Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: pgroff on January 01, 2012, 03:46:08 PM

Title: Bb/Eb/D layout, Paolo club conversion
Post by: pgroff on January 01, 2012, 03:46:08 PM
Hi all,

And Happy New Year!

Here's one for the inventive and open-minded.

We've had a few discussions here of "hybrid" layouts that have a couple of rows tuned a fourth apart, and a couple of rows tuned a semitone apart.  One of the earliest of these systems that I know about is the old Italian G/C/B system, often found on the melody side of button accordions that have a stradella left hand.  The outside two rows finger like a G/C 2-row box and all the sharps and flats (black keys of a piano) are available on the inside row.  The tonic note of the inside row is displaced up toward the chin relative to the tonic note of the middle row, so all the chromatic 1/2 step movements upward in pitch are very naturally accomplished going from the inside row to the middle row, in the same bellows direction.

The Irish-American D/C# boxes also had an inner row of accidentals tuned a semitone below the main melody row -- a reverse of the C#/D layout that is more common these days in Irish music. Unlike the Italian G/C/Bs, the Irish-American D/C# boxes usually have very minimal bass buttons (often 2 or 4, rarely 8 or more) which helps to keep the left side lightweight and makes it easier to play them like "a melodeon (outside row) with accidentals (inside row)."

OK.  Now here (pic below) is an unusual early Paolo Soprani club accordion, originally in a stock Bb/Eb/X club layout, now reversibly converted to Bb/Eb/D, with the Eb row and basses declubbed.  Its a 3 voice, LMM, with one lever switch behind the melody keyboard.  I find that with this layout, the box works for playing on the Bb row, melodeon style, with the Bb/F and G/Cm basses useful.  It plays on the Eb row, melodeon style, with the Eb/Bb, Ab/Ab, Bb/F and G/Cm basses useful.  And it plays a lot of tunes melodeon style in concert pitch, on the inside D row (ranging from middle D to the high D up 2 octaves, but missing the high C#), but with no useful basses . . . many of the classic Irish melodeon tunes fit within that 7-button D-row layout.

Then, played "2 row style," it works on the outer two rows as a full-keyboard Bb/Eb box (like a D/G transposed down a major third), with the basses you would expect on a Hohner.  Or, it works on the inside two rows as an Eb/D box -- just like the Irish-American D/C# boxes, but transposed up a half step for playing with Eb flutes for example, again with all 8 basses useful.

The full 3-row style on this box would need another topic to describe, but those who have played a G/C/B would recognize it right away, though transposed up a minor third.  D/G players can think of it as a D/G/F# box, transposed down a major third.

Of course, the body of this old Paolo would also make a lovely conversion to other layouts such as Bb/Eb/E, Bb/B/C, Bb/A/G#, Bb/Eb/Ab, A/Bb/Eb, B/C/C#, or most likely C#/D/D#. . . subject to the limitations of its 8 basses.  I wouldn't want to add basses though, since part of what makes this box so playable is its extremely light and agile left side -- despite the box being slightly taller than a 2 row Paolo.

PG







SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal