Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 12:20:00 PM

Title: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 12:20:00 PM
In a fit of panic, my reply to 'what on earth can I get you for Crimble?' was
"well, JK's English Choice tune book would always be handy....."
Apart from the obvious ( tunes! ) I'm finding the introduction from His Lordship utterly thought provoking and very resonant to me personally. Several of his comments about playing have drifted through many forum threads, but the introduction in this book has many of these thoughts condensed into a couple of sides of print.
Play tunes not melodies; play a tune for a while to get inside it as repetition gets you into the tune; learning the notes is not the end, it's the start.... and a whole lot on the tunes we mostly play are for *dance* and only come alive when danced to...... and on it goes.
I don't want to quote them all, or infringe copyrights or anything, but I keep reading the comments and they really do resonate with me....
Now I just have to learn how to play like him  :D
yeah, I know, dream on.....
Q in thoughtful mode.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 28, 2011, 01:01:10 PM
Yes - I also like JK's philosophical approach to playing tunes.

This article impressed me years ago and it still comes up in this forum from time to time. Definitely a 'Marmite' item, but personally I love it.
http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 01:30:12 PM
Yes I agree.
I 'rediscovered' the article recently when I was flitting through the 'Opus Pocus' tunebook, trying to get my eldest to have a go at 'Jump at the sun'. I'd forgotten about the article, but I re-read it made sense.

Some of his other points made coincide with my last session, where I had two good friends trading tunes, both playing 2 row D/G's and obviously trying to out-do each other. I remember thinking 'what more do you want? a 2 row and all these lovely tunes.... that's enough'
John touches on over elabourating tunes in this Introduction article. I confess to recently lusting after perhaps a 2.5 row, after enjoying the wizardry on 'Banquet of Boxes' where players are using mainly 'other' boxes.
A combination of that last session and this article has stopped me in my tracks and made me think.
Always a good think when I think......except it hurts *so much*  ;D
cheers
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Theo on December 28, 2011, 01:35:36 PM
I remember thinking 'what more do you want? a 2 row and all these lovely tunes.... that's enough'
John touches on over elabourating tunes in this Introduction article. I confess to recently lusting after perhaps a 2.5 row, after enjoying the wizardry on 'Banquet of Boxes' where players are using mainly 'other' boxes.

JK may have developed his view since then because he himself mostly plays his BCC# box now, and though I'm not suggesting he over elaborates, his playing style is pretty full with lots of fills, ornaments, variations, counter melodies on the bass and RH chords.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Stiamh on December 28, 2011, 01:54:28 PM
... elabourating...

Brilliant - a very felicitous misspelling. Combines elaborate and labouring in one word to indicate trying too hard and producing a dog's dinner. I'll borrow this if you don't mind.  :|glug
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 03:09:49 PM
Theo: I agree his style is full. Listening to the tunes on my ipod and trying to follow them in the tune book shows how a simple tune ends up an extraordinary one in his hands. I think his right hand is quite stunning!, yet I find his complex style still in keeping with the flow of the tune.
Not sure if I can say what I mean here...... maybe he keeps the fullness without taking it beyond the perameters of the tune's purpose (?).
Oh dear, rambling again  ::)


Steve: Errmm..... please feel free  :|bl
I do have problems at times, as I'm sure others have noticed, when translating from my native tongue....... but I know what I mean ;D
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Theo on December 28, 2011, 03:23:40 PM
yet I find his complex style still in keeping with the flow of the tune.

Because he is a musical genius.   I can't think of anyone else who can do all that and make it sound effortless.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 03:29:13 PM
Ahhh.... that too!
I knew there was something I forgot to mention  :D
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: baz parkes on December 28, 2011, 05:06:50 PM
. I confess to recently lusting after perhaps a 2.5 row, after enjoying the wizardry on 'Banquet of Boxes' where players are using mainly 'other' boxes.

Q


Just remind yourself of the specifications of the box JK used on that recording (in the notes).  That will put an end to that sort of nonsense....

Baz
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2011, 06:02:59 PM
Yeah Baz I know...... a perspective hit too.
Lots of things to make notes of from the book.
..... and whilst we converse, Seasons Greetings to you sir!
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2011, 03:29:00 PM
I do have problems at times, as I'm sure others have noticed, when translating from my native tongue....... but I know what I mean ;D
Q


English isn't your native tongue? I would never have guessed!
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 29, 2011, 03:35:52 PM
yer, you'm een fer a gurt slap if you iddn careful ;=)

Ahem.
I have no idea what you mean, Mr. Ukebert my good man. ::)
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Owen Woods on December 29, 2011, 04:14:29 PM
I'm confused now.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 29, 2011, 07:35:45 PM
ukebert: Don't worry too much, I spend all my life in a perpetual state of confusedness  ;D
cheers
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Ollie on December 29, 2011, 07:39:31 PM
I'm confused now.

Q's like Ross...
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 29, 2011, 07:41:03 PM
Arghhhh now *I'm* confused ???
life's a worry y'know
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 04:58:01 PM
Yes - I also like JK's philosophical approach to playing tunes.

This article impressed me years ago and it still comes up in this forum from time to time. Definitely a 'Marmite' item, but personally I love it.
http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp

I think JK got that idea from a session we were both in at Cricklade ECMW 1978, when the 'traditional' hammer dulcimer player, Reg Reeder, played Heel and Toe Polka for 30 minutes, in C (which upset all the G/D melodeon players), until Rod Stradling uttered the immortal line 'one more time!.......'

 I also agree with JK about medleys, but you can use the same approach if you have two tunes that go well together (e.g 3 around 3 followed by the Quaker) :
Don't stop playing after twice through each tune plus one more of the first one (a hangover from the early days of EFDSS, when that is all would fit on one side of a '78!) - play the set for 30 or more minutes.

You will find that the tunes 'take you over', you find new nuances, and float off in a trance......  We once played our Buttered Peas and Officers Polka set at a dance for 45 minutes. The dancers didn't want to stop, and neither did we - when we did, they wanted more! 








Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 25, 2012, 05:13:44 PM
pikey:
Absolutely agree... let the tune ( or maybe 2! ) just take over and float off........
and they do don't they!
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 08:15:04 PM
 (:)

Even Heel and Toe Polka takes on hidden meanings after the 30th time through.......
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pbsalt on January 25, 2012, 08:29:07 PM
This article impressed me years ago and it still comes up in this forum from time to time. Definitely a 'Marmite' item, but personally I love it.
http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp

Why is it a  "Marmite item " - can't see why anyone would disagree( !) - apart from his argument about playing a tune many times for dance also suits sessions - gives participants a chance to get to grips with the tunes and then develop wonderful harmonies ...     
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 09:29:20 PM
Some of those who have been entrenched in the ways of the English Folk Dance and Song Society for many years find it very difficult not to stop playing after twice through each tune.......

Up here we seem to have now settled nicely into three times each tune, but people still want to stop after three for one tune, and three for the next.

If you want to have fun, next time you lead a tune in a session, play it five or more times through before you move onto the next one - don't forget to shout 'again!' near the end of every repeart after the second!!

 ;D
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 25, 2012, 09:45:45 PM
I went to a workshop probably in the early 80's at Sidmouth run by the Oyster Band, and John Jones made the comment that after English music had almost died out due to outside influences, 'we're only just learning how to play the tunes again.....'
The 'playing a tune til you want to stop' attitude is now replacing the medleys once common and now despised, and it seems that was the way it used to be. As JK says, and I've heard from ther sources too, you played the tune until the dance ended......sometimes 15 mins or longer if it was longway sets and the Squire and Lady danced working all the way to the bottom of the set and then back up.
Perhaps JJ's comments are true - we have now realised how to play and indeed are now playing the tunes as they were played.
We've gone full circle.....
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 10:14:57 PM
I wish there was a 'Like' button!!   (:)
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Anahata on January 25, 2012, 10:29:26 PM
Up here we seem to have now settled nicely into three times each tune, but people still want to stop after three for one tune, and three for the next.

Three is also usual here in sessions, but our band tune sets are nearly all two tunes only. For a set dance with 4 or 5 couples, we like it best if the caller goes through the whole cycle twice, so the change is when it all starts again. Playing the same tune 5 times in a row seems to make more sense when there's dancing going on.

Quote
If you want to have fun, next time you lead a tune in a session, play it five or more times through before you move onto the next one - don't forget to shout 'again!' near the end of every repeart after the second!!

We have certain tunes where we like to do that!
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: IanD on January 25, 2012, 10:59:56 PM
This article impressed me years ago and it still comes up in this forum from time to time. Definitely a 'Marmite' item, but personally I love it.
http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp

Why is it a  "Marmite item " - can't see why anyone would disagree( !) - apart from his argument about playing a tune many times for dance also suits sessions - gives participants a chance to get to grips with the tunes and then develop wonderful harmonies ...     

Exactly what I was telling people at the Wantage workshop -- some really took some convincing that you *can* play a tune in a session more than three times.

My view is that if a tune's worth playing at all -- in a session or anywhere else -- it's worth playing more than three times. If it's not good enough to play more than three times, then why are you playing it?

Ian
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 25, 2012, 11:08:12 PM
... The 'playing a tune til you want to stop' attitude is now replacing the medleys once common and now despised, and it seems that was the way it used to be. As JK says, and I've heard from ther sources too, you played the tune until the dance ended......sometimes 15 mins or longer if it was longway sets and the Squire and Lady danced working all the way to the bottom of the set and then back up.

Basically, medleys are cr@p, they always were cr@p, and the fundamental thing the English scene needs to take on board (I specifically exclude Morris in this) is that if a tune is worth playing, it is worth ..developing  ;) .. exploring  :D .. arranging  ;D .. improvising >:E

    "We will play tune number 16 twice, then tune number 23 twice,  tune number 17 twice,  tune number 23 twice and finish with tune number 16 twice" {EFDSS dance group musical Dominatrix, approx 1997}

Did you ever heard such  a load of ..  OK, I've made my point  :|glug
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 31, 2012, 01:34:04 PM
I found JK's intro inspiring, but mainly the recommendation to a relaxed attitude to ornaments.  So many people get hung up on which ornaments to use and where, I like his happenstance approach.

As for the "one dance one tune" argument, I'm rather on the fence.  There are a number of dances with an eponimous tune which so encapsulates the structure and feel of the dance that nothing else comes close.  But in the PTA realms of barn dances, often a more plodding tune is good for the first run through with a change to a more energetic style to lift the dancers now they've got the hang of the dance.

Rob.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: IanD on January 31, 2012, 06:37:59 PM
I found JK's intro inspiring, but mainly the recommendation to a relaxed attitude to ornaments.  So many people get hung up on which ornaments to use and where, I like his happenstance approach.

As for the "one dance one tune" argument, I'm rather on the fence.  There are a number of dances with an eponimous tune which so encapsulates the structure and feel of the dance that nothing else comes close.  But in the PTA realms of barn dances, often a more plodding tune is good for the first run through with a change to a more energetic style to lift the dancers now they've got the hang of the dance.

Rob.

Agreed, in many cases two tunes work very well, if they fit together and the change works to lift the dancers -- so an "up" change, not a "down" one.

But I'd say only if the dance is a minimum of 8 times through (4 times each tune), preferably 10 or more, otherwise you can't get into each tune properly.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 01, 2012, 01:06:40 PM
I'd say only if the dance is a minimum of 8 times through (4 times each tune), preferably 10 or more, otherwise you can't get into each tune properly.

Ideally, yes.  But often it depends on the quality and stamina of the dancers and they're paying the piper!  We rarely get a practiced bunch of dancers like the Committee Band always had, but we have had occasions when the caller is sending subtle signals that the dance will be cut short, so for our own enjoyment we change to the second tune, the dancers are lifted and we end up playing the new tune a dozen times!  No complaints.

Rob.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: IanD on February 01, 2012, 10:12:21 PM
I'd say only if the dance is a minimum of 8 times through (4 times each tune), preferably 10 or more, otherwise you can't get into each tune properly.

Ideally, yes.  But often it depends on the quality and stamina of the dancers and they're paying the piper!  We rarely get a practiced bunch of dancers like the Committee Band always had, but we have had occasions when the caller is sending subtle signals that the dance will be cut short, so for our own enjoyment we change to the second tune, the dancers are lifted and we end up playing the new tune a dozen times!  No complaints.

Rob.

Of course you have to fit the music to what ever the caller and dancers are doing on the night. What I meant was that when planning dances/tunes anything less than 4 times through is a waste -- if you have to cut the dance short that's different.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Hello on February 03, 2012, 11:23:36 AM
It does presume that you have the ability and inclination to attempt variations on a tune. Playing literally the same notes over and over for a dance would become tedious.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Anahata on February 03, 2012, 11:51:23 AM
It does presume that you have the ability and inclination to attempt variations on a tune. Playing literally the same notes over and over for a dance would become tedious.

Of course standard practice of the dance bands JK is complaining about is/was to do exactly that. They play from the music, and if you play anything different from exactly what's written it's a wrong note.
And if you play a tune only twice, you don't get time to think of variations...

At the end of Medley Mania he promises at the next workshop
Quote
I shall pick a tune and play it for a whole hour. We'll all be exhausted at the end of it, and I'm sure speech will only return slowly, but we'll all have shared a wonderfully exhilarating experience

He did, and I was at that workshop. We played Davy Knick-Knack non stop for ages. At the end of it, an old boy with a piano accordion complained (a) that he didn't know the tune and (b) that no music was provided.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 03, 2012, 09:18:14 PM
At the Oyster workshop I mentioned earlier in the thread, 'playing the same notes' was touched upon.
As Jonsey famously said, - roughly -  'you can't play the same tune coninuously for 15-20 minutes or more and *still* be playing the same notes, or it'll drive you mad....'
He then went on to express a view that the English tunes were relatively simple to be a framework. Whatever happened within that framework was ok, it was designed as an idea to which you added your personal touch. Like a chef making his own classic dish but with his personal twist to the dish.
The 'two times and on' medley was an early EFDSS (?) attempt at getting us to play the tunes but assumed they tunes should be played as written dot for dot, which we now consider is totally missing the point. At that point in time they did not realise and thought they should be strictly adhered to. The medley ideas were from an era when the English tunes were rare, pre-Old Swan, Flowers etc. of the early '70's and everything was 'diddly diddly' stuff as opposed to good ol stompy English tunes we'd now recognise as standards in the repertoire.
The workshop above ended with a comment Oysters 'we never knowingly play the tune the same twice through.....'
I strictly adhere to this motto, but generally because of musical 'typo's'  that somehow get in ::)
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: IanD on February 04, 2012, 11:50:18 AM
At the Oyster workshop I mentioned earlier in the thread, 'playing the same notes' was touched upon.
As Jonsey famously said, - roughly -  'you can't play the same tune coninuously for 15-20 minutes or more and *still* be playing the same notes, or it'll drive you mad....'
He then went on to express a view that the English tunes were relatively simple to be a framework. Whatever happened within that framework was ok, it was designed as an idea to which you added your personal touch. Like a chef making his own classic dish but with his personal twist to the dish.
The 'two times and on' medley was an early EFDSS (?) attempt at getting us to play the tunes but assumed they tunes should be played as written dot for dot, which we now consider is totally missing the point. At that point in time they did not realise and thought they should be strictly adhered to. The medley ideas were from an era when the English tunes were rare, pre-Old Swan, Flowers etc. of the early '70's and everything was 'diddly diddly' stuff as opposed to good ol stompy English tunes we'd now recognise as standards in the repertoire.
The workshop above ended with a comment Oysters 'we never knowingly play the tune the same twice through.....'
I strictly adhere to this motto, but generally because of musical 'typo's'  that somehow get in ::)
Q

I/we just plain *never* play the tune the same twice...

Ian
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 04, 2012, 02:57:49 PM
Ian - yes but that's your *choice* whereas for me....  :|bl
 ...but yes exactly.  My point has just been wonderfully demonstrated.
After working the tunes these years gone, we now realise what probably went on, and so play them in what we percieve to be 'the old and intended way'
Long may it continue!
Q
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: Tom on February 04, 2012, 03:36:53 PM
Regarding playing things over and over.

Most of my day job is teaching Samba and African drumming. For both of these styles the most common way to learn is through serious repetition - playing the same 1 or 2 bar rhythm non-stop for at least an hour. I assure you it's a good way to learn music. If you repeat a pattern (rhythm or melody) solidly for an hour you reach whole new levels of understanding of it; you start to value the space between the notes, whole your pattern relates to other players patterns and how the pattern is complete in itself.

The problem is being raised in the "Western Music" tradition: we learn that complicated is good and important and therefore 'simple' is 'bad'. This means that, if you can play a tune three times in a row without making a mistake, it becomes 'simple' so we say "I can now play that, give me something harder" (and thus better).

I would really encourage you to try some serious repetition and don't add variations. That's a different skill. it's good too; but not the same.
Title: Re: JK's English Choice - intro. notes inspire.....
Post by: pikey on February 06, 2012, 09:45:15 AM
Spot on Tom.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal