Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: greybox1 on January 05, 2012, 08:34:30 AM

Title: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: greybox1 on January 05, 2012, 08:34:30 AM
Happy new year to all!

 Just wondering does anybody know is their a gps tracking device available yet that could be installed inside a melodeon? I know a few players that have had melodeons stolen in the past and were never recovererd. thanks!
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 05, 2012, 08:55:49 AM
Quick reality check:  Start of January (http://chrisryall.net/icn/tick.gif)  Start of April (http://chrisryall.net/icn/cross.gif)

There is one that goes into the car glove box to track 'young' drivers - a whole 10% insurance discount if in the opinion of the insurer you are a good driver  ???   Medics have talked for years of a strap on to track wandering Alzheimer's patients. I have to say I've never actually seen one.

Your widget has to find 6 satellites and also transmit its position out every so often. I think weight and batteries will be the issue. Our best defence is that melodeons aren't at all saleable outside this community, and to postcode them inside (bruise the wood with a biro). Then either insure (cheaper than the widget) or simply keep some 'bling' paste jewelry in the same room. Burglars will defo prefer that to a large box!  :|glug
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Marje on January 05, 2012, 10:35:39 AM
Just as a matter of interest, do you know if the melodeon thefts you've heard of were from a home burglary, or when people were out and about (say, at a festival)? And does anyone else here know any details of actual melodeon thefts? Don't list anything that you've heard via vague rumour, otherwise we might all be relating the same one or two incidents. I'd be interested to know how most melodeon thefts actually occur.

I'm guessing that mine is pretty safe at home, as there are more easily nickable and saleable items that a burglar would be attracted to. I'm more concerned about it when I'm out at clubs and festivals, where people who know about these things can see that it's a nice box, but even then I like to think that the folk community is pretty honest. And unless someone wants to keep it for themself, it wouldn't be an easy item to dispose of if you don't know the first thing about it.
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 05, 2012, 10:52:02 AM
My old red Erica happened to be in the car when it (the car) was nicked. I got the stripped remains of the car back, but never saw the box again. It had a couple of very distinctive modifications and had my details indelibly marked in three places inside but never turned up in any of the expected places.
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Microbot on January 05, 2012, 11:51:11 AM
Hi Greybox, Chris and all,

I love the fact that the previous post was by GPS ... !

OK ...I am very interested in this thread and it is very relevant to me just now as a restorer. I recently had an order for a melodeon, to replace an identical instrument I made last year for a Melnetter, which was then subsquently stolen. I'm currently finishing the replacement box.

I note there's a thread on 'security marking' melodeons internally, but I've just done a little research in the field of 'track and trace', which is already widely used for tagging and recovering valued items.

The technology is still evolving and there seem to be two main RFID systems (Radio Frequency identification).

 ... (1) 'Active' RFID devices, which emit a signal that can be located by a variety of technologies (including GPS) but the downside is the need for a battery/power source that is discreet/small/enduring ... thus the power/battery issue is a major point of development.

 ... (2) 'Passive' RFID devices, which emit a signal in response to a signal from an RFID scanner. The downside is the need for the tagged item to be within range of a scanner ... this range is being increased and is the major point of development with this technology...

The plus side of the 'passive' devices is that they can be no larger than a grain of rice, with a lifespan of up to 80 years. They emit a unique signal that identifies the owner and item, with registered data that can be changed when legitimately sold. The implanted 'tags' can detect and emit a signal through wood/metal etc casing and (according to web-literature) are already much used for tagging valuable stringed instruments.

One company claims to specialises in tagging musical instruments with these passive devices - 'Snagg' who are at ... http://www.snagg.com/

The major downside with Passive RFID tags is the need for the item to be within range of an RFID scanner/detector. Many (?) Police Forces now have this technology, but it is obviously NOT ubiquitous.

Another piece of research (2011 but sorry ... lost reference!) claimed the effective working distance for Passive RFID tags had risen from 10 feet to over 40 feet. This means it begins to be possible to scan buildings for tagged-and-stolen items - the intention seems to be to reach the point where 'neighbourhoods' can be scanned for passive-tagged stolen items by the police.

Other thoughts come to mind ... the need for a buyer to have an instrument/item scanned to ensure it has not been tagged-and-stolen, which could leave the buyer out-of-pocket. Can you take an item to a police station to have it scanned I wonder?

I've not looked at the details of buying and registering these "Passive RFID grains of rice" (see Snagg above?). But in terms of installation it seems they can be embedded within casework or in a discreet pool of glue in an interior corner/angle.

With the market value of musical instruments, plus the priceless added value to the owner ("it's set-up just right for me"), I wonder if this is a thread that could develop ... maybe even with some Melnet liason with the companies offering this technology? I wonder if, within 15-20 years, people who don't tag their favourite melodeon(s) will be like people who 'don't bother' with house insurance?

....And for a Greybox (or a Jeffries concertina?) - I'd really be investigating an RFID implant  ...

best wishes to all

Mike Rowbotham
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Owen Woods on January 05, 2012, 12:02:13 PM
batteries are getting ever smaller, it wouldn't surprise me if very soon an active device could be very small indeed. Not quite grain of rice though :P
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Theo on January 05, 2012, 12:23:27 PM
I wonder if, within 15-20 years, people who don't tag their favourite melodeon(s) will be like people who 'don't bother' with house insurance?


I think it's more like people who have their pets "micro-chipped" which I assume is a similar RFID technology.   This seems to be pretty much standard practice now with responsible dog owners.

Insurance is a different approach - it seeks to provide cash compensation in the event of a theft.  Security marking, whether with pen and ink, RFID, or smart water, is designed to deter thieves, and increase the odds of recovering a stolen item.  Two quite distinct but complementary processes.
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Strigulino on January 05, 2012, 01:02:38 PM
Mine is smartwatered.

If money is really no object, you could see if anyone has an old iPhone if they've recently upgraded.  There's an app on those called Find My iPhone - the idea is that if you lose your phone you can track it via the built in GPS from a PC or another iPhone.  You'd have to strap it inside somehow and keep plugging it in though.  But it would work...
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: greybox1 on January 05, 2012, 01:47:36 PM
I know that their is thieves that specialise in accordions ie grey paolos etc.
Insurance is grand but where would one get another grey paolo even if insurance paid up.I know one gentleman that had two of these nicked.
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: JD on January 06, 2012, 10:31:36 AM
A smartphone-like device could give you a reasonable estimate of its location from the cells that it can connect to. GPS might not be needed. Power for the device will be the main problem. Will you remember to charge the batteries in your melodeon before it's stolen? Perhaps this should be an option on the FR-18.

I use RFID tagging on my motorcycle. My suspicion is that its main value is as a deterrent. That's fine for a bike (or car, trailer, etc...) but if a burglar sees a case in your house with a big "Datatag" label on it does he think, "This must be valuable" and grab it anyway? RFID tagging would only work if all instrument dealers (and repairers?) routinely checked every box that passed through their hands against a database of stolen instruments. Considering the apparently low volume of melodeon-related crime and the cost of RFID readers I don't see that happening.

Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: oggiesnr on January 06, 2012, 04:49:35 PM

I'm guessing that mine is pretty safe at home, as there are more easily nickable and saleable items that a burglar would be attracted to. I'm more concerned about it when I'm out at clubs and festivals, where people who know about these things can see that it's a nice box, but even then I like to think that the folk community is pretty honest. And unless someone wants to keep it for themself, it wouldn't be an easy item to dispose of if you don't know the first thing about it.

Don't rely on it.  I had a three row lachenal, a mandolin and a guitar go in one burglary (as well as the video, my CDs and a pile of other stuff).  If it looks like it will fetch a tenner (what the concertina got carbooted for) then if they've enough time it will go.

Steve
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Hallelujahal on January 06, 2012, 05:25:02 PM
Quote
if they've enough time it will go.
Couldn't agree more...everything has a street value, even a loaf of bread...which sadly means that a priceless instrument may be easily sold/bartered for a cheap bottle of paint-stripper white cider or a bag of heroin (which round these parts is ridiculously cheap, less than £10 for a bag).

I'd be fully in favour of inserting some kind of tracking device, and I'm sure the technology is rapidly getting there. However, I'm not totally convinced of where to insert it... ;)  ?
AL
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Theo on January 06, 2012, 05:32:47 PM
However, I'm not totally convinced of where to insert it... ;)  ?
AL

And the range of possibilities is even wider if you catch the thief...
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Lester on January 06, 2012, 06:19:13 PM
However, I'm not totally convinced of where to insert it... ;)  ?
AL

And the range of possibilities is even wider if you catch the thief...

 ;D
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 06, 2012, 06:32:41 PM
ROFL!  .. and to think of some of the posts that I've had 'moderated'  :|bl
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 06, 2012, 08:13:39 PM
And then there's the subject of your "bottomline"  ..... ..  . .   .  :|bl
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on July 13, 2016, 12:49:33 PM
Found this link on my FB page today. Looks interesting.


Sir John

https://buy.thetrackr.co/br/07/?utm_source=1664&utm_medium=FB&utm_term=30815183&utm_content=321&utm_campaign=GU&aff_id=1664&camp_id=10424&clk_id=30815183&sub_id=FB
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on July 13, 2016, 01:16:22 PM
Also here. Not cheap, but what's your box worth to you?


Sir John


http://www.thetrackr-uk.co.uk/product/trackr-bravo-2/
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 13, 2016, 02:54:18 PM
Also here. Not cheap, but what's your box worth to you?
It's not really meant to be an anti-theft device or full GPS tracker. I think you will find that it only has a limited range - within the Bluetooth signal range of your mobile phone, quoted as up to 100 feet. Scroll down the page on the link which you provided:
http://www.thetrackr-uk.co.uk/product/trackr-bravo-2/

Not much use if someone actually nicks the box and makes off with it pronto.
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Guy on July 13, 2016, 11:54:19 PM

I'm guessing that mine is pretty safe at home, as there are more easily nickable and saleable items that a burglar would be attracted to. I'm more concerned about it when I'm out at clubs and festivals, where people who know about these things can see that it's a nice box, but even then I like to think that the folk community is pretty honest. And unless someone wants to keep it for themself, it wouldn't be an easy item to dispose of if you don't know the first thing about it.

Don't rely on it.  I had a three row lachenal, a mandolin and a guitar go in one burglary (as well as the video, my CDs and a pile of other stuff).  If it looks like it will fetch a tenner (what the concertina got carbooted for) then if they've enough time it will go.

Steve

I had my Dobro nicked,  along with my computer, TV and stereo system. The thief left the much more valuable melodeons and Lowden guitar. Make of that what you will...
Fortunately he dumped it all at his girlfriend's house, and she shopped him to the police after realising that he was only stopping off there on the way back to his wife and family. He said he'd "bought it all cheap off a bloke in a pub", but they found the remote for the TV in his van which he'd sworn blind he hadn't used that day. I picked it all up from the police station next day, but wasn't allowed to leave until I'd played "Romeo and Juliet" on the Dobro, just to show that's what it did....these incidents can have happy endings, but I was very fortunate....
Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: JimmyM on July 14, 2016, 08:36:41 AM
 It might be worth remembering that most burglars/thieves are not sensible well educated chaps that will make rational decisions based around the ease of disposal of your wide screen, but huge, TV against the liklihood of unloading a more transportable Castagnari but in c/f  :'(

Possibly foolish of me but I feel my boxes are safer around other musicians but then I play music with some proper dodgy characters  >:E
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Stockaryd on July 14, 2016, 10:36:25 AM
In Sweden was recently   (may 2016)  a number of boxes stolen. Total value  approximately 100,000 pounds.

http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/StulnaDragspel.pdf       
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on July 14, 2016, 11:29:02 AM
This proves that Sweden has more cultured burglars, than we do. >:E


Sir John
Title: Re: Tracking device for melodeons!
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 15, 2016, 03:08:40 AM
I'm surprised that there is not a cost effective atmospheric pressure change or motion powered device yet for generating electricity for small devices - although the former used in a bellows box might outstrip the pressure differences expected in a more pneumaticlly passive instrument. Not sure what sort of power consumption active RFID devices have but Kinetic type watches use a relatively small and very mature technology.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal