Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: waltzman on January 02, 2012, 12:28:13 AM

Title: unstable reed
Post by: waltzman on January 02, 2012, 12:28:13 AM
One of the high G reeds on my G/C Casta seems unstable.  It's the high G on the G row and it just seem to behave erratically for no apparent reason.  The pitch seems to wander around. Only one of the two reeds does this.  The other one behaves normally.  These are good quality AM Antonelli reeds.  Is there such a thing as a 'bad' reed that just wont' function normally?
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: forrest on January 02, 2012, 02:17:17 AM
One of the high G reeds on my G/C Casta seems unstable.  It's the high G on the G row and it just seem to behave erratically for no apparent reason.  The pitch seems to wander around. Only one of the two reeds does this.  The other one behaves normally.  These are good quality AM Antonelli reeds.  Is there such a thing as a 'bad' reed that just wont' function normally?

Could be the valve on the inside of the plate is not opening fully (maybe rubbing the wall of the reed chamber), or reed tongue fouled by a hair or bit of fluff, or reed slightly askew in the plate  ???
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 02, 2012, 09:03:12 AM
One of the high G reeds on my G/C Casta seems unstable.  It's the high G on the G row and it just seem to behave erratically for no apparent reason.  The pitch seems to wander around. Only one of the two reeds does this.  The other one behaves normally.  These are good quality AM Antonelli reeds.  Is there such a thing as a 'bad' reed that just wont' function normally?

Could be the valve on the inside of the plate is not opening fully (maybe rubbing the wall of the reed chamber), or reed tongue fouled by a hair or bit of fluff, or reed slightly askew in the plate  ???
Yes, possible reasons, although probably for these highest reeds there are no valves anyway.
It can be hard to get the high reeds to behave properly - they are so sensitive to the minutest adjustment in tuning and setting of the gap.

Does the pitch variation your problematic reed change with differing bellows pressure? If so, it is possible that the gap setting isn't quite right. Variable pitch can often (but not always!) indicate that the gap is too small. Have a careful look to see if it is the same as it's well-behaved partner. You could try easing the reed tongue upwards a little using a very thin shim - go very carefully, a tiny, tiny amount at a time to see if that improves the pitch stability. Adjusting the gap will also affect the response of the reed and probably its tuning too, so be prepared to do some very exacting work to get the pitch, response and stability just right.

Quote
Is there such a thing as a 'bad' reed that just wont' function normally?
I think this sometimes happens though it's very rare. I once had a Binci reed which refused to stay in tune; I tried all sorts of things - adjusted the gap, replaced the valve, checked the seating of the reed plate (screwed on leather in this instance), etc. but to no avail. In desperation I wondered whether the reed tongue was riveted firmly enough to the reed plate. It didn't appear to be loose but everything else had failed to remedy the problem. I took the reed out of the box and supported it on a steel block and gave the rivet head a couple of extra whacks with a hammer. Bingo! I retuned the reed and it has behaved itself ever since.
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: Theo on January 02, 2012, 09:19:23 AM
But the most likely by far is some dirt in the reed.  Eliminate that possibility first.
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: waltzman on January 02, 2012, 03:52:37 PM
Thanks for the replies.  I have inspected the reed and gap and valve closely and cannot find anything simple. No foreign material and the valve looks normal and does not appear to be impinging on anything but I guess it could be.  I have not replaced the valve yet.  ( or hammered the rivet ;D)
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 02, 2012, 04:02:30 PM
Have you inspected under a reasonable degree of magnification? I've had reeds that refused to speak at all, and to the naked eye - or even under a handheld glass - there appeared to be no obvious problem. But under 12x magnification a few specks of crud were revealed and removed - hey presto, a beautifully clear-sounding reed.  Mind you, in this case the reeds were out of the box and I was able to inspect the reed-plate unencumbered by bodywork......
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: Theo on January 02, 2012, 04:26:25 PM
Another possibility is that the reed plate is not held tightly by the wax allowing the reed plate to vibrate.  This can be quite hard to detect, best way I have found is to press on the reedplate with a small screwdriver while sounding the reed, then taking the pressure off while the reed continues to sound.  The sound should not change.
Title: Re: unstable reed
Post by: waltzman on January 02, 2012, 05:19:13 PM
Another possibility is that the reed plate is not held tightly by the wax allowing the reed plate to vibrate.  This can be quite hard to detect, best way I have found is to press on the reedplate with a small screwdriver while sounding the reed, then taking the pressure off while the reed continues to sound.  The sound should not change.

Another good tip.  Thanks.   It is mind boggling how many different ways these bits of steel can misbehave.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal