Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: gioui on November 29, 2011, 10:31:33 AM

Title: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on November 29, 2011, 10:31:33 AM
Hi, I have to replace  commercial reeds on my melodeon  and let me know, in your opinion, what is the difference between reeds Binci  vociarmoniche and ciccarelli a mano ? which are better?
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Simon on November 29, 2011, 10:39:10 AM
Try searching the forum for 'voci armoniche' or for 'ciccarelli'. There are already a couple of threads over the diffent types of reeds.
Here's one for ciccarelli reeds (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7797.0.html).
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: blafleur on November 29, 2011, 02:05:14 PM
I think in comparing those three, "better" will come down to personal preference.  All make good reeds. I've installed 3 sets of Cicarelli reeds now and all perform great, very good response.  Sound is slightly different than Binci, but to me, just as good in performance.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on November 29, 2011, 05:09:47 PM
What changes in the sound compared to binci reeds ? I have binci and the aluminium tongue is more thin than vociarmoniche but the sound is more powerful . but i don't know ciccarelli reeds
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: blafleur on December 01, 2011, 12:05:05 PM
Not sure I can quantify it in words the difference I hear, and my experience is pretty limited.  Diatonix has much more experience with different styles of the Cicarrelli's, maybe he'll chime in.  And that's another consideration, comparing just the name is not necessarily effective, each brand has several different styles, each with it's own character.  Going with brass bases or aluminum alone has a pretty big impact on sound.   And I'm really beginning to believe each genre of music, and style of accordion, has it's own expectations/desires.

Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Theo on December 01, 2011, 03:15:40 PM
In addition the particular instrument you put the reeds in has a big influence on the sound, so for example Binci reeds in a Saltarelle, or a Castagnari or a Hohner will all sound distinctly different.  So it may be that for your box some makes would perform "better" than others, but in a different box a different reed would be "better".


It also depends on what appeals to the player, and what kind of playing you do.  You might prefer the sound of one reed, I might prefer another.  And as well as sound there is playability so Binci (and also Ciccarelli I'm told) have a longer scale length than used by the bigger makers such as VA and Cagnoni.  Bigger scale length generally gives you wider dynamic range, but at the cost of increased air consumption.  Shorter scale length usually gives slightly increased maximum volume, but less responsiveness at low volume.   So it's swings and roundabouts and you probably just have to make your best guess and take a chance,  but all makers make good reeds.   Compare it with cars, do you want a BMW, Audi, or Saab?   All good cars, but they appeal to different people.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: rees on December 01, 2011, 03:55:41 PM
Very well put, Theo.
I have to explain this to customers almost every day.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Andy Simpson on December 01, 2011, 04:08:29 PM
In addition the particular instrument you put the reeds in has a big influence on the sound

Indeed.

When I used Ciccarelli A Mano reeds in my super pokerwork, (in view of Lester calling his the Penguin of Death, I have retroactively dubbed my creation the Otter of Moderate Discomfort), the C bass chord reeds just wouldn't work properly and had to be replaced with Cagnoni macchina reeds that performed better in that situation. The low notes on the treble side were Cagnoni macchinas from the outset and there wasn't a huge difference between them and the A Mano reeds everywhere else to be honest...

To use another car analogy, I'm now of the opinion that putting A Mano reeds in a Hohner is a bit like fitting a Ferrari engine in a VW Beetle. It'll make it go a bit faster but on the whole, the car just isn't capable of exploiting the extra power properly.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: blafleur on December 02, 2011, 05:03:56 AM
On top of all that, put the exact same type reeds in 2 seemingly identically made accordions, could very possibly end up with 2 quite a bit different sounds.   Like kids, 2 from the same parents should be similar and sometimes are, but are often very different characters.  And like any character, it changes with age and use, so comparing old reeds to new ones are of no help.  I've wondered if any of that comes from different individuals making/fitting reeds for the same company.

Andy, I ran into a similar problem when I put the large bass reed (which is slightly larger than my Bincis) from the Cicarrelli set in a block that I based off dimensions I use for Binci. It had problems reliably starting no matter what I did with the reed gap, but putting a deeper block fixed it.

Confused yet, gioui?  I am.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Graham Collicutt on December 02, 2011, 02:39:33 PM
In addition the particular instrument you put the reeds in has a big influence on the sound

Indeed.

When I used Ciccarelli A Mano reeds in my super pokerwork, (in view of Lester calling his the Penguin of Death, I have retroactively dubbed my creation the Otter of Moderate Discomfort), the C bass chord reeds just wouldn't work properly and had to be replaced with Cagnoni macchina reeds that performed better in that situation. The low notes on the treble side were Cagnoni macchinas from the outset and there wasn't a huge difference between them and the A Mano reeds everywhere else to be honest...

To use another car analogy, I'm now of the opinion that putting A Mano reeds in a Hohner is a bit like fitting a Ferrari engine in a VW Beetle. It'll make it go a bit faster but on the whole, the car just isn't capable of exploiting the extra power properly.

As the current owner/player I think it was worth fitting the A Mano reeds. For me it is not about power but the ability to play very quietly. I can pick out the macchina reeds on the treble side, air use about a 1/3 higher on the shorter scale macchina reeds ( A3 draw compared to A3 press Ciccarelli reed ) at low volume.

I am very pleased with it.

Graham
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on December 02, 2011, 08:59:04 PM
I only know antonelli and Binci, but I'm curious to try  ciccarelli reeds , here in italy are not widely used .
in my experience the antonelli vociarmoniche have a sound more powerful  than binci  , the thickness is largest than binci .Bincis are more thin they are called "a nastrino ". if you pull a lot  they broke first
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Christopher K. on December 04, 2011, 12:25:32 AM
I only know antonelli and Binci, but I'm curious to try  ciccarelli reeds , here in italy are not widely used .
in my experience the antonelli vociarmoniche have a sound more powerful  than binci  , the thickness is largest than binci .Bincis are more thin they are called "a nastrino ". if you pull a lot  they broke first

That's funny, the difference between the Binci and Antonelli reeds I have experienced is the other way around - Binci more direct/powerful, Antonelli softer/flutier.
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: student I on December 07, 2011, 02:06:31 AM
What melodeon is it? Why do you have to replace them? Do you want to improve or restore?
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on December 21, 2011, 09:53:01 AM
is a new castagnari dony A-D-G musette
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Theo on December 21, 2011, 10:17:58 AM
is a new castagnari dony A-D-G musette

Very surprising that they are now fitting commercial reeds to that model,  it always used to be tipo a mano, either Antonelli, or more recently VA.   What is wrong with them?
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on December 21, 2011, 10:58:27 AM
the TAM  are perfect but the hand made  Reeds  are much more reactive to my type of music.I'm also thinking to set brass reeds, but I never try and do not know if they could be  reactive like durall
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: Theo on December 21, 2011, 11:16:15 AM
Even TAM reeds can be often be adjusted to be more responsive than they way they come from the factory - even from Castagnari.   The same will apply to any other kind of better quality reeds - You need to find a reed technician who can set them up for your style of playing.   
Title: Re: a mano reeds
Post by: gioui on December 21, 2011, 12:39:59 PM
 I want to experiment and change, Castagnari Tam are  perfect but all the instruments have the same sound, binci is another type of Reeds (a nastrino),  the sound and response are different  , my castagnari cortina was born whit Antonelli TAM reeds and i replaced whit binci a mano and the result feels good .  i don't know binci and ciccarelli  brass  reeds and I want to try, I said they sound sweeter and are more responsive than durall
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal