Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on December 26, 2011, 09:45:37 PM
-
does any one have a recomendation for a budget portable tuner suitable for free reeds?
-
Ihave a Snark SN2 I bought recently. It is the easiest tuner I have ever used. It is very accurate, and has a huge tuning space note to note which makes it even easier to use.
It will record note, or interval played, either accoustically, or via vibration. The vibration sensor gives an immediate read out of all the notes played, and on a 3 reed box, it's interesting to get a perfectly pictched note, then remove either set of reeds, and get a flat or sharp reading from the same button!!
http://leftyfretz.com/review-snark-clip-on-guitar-tuner/
I think I paid £12 for mine.
-
Another vote for the Snark. Mary got one to replace the so called "Intelli-tuner" for use on her banjo. It detects the correct note instantly (important on a banjo when you don't have much time before the sound decays) and gives a very clear display.
-
looks like il go for that one then !
so if you tune a two voice box with this little tuner , and you tune e.g, a c reed surley when you tune the other c reed (on a two voice box) you end up with a very dry tuning, is that correct?
-
looks like il go for that one then !
so if you tune a two voice box with this little tuner , and you tune e.g, a c reed surley when you tune the other c reed (on a two voice box) you end up with a very dry tuning, is that correct?
Only if you tune both reeds to exactly the same pitch. I'd guess the Snark, like most small electronic tuners, will have a +/- scale, probably calibrated in cents, so that you can see a) exactly how flat or sharp the string or reed is that you want to tune and b) the exact degree of sharpness (or "wetness") when you're tuning the second reed. Both my small tuners are like that, and once you've established a degree of sharpness/wetness/tremolo/whatever that you like on one pair of reeds it's relatively easy to use that as a reference to give you a rough degree of sharpness for all the other pairs, which you then refine by ear.
-
Another vote for the Snark. Mary got one to replace the so called "Intelli-tuner" for use on her banjo.
My wife bought an "Intelli-tuner" some time ago, oddly enough it won't stay put on the headstock of my Ovation Balladeer and just slips off. It cost a tidy sum at time and seemed no better than many similar devices I've seen and she reverted to a more conventional electronic tuner resting on a music stand shortly thereafter. The Snark sounds intriguing, I'll have to check one out!
-
If by cheap you mean FREE try
http://code.google.com/p/ctuner/ (http://code.google.com/p/ctuner/)
Runs on your PC a
nd written by Bill Farmer of this parish
-
If by cheap you mean FREE try
http://code.google.com/p/ctuner/ (http://code.google.com/p/ctuner/)
Runs on your PC a
nd written by Bill Farmer of this parish
Excellent it is too - but gypsylad asked for portable as well (which I suppose it is if you install it on a netbook!) ;)
-
The cheapest portable I've come across is the Strobosoft on an iPhone or iPad at £6.99 or so. It works really well, but you need to get someone to give you their old iPhone. It may work on an iPod, I don't know. When my daughter, who has all the toys a bloke could want, gets bored with her macbook I might have a go at producing a version of my tuner on an iPhone.
-
The Peterson app for iPhone or iPad really is excellent, it is the most precise tuner I've used and easily shows the small differences (less than 1 cent) that you get when changing how hard you blow the reed. The big problem I always found with any of the LCD display tuners is that you have no scope for judging a deviation less than the range that the tuner is programmed to consider in tune which I think is typically +/- 1 cent, but may be more for some models.
-
I've just tested this, the Peterson strobe display still moves very slowly at 0.1 of a cent. It differs from my tuner by 0.2 of a cent at 440 Hz. That's with a steady tone. I can't get a steady enough note out of a single reed to check it any closer than about 0.4 of a cent.
The thing it does which I think is really clever is to blur part of the strobe display when it is moving quickly so it doesn't appear to be going backwards. The blurred part doesn't move.
-
The Strobosoft App will work with an iPod but you need to buy a plug in microphone (very inexpensive and tiny) as this type of device doesn't normally have any means of inputting sound!
-
to be honest, i think " idiot proof " would have been a better description of what im after ...
-
right, ive decide on a snark, i guess if you tune one reed a few dots before the corect note and the coresponding reed a couple dots after the corect note, thats how you achieve wet tuning? :|bl
-
right, ive decide on a snark, i guess if you tune one reed a few dots before the corect note and the coresponding reed a couple dots after the corect note, thats how you achieve wet tuning? :|bl
Not only wet but Dedic/Vienna tuning too
(the old fashioned way was one reed on pitch, the other sharp)
You need to work out how many dots sharp and flat to go then... depends on how wet you want and also on the pitch of the note - as far as I can see the dots represent 2.5 cents each on the Snark. You need to go fewer dots away on the high notes and more dots on the low notes.
-
its definatly going to be trial and error! just sorted out a tuning table, and the snark is about to be posted! do u tune by the tuner and then fine tune by ear?
-
its definatly going to be trial and error! just sorted out a tuning table, and the snark is about to be posted! do u tune by the tuner and then fine tune by ear?
If you are tuning a two voice box, there will be two sets of reeds on each reed block, one will be about 'at pitch' (M), the other will be tuned sharp (M+).
Use your electronic tuner to identify which is which (temporarily blank off one set of reeds with a slip of paper in the reed tongue, so you only hear a single reed).
Once you've identified this, blank off the entire row of M+ reeds using a strip of paper under the reed block to blank off the ports. Make sure the M reeds are still unobstructed.
You need to decide whether you are going to tune 'conventionally' (M and M+) or 'Dedic' tuning (M- and M+). For a first tuning project, I would recommend the former, it's just easier to do.
Using your tuner as a guide, tune the M reeds to 'at pitch'. This might take you a good few hours (days) initially. Go very slowly and check, check, check all the time. Remember that the pitch of the reeds 'in the box' will be different from the pitch when the reed blocks are out of the box, so always carry out your final tuning with the reed blocks mounted in the box. Also remember to try out intervals such as fifths and octaves as you go along, to make sure they sound right to your ears, regardless of what the tuner might be indicating.
Once you are happy with the M reeds, remove the paper blank from the M+ reeds. You can either then blank off the M reeds and tune the M+ reeds using the tuner as a guide, or else (better) to have both M and M+ reeds sounding together and adjust the M+ reeds a bit at a time until you achieve the desired tremolo rate (which is a matter of personal taste).
Finally, remember that before you even start tuning, you need to check that the reed wax and valves are in good shape. If the wax is old and brittle, replace it. If the valves are curled or not laying flat, replace them. Tuning reeds without replacing poor condition valves is a waste of time.
-
cheers steve, im going to replace all the valves and reed wax anyway,
when the reeds are in the blocks, how do you tune the reeds on the inside of the reed plate? i was going to take off the reed plates and tune them like this guys set up....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U--Vf99jyTA
is this a good set up?
-
cheers steve, im going to replace all the valves and reed wax anyway,
when the reeds are in the blocks, how do you tune the reeds on the inside of the reed plate?
Theo has a good set of photos here (http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&l=5be6150682):
i was going to take off the reed plates and tune them like this guys set up....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U--Vf99jyTA
is this a good set up?
No - I wouldn't recommend this at all. Unless the reeds are in-situ in the instrument, they will sound at a substantially different pitch - possibly as much as 5 to 8 cents off. Factors such as the rigidity of the set up, the size/shape of the reed chamber, the proximity to other components in the instrument, and probably others, all affect the pitch of the reed. There has been several threads on this over the years, most recently this one:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8551.msg106190.html#msg106190
-
the snark turned up to day, im quite impressed with how easy it is to use, but i cant believe how out of tune the reeds are, the lowest reed on the c row is showing as a push g when it should be a push f#
-
the snark turned up to day, im quite impressed with how easy it is to use, but i cant believe how out of tune the reeds are, the lowest reed on the c row is showing as a push g when it should be a push f#
Be careful! Remember that a pair of reeds tuned slightly apart to give a tremolo, especially if it is a strong tremolo, may well confuse an electronic tuner and give a false reading. If the Snark only reads to the nearest 2.5 cents anyway, you may not be seeing the most accurate of results. Have you tried blanking off each set of reeds in turn and testing the tuning?
-
nah i blew down the hole! wrong i know, but i wanted to try out me tuner! :|bl
-
The Peterson app for iPhone or iPad really is excellent, it is the most precise tuner I've used and easily shows the small differences (less than 1 cent) that you get when changing how hard you blow the reed. The big problem I always found with any of the LCD display tuners is that you have no scope for judging a deviation less than the range that the tuner is programmed to consider in tune which I think is typically +/- 1 cent, but may be more for some models.
Just read Theo's post, two minutes later I'm trying it out. Gosh this is fun. Quite impressed. I have only a 20b concertina to hand but I can pick out the recent replacement reed from its peers just by comparing the tuning.
Now I suppose I'll have to tune it... :D
-
right... im lost .
which are the push reeds? on the inside or outside of the reed block? :|bl
-
right... im lost .
which are the push reeds? on the inside or outside of the reed block? :|bl
The push reeds are on the outside and the pull in the inside, had me going for a fair time as well ;D
-
thanks lester, its all confusing cos i got 3 reed blocks, 2.5 rows of buttons and 2 sets of palletts ! the reeds have 15 in each side of the block, but the rows of buttons are 12/ 11 / 7 so working out which reed block has which reed is difficult, especialy when they are out of tune....
i have located the C/C button .
i dont know if the best thing to do is to bring them all up to pitch then work from there ?
i should revalve and wax them all first yes?
many thanks
tommy
-
thanks lester, its all confusing cos i got 3 reed blocks, 2.5 rows of buttons and 2 sets of palletts ! the reeds have 15 in each side of the block, but the rows of buttons are 12/ 11 / 7 so working out which reed block has which reed is difficult, especialy when they are out of tune....
i have located the C/C button .
i dont know if the best thing to do is to bring them all up to pitch then work from there ?
i should revalve and wax them all first yes?
many thanks
tommy
I would take all the blocks out and then operate each key to see which hole is opened and thus create a map of which button operates which reed.
Yes rewax etc first tuning should be the last thing you do.
-
thanks lester! i shall do that tomorow, now is time to play!!! :||:
-
Essential: make a diagram showing the positions of every reed on each reedblock.
You might also find it useful to stick a strip a masking tape along the top of each block and write the notes there too. Where reeds for three rows are shared between two sets of blocks that will save you a huge amount of time, especially if the reeds get muddled.
On the other hand I think it is a waste of time to mark every reedplate with the notes because with a tuning bellows and an electronic tuner its is a matter of moments to sound a reed to see what note it plays.
-
just realised that this is a three voice box - all the reeds are the same size so i guess its M/M/M ?
how do you go about tuning a 3v ? i want it realy quiet dry almost like a flange effect tuning, should i tune them all to pitch and let the 2.5 cents leeway on the snark do its thing?
-
Essential: make a diagram showing the positions of every reed on each reedblock.
Agreed. The first time I tried revalving my club they got mixed up, and of course it was the accidental ones that went awry.
-
just realised that this is a three voice box - all the reeds are the same size so i guess its M/M/M ?
how do you go about tuning a 3v ? i want it realy quiet dry almost like a flange effect tuning, should i tune them all to pitch and let the 2.5 cents leeway on the snark do its thing?
If you want that flange effect, known in the accordion world as slow swing, or sometimes just swing tuning, you can use your electronic tuner to get close but you will have to use your ear to get the effect consistent across the instrument. I suggest starting by tuning the middle reed to concert pitch then take the reeds in pairs eg M- and M as a pair and M and M+ as a pair.
2.5 cents is probably too small an offset for all but the top end, 4 to 5 cents would be a better starting point.
-
ok ,
old wax and valves all gone,
reed blocks all masking taped and marked, notes maped ect ect,
HOPEFULLY city link have found my parcel of parts and the reeds will be re-valved and re waxed by saturday night.
definetly going for a swing tuning after hearing this P.A box ....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCPUEe4nfs
it s a 3 voice M/M/M same as mine but P.A
theo, i dunno if you want to move this thread now?
-
might also be worth listening to some other similar but different tunings on you tube. ( & played using3 voice muisette ) Brandon Mcphee playing dark island on hohner gaelic when aged 14 ish!. Ian Cruickshanaks playing The Sargeant Major March on SHAND MORINO + loads of his other stuff . Also Phil Cunninghams piano box has a very nice tuning as does the one plaayed by Mick Foster (of foster & allen) all these & more on youtube.
george
-
ok ive rewaxed and revalved the first reed block, but half of the reeds now wont play or sound realy raspy is there a cure? i hope so ... :( please help!
-
There will be advice more expert than mine, but I've generally found non-sounding reeds to be due to one or more of: tiny, almost invisible bits of debris in the reed slot; incorrect "set" of the reed; reed not centrally aligned in the slot. Also check that there is no wax or valve adhesive interfering with the free movement of the reed. Raspy sounds I've usually found to be cured by replacing the valve - check your work on the new valves very carefully. If that is the problem, at least they're cheap enough to chuck away and have another go.
Graham
-
mmm. am i gonna have to undo all my work and start again? also, is a piano accordion reed the same as a melodeon reed , just one reed tuned differently to the opposite ?
-
OK, so check that the valves are stuck down properly, check that the reed tongues are unrestricted in movement, especially check whether opposing valves aren't flapping over the opposite reed or whether some splashed wax is preventing them moving, check that you haven't put any wax on the reed, check that the wax is smooth and that reed plates are properly secured with wax, not floating with blobs here and there and gaps everywhere else. You might have to tear everything off and start again, but this is a learning process and it's how you learn! Replacing a valve is easy if it's on the outside of the block, so try that first. In order to set reeds, hold it up to the light to see the clearances and gently twang it with a shim to check that it moves freely. If it doesn't then very carefully, with a shim, insert it in the gap and lever to the appropriate side. This requires next to no force and you need a really thin bit of brass and a great deal of care. Not sure about the best way of setting them in the out of block direction, but that is to do with response more than getting rid of rasps.
I've done all of the things mentioned above by the way. You learn!
-
All good advice. I'd only add - just do one creed at a time. Take your time and observe carefully. It is a learning process, and just like learning to play it takes time, you will make mistakes, and hopefully you can learn from your mistakes. If it is any consolation the factories make mistakes too, I've lost count of the times I've found a reed not sounding quite right and on investigation it is obvious that the fault must have been there from new.
-
In answer to your question about PA reeds - yes, exactly the same except that on a PA the "pull" and "push" reeds on each plate both sound the same note (unisonoric) unlike a melodeon, where each reed (usually) sounds a different note (bisonoric). If you need a bisonoric reed pair that's not readily available you can sometimes use a unisoric pair by flattening one side and/or sharpening the other to the required pitch.
-
Ok tonite im going to undo my work and rewax and valve one reed at a time whats the best thing to clean off new sticky wax and can it be reused?
-
As it's fresh it will still be tacky and probably reluctant to come away cleanly. A small blunt screwdriver will remove most of it. I usually use white spirit or meths in conjunction with a scalpel and kitchen paper or clean, lint-free cloth (such as an old cotton handkerchief, thoroughly laundered) to remove residual wax from reedplates, and there's no reason why that shouldn't work on the blocks as well as far as I can see. Re-use of wax is not recommended.
Graham
-
currently replacing one at a time, revalving and waxing checking that they play on the tuneing bellows and adjusting as required.....its going to be a long night!
-
currently replacing one at a time, revalving and waxing checking that they play on the tuneing bellows and adjusting as required.....its going to be a long night!
My tip on this is:
When waxing on a new set of reeds I just tack each plate on with a spot of wax at each end of the plate. Then take the block to the tuning bench and check each reed sounds and is in the correct position. When you find a problem it is easy to lift the reedplate to sort it, and pressing the plate back onto the wax spots is usually enough to hold it till you've checked the rest of the block. Once its all playing do the full waxing.
-
yeah, ive ben doing that ! its a long slow process going through every reed taking 15 mins getting the reed playing properly ( and not knowing how your doing it ) only to go to the next one and do it all over again , but i reckon it will be worth it
-
so how should the reed tounge sit on the reed plate?
should the tip of it sit slightly higher than the gap? should the base sit flat against the plate? i think this is where the majority of my problems lie... :|glug
-
Tip should be slightly above the plate. The height of the tip above the plate has to be found by trial and error, but should not need drastic change from what it was originally. Small reeds need much less height than big.
-
Ive read a few places that u should hold the plate upto a light to inspect it but what are u looking for ?
-
To check that the reed tongue is centralised in the slot.
-
I spent part of this afternoon sorting out a bunch of salvaged reeds; some of them failed to speak on the tuning bellows, and in every case it was because the reed wasn't centred in its slot. A gentle nudge with a fine shim and away the went like good 'uns.
-
so how do you tell if you gotta realign a reed
-
Hold it up to the light - you should be able to see a line of light up both edges of the reed tongue
-
brilliant ! i shall report back ....