Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: stevejay on December 06, 2011, 02:55:12 PM
-
A while back I said I purchased a Lilly G/C. Midis were off in G or C, so I figured, ehh midis, must be that. Doh. Homer Simpson reference.
Correction, it is a F/Bb! It was sold to me as a G/C and I didn't think anything of it, and haven't played with recordings or people yet.
So, what do you think? I'm not unhappy, but I was hoping to play along with recordings more... Maybe I should consider joining the Salvation Army Band, seems pretty useful there. Bb would be welcomed.
This little guy certainly has a low voice.
All I can say is... doh :|bl
-
Presumably if it's only a semitone off you could have the reeds trimmed a little? Is that how it works?
Presumably its previous owner sold it to you thinking it was flat!
-
Presumably if it's only a semitone off you could have the reeds trimmed a little? Is that how it works?
It is a whole tone flat of GC F>G and Bb>C rather a long way to take reeds by filing.
-
No, wouldn't change it. Funny though, he said he recorded with it and he does play the fiddle. Very strange it was advertised as a G/C. I still like it regardless, although it is a bit unique to have it so low in such a small instrument. Concertinas sound great in F/Bb so what the heck.
-
You're right, of course. A tone. Maths was never my strong point. :)
-
All I can say is... doh :|bl
Or in fact "fa", if its lower-row key is F.........
Graham
-
So, what do you think? I'm not unhappy, but I was hoping to play along with recordings more... Maybe I should consider joining the Salvation Army Band,
At the French dance weekend in Otley in October Bernard Loffet played a lot of his Breton material on a F/Bb box with Yves Leblanc on clarinet. It was a great sound.
-
Personally I love the sound of boxes in flat keys - my Hohner C/F is my current favourite box as far as sound is concerned, closely followed by the Bb/Eb Club II. The best-sounding box I ever played was a Bb/Eb Hlavacek Heligonka - melodeon heaven!
Graham
-
Stephane Delicq played an F/Bb on a couple of youtube videos, so you're in good company. ;) More in this thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3786.0.html).