Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 03:22:43 AM

Title: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 03:22:43 AM
Hi Everyone -
so for the Christmas break I'm working on designing and cutting out a custom grille for my Cairdin mini 21 -

If interested, please take a look at this grille design and tell me if it has enough opening to allow for adequate air flow -

I'm planning to use 1/4 inch baltic birch - in the attached design, the tan is wood and the maroon is a fabric covering for the openings --

comments/opinions welcome --

Reed
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: old geezer on December 19, 2011, 05:13:52 AM
I suggest a couple of stencil lines through the stretched M cutout to add strength to the center, or to add hidden supports behind the fabric.

as to adequate air flow; others may have some experience as to sufficient opening required.
looking at the growl end of a Hohner, it doesn't require a large amount of open area to sound large bass reeds and cords.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: RGF on December 19, 2011, 05:17:57 AM
Open area aside, I'm guessing that there might be some lack of sturdiness. For lack of a more accurate or correct description, I'll refer to what looks something like the letter "M". I think the wood beneath that horizontal opening will need to have some structural connection to the part above that opening, perhaps some vertical pieces mounted behind the fabric or something. Otherwise it looks like it could easily fall victim to a blow. Just doesn't strike me as having enough structural unity. Or maybe I'm just not envisioning it correctly.
Bob
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: RGF on December 19, 2011, 05:33:27 AM
PS

Nice design, though. What's the significance?

My guess: M for Munson, oak leaves for mom & dad, acorns for four lovely daughters.

Bob
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: forrest on December 19, 2011, 06:09:53 AM
Airflow will probably not be hindered, although the volume and timbre might be something to consider.  There may be a marked difference with how the inner row sounds compared to the outer, as well as where the notes are located, sequence-wise. In other words, you may find that volume and timbre of  the reeds located behind the wood areas could be significantly different than that of the reeds behind the fabric.
  It's quite a lovely design, though.  (:)
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 02:31:22 PM
Thanks for the comments - good points - I will take these into consideration -
Bob - you are very perceptive! I actually hadn't thought of that - other than the M for Munson (and melodeon.net) - with the oak and acorns idea, I was just going with shapes I like from nature -

I'm curious to see how the sound of the box is changed by the grille - I'll make a cardboard cut out first just to get a sense - it might sound horrible! If it makes the box quieter my family will like it ;)

R
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 04:40:26 PM
got motivated and knocked out a rough prototype/test of concept -

the design is very flimsy and I don't think it would hold up as it is - so as per Geez's suggestion I'm looking into putting a lattice patern inside the M -

air flow seemed adequate

I like the sound of the cardboard grille - it mellows the sound of the box - where the metal grille is bright and brilliant, with the cardboard grille the sound is a bit more mellow/rounded off -

take a listen - maybe I'm only hearing what I want to hear --
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtGmMoqhZaI (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtGmMoqhZaI)
compare with the previously posted video with normal grille
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 04:42:47 PM
I can't tell any difference... curse youtube sound quality -
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 06:05:28 PM
looking ghetto with some black speaker grille fabric off an old set of jenson speakers - doesn't effect the sound
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: RGF on December 19, 2011, 07:06:43 PM
I don't know why you would necessarily have to put lattice into that space and disrupt the flow of the "M". Why not make the grille, attach the red fabric to the backside, and then put some 'crossbars' (for lack of a better term) across the gap, behind the fabric.  If you were to paint them the same color as the cloth, and then glue them through the cloth to the backside of the upholstered grille, I'd should think that they would do the job and be almost invisible.
Bob
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: tedrick on December 19, 2011, 10:41:50 PM
ah! Good point - thanks Bob - yes - it would be easier to do it that way - the lattice work looks nice but would make for more difficult cutting -
I'm hoping my friends in the Art department can let me use the laser cutter the week between Christmas and New Years - I might go with lighter plywood so it cuts easier -

I'm thinking of adding felt behind the grill like sound baffling inside a speaker -

ala: grille || fabric || felting on solid parts
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 20, 2011, 04:02:20 AM
You may want to try the really fine grain plywood that is sold at hobby stores for the grill. This would get rid of some of the structural issues you may have with the cutout design. You can veneer it with your choice of wood.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Telemorris on December 20, 2011, 05:45:36 AM
One option that I used to use when reinforcing the rosette carving for a lute: glue bracing in several spots but color the glued surface with black marker first. Use a clear drying glue such as hide glue. You can barely see the bracing because of the shadow inside the box itself. Yes, you'll have to glue the fabric to the back of the bracing but if you make the bracing 4mm thick it should do a fine job of supporting the pieces of the grille and look good. I know using a marker to color the bracing sound odd, but I learned it from a top notch luthier when I studied with him many years ago. Couple the coloring with a black fabric and you'll have a striking grille and never notice the bracing unless you're looking for it. I know I've seen melodeons with black fabric behind the grille.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: old geezer on December 20, 2011, 08:27:14 AM
Yes, you'll have to glue the fabric to the back of the bracing but if you make the bracing 4mm thick it should do a fine job of supporting the pieces of the grille and look good.

If space is allowable for 4mm bracing over the cutout, then cut a 1.5mm relief in the brace over the opening.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Malcolm Austen on December 20, 2011, 10:02:27 AM
Perhaps we should all have a go and have “grill of the month” or just a Christmas special to use up some of that holiday season time off and some of that waste packaging.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 20, 2011, 10:10:41 AM
Go for it.  Here are a couple Frans v d Aa sent over when I was thinking about grilles.  The condor is clearly from his time in South America. Sadly that humming bird is a unique 'one off' for a client but it gave me ideas ..

I'm definitely not going off to Bolivia m'self!  :|glug
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Malcolm Austen on December 20, 2011, 12:09:53 PM
A quick cut and paste in Solidworks.
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: oggiesnr on December 20, 2011, 12:41:53 PM
Quarter inch seems a bit chunky, I'd have thought that you'd get away with 3 mm (1/8)

Steve
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: RGF on December 20, 2011, 03:05:50 PM
Here ya go, Reed......talk about an oak-themed grille!
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: old geezer on December 20, 2011, 08:20:20 PM
interchangeable grills for every occasion

now there's an idea  ::)
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Lyra on December 21, 2011, 12:40:57 AM
Would that constitute a mixed grille?
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Neil_M on December 31, 2011, 05:02:54 PM
Now that's funny!!  ;D
Title: Re: designing my own grille
Post by: Tom on January 08, 2012, 06:37:32 PM
Alright- Newbie questions.
Am i right in thinking that i can replace the grille on my (totally knackered) pokerwork with a piece of good wood (say birch) and, as long as there is a fair amount of open space spaced evenly across the new design, it should work?
A wood grille will soften the sound?
Do i need to treat the wood in some way?

please forgive my ignorance...
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal