Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Dazbo on December 23, 2011, 01:02:08 PM
-
I ordered this box in the middle of June and was told it would be a 6 month wait. I went for a two row, three voice with a stop for the low treble reed and to remove thirds from the chords. Cosmetically, I went for the natural wood look.
First impressions are that it looks great and sounds great and very well put together.
Only one minor niggle has come to light so far - some of the wetness is a bit variable but most people wouldn't notice.
A few things to get used to: the buttons don't have a positive end of their travel (like on a pokerwork) and the air button slides rather than pushed in (again like a pokerwork) and the overall shape and size compared to my Tommy.
All in All - well pleased :D
(photos to follow probably after Xmas but can be seen on my facebook page - although it might only be for friends)
-
ongratulations on your new Eric Martin!! An excellent early christmas present. These melodeons really are special, different, but special. John Spiers has one, and it's a real gem. I owned one myself until August, and I really regret selling it, but alas, I needed the cash:(
I hope it gives you immense enjoyment. I'm looking forward to seeing the pics
Happy Christmas.
-
Welcome back Darren. Not seen so much of you on melnet lately. Look forward to seeing / hearing the new box. This should be sodifferent from your Organetto's.
I'm trying to do a video for youtube of my Mod53A Giustozzi, similar LMM with L stop. Can't get everything to work together yet, video / computer, recorder etc not the box or playing.
Have a good Christmas, look forward to the new year offerings.
Martin
-
Looking forward to having a go in the new year. Plleeeeeeaaaase ;D Have a good squeezy Christmas!
Lizzy x
-
Congratulations, Darren!
I look forward to seeing your new box and (like Liz) having a go, please!
-
And a very jealous Christmas to you too!!!
-
Nice one Darren.
I love Eric's boxes although the one I have is rather agriculturally built and has needed much fettling.
It's my favourite D/G box and has many admirers.
-
Can't believe that I've had this box almost 5 years now. It didn't get as much playing as it should have had for the first few years (stuck to my Tommy for most things in public) but since my wife decided she needed a box lighter that a Black Pearl II it seems to have become hers.
So I still love playing it and really love the extremely low bass notes on the left hand side.
Not a box for a beginner I think (you might spend too long fighting with it rather than playing it which might put you off) but definitely highly recommended
Darren
-
Not a box for a beginner I think (you might spend too long fighting with it rather than playing it which might put you off) ...
That doesn't sound like a ringing endorsement! What do you mean exactly?
-
I'm sure it is a ringing endorsement and I know exactly what Darren means as I have one myself.
They're not the easiest boxes to control, they eat a lot of air and throw it through the reeds in bucketloads, the sound is very direct and raucous. Maintenance has proved to be harder than for most of the other modern boxes I own ... it's very easy to bend the metal rods that attach the pallets to the buttons because it doesn't have a grille, the buttons have fallen off, the air button mechanism has broken, the wood the thirds stop was screwed in was so soft that the thread has gone and needed replacing, springs go quite often on the keyboard, the bellows aren't the strongest and the corners have fallen off, the black paint finish chips very easily, the treble reeds go out of tune very very often and the bass reeds choke under high pressure and this is clearly due to the design of the bass reed blocks.
But after all that which are problems that would make me try to sell it and get something else in nearly every circumstance ... my Eric Martin has an amazing character and a power that is so very different from every other box I've ever played that it's worth the hassle ... it sounds more like a 1 row 4 stop box on the treble side than any 2 row 4 voice box I've ever tried despite only having 3 voices. It's not a box for a beginner - but it's definitely a box to aspire to.
-
I don't know what to say after that! :o
-
They're not the easiest boxes to control, they eat a lot of air and throw it through the reeds in bucketloads, the sound is very direct and raucous. Maintenance has proved to be harder than for most of the other modern boxes I own ... it's very easy to bend the metal rods that attach the pallets to the buttons because it doesn't have a grille, the buttons have fallen off, the air button mechanism has broken, the wood the thirds stop was screwed in was so soft that the thread has gone and needed replacing, springs go quite often on the keyboard, the bellows aren't the strongest and the corners have fallen off, the black paint finish chips very easily, the treble reeds go out of tune very very often and the bass reeds choke under high pressure and this is clearly due to the design of the bass reed blocks.
But after all that which are problems that would make me try to sell it and get something else in nearly every circumstance ... my Eric Martin has an amazing character and a power that is so very different from every other box I've ever played that it's worth the hassle ... it sounds more like a 1 row 4 stop box on the treble side than any 2 row 4 voice box I've ever tried despite only having 3 voices. It's not a box for a beginner - but it's definitely a box to aspire to.
I must say, I loved the sound of Katie's "green 'un" when I heard the CD, and was hugely impressed with the box when she actually let me "have a go on it". They're the only new 2-row box that (I've played and) I might aspire to owning...
-
I must say, I loved the sound of Katie's "green 'un" when I heard the CD, and was hugely impressed with the box when she actually let me "have a go on it". They're the only new 2-row box that (I've played and) I might aspire to owning...
Yes - I was impressed by it too. So much so that I nearly bought it when it was previously up for sale at Melodeons at Witney. But I dithered just a bit too long and Katie (who happened to be there as a tutor) went for it instead, for which I was supremely grateful as she solved my dilemma for me. It has turned out to be a lovely box and Katie plays it gloriously. The box could not have gone to a better home. (:)
In case anyone is wondering, 'Katie' is of course Katie Howson of this forum and co-director of the East Anglian traditional Music Trust (http://www.eatmt.org.uk/index.htm).
-
Not a box for a beginner I think (you might spend too long fighting with it rather than playing it which might put you off) ...
That doesn't sound like a ringing endorsement! What do you mean exactly?
Squeezy has hit the nail on the head. Getting used to playing the Martin whilst trying to learn how to play a melodeon could put many off. To my mind you want a lightweight box with as few ideosyncrasies as possible to learn to play a melodeon on an the Martin doesn't quite fit that bill. Like you wouldn't recommend someone to learn on a Handry 18 ;)
-
Maintenance has proved to be harder than for most of the other modern boxes I own ... it's very easy to bend the metal rods that attach the pallets to the buttons because it doesn't have a grille, the buttons have fallen off, the air button mechanism has broken, the wood the thirds stop was screwed in was so soft that the thread has gone and needed replacing, springs go quite often on the keyboard, the bellows aren't the strongest and the corners have fallen off, the black paint finish chips very easily, the treble reeds go out of tune very very often and the bass reeds choke under high pressure and this is clearly due to the design of the bass reed blocks.
Fortunately, I've not come across most of these apart from the bass C note choking occassionally when I try and give it some welly.
... my Eric Martin has an amazing character and a power that is so very different from every other box I've ever played that it's worth the hassle ... it sounds more like a 1 row 4 stop box on the treble side than any 2 row 4 voice box I've ever tried despite only having 3 voices. It's not a box for a beginner - but it's definitely a box to aspire to.
That's it in a nutshell
-
Not a box for a beginner I think (you might spend too long fighting with it rather than playing it which might put you off) ...
That doesn't sound like a ringing endorsement! What do you mean exactly?
.. To my mind you want a lightweight box with as few ideosyncrasies as possible to learn to play a melodeon on an the Martin doesn't quite fit that bill. Like you wouldn't recommend someone to learn on a Handry 18 ;)
That makes sense.
-
Darren, I suspect you haven't subjected yours to quite such an extreme regime as I have - and most boxes complain about it in some way sooner or later! Your box is a similar age to mine too! I'm sure with a careful owner and gentle occasional playing they'd last a lifetime.
The right hand side is the real king on these - the sense of pure raw power I get from mine is exhilarating when I play it ... and they can also cope with surprisingly gentle stuff too.
-
I've managed to try out a couple of Martin 2 rows (and they are good fun) but has anyone got any experience with his 1 row boxes? I'd assume they are similarly rowdy, but I've never seen one in person.
-
The right hand side is the real king on these - the sense of pure raw power I get from mine is exhilarating when I play it ...
To what would you attribute this raw power?
Are there design features that are unique to this box?
-
Darren, I suspect you haven't subjected yours to quite such an extreme regime as I have - and most boxes complain about it in some way sooner or later! Your box is a similar age to mine too! I'm sure with a careful owner and gentle occasional playing they'd last a lifetime.
The right hand side is the real king on these - the sense of pure raw power I get from mine is exhilarating when I play it ... and they can also cope with surprisingly gentle stuff too.
Squeezy, your so right mine's had a very sedate life compared to yours and the quiet stuff sounds really nice too :||:
-
The right hand side is the real king on these - the sense of pure raw power I get from mine is exhilarating when I play it ...
To what would you attribute this raw power?
Are there design features that are unique to this box?
I think it's fairly simple to be honest: Binci a mano reeds, open pallets, large holes, a keyboard mechanism which lifts the pallets a good distance from the soundboard and presumably a well engineered set of treble reedblocks to make the most of all of the previous points.
As I said before that really is let down by the bizzarre single reed block which holds all the reeds for bass and chords that severely wastes the potential of the good Binci reeds in there by sending the air in all kinds of strange directions and through chambers and holes that are too small to do justice to them.
But the box is all about the right hand really. I've had it in my mind to design a completely new left hand to screw in place that could make it in to an absolute winner ... 12 spoon basses seemed like an appropriate match ... but it's a lot of research and skills to apply in order to even attempt a prototype!
-
The right hand side is the real king on these - the sense of pure raw power I get from mine is exhilarating when I play it ...
To what would you attribute this raw power?
Are there design features that are unique to this box?
I think it's fairly simple to be honest: Binci a mano reeds, open pallets, large holes...
Square or round holes?
-
Square holes. Round pegs.
-
I have only had the opportunity to play a one row 4 stop Eric Martin D box and I really liked the sound and feel of the treble keyboard. I got to compare it with one of Marc Savoys Acadian(mine) an Junior Martin, and a Pointe Noir( made by "Dick" richard)box at the same session. I liked it the best of the five mentioned in this post.