Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 10:31:32 AM

Title: Do you need more?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 10:31:32 AM
I confess to being somewhat lustful of late  :|bl
There has been several very nice 2 1/2 rows being sold and I confess to dribbling a little just reading about them, especially as they've been in lovely wood ( must have been a woodworm in previous life? ). In a place where I never see such instruments, I confess to wondering what they're like and drooling.
Then I went along to my local session last thursday........

Two old friends ( one just returned to the area ) both very good melodeon players in slightly different styles, trading tunes from differeing regional repertoires. All wonderfully rhythmic and very well played on two rows........
English standards,  older ones rediscovered, some French standards, a Swedish polska popped into the mix....
I came home realising that though I might lust over something with an extra row and a few more basses, all I need is what I've got in my hands - a 2 row D/G.
Just need to play it better  ::)

But lusting is nice >:E

hey ho
Q
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Ollie on December 04, 2011, 10:56:43 AM
I really wish more people had your attitude, Q!
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 04, 2011, 11:03:10 AM
I think it partly depends on a) what notes your half-row provides, b) what notes you have available at the chin end (let's not get into the top/bottom debate again!) and c) what kind of repertoire you play.  For myself, I normally play a 21+4 Saltarelle, with 4th-button start and low notes giving me a full 3 octaves on the full rows.  The accidentals that conventionally appear at  the chin end of a 21-button 2-row are on the half-row, twice - an octave apart (though reversed from the usual push-pull pattern, which sometimes leads to interesting moments when I play someone else's box or someone else plays mine).  The half-row makes the accidentals easily reachable without a stretch, but there are very few tunes I can't also do on a bog-standard Pokerwork - it just takes a little more effort. There are some tunes I play that do require the low notes or the accidentals in the "other" octave on the Saltarelle, so I have to fudge those or just avoid playing them on an ordinary 21-button 2-row.  So for me, it's a convenience but not absolutely necessary.  On the other hand, some players use their half-rows to provide "reversals" (ie notes on the push that are normally available on the pull or vice-versa), and if you play a lot of cross-rowing I can see that would be an advantage. The vast bulk of my repertoire is English dance tunes, most of which I play largely "on the row" , at least in major keys. So do I NEED more? No, not really.  Would I LIKE more?  Well that's another question..... :||:

Graham
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 04, 2011, 11:59:31 AM
Having two excellent instruments -- a 2 row and 2+5 -- I find that the MORE that I use the 2+5 for is the 3rd low reed on the right hand.  The accidentals hardly ever come into my repertoire, but having the choice of that extra bank of reeds is pretty dang nice.  BUT I do spend most of my time on the 2-row MM box ... a thing of beauty, a wonder to behold.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 12:19:12 PM
cheers Ollie  ;)

Both: they are interesting thoughts - having the accidental but not necessarily using them. I've had the 'Theo tweak' and got a low G start, so it's handy to get to those notes others rely on a 3rd row for.
I think the main thought I had the other night was that withing the English repertoire, we have absolutely cracking tunes. 
When listening to cd's I sometimes forgt the wealt of stuff we have. I forgot to mention the other night we had at least 5-6 morris tunes thrown into the mix too, again they are just lovely stuff. I tend to forget that, as they are a means to an end when I dance, telling me when and where  to put my feet. Take them out of morris context and play.....great stuff!

With such a collection of tunes I really felt I didn't need to go anywhere else....... that thought really hit me.
Q
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Martin J on December 04, 2011, 12:39:04 PM
I have both and really do miss Bb and F if they are not there.  I also use the D reversal all the time although this can be overcome at the expense of fluidity in playing.  But the real crux is as you have said, the quality of the player which I believe is some talent with a massive amount of continual hours daily practice. :||: :||: :||: until  :Ph
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 02:34:16 PM
Practise - yes indeed!
Though has to be balanced with annoying the family with repetitive tunes; currently not interrupting both kid's revision for exams..... and the curse of the working classes, downright tiredness!
I love my woodburner, and these dark nights sometimes I realise that time has passed unintentionally  :D
.... and practise best left for another night when I might be awake!
Q
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 04, 2011, 07:44:19 PM
The advantage of a 2.5 row box is that mostly it has 12 bass. This is far more useful than an accidental row!
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 08:52:31 PM
Ukebert: I've heard that before ( might even have been you! ) and it makes sense.
I see that
Q
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Andy Cutting on December 04, 2011, 09:04:56 PM
Sorry Ukebert but I have to disagree. The more buttons you have on either end allows you more versitility. Personally the 2.5 row 12 bass setup I use is ideal for me and still gives me the limitations I think are so important in this instrument.
Andy
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Ollie on December 04, 2011, 10:05:56 PM
I guess it depends what you're playing.

If you want to play in more interesting keys, then both the half row and extra bass are useful.
However, if you just want to add extra harmonic interest to tunes in standard keys, then the half row is fairly redundant.

It also depends on the set up of the instrument.

My main box is a 2.5 row 12 bass set up to play in 'funny keys' (Gm, Dm, F, C, Bb etc), and I actually find I don't use the half row very much, nor the Bb, Eb or F extra bass (I use F# a lot). This is probably because I've yet to explore the instrument's full capabilities. I use the pull D a lot, and the other accidentals very rarely.
I'm (hopefully) taking delivery of a 2.4 row 12 bass box soon, set up for making life easier when playing in standard keys. Even from just looking at layout, I can tell that I will be using the extra buttons on this a lot more than on my 2.5 row.

Horses for courses.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 04, 2011, 10:08:02 PM
Andy: If you kept to the 'central' English tune sets ( i.e. normal session stuff ) without straying too far into some off piste tunes, would you still feel you needed a 2.5 row/12 bass setup?
Q
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 04, 2011, 10:26:17 PM
Sorry Ukebert but I have to disagree. The more buttons you have on either end allows you more versitility. Personally the 2.5 row 12 bass setup I use is ideal for me and still gives me the limitations I think are so important in this instrument.
Andy

Well yes and no. It depends very much on what music you want to play. Take for instance the F# bass. This adds a huge amount of versatility to the left hand and it can be put in entirely independent of a half row (as whether on push or pull it can be used very effectively without the additional accidentals and reversals that a half row provides). The same can be said for the C# bass (if it is on the pull). The F bass is fantastically useful even when there isn't an F in the tune, although this really does have to be on the pull. So already there are 3 basses that can be used very effectively without an additional half row. The fourth bass relies on the low accidentals on the standard 2 row box being flipped, but good use can be made of either Bb or Eb on the push. So 12 basses can operate effectively on their own, independently of the half row.

A well designed 5 button half row can enable you to play in lots of keys on the right hand, but without the bass to back it up it is as nothing. Similarly, the harmonic potential of the half row can be wasted within the standard keys and modes if the right basses aren't there. I suppose I'm saying that a change in the bass (i.e. playing an F# instead of a D) is more significant than having that extra accidental in the right hand.

So I would say that having a 12 bass box with a two row treble is preferable to having an 8 bass box with a 2.5 row treble. That's all I'm saying really. I'm not disputing the power of the half row and I would say that there is a reason that modern boxes have both!

However, that is only my view. I am a player whose skill (such as it is) is confined to the right hand, but I consider the bass to be more important. This is primarily to do with my playing style and my repertoire and other repertoires, especially French tunes, demand different analyses. Having said all that, there is a grey area, because reversals on the half row enable different basses to be used. Also, the standard accidentals can add huge amounts to a tune if used properly even with an 8 bass and I've tried this (even if I do go far too fast and stumble a bit (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1n3lkSc5JAs)).

The only other thing that I'd add (in reference to limitations of the instrument) is that often when people think up a new system for the instrument people talk about how important the limitations are of the old one. This is true, but I'd dispute that inventing a new system will have no limitations, it will just have different ones. The stradella system is arguably (well, I'm arguing it) just as limiting as the 8 bass system, but in different ways. Working your way around the limitations of any instrument is the only way to play it to it's full potential. It so happens that the limitations of a melodeon lead to a very satisfying sound, but this does not mean that a different system will lead to a less satisfying sound.

Anyway, the words grandmother, eggs, suck and teach come to mind :P
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Christopher K. on December 05, 2011, 05:37:49 AM
I wanted an old 3 voice Hohner Club, convinced that I 'needed' the extra notes and voices. I had dreams about how perfect it would be. Wrong! It's heavy (zinc frames + low voice) and I hardly feel inclined to reach for the accidentals. Maybe I'll try again some time...  :|glug
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: baz parkes on December 05, 2011, 12:35:36 PM

   Ab on the pull  :P

I wish him the best of luck... ;D

Baz
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Earbrass on December 05, 2011, 02:40:38 PM
OK, here's a question from someone who has only ever played a 2 row D/G. If having the 12 basses is reckoned to be such a boon, how would people rate the usefulness of the "posh" Italian D/G 2.n row + 12 bass layouts versus say a (much cheaper) Hohner Corona/Compadre A/D/G 3 row + 12 bass layout for English and similar repertoire? I realise the selection of basses is different.

Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 05, 2011, 05:03:34 PM
OK, here's a question from someone who has only ever played a 2 row D/G. If having the 12 basses is reckoned to be such a boon, how would people rate the usefulness of the "posh" Italian D/G 2.n row + 12 bass layouts versus say a (much cheaper) Hohner Corona/Compadre A/D/G 3 row + 12 bass layout for English and similar repertoire? I realise the selection of basses is different.

Well you've got to tradeoff having more weight and more bulk against the usefulness gained. The 12 basses have (in my opinion) only one more useful bass compared to the 8 bass: the F#. All the others are reversals, which are very useful, but not imho worth the increased weight. The treble end as well leaves something to be desired, as it doesn't have any accidentals as such (other than the G#), so the harmonic possibilities of the half row aren't particularly significant with a whole extra row.

But it really depends on what you want to play. If you are into going up and down the rows playing dartmoor style or similar then it would be ideal. Similarly if you are going for continental German/Austrian stuff, very smooth across the rows then it would also be fine.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: waltzman on December 05, 2011, 05:10:15 PM
The treble end as well leaves something to be desired, as it doesn't have any accidentals as such (other than the G#), so the harmonic possibilities of the half row aren't particularly significant with a whole extra row.


Not true.  A standard three row ADG has all of the accidentals that are on a typical 2.5 row except one and many more of the very useful reversals.  A very economical and versatile option in my opinion.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 05, 2011, 05:19:51 PM
Ab on the pull
I wish him the best of luck...
should be a breeze, what with his zinc frames and low voice.

Didn't mean that sort of pull! :o  Anyway - wrong Chris! The Oakwood doesn't have pull Ab and it'd be really useful when sessions play in A. Yes you always need 'more' - but then you should have bought a CBA in the first place.

Andy: If you kept to the 'central' English tune sets ( i.e. normal session stuff ) without straying too far into some off piste tunes, would you still feel you needed a 2.5 row/12 bass setup?  Q 

See above  :|glug

OK, here's a question from someone who has only ever played a 2 row D/G. If having the 12 basses is reckoned to be such a boon, how would people rate the usefulness of the "posh" Italian D/G 2.n row + 12 bass layouts versus say a (much cheaper) Hohner Corona/Compadre A/D/G 3 row + 12 bass layout for English and similar repertoire? I realise the selection of basses is different.

I think the extra 4 basses would get very little use, but its pull Ab would get quite a lot  ;)
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 05, 2011, 05:20:46 PM
The 12 basses have (in my opinion) only one more useful bass compared to the 8 bass: the F#. All the others are reversals, which are very useful, but not imho worth the increased weight. 

My 12-bass doesn't have an F#, and never has.  My extra basses are Bb/F and A/E, which gives me both E minor in its usual position and E major on the pull, and A major in both directions.  And yes, I do use them - but not very often!

Graham
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Christopher K. on December 05, 2011, 05:38:22 PM
Ab on the pull
I wish him the best of luck...
should be a breeze, what with his zinc frames and low voice.

 :D
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 05, 2011, 05:58:14 PM
The treble end as well leaves something to be desired, as it doesn't have any accidentals as such (other than the G#), so the harmonic possibilities of the half row aren't particularly significant with a whole extra row.


Not true.  A standard three row ADG has all of the accidentals that are on a typical 2.5 row except one and many more of the very useful reversals.  A very economical and versatile option in my opinion.

Oops, forgot about the ones at the chin end. But whilst those can be very useful, they aren't as easy to use as the half row. And you still don't have a C reversal (the third most useful reversal) and the weight and bulk is still significantly more. Yet to be convinced about the ADG, although I know that a lot of people like it. Admittedly it is very cheap.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Randal Scott on December 05, 2011, 06:16:43 PM
Yes you always need 'more' - but then you should have bought a CBA in the first place.


Just when I thought I was making progress in therapy!    :-\  :|glug
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Earbrass on December 06, 2011, 10:05:03 AM
Oops, forgot about the ones at the chin end. But whilst those can be very useful, they aren't as easy to use as the half row. And you still don't have a C reversal (the third most useful reversal) and the weight and bulk is still significantly more. Yet to be convinced about the ADG, although I know that a lot of people like it. Admittedly it is very cheap.

Not sure about the weight/bulk argument - the Corona range weighs between 4 Kg (2 voice) and 5.7Kg(3 voice Extreme model) with a size of 31 x 19cm. The Mory for sale currently on these boards is quoted as 5.4Kg and 30 x 20cm on the ebay ad.
Title: Re: Do you need more?
Post by: Bob Ellis on December 06, 2011, 10:21:32 AM
Weight/bulk need not be an issue. I suffer from spinal arthritis, which meant playing the Castagnari Mory and Dony I used to own was very uncomfortable, especially when playing standing up. The solution was to sell the Mory and Dony and buy a Benny - three rows, twelve basses, very little weight or bulk and an end to back problems when playing.  (:)

With regard to the four extra basses, mine are F and F#m on the pull and Bb and Eb on the push. I use them a lot and would not be without them, but it depends on what you play. The main use I make of them is when playing French and Scandinavian tunes in keys other than D and G, especially in C, Am, Dm and Gm. However, the F and F#m are also useful for adding extra colour to tunes in D and G.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal