Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: sandwich on December 10, 2011, 08:23:56 PM
-
I'm sure this has been posted about previously, but couldn't find a specific thread on the subject. Just wondering has anyone ever tried a bit of DIY on the basses to reduce the sound of clicking. Maybe someone could share their experiences on measures they've taken to nullify the clip-clop of the bass buttons. The clicking noises on my basses are driving me nuts.
-
On Pokerwork/Ericas you can do a lot to quieten the basses by fitting better felt/leather to the pallets and then reaming and bushing the holes where the bass buttons go through the casework. The bushing of the button holes is probably the more important of the two in the case of Pokerwork/Ericas
-
On most makes of box you have to pay extra for the percussion buttons - however, Hohner generally includes them at no extra cost.
;D
-
I have no idea how to fix this, but I can sympathise with you as I also have a similar problem but it on a 96bass box, my C in particular has developed a very annoying pinging noise, something like a bit of metal hitting off another, I find this very distracting as it is very noticeable, in general the other bass button or bass mechanism is becoming noisy.
I don't want to hijack your post, but it sounds as thought we might have a similar problem.
-
My Erica also has clackety basses. At present I tend only to play the melody, but it needs to be addressed before I seriously get into learning to use the basses as it's most distracting.
You need to work out where the noise is coming from - the palettes, on release of the buttons, or pressing the buttons and the buttons hitting the side of the holes.
The first can be fixed, as Lester points out, by replacing the felt that seals the palettes (and also acts as a shock absorber/silencer). You can buy a felt/leather combination to re-face the palettes or there are those here - Theo, Lester, Mike Rowbotham and several others, who can do it for you at not unreasonable cost.
I don't think you said what box you have.
If it's the buttons/holes then again it can be fixed. But maybe if you can identify your box, and specifically when the noise occurs, you'll get a better answer.
-
On Pokerwork/Ericas you can do a lot to quieten the basses by fitting better felt/leather to the pallets and then reaming and bushing the holes where the bass buttons go through the casework. The bushing of the button holes is probably the more important of the two in the case of Pokerwork/Ericas
What does "reaming & bushing" mean? It seems to me that the noise on my Pokerworks comes primarily from the bass pallets clacking down on the body of the box. Bass intensive tunes are really unbelievably noisy on the Pokerworks! My Morgane, in contrast, is totally silent, both on the treble & bass buttons.
-
What does "reaming & bushing" mean?
I find the bulk of the noise from Pokerworks and Ericas emanates from the buttons impacting the holes in the casework to sort this you need to remove the rods from the bass mechanism by straightening out the hinge pins (nails), being sure to number the rods so they go back in the same place. Then you need to open up (ream) the holes in the case work, this is done with a tapered reamer:
http://www.maplin.co.uk/reamer-3869 (http://www.maplin.co.uk/reamer-3869)
Once the holes are opened up they need to be lined (bushed) with proper bushing felt:
http://concertina-spares.com/catalogue.htm (http://concertina-spares.com/catalogue.htm)
The art with this is knowing how far to ream the holes out.
I have a box in at the moment for this job and will take photos when I do it in the next few days.
-
I find the bulk of the noise from Pokerworks and Ericas emanates from the buttons impacting the holes in the casework
My take on this is different, I find that in all of the Hohners I see the loudest noise by far is the slap as the pallet goes down on releasing the button, the button hitting the case is usually the next most prominent, but there can also be significant noise from the action itself, mainly from the pivot which Lester describes separating to take the rods out. Your playing style can also have an influence on which source of noise is the most objectionable.
-
I seem to remember John K at a Witney workshop talking about the uniqueness of melodeons and Hohners in particular - what other instrument can play melody, bass accompaniment and percussion at the same time - a full orchestra-in-a-box (:)
-
My take on this is different, I find that in all of the Hohners I see the loudest noise by far is the slap as the pallet goes down on releasing the button,
Yes, I'm not really understanding the point of reaming - especially not since it seems to involve an "offensive weapon"! Is the button itself supposedly connecting with the sides of the keyboard around the button hole? I don't think this happens with my Pokerworks. As far as I can tell, all the significant noise on my Pokerworks occurs when the pallet slaps onto the body of the box after releasing the button. A tune that involves a lot of jumping around on the basses is a positive cacophony of clacking. On the other hand, a slower tune which involves holding the basses & releasing gently results in no noise.
-
Yes that is what I mostly notice.
Players who have a more percussive left hand playing style may get more noise from the buttons. And the direction that your finger is moving when it hits the button will make a difference too, anything except vertically down on top of the button has the possibility of causing the button to hit the side of the hole in the wood.
-
On Pokerwork/Ericas you can do a lot to quieten the basses by fitting better felt/leather to the pallets and then reaming and bushing the holes where the bass buttons go through the casework. The bushing of the button holes is probably the more important of the two in the case of Pokerwork/Ericas
What does "reaming & bushing" mean? It seems to me that the noise on my Pokerworks comes primarily from the bass pallets clacking down on the body of the box. Bass intensive tunes are really unbelievably noisy on the Pokerworks! My Morgane, in contrast, is totally silent, both on the treble & bass buttons.
Here is an example of the bass button holes on a Hohner Erika reamed (enlarged) and bushed. The photo also shows the re-faced pallets.
Martyn
-
When you talk about reaming the holes, are you referring only to the bass button holes?
Martyn, looking at the photo of the Erika, what are those red discs - are they the buttons or some kind of added, wider casing that the buttons fit through?
It seems to me that perhaps 80%- 90% of the noise comes from the palette striking the body of the box. The remaining noises would become noticeable only when the dominating palette noise is eliminated.
I know this may be a pointless question to pose here, but why on earth doesn't Hohner fix these niggling problems with their boxes? The Morgane (Ligne Naturel) addresses all these issues (plus better bellows, bellows tape, hardware) & is barely more expensive than the Erica/Pokerworks line.
-
Just in case Martyn doesn't see this for a while, I'll do some of the honours....
When you talk about reaming the holes, are you referring only to the bass button holes?
Yes.
looking at the photo of the Erika, what are those red discs - are they the buttons or some kind of added, wider casing that the buttons fit through?
They are not discs. If you look at the photo carefully, you should be able to see that the red pieces are actually the ends of short 'tubes' of bushing felt (actually a woven material) which have been glued around the circumference of the enlarged bass button holes. The photo has been taken prior to the re-fitting of the bass buttons in order to properly show the bushing felt.
It seems to me that perhaps 80%- 90% of the noise comes from the palette striking the body of the box. The remaining noises would become noticeable only when the dominating palette noise is eliminated.
I think that most people would agree with that.
-
You might also find these threads of interest:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7608.msg94437.html#msg94437
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7836.msg97489.html#msg97489
-
"De-clackifying" in the States done nicely (and very reasonably) by Michael at Dancemaster.
While at it, get the treble padded. (even more reasonably priced)
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7608.msg94437.html#msg94437
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7836.msg97489.html#msg97489
Do the execs at Hohner read these threads & chuckle to themselves? >:E