or remove the small pin that holds the pushrods to the mechanism.
Depending on which spring it is you can sometimes withdraw the axle far enough without taking the mechanism out.
-
Thanks Theo.
-
It is the same process as for a treble spring, though it is more difficult to get the mechanism out - you either have to remove the buttons from the ends of the pushrods, or remove the small pin that holds the pushrods to the mechanism.
Depending on which spring it is you can sometimes withdraw the axle far enough without taking the mechanism out.
Well - a partial success. I dropped into Emilio Allodi's shop and he supplied me with a spring. He also suggested that instead of removing the mechanism completely, one could unscrew it and move it to an easier position to work on without removing the bass buttons - just poke the rods further out through the holes. In the end I found I didn't even need to do this - I was able to replace the spring with the mechanism in place. However, when re-attaching the springs I realised that the spring I had been given is quite different in strength to the others - much weaker, although thicker wire. It all works OK, but the 'C' chord button is now noticeably less springy, and makes more of a "clack". So at some point I will have to get the proper spring and do it all again. :-[
Still, pleased to have tackled it myself - I will be a little more confident next time, hopefully.
-
Hello all,
I decided I will try to fix by myself a broken spring on my Pokerwork.
But first of all I will need the Spring (:)
Does the pokerwork requires a special Spring; if yes what is the model and where can I find it?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#7 - is this one ok? there are other vendors? Probably I will need to buy it in the UK and ship to Portugal...
Thank you in advance.
-
There are several varieties of the spring used on pokerworks. They are all the same shape, but the thickness of the wire can be different. On the treble side there are two different thickness, For the outside row, which have longer levers the thickness is usually 0.55mm, for the inside row with shorter levers the thickness is 0.5mm. Tell your supplier which thickness you want.
-
Thank you for the information.
I don't have the springs yet, but already tried do get to the broken Spring, and I'm having lots of trouble to pull the axle rod!
I didn't screw the mechanism to a piece of board yet, but it seems that even when I will do that, it will be very hard to pull the rod with a plier from the opposite side, because the rod is very tight (I already released all the springs).
Please let me know if there are any tricks doing this work, or if just a matter of strengh.
Thank you!
-
Put the axle rod in the chuck of a cordless drill then draw the axle out at a low revs. Follow through with another rod to keep everything in place.
-
I also read in another post about using the drill, I will try that. Thank you Rees.
-
Remember to release all the spring ends from the levers before trying to withdraw the axle.
Also, read the older posts on this thread - there is some good information contained in the links which are mentioned.
-
Thank you for all the information.
With the help of a good plier first, and then a drill chuck well tight, I could remove the axle very easily, and so it was easy to remove the broken Spring and replace with a new one. So the treble mechanism is now ready for playing.
But then I had this problem: it is very hard to screw the treble mechanism in it's place (4 screws), because the mechanism is far from the screw holes. Do you think I need to unhook the springs to do this? (because I already hooked the springs with the loose treble mechanism...)
-
Thank you for all the information.
With the help of a good plier first, and then a drill chuck well tight, I could remove the axle very easily, and so it was easy to remove the broken Spring and replace with a new one. So the treble mechanism is now ready for playing.
But then I had this problem: it is very hard to screw the treble mechanism in it's place (4 screws), because the mechanism is far from the screw holes. Do you think I need to unhook the springs to do this? (because I already hooked the springs with the loose treble mechanism...)
Where possible you should always unspring the mech before refitting
-
Ok, I will try that way. I'm a bit cautious because I imagine it will be hard to hook the springs with the treble mechanism screwed, because of the few space available to do it properly. But I think I don't have a choice here. Thank you.
-
It is usually possible, if the springs have poor access, to push the keyboard carefull into place, then put in the screws. You might be able to devise a way to clamp the keyboard into position, or get an assistant to help.
-
It is usually possible, if the springs have poor access, to push the keyboard carefull into place, then put in the screws. You might be able to devise a way to clamp the keyboard into position, or get an assistant to help.
I'm very wary of doing this as I managed to really mess things up the first couple of times I replaced springs on my pokerwork. The problem with leaving the spring tension there before screwing the tiny screws back in to the fondo, there's a high chance that the screws will rip out of the wood if it springs back ... and once that has happened it can be very hard to get the screws to stay in! I ended up having to use some tiny long nuts and bolts to solve my mistake.
It is difficult to get the springs back in place after reassembly, but I've found the ideal tool in a very small crochet hook that can easily hold the spring without it slipping.
-
It is usually possible, if the springs have poor access, to push the keyboard carefull into place, then put in the screws. You might be able to devise a way to clamp the keyboard into position, or get an assistant to help.
I'm very wary of doing this as I managed to really mess things up the first couple of times I replaced springs on my pokerwork. The problem with leaving the spring tension there before screwing the tiny screws back in to the fondo, there's a high chance that the screws will rip out of the wood if it springs back ... and once that has happened it can be very hard to get the screws to stay in! I ended up having to use some tiny long nuts and bolts to solve my mistake.
It is difficult to get the springs back in place after reassembly, but I've found the ideal tool in a very small crochet hook that can easily hold the spring without it slipping.
I bought a set of Dental Picks on Ebay for a few pounds only, they come with various shaped hooked ends,......very useful for manoeuvring springs and the like back into position, I have even heard of them being used to lift reeds for tuning.
-
I found a long thin screwdriver with a small slot or V in the blade works quite well to unhook or replace springs.
Mike.
-
I found a long thin screwdriver with a small slot or V in the blade works quite well to unhook or replace springs.
Mike.
I use that very same thing.
-
It is usually possible, if the springs have poor access, to push the keyboard carefull into place, then put in the screws. You might be able to devise a way to clamp the keyboard into position, or get an assistant to help.
I'm very wary of doing this as I managed to really mess things up the first couple of times I replaced springs on my pokerwork. The problem with leaving the spring tension there before screwing the tiny screws back in to the fondo, there's a high chance that the screws will rip out of the wood if it springs back ... and once that has happened it can be very hard to get the screws to stay in! I ended up having to use some tiny long nuts and bolts to solve my mistake.
It is difficult to get the springs back in place after reassembly, but I've found the ideal tool in a very small crochet hook that can easily hold the spring without it slipping.
Yes quite right Squeezy. I thought we were still discussing an older box with a wooden keyboard. Having the-read the preceding posts I see it's a Hohner bass end that is being discussed, and yes releasing the springs is the only way to do it. With the right tool it is not hard to get the springs hooked up.
-
I managed it easily and I am not brave at these things.
-
Ok, it's done. Thank you for your comments.
Actually I was replacing a spring on the treble end of a Pokerwork. I strongly advice everyone that after reassemble the springs and the axle back in place, to screw the treble mechanism first (4 screws), and only then hook the springs. After all, it's not difficult, I didn't had a crochet, but I did a small hook from a clip to lift the springs, and then with a plier pushed the spring up to it's place.
...
But after all it was not a 100% happy ending, cause after reassemble everything I noticed there's a note that's only sounding one voice... so I think I will need to reopen the box again... grrrr :o
-
after reassemble everything I noticed there's a note that's only sounding one voice... so I think I will need to reopen the box again... grrrr :o
Yes, but you won't have to take the keyboard mechanism off again for that :Ph
(just four bellows pins and whatever's holding the reed block in... much simpler)