Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Bobtheboat on January 08, 2012, 07:26:13 PM

Title: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Bobtheboat on January 08, 2012, 07:26:13 PM
Well folks I've got it!! Some of you may have read of my quest for an ideal (and affordable) box to accompany me on my journey into french music.
Briefly, I started off thinking I needed a G/C/F having mistakenly identified the boxes of players I admired as such. Disabused of such ideas and informed it was a G/C/acc 12 bass that I was after.
 I arranged with Mike Rowbotham to purchase a 1930's wooden bodied 2 1/2 row Hohner Erika for the project and we were off! I was then into layouts and the question of thirds in/out. I asked the question on the forum and got a large amount of helpful advice..... still stuck, I got a call from Mike. Being the clever and innovative chap he is he had developed a method to add a stop to remove the thirds!! Perfect!! The project was agreed and after a short wait the box arrived on Friday!!
I've spent the weekend with my new love and am happy as an exceedingly happy thing!!
I've dubbed the new arrival the 'Rowbotham Erika Extraordinaire'. It's a fabulous box. The tone is to die for, full bodied but mellow and 'woody' ( oh god I sound like Jilly Goulden), really soulful. The action is fast and responsive with very little clack. The bass stop is awesome and feels very well implemented indeed, really interesting possibilities are emerging. AND I've got 4 extra basses!! I (on Mike's advice) opted for third button start with low notes on the first two buttons which I love, they rumble!! Accidentals are on the 1/2 row. Great!!
I'm very pleased to be the owner of such a lovely ( and possibly unique) instrument and hope we have a long and happy career together.
Huge thanks to Mike for sorting out such a fantastic box for me. The bass stop, the 12 bass conversion, the action, other mod's and tuning have all been executed beautifully,I'm made up!!
Right, I've spent far too long on the wrong keyboard! Bob.
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Owen Woods on January 08, 2012, 08:21:37 PM
pics or it didn't happen :P
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Bobtheboat on January 08, 2012, 09:06:13 PM
Hehe, I'll ask Mike if he could post some. I don't have the technology on my phone to add attachments.(at least I don't think I do!) Bob.
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 04, 2014, 10:12:27 AM
Hi Bob,

I thought I'd resurrect this thread as I am having thoughts of a similar GC Erika Extraordinaire from Mr Rowbotham.

Could I ask a few questions:

What layout did you go for?

Any advice for someone starting the same process?

Thanks in advance.

Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 04, 2014, 10:40:58 AM
Defo 3rd button start on a GC base, the DG "squeaky end" doesn't apply, and FWIW I am entirely happy that way on my (effectively) accs/DG and accs/GC.

For a twelve base classically you'd add in *DG chordage. My old DG Oakwood went for an F(!) in the outer row (Ed Johnson was 1st owner) and I used that lots! In GC terms that's

  F/F     E/Am    B/Em
  C/G    G/D      D/Bb

A 3rd stop makes this very fluid (ie Dm works) and you have accompaniment in F, and can also drop a "blue" Bb in when playing in C, or a C,B,Bb,A chromatic run. But lots of other options, especially if you want to play it in *D. This setup is nice for minors. Whereas an F#/C# button would facilitate major bass runs? As ever, depends what you play. You also need to decide whether any extra chords should be nearer your nose … or toes ;)

Good luck in your journey.
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 04, 2014, 11:05:11 AM
Thanks Chris,

I'm don't yet understand how to chose the B direction. Anahata pointed there is no Fsharp on the push RH side, and I think I understand why this is relevant.

As for music choice, I love all the classic French 2 row G/C stuff on youtube, and my sandpiper G/C is great for this, but my I think I'm wanting a GC melodeon that is more suitable for also playing Em and Edorian Scottish and Scandinavian pieces.

Stephen
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 04, 2014, 02:34:21 PM
E dorian is second mode of the D scale EF#GABC#DE and as such is the "auto minor" on a DG, bit more work where you are going? Your "on rows" E scale will be simple/Neapolitan with a C natural, the "relative minor" to G (same as Bm on a DG). For E dorian I'd like a push C# acc.

It might work OK for Scandi in Em which can be "harmonic" with its D#leading note. You'll usually want your B chord same direction as the D# accidental for this to handle the dominant B major in that scale BD#F#(A). But a lot of Swedish stuff in particular is pretty "flexible" in its minor mode, that's to say C(#), D(#) depending what they're up to or mood! To get fluency you'd want all these note same direction?

Otherwise For the accs "standard French" is pretty good, but that's optimised for Am; there are alternatives. I'm sure Mike will offer shrewd advice. Why not do what Bob did, paste up your proposed layout and get some nitty gritty suggestions from the team here, as you focus in?
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 04, 2014, 04:28:32 PM
Thanks Chris,

Its making sense. I was thinking of A dorian when I wrote E Dorian, but I do dimly I understand how a push C sharp(s) on the accidentals will help. Harmonic minors are a bit of a mystery yet.

I'm hoping Bob can post his layout or point me towards it, and I'll definitely be consulting here once the build date nears. The Erika is a long term project, with no time pressure, so I'll keep playing and learning as I go to inform my chord selection to create something strong in its home keys, associated minors, and modes. Yup, the holy grail is near....

Today's epiphany was using D bass plus F chord and E bass with G chord to create some interesting minor sounds.

S
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 04, 2014, 07:37:57 PM
G# is the regular choice i believe for machines in GC like yours, instead of the D on push,

And i use that quite a lot too, especially when play in Amharmonic,
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 08, 2014, 06:35:18 PM
Thanks Wouter!

?G# vs D bass, I'd be grateful if you and Chris (or anyone else) could expand on the benefits/compromises inherent in each choice, with regard to my idea of having a GC melodeon "strong in its home keys, associated minors, and modes".

Layout at present may be something like this:

F/F E/A A/B or Eb/B
C/G G/D G#/Bb or D/Bb

Dutch reversal ie A/G on 5th button

Accidentals may be:
             
             C#/Eb G#/Bb A'/G' C#/Eb or maybe a reversed F or other
 G#/Bb
C#/Eb

Inspired in part by Finnish set up, Em on push. I think this should work well with Am, Em, both natural and harmonic.
Have not thought modes through carefully, any comments welcome here too on Dorian/Mixolydian possibilities.

BTW Chris, ref your earlier post, what does *D mean?
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 08, 2014, 10:09:33 PM
Well,...

I don't use the D on push a lot even when i have it on my 18 bass. I only use it in bassruns really. But i suppose if you like to play the German/Austrian way of playing Umpa it is useful. ( as in G g g D g g  for example) works pretty good on polka's as well i suppose. but like i said i dont use it a lot, perhaps Chriss can help you there.

The G# on push i DO use a lot, when playing in Am. The main use is as a transition-bass before going to Am again. And if you play without thirds and you want to give you E the real major flavor you can add your G#-bass in.

As for your other basses:
I have G#/Bb and Eb/B

The B and Bb are nobrainers, to me G# is as well.

The Eb is up for debate if up to me. I don't use it a lot, only when i am playing outside of the homekeys. (like in Gm, to play with pipes). Sometimes i use it as transition-bass to go to E.

You propose to put an A on push there, i can see that make sense. I find it especially useful when playing in Dm, which is almost homekey ;-). I dont use it a lot for other purposes, and i play with dutch reversal too (doubled).

Did you consider F#? Would make a lot of sense when playing in G. but ofcourse it's annoying that you would have the f# on yourmelody on pull and the F# bass on push. It could be an option perhaps to make the Bb push, and F# pull? But then you would have to make the accidental bb on your melody push as well, so that perhaps changes too much,...

oh well, just some musings, hope it helps you a bit.

Oh another thing: i play with F/F as well, but i have been thinking aboutr changing the F on push to something else. push B perhaps.

What do you mean with the "inspired by Finnish set up: Em on push"? I saw that they do that, but,...it's the position of the B that makes it Finnish i think.

W
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: pikey on May 08, 2014, 10:27:25 PM
How do you play in D without a push D bass ???
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 08, 2014, 11:18:55 PM
Thanks Wouter,

Lots of good ideas there. I'll have a good think about it in the morning. In the meantime please tell me what a doubled Dutch reversal is.

Thanks,

Stephen
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 09, 2014, 09:14:30 AM
W,

Regarding the Finnish set up, I was referring to some 2 row 8 bass GC melodeons set up for Em on the push with a A/A and E/B bass.

S
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 09, 2014, 09:52:17 AM
How do you play in D without a push D bass ???

Er … exactly the same way you play in A mixolydian (and you do!) which has same notes (5th mode of D major scale). You have a D pull bass(?) and EF#GABC# are all pull notes? Only issue is when you want to play the tonic D?

Well, you can just miss the note out "melodeonism" or use that feindishly clever "Dutch reversal"; one of the (identical) D/E plates flipped over, "simples"?

Well it is … if you spell Couper with a U and learned the box in the huis of your Oma. Walrus should be warned that Dutch reversing involves "unlearning" every tune you ever played, it is musically unstable should your finger reach instinctively for that D, but get E :|bl I tried it for a whole summer; it was painful. Incredibly logical, but something you need to embed very early in a Melodeonista's education.

Whereas my pull D on helper row, I now use all the time, geen probleem. Either mod makes all modes of D finger better, eg the ubiquitous E dorian, or B "relative" minor, and its derivative B blues scale
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 09, 2014, 11:19:25 AM
How do you play in D without a push D bass ???

Uhm we are talking GC here. and homekeys. so,...on the pull obviously ;-)

But i don't play in D major a lot. Dm i do. on the pull as well.

a D-bass on the push,...does that help? Dunno, you English-speakers are in the know i guess ;-) but with the only f# on the pull i would say a D on push doesnt really help a lot.
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 09, 2014, 12:06:26 PM
W,

Regarding the Finnish set up, I was referring to some 2 row 8 bass GC melodeons set up for Em on the push with a A/A and E/B bass.

Lots of good ideas there. I'll have a good think about it in the morning. In the meantime please tell me what a doubled Dutch reversal is.

Thanks,

Stephen

with doubled Dutch reversal i meant that in my lower octave i ave an a on push as well (and i dont in the upper octave).

And about the Finnish thing: yeah, i rread about that. But what makes the difference i think is having the B on an 8-Bass, the Em on push is not what you miss for playing in Em. :-) Oh wait, you were referring to the A on push probably...perhaps you should ask that to one of the Finnish guys. When i play in Em i always use A on pull, but perhaps it is easier on push for those scandinavian tunes.
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 09, 2014, 04:59:57 PM
Well Chris, the Walrus is triply blessed in having an Ouma, a 2 row with a Dutch reversal, and a very small repertoire.

Wouter, could you please clarify the details of your reversal, I'm not sure what you mean.
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 09, 2014, 10:15:16 PM
Well Chris, the Walrus is triply blessed in having an Ouma, a 2 row with a Dutch reversal, and a very small repertoire.

Wouter, could you please clarify the details of your reversal, I'm not sure what you mean.

The other isnt really a reversal, but i have an "a" on push on my 2nd button innerrow. you would have to order a different reed, you cannot just flip it.
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 18, 2014, 06:20:31 PM
Interested to hear what you decide :-)
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 18, 2014, 09:10:16 PM
Thanks Wouter,

C row: Low A instead of G, then a reversed 5' (A/G). Maybe another 'reversal' in the high octave.

Basses remain difficult choice:

Option 1:

F/F E/Am G#/B
C/G G/D Bb/Eb

Accidentals G#/Eb Bb/C# G#/Eb Bb/C#

Option2:

F/F E/Am Am/B - adding B for Em and a few handy reversals.
C/G G/D  D/C

Accidentals similar.

I don't understand the long term consequences of either choice, but the second may be limiting or teach "unisonoric" habits. I imagine Am and Em in harmonic minors will feature in what I play (I like French and Scandinavian playing) though if I go for option 2 having G#/Eb and C# on the accidental row are a useful place to start exploring, and basses can always be changed.

Option 3:

F/F E/Am B/Em
C/G G/D D/Bb

I can certainly see the merit in your setup Chris, also on the list.

And as an aside - it now makes complete sense to me why a D/G is the weapon of choice for Em and E dorian.

Yours in confusion,

S



Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 20, 2014, 02:20:38 PM
Wouter,

Here is another potential layout based on your F# recommendation:

The "Cooper" layout:

F/F E/Am G#/B
C/G G/D Bb/F#

Accidentals: would you go for G# and Bb push, Eb and C# on pull?

S

Translated into D/G that would be:

C/C A/Em Eb/F#
G/D D/A F/C#
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on May 21, 2014, 07:59:37 AM
Wouter,

Here is another potential layout based on your F# recommendation:

The "Cooper" layout:

F/F E/Am G#/B
C/G G/D Bb/F#

Accidentals: would you go for G# and Bb push, Eb and C# on pull?


With this setup of your basses, the direction of your acidentals makes a lot of sense, yes.
And i think the setup of your basses looks good as well. I dont play a 12-bass (its 8 or 18 for me), but if i did, i would follow this.

What is the rest of your accidental row? You really want that G# on push like you have. but having it on pull would be nice as well.
W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on May 21, 2014, 08:39:23 AM
Wouter,

Its a converted Hohner Erika, so 2.4 plus 12.

As mentioned I already play with a 'gedraaide 5' so won't need a reversed A/G on the helper row. I like your idea of a low A on the 2nd inner row button.

I could use the chin buttons to give me low notes or more accidentals (so a total of 6 buttons available) There may be place for a pull G#.

Your setup suggestion would be most welcome:

                    ?/? ?/? ?/? ?/?
  ?/?
?/?

Thanks
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 21, 2014, 10:16:48 AM
Option 1:

F/F E/Am G#/B
C/G G/D Bb/Eb

I'd tend to have the Eb same way as E, which brings Bb same way as B  (:) and you'd be set up for some amazing chromatic bass runs without having to change bellows direction (and then fit tune back in t'other way). It isn't mega important as you could flip the plate later, but my 12 bass era experience was that C,F,Bb same way facilitated playing in F. F's relative and dorian minors are D and G respectively; you have those pull too.  But this it to offer the "all on the pull" way of playing, I'd call it "continental". But I think this applies to any melodeon playing off the main row modes?

I'd see G# as a push bass, working with E in A harmonic minor. All of these will have consequences for your right end helper row though. There might even be some Eb playability, but my experience has been that to play "that far" off main row keys, needs left chromaticity both ways (18 or 24 bass)

Don't forget cross chords, I'm experimenting melding F, Bb and Eb basses with C, D and A chords (needs to be no thirds) for some quite lush effects in Bb.

This layout is weak in D? My DG,12bass had equiv=A both ways and that was very useful, A became a push key for me. In a sense a lot of this is about whether you are seeking to play majors or minor tunes, and (related in a way) whether you will tend to go off piste into flatter keys, or sharper.

Hope this "philosophical" approach is helpful rather than confusing. As ever all depends on what one plays :|glug
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on July 25, 2014, 10:03:01 PM

Oh another thing: i play with F/F as well, but i have been thinking about changing the F on push to something else. push B perhaps.

What do you mean with the "inspired by Finnish set up: Em on push"? I saw that they do that, but,...it's the position of the B that makes it Finnish i think.
W

Wll, i changed one of my 2r8b-boxes to having a Bm on push instead of the F, will let you know how that goes. ;-)
(In DG-terms that is: instead of push C i have push F#m)

First thing to note: i need to alter all tunes that i played in Em (Bm in DG-speak). And it is odd, most tunes have the I in one direction and the V in the other. Not the case now.

W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on July 30, 2014, 09:21:49 PM
Wouter, keep me updated as to progress.

By "Em on the push" I was referring to the way Em was played on a GC (I on the push, V on the pull), the opposite of Am (I pull V push) ie the position of the E and B basses relative to each other.

The Finns seem to have 2 bass setups described, one thus:

G/D       C/G
Em/Am   B(7)/B(7)

and the other thus:

G/D        C/G
Em/B(7)  Am/Am

with 'standard' accidentals and a Dutch reversal.

When you play in Em on a 3 row 12 bass, do you use a pull B(m).

Stephen
 
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 31, 2014, 09:16:22 AM
Steven, harmony depends on the 'mode' of the tune. There is no standard "minor" as only notes 1-4 of a scale define minorness.

If your are in folk tune genres then the B=V triad will always be Bm. Virtually all the other melodies will want a B7 chord to get a dominant cadance. That includes harmonic minors (quite a lot of that in Finland!) Balkan, Klesmer, most classical (see lecture 1 in the Edinburgh theory summer course) and quite a lot of minor blues. Melodeons don't offer true (4 note) "7" chords but a major B triad works.

fixes usually recommended here are either 3rds out left end chords, or crossing a D triad with B bass (Bm7) … or a bit of both ;)

Yes, a pull B(whatever) helps against a push Em scale, you've gotta fill those bellows occasionslly
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: The Walrus on September 03, 2014, 09:25:46 PM
Wouter,

How is the Bm push experiment going?
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on September 05, 2014, 09:24:55 AM
Wouter,

How is the Bm push experiment going?

I quite like it, although it is on my 2row which i play not so often as my 3row,..so the judgment might be premature.

The options that i get with that B bass, and Bm-chord make me very happy.
But as it turns out i used the F on push a bit more then i thought. Sometimes keeping it pushed in for  bellowshake effect on the f-chord with a nice push-pull-melody, and also in combination with G: Gf or Fg (for sort of Gsus4 and G7). So it is a bit of adjusting.

So it's not as much "win" as i thought, as what i lose was bigger then i thought. Still i think the Win is bigger than the Loss.

W
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 07, 2014, 12:00:19 AM
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and I like to learn.

I know you'll take this in good part Wouter! A low sounding instrument or note is said to be in the bass register. The heavy bottom of a floor standing lamp and the concrete bit at the bottom of a garage are the base of the object in question. If you reduce a conversation to the worst of bad language (swearing) this too is regarded as base. So bass for music and base for everything else that is as low as you can go.

Be well,

Pete.  ;D
Title: Re: My new (baby) Melodeon!
Post by: Cooper on September 07, 2014, 09:13:46 AM
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and I like to learn.

I know you'll take this in good part Wouter!
I do, thx!
W
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal