Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: MandoC on December 13, 2011, 06:06:08 PM
-
I was recently asked to play at an English Country Dance here in Fairbanks Alaska. I am mainly a contra dance musician,although I am aware of the English Country Dance group and know the organizers of these dances well. My question is, how many melodeon net musicians play for English Country Dances in England? I am under the impression that a lot of you play for Morris, which is not English Country Dance. Theo lists himself as playing with a "Ceildh Band". The music used for the dance I played at was from the Peter Barnes books of English Country Dances. Peter is an American and a crack contra pianist as well as playing in an American English Country Dance Band "Bare Neccessities". I am wondering if melodeon is a common instrument used in English Country Dance Band in England. I am hoping to play some BC accordion in the band, since some of the melodies are relatively simple. Any Information would be appreciated. Charlie
-
Depends what you mean by "country dance" & "celildh" bands, both of which are open to more than one interpretation. For many years in UK I played in "country dance bands", starting in the 1960s in an EFDSS-style, American & Scottish influenced "straight-down-the-middle" piano-accordion-led band, then in a "folk-rock" electric band modelled pretty much on the Steeleye Span/Fairport approach to reels & jigs; then came the Polka Revolution led by bands such as Oak, Webbs Wonders and of course Old Swan, at which point I not only embraced this fresh approach to English traditional dance wholeheartedly, but switched from bass to melodeon (I was already playing for morris), which I played in my next 3 bands and still do here in Cyprus, playing a 95% English, 95% traditional repertoire of tunes. For my money, an "English Country Dance Band" these days means a band in the tradition of Old Swan, Flowers & Frolics, Gas Mark 5, and the many essentially English bands they inspired.
I may be entirely wrong, but I get the impression that "English Country Dance" on the other side of the pond often means Playford or dancing master dances, and that traditional English village dances are rarely done. Please correct me if this is not the case.
Graham
-
(It means Playford in France) I guess if MandoC might name some of his tunes it would settle the matter fairly quickly.
-
I've played for over 30 years for 'barn dances' which are mainly English/British country dances but usually with a novice audience of dancers. Once a month we played for a country dance club. At the barn dances the caller would ask for a Jig, Reel, hornpipe, polka etc in 32 or 48 bars and we would play our favorite tunes in the rythmn asked at the tempo that suited the age of the dancers. For the club dances the caller named the tunes he wanted. Mostly strict tempo. The dance club would sometimes perform Playford as set pieces at music festivals and we would have to practice with them to get it perfect.
-
At the barn dances the caller would ask for a Jig, Reel, hornpipe, polka etc in 32 or 48 bars and we would play our favorite tunes in the rhythm asked at the tempo that suited the age of the dancers. For the club dances the caller named the tunes he wanted.
That's how I understand it works. I've done lots of the "barn dance" type gigs (got one tonight...) and it's usually jig, reels/polkas and how many bars, but I have an "English Country Dance" coming up next year for which the caller will be sending us the music. We have done a couple of dances for The Friends of Cecil Sharp House with Colin Hume who is revered among the Social Dance community (that's what we often call ECD here) and it was similar - he sent us or recommended tunes for many of the dances but gave us some choice with others.
I don't think you find many melodeons in ECD though. It's the domain of piano accordions. Tunes are in whatever key they feel like being in. Adapting for melodeon is going to be interesting. I have discovered, though, that The Dennington Bell and The March of the Men of Devon make good substitutes for American Reels which ironically are a key component of so-called English Country Dance here.
-
I'm not sure you'll ever find a definition of this, because English traditions seem to change so much over the years, in comparison with those of many other Countries.
I learned to play box in the seventies as part of what we called an 'English Country Dance' band, and our violinist leader and guru, who started playing in the nineteen thirties, had quite a mixed repertoire of English, Irish, Scottish, American and (a little) French music. Although much came from EFDSS sources, he would also happily include morris tunes, Playford, popular music of the thirties and forties, 'gypsy jazz' standards, and popular 'traditional' pub tunes (though many of these were well beyond my skills). He started playing for social dancing in the nineteen fifties (which I imagined to be the 'cocoa and campfire' years of folk festivals, judging by the equipment he used to bring with him to the early Towersey Festivals!) Funnily enough, it was his complete mix of styles of music (without being too restricted to one tradition) that somehow marked him out for me as being 'English'. He went on to embrace a lot of the more solidly 'English traditional' music of the seventies dance revival, but our repertoire still kept in a lot of the other stuff, which I suppose came from the sort of live (and of course unamplified) musical entertainment his generation would have enjoyed listening to and dancing to. Our band seemed to me to hark back to an era of English music that was certainly traditional, but in an almost nostalgic mid-twentieth century way rather than from earlier folk music alone.
-
There have been articles in "English Dance and Song" over the last few issues comparing the various types of Social Dancing and how they are named and practiced in various places.
I started playing in the early 70s as a double bass player. I was at university near Cecil Sharp House, and was drawn into bands playing more or less formal country dancing where most of the tunes were dictated by the caller's choice of dance (ECD in American-speak). This continued over the ensuing 40 years with bands North and South, Mosaic, High Jinks, Merlin and Stradivarious. But at the same time I was playing melodeon for what is now called English Ceilidh and the two came together in High Jinks where I would change from Bass to Melodeon for different dances and then in Stadivarious where we could morph from Fiddle, Accordeon, Bass and Drums to Fiddle, Melodeon, Piano, Drums.
I've now given up the ECD and play almost entirely English Ceilidh with Fish 'n' Taters and Up Tails All (Curiously a ceilidh band taking its name from a Playford Dance). The bass comes out for the Old Fashioned Trio (with Fi Fraser from the afore-mentiond Old Swan Band and Pete Bullock from the Albion Band). I'm introducing tunes from my past ECD playing which we use in as concert pieces or in combination with songs and Fi brings ceilidh tunes from her background and I often play melodeon for these.
However, take a look at a book called Push Pull Playford by a friend of mine Tony Batilana where he sets out all the first edition playford tunes in melodeon-friendly keys.
Howard
-
One of the great things about the English trad music scene, whether for social dance or not is that it is pretty anarchic and includes tunes and stylistic influences from Scotland, Ireland, N America and mainland Europe. There is evidence that it has always been so for example the William Vickers tunebook (http://www.dragonflymusic.co.uk/greatnorth.html) dated 1770 and probably compiled in the North east of England includes tunes from England, Scotland, Wales, Ireland, France, and Scandinavia. Much the same goes for English dances. I call my band a ceilidh band but that is just fitting in to current usage, a few decades ago it might have been better to call it a barn dance band, or a country dance band. It is all part of the same melting put of music and dance. Our main criterion for selecting dances is that they can be done by novices with a minimum of instruction, but that still leaves the choice wide open. For music we choose tunes which are good to dance to and fun to play. To be honest the way the tunes are played is usually more important to the dancers than the actual choice of tunes.
-
I started out in the late 1960s as a social dancer and soon became a caller with bands such as England's Green Unpleasant Band, North Circular Accidental Band and the Radstock Band, amongst others. It was another three decades before I began to play the meldoeon at social dances/country dances/ceilidhs or whatever you like to call them.
The one thing that seems to me to have been a consistent characteristic of the music played for these dances over the years I have been involved with them has been the eclectic mix of tunes - English, Irish, Scottish, French, Scandinavian, American; traditional folk tunes, recently written folk tunes, rock/pop songs, TV themes, whimsy. Anything went and still goes! One example sticks in my mind as encapsulating this ecleticism. When asked for a set of step-hop hornpipes, we would play some or all of Harvest Home, Nellie the Elephant, Redesdale Hornpipe, Monty Python's Flying Circus (Liberty Bell March).
-
The Barnes book is a crackers of a collection and is not a is well known over here in the UK as it deserves to be. My copy was given to me by an English friend living in the US.
It contains a lot of the "ceilidh" standards used in England today, as well as a great many of the Playford-style tunes favoured by the more formal "country dance" groups. I think that in the US, you're probably going to find that the latter style of dance is what they consider "English country dance", sometimes done almost as historical re-enactment. In England, this style is popular at English Folk Song and Dance Society dances (generally carried out in rather a plodding, genteel style by people over 65), whereas a wider range of tunes and dances, danced in a much bouncier style by somewhat younger dancers, prevail at "English ceilidh" dances, which can loosely be considered English country dances too. Socially they are possibly more like your "contra" dances. Melodeons are more popular in the ceilidh-style dances, perhaps because of the natural bounce they give to the music (compared with the smoothness of an accordion) but there's quite a bit of overlap between instruments and styles.
So you will find that many melnetters do play for some form of social dancing (i.e. not morris but dances that are mainly for couples, and not as a performance) but probably more for English ceilidhs than Playford-style "country dance".
-
Always a shame, the way Playford gets treated like that by EFDSS and co. Buttocks clenched, nose in the air..... ;D
Some lovely tunes and dances, both of which really respond to being done with welly. I can't believe that they survived from the C18th in such a courtly fashion.
Having grown up with my father's "proper" country dance band, playing the "correct" tune for dances, I've always recognised that some dances really fit their designated tune well, but most, particularly more recent inventions, go to anything with the right tempo and bar count.
At this time of year, this enables you to insert appropriate festive tunes in the middle with impunity.
-
(generally carried out in rather a plodding, genteel style by people over 65)
Steady on! I've never been accused of plodding or being genteel!
;D
-
I think Anahata's point is correct. In the US, many different tunes will work for a specific contra dance (some better than others, of course) but in English Country dancing there are specific tunes for each dance. No reason a B/C accordion wouldn't work. You'll want to get the music ahead of time....they should give you a list of specific tunes/dances that will be called.
-
Always a shame, the way Playford gets treated like that by EFDSS and co. Buttocks clenched, nose in the air..... ;D
...
I think it's time to visit Cecil Sharp House or at least the EFDSS website and see if this stereotypical image still exists in reality.
Take a look at the educational work they do, the support for performers, up-coming projects like the Full English, the digitisation of the library etc.
Howard
-
I did English Country Dance for a Girl Guides badge back in the day. I clearly remember doing a Cumberland Square Eight to "My Love is But a Lassie Yet". However, it's ruined me for country dancing because, as I was one of the older and therefore taller Guides, I had to do the boy dancing and so now whenever I try and do a dance I try to lead. It does put the chaps off a bit.
-
I think the comments about the EFDSS-style dancing (well, my comments at least) were referring to the local groups around the country who run regular dances. The central hub at C# House may well be doing more exciting things, but across the country there is still a lot of elderly plodding going on. And I am told that it is this style of "English country dancing", sometimes in Regency costume, that is most often done in the US, although I'd be happy to be corrected on this.
-
Must admit my mental image of the thing is a bit like in Back to the Future 3 where they've gone back to the Wild West and Emmett is dancing with the schoolteacher... lively partner dances. I've not seen this elderly promenade of which you speak, and it's probably just as well.
-
Here, on the east coast of the U.S., the melodeon is quite common for English Country Dance. There is always a distinction between this type of dancing and Contra Dancing and the bands and dancers are different. One of the difficulties with English Country Dance here is the insistence that there is one "proper" tune for each dance (hence Peter Barnes two great collections of tunes). The Boston Center English Country Dance posted a list of what seemed to be well over 300 different dances they did over the year. Quite a repertory! It makes the ability to sight read quickly almost a necessity. Also no medleys; making arrangements of the tune, to keep it fresh over the period of a long dance, important.
-
We did this,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9zYQb0k6a58&list=UUkDlYPtu3EFTRN-Bajg1K6g&feature=plcp
recently at, http://www.salisburyfolkdance.org.uk/ Whom I joined when I moved here in September.
I'd really only done so called, Barn Dances proir to this. (Oh yes. And some Swedish stuff too)
We only have a band (as such) on occasion. (like this) Otherwise it's CD's.
All a bit more sedate than the "Dippping and Diving" and "Widow Stripping" of the Barn Dance brigade.
Chas
-
In case there's any English ceilidh/barndance players here who don't fully appreciate the distinction Marje has summarised so well, search YouTube for "English Country Dance" and you'll find mostly American dancers doing Playford and similar in a genteel walking style.
The EFDSS used to be controlled by dancers of this sort who weren't all that interested in other forms of dance or song - it isn't now, but there are still folk dance clubs all over the country who do this. It's definitely not for the inexperienced as the figures are complicated. Fidjit's link is a typical example, I guess.
-
The term 'english country dancing' is a very loose one indeed! It can be used interchangeably with 'barn dance' 'hoe down', 'ceilidh' or whatever using much the same formations of dances. Just how one sets the pace for whatever it is deepends , to me , on the clientelle rather than the names of the dances & using the same tunes can very from 'ploddy' through 'jaunty walk, to ' putting some drive into it!'
Similarly I put dancers into one of three catagories 'thorough and precise but ploddy' - ' havn't a clue but can cope with a jaunty walk' - and 'lets have some fun cos reaching the destination is more important than exactly how we get there'. At the risk of stereotyping callers seem to sometimes fit into one or other of these catagories 'bossy and po faced' - ' pleasently cagoling' - and ' lets make this fun'
I enjoy playing for the latter catagory!
george :||: :Ph :|glug
-
...The EFDSS used to be controlled by dancers of this sort who weren't all that interested in other forms of dance or song - it isn't now, ...
I hear that there are even melodeon players on the board of directors!
http://www.efdss.org/front/Governing%20EFDSS/board-of-directors/23 (http://www.efdss.org/front/Governing%20EFDSS/board-of-directors/23)
-
(http://icanhascheezburger.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/funny-pictures-extremeriver-dancing.jpg)
-
Oh terminology....
In North America the term English Country Dance (ECD) has meaning(s) apparently different from the land of its birth.
I would direct all to the Country Dance and Song Society (the U.S. offspring of EDFSS) for definitions etc. of the form as danced in North America.
http://www.cdss.org/ecd.html
I play for Morris and ECD and have danced contras for many (too many?) decades. while Playford may be one of the source documents (there are many "Playford Balls" drawing solely on these tunes/dances) of the repertoire, there have been many additions 'in the style of....'. For many musicians the two volumes by Peter Barnes contain over 90% of the tunes.
-
My thanks to all of you who replied. The tradition here in the wilderburbs of Fairbanks seems to be the more conservative strain of English Country Dance. In contra dance, we use any tune that is danceable that strikes our fancy and play medleys of 3 to 4 tunes per dance. Sometimes, there is music that goes with a dance (such as Petronella) but more often it is left to the band to come up with tunes. Sometimes callers have favorite tunes for some dances (and often we have found they are not particularly good for the dance they call). Most contra musicians play without music, and hold regular practices where we work on arrangements, harmonies, call and answer, improv etc. In English Country Dance, the tune goes with the dance. Everyone in the ECD band I played with (except me) is a great sight reader so they play the music almost effortlessly. I did OK on the slow tunes by ear and barely functional reading but Barbarini's Tamborine left me in the dust. The band is made up of mostly classical musicians and a Celtic harpist. They do not hold band practices. They are very inventive with improv and coming up with harmonies on the fly. As someone described it, the dance was almost a reenactment of an old ritual. Some of the dances we played were:
Barbarini's Tamborine, Alice, Auretti's Dutch Skipper, and Enfield Common (In 3/2 time!). Charlie
-
Wow, that stirred up a hornets' nest of terminology! Most of the social/barn dance bands around the Southern UK nowadays are lead by a box player. There's quite a trend over the last couple of decades to have box and fiddle with a rock group behind them. The band I play in has melodeon, anglo concertina, piano, guitar, fiddle and drums. We play the tunes we like and use our own callers - non-playing spouses - and include some Playford tunes, which can be played with plenty of drive. It's not profitable to have so many in the band, but we enjoy it. We used to have more, but at our age they keep dying off.
I once did a stint as sound engineer for a band with a banjo, but the band leader informed me that after sound checks his channel should be switched off!
Rob.
-
It is very often the case that something like English country dance, Welsh border morris and Irish pubs are unrecognisable to people to the named countries as being something that's actually supposed to be from there.
-
It is very often the case that something like English country dance, Welsh border morris and Irish pubs are unrecognisable to people to the named countries as being something that's actually supposed to be from there.
It should be noted that Welsh border Morris is almost entirely English, only he border is Welsh ;D
-
My point exactly. Sort of the English version of the haka. That "come and have a go if you think you're hard enough" intimidation ritual. :)
-
I once did a stint as sound engineer for a band with a banjo, but the band leader informed me that after sound checks his channel should be switched off!
Rob.
Sound advice (pun shamelessly intended!). What's the difference between a banjo and a trampoline...............? ;D
Graham
-
Similarly I put dancers into one of three catagories 'thorough and precise but ploddy' - ' havn't a clue but can cope with a jaunty walk' - and 'lets have some fun cos reaching the destination is more important than exactly how we get there'.
Do you not have a category like "B****y good dancer and really makes the most of both the dance and the music? >:E
-
there is still a lot of elderly plodding going on.
Again with the "elderly"! Some of these "elderly plodders " are only in their 30s........if it's true that you're as old as you feel then I've been 19 for the last 45 years (except for the odd day when I've been 97....) Age is only a state of mind - I went to school with some people who had been 40 since their second birthday!
Graham
-
[
Do you not have a category like "B****y good dancer and really makes the most of both the dance and the music? >:E
[/quote]
Thats the one whose feet I play to!
george ;)
-
Always a shame, the way Playford gets treated like that by EFDSS and co. Buttocks clenched, nose in the air..... ;D
Some lovely tunes and dances, both of which really respond to being done with welly. I can't believe that they survived from the C18th in such a courtly fashion.
Not sure what the EFDSS has to do with it - the country dance clubs to which my wife and I belong (neither yet 65!) are quite independent and dance a range of styles.
We are indeed among the youngest, but plodding is not encouraged - and some of the dances, properly stepped with dancers who know how to do it, are a pleasure to watch.
On the other hand, as a ceilidh goer (often similar dances, simplified and with more welly) and Morris dancer, it is quite fun to dance in an elegant, courtly style. Like other many other things, it's easy to knock until you actually try to do it well.
Coming back to boxes, I know one melodeon player, Dave Byett, who often plays for a country dance club and it works very well.
-
Well, perhaps "elderly" is a state of mind rather than a number of years - I'm not far off 65 myself, so no slur was intended on those who've got there first. I suspect that what I regard as an "elderly" style of dance is in fact the way a certain cohort of people have been doing in since their young days in the 1960s/70s.
It's really a horses-for-courses thing - if you want to gallop around energetically and even improvise a bit on the moves, you go to the ceilidh-style dances, whereas if you prefer a more stately and restrained style, you to to EFDSS or similar Playford-style dances. There is definitely a difference in the overall age profile of these two types, with some overlap.
We used to go to ceilidhs quite a bit but now it seems to be just the occcasional one-off (weddings etc). My husband is not a natural dancer and couldn't manage anything resembling courtliness, but can cope with the gallumphing style of a ceilidh, having learned that the main thing is to be in the right place at the right time - any refinements are optional.
We have also danced with people who are used to the plodding style, and we actually got told off once for being too energetic and bouncing around. I've also had a go at Scottish Country Dancing, which is very precise and controlled. I was asked, when practising (and you have to practice, there's no caller) not to let my arms flap around loosely but keep them by my sides in case I knocked against someone! (Where's the fun in that?).
-
Like Theo and many others round here, I too play in an English 'ceilidh' band. In England, what to call a dance band who play folk music, has been a bit of a problem for all the years I've been playing, especially as 'ceilidh' isn't an English word. Hugh Taylor and I were founder members of Tumbling Tom more than 30 years ago. The mainstay of our gigs, especially in latter years, has been private functions - weddings, retirements - that sort of thing. In the early days it seemed to me that there were two distinct and parallel scenes - that of the EFDSS type dance club and that of bands like us who, as GPS says, were influeneced by Old Swan, Tiger Moth, EII etc.
This topic was also discussed in the recent issue of EDS magazine and it set us to thinking quite hard about what our role as a band is and whether we should be seeking to do different things. The other day Hugh and I were discussing the possiblity of a monthly get together of dancers and players to go a bit deeper into the techniques of steps, dances, tunes etc.
Ever since Albion Band (I think) used the term 'English Country Dance Band' for a band playing English music for dancing that's been my preferred description of us. We've always tried to keep our repertoire mainly English but as Theo says, there's lots of influences, especially here in the North West of England from Scotland and Ireland. And, Strig, one of the few tunes we've been playing since our beginnings is indeed 'My Love She's But A Lassie Yet' for Cumberland Square Eight, which being in Cumbria, we have played probably thousands of times. It does seem to have acquired a bit of a rockabilly beat to it though over the years. My main thought though is that despite having played in this band for so long, I couldn't really begin to define what 'English Country Dance' is.
-
Reading the wealth of interesting comments here, I'm tempted to recall the old saying, "The meek shall inherit the earth! (er... If that's all right with everybody else?)"
I don't think we should apologise for our culture - but that should not mean rejecting the cultures of others - because tolerance is a great part of our own.
-
And taking that point in a slightly different direction Chris, I think the similarities between English, Scottish, Irish, and European folk dances and music are much greater than the differences.
This struck me most forcibly when in 2003 I visited Estonia and went to a small concert in a pub by two young Estonian musicians who described their repertoire as Estonian traditional tunes, and I recognised about half the tunes they played! We forget that even before cheap air travel people (including musicians) did travel and the music travelled too.
-
I've always thought its not the tune that matters its how you play it. You can take for example an Irish tune and play it in an English way and if its a good tune it will still sound 'right'.
-
Quite right, Theo - the word 'traditional' surely (and simply) means 'something that was frequently done in the past'. The fact that it might have origins outside a given country is irrelevant, I would have thought. In fact the existence of this cross culture is in itself of great interest, as Annie Proulx has written about so brilliantly.
(And of course the word 'Traditional' applied to a piece of music shouldn't really mean the same as 'We don't know who wrote it, and haven't bothered to find out.'!)
-
Most things that are "revivalist" traditional tend to be a romanticised idea of what happened in the past. At best, an educated guess. That said, however, just because we have no idea whether these things are accurate doesn't mean they're not worth doing.
-
You mean .. the women didn't wear circular skirts .. and the larks didn't play melodeons :o
You'll be telling me there's no Father Christmas next :|glug
-
It is very often the case that something like English country dance, Welsh border morris and Irish pubs are unrecognisable to people to the named countries as being something that's actually supposed to be from there.
Try watching Shrewsbury Bull and Pump, and Iron Bridge Iron men dancing Border morris around the Welsh and English border towns. Two of the very best exponents of the art, and always appreciated, wherever they go in the Welsh/English border country. Unreconiseable?? Not on your life!!
-
From what I've gleaned over time......
I think the 'gentle' dances, Playford and gentle EFDSS sorts currently danced have a direct lineage from the gentle folk i.e. the country gentlemen and women who had 'proper' dances in the squire's house and decorum was a necessary part of the evening's etiquette.
When the village band then packed up and went down the pub, or played the next night at a village 'do' with working class people who were not 'gentlefolk' then the rumpy stompy stuff happened, like what we now think of as 'English Country style ceilidhs.
You couldn't do delicate stuff in working boots or hob-nails! ( don't 'spose you'd dance in them, but you get the drift..)
Only my opinion of course..... :|glug
Q
-
There's quite a trend over the last couple of decades to have box and fiddle with a rock group behind them.
Been there, done that. Village hall with a tin roof, bathroom acoustics, fiddle and melodeon playing a duel instead of a duet, three chord trick in D on the guitar to a tune in G, Bass player who wants to be a rock star and the drummer who sounds like he is building a shed. The wall of sound is incredible, but guess what, the dancers are still dancing.
-
There's quite a trend over the last couple of decades to have box and fiddle with a rock group behind them.
Isn't that a bit retro? I was in a couple of bands doing that 30 years ago.... ;D
Graham
-
There's quite a trend over the last couple of decades to have box and fiddle with a rock group behind them.
Isn't that a bit retro? I was in a couple of bands doing that 30 years ago.... ;D
Graham
Some of us are still doing it...but with a second melodeon rather than fiddle .... :||: :|||:
Baz
who finds it interesting that on a site dedicated to melodeons, the spell checker refuses to recognise "melodeon"....
-
It is very often the case that something like English country dance, Welsh border morris and Irish pubs are unrecognisable to people to the named countries as being something that's actually supposed to be from there.
Try watching Shrewsbury Bull and Pump, and Iron Bridge Iron men dancing Border morris around the Welsh and English border towns. Two of the very best exponents of the art, and always appreciated, wherever they go in the Welsh/English border country. Unreconiseable?? Not on your life!!
How very kind...I'll let them know...I don't think any of the Ironmen box players visit here. Ray L. of course is a mainstay of Bull and Pump
Baz
Ex squire of said Ironmen
-
I don't think we should apologise for our culture - but that should not mean rejecting the cultures of others - because tolerance is a great part of our own.
And of course the reverse applies too.
-
True, Ollie - you may be hinting at something, but I'm not sure I would want to go there!
By 'great', I think I really meant 'laudable' rather than necessarily 'extensive'. ;) My point was a limited one, that within 'English country dance music' (whatever that is), there is often material which came from other countries, and we should be proud of that.
-
From what I've gleaned over time......
I think the 'gentle' dances, Playford and gentle EFDSS sorts currently danced have a direct lineage from the gentle folk i.e. the country gentlemen and women who had 'proper' dances in the squire's house and decorum was a necessary part of the evening's etiquette.
When the village band then packed up and went down the pub, or played the next night at a village 'do' with working class people who were not 'gentlefolk' then the rumpy stompy stuff happened, like what we now think of as 'English Country style ceilidhs.
Q
There are also records (dunno where!) that a polite evening started with the more formal dances, but later in the evening the "country dances" were danced. One suspects that most of the older dancers may have retired from the floor by this time, but the record I have in mind, which I think refers to royalty, suggests that they stayed and watched.
But I also think that country and Playford dancing in earlier years had a lot more footwork and action in it, and was prettier to watch, than is perhaps the case now.
-
Malcolm: I remember talking to a respected morris sage about this, as often the people involved with the morris were involved in the village band, mummers etc.
Also in my mind was Thomas Hardy. I can't remember in which book, but there is a story about the village band playing in church and drifting off to sleep, aided by mulled cider :|glug, only to awake, forget where they were and launch into a brisk reel when it should have been a hymn or carol, much to the annoyance and embarrassment of the Squire who had guests for Christmas!
I also have a memory stirring of attending a Hardy lecture at Sidmouth, ( Dave Townsend early 80's? ) as the Hardy players and Melstock band thing was in an embryonic stage. The lecture reflected on Thomas Hardy and Hardy Snr. were both respected fiddlers, as I'm sure you're aware. I do remember them saying they played until the top couple ( master and mistress of the Big House !) danced all the way down the hall and back in longway set dances, so dances went on for a long while and those playing tunes often improvised to prevent inanity :D
but I digress......
Q
-
I believe it was Hardy who described country dances, where the furniture was removed from the dining room and the farmers stripped off their shirts and danced with great gusto until their faces were the colour of their sweat soaked flannel vests.
Rob.
-
Rob: Have you any idea where such references can be found?
.... I find it all quite interesting.
It reminds me of my Gran, who remembered before WWI talked of 'the men' returning from the pub and going to one person's house to sing all night, another time to play and another night to step dance ( that was in East Devon, where they too stepped, it's just on 'Dartmoor' they managed to kept going longer so created the illusion that it only happened there ).
She of course used to end with " and none of those lads came back so it stopped.... " A common comment, and it happened all over the place as we all know.
Q
-
Hi Baz,
I remember once being at a day of dance, and standing on one end of the Iron bridge, and watching the Iron men and the 7 Gilders appearing from the opposite side of the bridge through a mist. The riot of colours, the sound of metal shod clogs, and the sheer noise of the musicians echoing across the valley was spine tinglers.
The Iron men are on of my favourite border sides.
Doug
A former Carlisle musician and Border morris dancer.
-
Rob: Have you any idea where such references can be found?
Sorry, it was just a vague memory of somebody else quoting something...
Rob.
-
Hi Rob, I know exactly what you mean.....
One day I'll pin it all down with proper references!
cheers
Q
-
I think the village band reference is from "Under the Greenwood Tree".
-
thanks Tufty, will keep an eye open for that.
Q
-
Tufty - just ordered it from Amazon, so will find out later!
cheers
Q
-
there is a story about the village band playing in church and drifting off to sleep, aided by mulled cider :|glug, only to awake, forget where they were and launch into a brisk reel
Q
And to make it worse the tune was "Devil Amongst the Tailors"... (:)
Some time last week on Radio 4 was "Thomas Hardy's I-Pod"...worth a listen, if a bit po faced in places (if you can be po faced on the radio)...
Baz
-
and the sheer noise of the musicians echoing across the valley
Yes, as amplifiers go, the old Severn Gorge takes a bit of beating
Cheers Doug, you're too kind...
Baz
-
Baz: Yes I remembered that bit too!
Will try and listen to Hardy's ipod, it sounds my cup of tea.
cheers
Q
-
Be interested to know what you think of the Hardy programme. I found it very mixed, but I won't prejudice you by saying what I liked and what I hated. Judge for yourself.