Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Steve C. on December 07, 2011, 11:12:24 PM

Title: Open B/ Open E chord
Post by: Steve C. on December 07, 2011, 11:12:24 PM
Regrets:  I cannot find this post, I know it's here somewhere:

To change the usual B major / E minor chord to open chords by retuning the reeds, what would the notes be for each reed, both for a 2 voice and for a 3 voice?

On the 3 voice, if you double up one note (2 reeds, same note), which note?

Thanks, regards, Steve
Title: Re: Open B/ Open E chord
Post by: pgroff on December 08, 2011, 12:12:49 AM
Steve,

You didn't specify whether you are asking about a Hohner, a Castagnari, etc.  In the harmony or triad section of accordion bass reeds, which notes are paired on the same reedplate differs between different accordions (see below).

But in case this helps, here's the theory you need (using the english-language convention that "B" refers to the note 1/2 step below C).

1) B triads.  B major triad = (B, D#, F#).   B minor triad = (B, D, F#).   B "neutral" or "open" interval (root and fifth, but no third) = (B, F#).

2) E triads.  E major triad = (E, G#, B).  E minor triad = (E, G, B).  E "neutral" or "open" interval (root and fifth, but no third) = (E, B).

Back to your question, in converting your B major triad to the "neutral" (thirdless) interval, you will remove the D# note.  In converting your E minor triad to the "neutral" (thirdless) interval, you will remove the G note.  

How you achieve that, and what notes you prefer to double up, depends on the whole way your bass and chords are set up.  For a box where the D# and G are on the same reedplate, you could change that plate to an F# / B plate.  Or you could flip the original plate after retuning it to E/F#, giving F#/E.  But that would double up the fifth (F#) for the B interval and the root (E) for the E interval.  Might be better to substitute in a new F#/B plate.  

On some accordions, the D# and G will be on different reedplates so then you will have other options.

For the theory that underlies the above:

An interval is 2 pitches considered together (played together, or as a measure of the distance in pitch between 2 notes).  The "neutral chord" (sic) B - F# is really a perfect fifth interval. B - D is a minor third interval, B - D# is a major third interval.

A chord is 3 or more pitches considered together (played simultaneously, or just conceptualized together as in an arpeggio): a triad is a 3-note chord.

A major triad consists of a root (note after which it's named), a "third" which is an interval of a major third (2 whole steps) above the root, and a "fifth" which is an interval of a perfect fifth above the root, ex: (C, E, G), (B, D#, F#).

A minor triad consists of a root, a "third" of the triad which is an interval of a minor third (1.5 whole steps) above the root, and a fifth which is an interval of a perfect fifth above the root, ex (C, Eb, G); (B, D, F#).

Apologies if you knew all this, hard to tell from your question.

PG
Title: Re: Open B/ Open E chord
Post by: Steve C. on December 08, 2011, 02:29:10 AM
PG, this is exactly what I was looking for (and a little bit more).

Open E = E, B;  Open B = B, F#

Will go and open 'em up and see how arranged (one is a Pokerwork, the other a Lilly)

Thanks and regards,  Steve
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal