Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: Lyn on November 28, 2011, 08:31:05 PM

Title: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Lyn on November 28, 2011, 08:31:05 PM
I've just got home from attending the Big Accordian weekend at Halsway Manor in Somerset. Not because I've got a big accordian. I went because Andy Cutting was melodeon tutor. And very good it was too, both as a venue, and the content of the whole weekend. Learned a lot and met some great people.

One gripe; some folk just don't acquaint themselves with workshop etiquette before they turn up at one. How they've got so far in their musical careers without having the riot act read to them amazes me. ??? Noodling away to oneself while the tutor is either talking, or playing is NOT GOOD MANNERS!Leaning over a tutor who is playing a tune for someone to record and trying to play along - badly - and then asking at the end if they could play it again 'so I can record it'  just beggars belief.  :o :o :o

Ok, maybe this particular tutor was too well mannered to tell him where to get off, but the guy should really be up to speed with how to behave by now. No idea who he was, and it wasn't me who he interrupted - though he did later in another class carry on noodling while we were trying to learn a tune phrase by phrase- and I'm sure outside the workshop scenario he was probably a nice guy.

OK, rant over. It was a great weekend, and I would thoroughly recommend it. Off to practise my bass runs.......... :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||:
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Frank Lee on November 29, 2011, 12:37:23 AM
This phenomenon is as infuriating as it is bad mannered, selfish and unbelievable; sadly it's also almost universal and often requires firmness almost to the point of rudeness on the part of the tutor to deal with it,  not many tutors are willing to go this far.   I've attended many Melodeon workshops and can't think of one where this didn't happen, or threaten to happen, even, in one case, where a punter took his chair and sat on stage, next to the tutor (Chris Parkinson) on the pretext of wanting to avoid the 'mirror image' problem when facing the tutor. In fact his intention was clearly to offer alternatives to anything Chris suggested and thus appear to be on equal terms.  Of course, the folks on this forum are not guilty and won't be reading this!
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Frank Lee on November 29, 2011, 12:52:02 AM
Ooops. Sorry,  Cut and paste error.  Last sentence should end " ......and the guilty won't be reading this".
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 29, 2011, 08:04:35 AM
Frank (not per this topic but it seems many don't know this facility)

  .. there's a "(http://forum.melodeon.net/Themes/melodeonnet/images/buttons/modify.gif) Modify" button top left above (only) your own posts.

It takes you back to 'Edit' . You can either correct the type and 'Save' again. If I've made a booboo and am changing something factual I'll commonly use the S button to cross out the old text and offer a clear correction. Up to you

[topic] Yup, Halsway Manor is a good place. They give a good room/food support, have a useful bar and very friendly staff. If the tutors are the same quality you've got a really super weekend.   I've never heard of "course etiquette", but playing in with the leader when others are recording certainly is "coarse"  ::)
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 29, 2011, 08:11:12 AM
This phenomenon is as infuriating as it is bad mannered, selfish and unbelievable; sadly it's also almost universal and often requires firmness almost to the point of rudeness on the part of the tutor to deal with it,  not many tutors are willing to go this far. 
I do insist on this in my own workshops. Hopefully I do it politely but firmly. I always outline the position right at the very beginning so that everyone knows exactly what is expected from the start.

In a workshop situation people do need to try things out a little bit for themselves and I am tolerant of minor twiddling e.g. when people are trying to 'find out where the notes are'. I will also usually allow a minute or so of free 'twiddle time' every so often during the course of the workshop when I want people to try things for themselves.

But if twiddling starts up when I am trying to make an important point, I will stop in mid-sentence and remain totally silent until I have quietness again. When I wish to demonstrate some playing, I will always start by saying 'OK, my turn now' or similar. Once again, if twiddling starts up, I will instantly stop playing myself and wait for silence before resuming. It usually works fine and people don't normally need to be told more than once.
Title: Workshop etiquette
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 29, 2011, 09:13:27 AM
We are actually talking about behavioural issues in workshops here.  Lyn started it, and might consider changing the thread title?

There is a big 'leadership' aspect to this, and it sounds that Steve is doing exactly the tight thing. There is a genuine need for twiddle time amongst non sight-readers and allowing time for this is very wise. Brian Peters (occasionally of this parish) also runs a very tight workshop and tolerates no indiscipline. I think he's one of the best leaders I've been under.  

In contrast there are some super, arguably "top" players who seem to have little clue how to teach. To be fair, they are usually being too "nice" about it.

There's no way Parky (whom I mention only wrt post above) should have put up with the behaviour described above. In the limit the tutor needs to assert control of the overall process and if that means inviting someone to try out a "different" workshop - that's fine by me. If rules were clear at the start there should be no complaint. One suspects the wider group will support him all the way to the door, but it shouldn't really get that far.
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Lyn on November 29, 2011, 09:17:34 AM
.....and that worked fine at MAW, Steve. You put it very gently and diplomatically. I do remember there being a tiny bit of noodling and I was guilty once of doing it myself ::) - but on the whole these were brief little bits of noodling while folks sorted themselves out, as you say. This w/end it was full-on 'I am going to play this through til I get it right' noodling.

Chris, I think there is indeed a 'workshop etiquette', maybe unwritten, but we all certainly abide by it when I go to the Burwell Bash for my fiddle summer school. If the tutor doesn't pull them up, other students will make it clear such behaviour is unacceptable.

Accidental noodling happens briefly and is usually accompanied by the embarrassed realisation by the perpetrator that they have twiddled on too long. This was full blown arrogance and ignorance.

But I want to stress that the weekend was really, really good and I will certainly be booking again next year once I see who the tutors are.
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Frank Lee on November 29, 2011, 10:15:31 AM
Thanks for the tip Chris.
Re. The topic. 'trying out time' is usually an essential element of a workshop; and the ability of the tutor to deal with inappropriate twiddling in a polite and friendly way is pre-supposed. My observation is that the patience of tutors is too frequently pushed to the limits. But it seems we represent a cross-section of society as a whole and perhaps this behaviour shouldn't be surprising. Re. 'Parky', I didn't suggest he put-up with the rudeness described for long!   
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Bob Ellis on November 29, 2011, 03:33:34 PM
Having attended workshops led by a wide variety of tutors, I have found that most of them have managed to discourage inappropriate noodling very effectively, although there have been a few exceptions. When these exceptions have occurred, either I or another participant has pointed out, diplomatically but firmly, that it is difficult for others to concentrate on what the tutor is saying or playing if someone else is playing in the background. This is usually sufficient to overcome the problem.

Lyn: Since you intend to go back to Halsway Manor next year and don't want to experience a repeat of this ill-mannered and selfish behavoiur, it might be worth informing the course organisers of your experience this year and suggesting to them that they announce clearly at the start of next year's course that such behaviour is unacceptable.

The best put-down for inappropriate noodling that I have heard came from Emmanuel Pariselle. When someone offended in this manner, he said: "Please don't play when I am talking. Such things happen in France, but should not be allowed in civilised countries!"
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Katie Howson on December 09, 2011, 10:20:49 AM
Emmanuel has so many good one-liners!

I think I shall put this one - slightly modified - into the tutors' info for Melodeons and More - perhaps "These things happen in Norfolk, but not in civilised counties such as Suffolk!"

Some wise words in this thread, and I would just like to add that our policy for Melodeons and More is to mix tried and tested tutors with excellent musicians, particularly local ones, who may be dipping their toe into tutoring for the first time, to whom we offer support and advice along the way.

I think this aspect is indeed the hardest one for many new tutors to control.
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: ladydetemps on December 09, 2011, 10:41:15 AM
I have prepared two posters ;)
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Anahata on December 09, 2011, 11:17:16 AM
Crikey! The second one's a bit extreme, isn't it?  :o ;D
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: ladydetemps on December 09, 2011, 11:25:32 AM
Crikey! The second one's a bit extreme, isn't it?  :o ;D
:|bl was thinking of it more in the terms of careless talk costs lives. Oops!
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Lyra on December 09, 2011, 02:40:44 PM
maybe careless noodling costs wives  :-\
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Earbrass on December 09, 2011, 03:02:39 PM
Surely careless noodling costs noodles?
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: xgx on December 09, 2011, 04:26:10 PM
Reverse psychology:

Don't let the
Tutor
TALK
over
YOU
noodlin'
Title: Re: The Big Accordian Weekend
Post by: Anahata on December 10, 2011, 10:23:59 AM
was thinking of it more in the terms of careless talk costs lives.
Oh, I know where you got it from. Not that I was actually around at the time, you understand...

maybe careless noodling costs wives  :-\
Severe thread drift in one letter change!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal