Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on December 22, 2011, 03:39:35 AM

Title: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 22, 2011, 03:39:35 AM
I have had one "expert" tell me that I should play and keep one accordion and not switch between different sizes and weighted boxes.  The theory this chap had was that as you become more accomplished you become more comfortable with the performance, weight and size of the one box you play consistently.  While I find this to be logical I also have no wish to just play one box.  I switch between two and three voice boxes and soon a four voice.  Is this detrimental to my learning and playing?  Or is this complementary to it?
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: tedrick on December 22, 2011, 03:57:23 AM
I can see the logic in this idea -
but there are plenty of examples of players who play and record on 2 or more boxes

I think the musician has the ability to adjust between instruments - especially if they play on those instruments several hours per day -
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 22, 2011, 05:22:57 AM
All my boxes feel very different from each other in size, proportion, weight, action and feel, and the 1-rows demand a different approach to the instrument, but I can't say I've ever found that a hindrance.  I bought my first 1-row about 18 months after my first ever 2-row (an Erica) and I don't think it held me back.

Graham
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: george garside on December 22, 2011, 09:18:38 AM
I would add that if owning/using several boxes, particularly of different systems eg 4th apart  , semitone chromatic,  1.2 &3 rows  , different size buttons , varied weights etc it is very important  to play them all regularly & if possible in more or lessequal proportions.

 As  an example I now rarely play my 3 row 80 bass paolo soprani ( because the weight doesn't go well with angina!)  - ( might reluctantly think about selling it) but use my 48 bss casali quite regularly.  As a result the paolo 'takes a bit of getting used to' whenever I play it.  On the other hand I can switch  easilyregularly played DG, Bc& BCC#  boxes without detriment.

george
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Accordion Dave on December 22, 2011, 02:04:49 PM
I play a variety of button accordions and piano accordions.

I am able to switch between the button boxes without too much difficulty as long as I remember the way the bass buttons are configured on a particular box, and whether I am playing one row or two rows on the treble side.

On the piano accordions the spacing of the buttons and the keys can be a problem. I am used to playing full sized 120 bass  piano accordions.

The "lady's" models have keys that are narrower and closer together. That presents some problems when jumping from octave to octave as the distance is different. 
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 22, 2011, 03:55:18 PM
There can be advantages to playing different instuments.  Some tunes just sit better on a particular box, especially when it comes to the accidentals.  It takes a few minutes to get into a significantly different size and action, though.

Rob
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 23, 2011, 04:07:24 PM
it is very important  to play them all regularly
george

I agree.  I play my two voice, 8 bass Nik most of the time, and even switching to the three voice, 12 bass Pastourelle III makes me feel the strain in my arm.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: nfldbox on December 23, 2011, 04:13:14 PM
I certainly can play them all but while I can switch to the one row easily, switching to the old Hohner can be a bit of a trial. One possible reason is the same button configuration as the cairdin--albeit with a third button start--and thus no obvious thing to mark the difference for me. My guess, however, is rather that the Hohner just IS a bit clumsy and it's not really my fault ;D
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 23, 2011, 04:17:25 PM
it is very important  to play them all regularly
george

I agree.  I play my two voice, 8 bass Nik most of the time, and even switching to the three voice, 12 bass Pastourelle III makes me feel the strain in my arm.

Yes - most of the time I play my Pastourelle II; but then swapping to the 1940s-ish 2915 (still 2-voice) it feels featherweight - as though they'd forgotten to put the reeds in!  But it also has a much "softer" bellows, so the lighter weight is offset by the extra bellows effort..........

I also put in a fair few hours on the 1-rows - a totally different animal, and to my mind much more physically demanding, despite the light weight.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Steve C. on January 20, 2012, 02:02:34 AM
If you have lot of time, switching between boxes is great fun.  Especially if they are very different. But you will learn, overall, more slowly.

But, if you "want to get good" and learn a bunch of tunes, and play them decently, sticking to one box really does help.

Even boxes with the same layout, but different feel can slow you down (though provide variety)

As an example, you can play all over the place on one row with a Lilly, the push and pull happen so fast.  But don't try it on a Benny, with the heavy bass end.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: oggiesnr on January 20, 2012, 08:49:12 AM
Couple of thoughts.

The biggest problem I have is between switching between the Loffet and the Black Pearl when playing in G (or Em) because on the Loffet I play upper register (it's a G/C) so all cross rowing and chords are in different places as are all the pull notes (one button out).  I come to the conclusion that I need to learn one set of tunes on the BP and another on the Loffet.

Second point is that whilst I'm getting the strength back in my wrist I actually find that the bigger Loffet is easier to play as it requires less bellows movement than the BP.

Steve
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: george garside on January 20, 2012, 10:58:36 AM
and a couple of thoughtsw from me!

1. Avoid MAD and stick to just one box untill you have a good degree of competence on it.  Trying to get the hang a  several boxes as a beginner brings the cliche 'jack of all trades and master of none!' to mind.

2.  If have several boxes  , perhaps of  different but similar systems eg DG.CF ,BC (C#) or perhaps include definately different systems eg piano acc, continental chromatic.   Play all your tunes on all your boxes ( subject of course to technical limitations of instrument eg lack of accidentals on one row)

3. Occasionaly play all your tunes in each and every key the box is capable of and for BCC#, piano acc & continental this includes all 12 major keys.  It can be fun & definately familiarises one with what is where on the box. >:E

george
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Sandy Flett on January 20, 2012, 12:34:09 PM
Last September, on return from holiday, I set about learning all sorts of new stuff on my recently modified Hohner-Tommy. I forgot all the lessons I had learned the hard way in previous years, and after a week or so of intense playing/learning I ended up severely aggravating the (long standing) tendinitis in my right arm. My physio assured me that rest from the offending activity was essential, so I put the Tommy in its box and have left it there to date (as my arm has still to recover fully). Oddly enough, however, playing the piano accordion does not aggravate the tendinitis - I think something to do with my arm moving up and down as I play rather than being anchored in one position as with the melodeon. So I have concentrated all my playing and development on the PA for the past few months and (to get back to the subject of the thread) I am amazed at the number of little improvements that have crept in, and the more challenging tunes that now seem to be a bit more manageable. In fact, now I do not feel like diluting the progress I am making by going back to spending any significant time/development on the melodeon. I am sure I will ease myself back into playing melodeon at some stage, but there is something very satisfying about "playing better than ever" through a strong focus (and lots of practice).
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on January 20, 2012, 10:12:43 PM
i bought a nine switch 4 voice box so i wouldnt have to buy / learn to play another box.
but i still bought one...
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Ollie on January 20, 2012, 10:21:31 PM
I think this is very true when you're a beginner. However, once you get proficient on the instrument, I don't see why you shouldn't branch out and try something different.

None of my boxes have the same layout, two of them have gleichtons, they're in 3 different keys, both my 12 basses have different bass arrangements, etc etc, and I don't have trouble at all switching between them, and I don't think it affects my playing at all.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 20, 2012, 10:37:21 PM
 
  Shame you  b'gg'r'd off so soon at the weekend then young Jedi - I was offering a CBA out on loan
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Ollie on January 20, 2012, 11:03:49 PM

  Shame you  b'gg'r'd off so soon at the weekend then young Jedi - I was offering a CBA out on loan


There's a line in the sand... :P
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Lester on January 20, 2012, 11:26:59 PM

  Shame you  b'gg'r'd off so soon at the weekend then young Jedi - I was offering a CBA out on loan


There's a line in the sand... :P

 ;D.  And that is spoken as an English Concertina player  >:E
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: diatocz on January 21, 2012, 08:17:19 AM
Personally, I change accordion by type of music I play. For the traditional dance I take my two rows Loffet. French musette waltzes for, I prefer my Hohner with a strong vibrato, For music-intensive sharps and flats, of course I take my two rows and a half ..
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: oggiesnr on January 21, 2012, 08:45:17 AM
I think this is very true when you're a beginner. However, once you get proficient on the instrument, I don't see why you shouldn't branch out and try something different.

None of my boxes have the same layout, two of them have gleichtons, they're in 3 different keys, both my 12 basses have different bass arrangements, etc etc, and I don't have trouble at all switching between them, and I don't think it affects my playing at all.

Ah but you're still young and agile, some of us have ossified (pickled) brains  >:E

Steve
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: AirTime on January 21, 2012, 04:54:51 PM
This is an interesting (& pertinent) thread!  I started with a small PA & then quickly realized that the DBA was used for the music I liked best (& in fact, the PA is, for the most part, used for music that I barely like at all).

I picked up one, & then another Pokerwork. This was joined by a (very) old Hohner one-row (that is not in playable condition yet) & then a Hohner Morgane & another vintage Hohner. Although the Morgane & the Pokerworks are significantly different in "feel", they are essentially the same 2 voiced instruments, so switching makes little appreciable difference to my (lack of) technique.

However, Ebay is a constant temptation: there's a fascinating array of 3 voices, 4 voices, 2.5 rows, 3 rows, clubs, de-clubbed clubs, 12 basses, 16 basses, stradella basses, German, French, Italian, celluloid, wood, & sparklies on offer.  And that's without getting sidetracked by concertinas & CBAs! Surely, there's no other instrument with this variety of options available (& at bargain prices too!).

I realize that I'm probably better off focusing on one box until my skills develop however.  :||:



(There is this old, old Italian 3 row with a stradella bass though that is sooo purdy ...)
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 22, 2012, 01:21:09 PM
My main two boxes are a Castagnari Benny and a 2.6 row instrument I made on a course with Emmanuel Pariselle, which I have called an 'Ellis Pariselle'. The EP has a lighter action and more responsive reeds than the CB, so I find that I can play tunes more expressively on the former than on the latter. However, the biggest difference is with the basses. The distance of the jump from the G/D/C basses at the bottom to the Eb/F#/Bb/F basses at the top is greater on the EP than on the CB, which causes me to miss the button sometimes. I am sure that it would be less of a problem if I stuck to just one box, but where would be the fun in that?

Changing to my one-row Cajun box is much easier because it feels so different from the EP and the CB that I think my mind regards it as a completely different species.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Hello on January 23, 2012, 10:52:06 AM
I think that playing multiple instruments of a similar ilke is actually beneficial and develops transferrable skills.

For example, playing the BCC# is, for me, about 10X harder than playing the melodeon. However, when some mastery of it is achieved, then playing the melodeon becomes that much easier. You are also able to expect more from yourself and then push to achieve that, sometimes in directions that, had you not played another instrument, you wouldn't have considered.

Similarly, my pokerwork is Chinese with terrible action (lots of elastic bands replacing the broken springs) and huge button travel. But I like playing it because if you can get good results on that, then when you play a better box you're in a much better position to make the most of it.

Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 23, 2012, 03:44:59 PM
I have a couple of Club boxes which still have the original layout and although I have never used them outside the home, using them from time to time has made me more aware of different fingering options which transfer to the other boxes.

Rob.
Title: Re: Switching between accordions and the affect on learning and skill
Post by: bb23 on January 23, 2012, 04:32:40 PM
I have had one "expert" tell me that I should play and keep one accordion and not switch between different sizes and weighted boxes.  The theory this chap had was that as you become more accomplished you become more comfortable with the performance, weight and size of the one box you play consistently...

I think the expert's theory should be demoted to hypothesis pending completion of a doubled-blinded randomized controlled trial
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal