Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Keithypete. on January 09, 2012, 02:42:41 PM
-
I have found that just lowering the action reduces some of the 'unwanted' treble mechanical noise. Not enough though. What are the tried & trusted methods for quietening, or de-clacking the mechanism? Also I would like to replace the buttons with either black pearl or plain black - do such things exist or does one have to adapt or bastardize something else?
Thanks in advance.
-
Pete--there is a good thread on this somewhere already, but I can't off hand find it.
Try search "clack".
The key is in re-padding the pads, not so much the action.
Though reducing the treble button travel is probably the best fix for general playability. And super easy to do.
-
I had a bit of look for pertinent threads, but I often get nothing with the search facility.
When you say 're-padding', do you mean the pallet faces? I can think of a number of ways to do this but I'm sure there is a best way.
-
My Club II was MUCH quieter after refacing pallets with felt-backed Persian leather. Mind you, I quite like a bit of clack (in a Hohner, that is...... :D).
Graham
-
What you need to do is remove the pallets and fit some of Charlie Marhall's Super Pallet leather (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#3)
Some pics of the job being done on a one row pokerwork (https://plus.google.com/photos/109058536503428722881/albums/5543569938481130433)
-
What you need to do is remove the pallets and fit some of Charlie Marhall's Super Pallet leather (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#3)
Some pics of the job being done on a one row pokerwork (https://plus.google.com/photos/109058536503428722881/albums/5543569938481130433)
Yep - that's the stuff.
-
Is it by any chance sticky-backed, or would some sort of contact adhesive be used?
-
Is it by any chance sticky-backed, or would some sort of contact adhesive be used?
I use Copydex.
-
I used a white PVA-type glue. There plenty of safe, easy to use glues that will successfully stick felt to wood.
-
And see here, too: https://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?authkey=Gv1sRgCP7Y9Kjp0pCacw#5548832015960157282
Bob
-
And see here, too: https://picasaweb.google.com/robtgf/HohnerPokerwork?authkey=Gv1sRgCP7Y9Kjp0pCacw#5548832015960157282
Bob
[/quote
Thanks for the post. Brilliant stuff. I especially like the bass action wooden conversion thing.
-
I think I have used what is called "craft glue".
-
Is it by any chance sticky-backed, or would some sort of contact adhesive be used?
Charlie Marshall recommends Bostick general purpose glue, which is a contact-type adhesive. I've used it for refacing pallets and it works just fine. Do a batch of pallets at one time, side-by-side on the leather/felt sheet laid out on a cutting board or similar. Use a thin film of glue on both the pallet surface and the felt, allow a couple of minutes to become tacky, then just press together. Since a strong bond forms almost immediately, you can then get on with the business of using a sharp blade to separate the individual pallets and trim off any excess facing material.
-
Almost any glue with reasonably quick grab and a shortish open time will do the job; whatever your favourite is. Incidentally, there are two Bostik GP glues - a white PVA and a clear.
-
Incidentally, there are two Bostik GP glues - a white PVA and a clear.
OK - it's clear sort which Charlie recommends.
-
Thanks to everyone for their input, really helpful. Is limiting the button travel as easy? Will it have any impact on the noise of the action?
-
Thanks to everyone for their input, really helpful. Is limiting the button travel as easy? Will it have any impact on the noise of the action?
I believe it will help and Theo's masterclass is HERE (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.137624888166.109685.709188166&type=3)
-
Thanks to everyone for their input, really helpful. Is limiting the button travel as easy? Will it have any impact on the noise of the action?
I believe it will help and Theo's masterclass is HERE (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.137624888166.109685.709188166&type=3)
Here is the link which bypasses the Facebook login window.
Theo's method (http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.137624888166.109685.709188166&l=c564b24e38)
Limiting the button travel is definitely to be recommended. I've used Theo's method successfully on two instruments and it works very nicely. The only modification I like to make to Theo's method is to glue a thin leather strip on top of the buffer bar. It cuts down the noise even more. I guess eventually it will wear through to the wood, but it hasn't happened so far in two years of playing. The leather strip can easily be renewed if and when the time comes.
-
The only modification I like to make to Theo's method is to glue a thin leather strip on top of the buffer bar. It cuts down the noise even more.
Yes you can do that. It will also make the feel of the action softer. Whether you prefer this or the more positive stop you get without it is a matter of personal preference. The kind of wood you use also makes a difference. I always use western red cedar, a very soft timber, and I find I don't need to add a softening strip. The main reason I don't like to use the added strip is that it make it very difficult to get the exact distance of travel you want. The inner row levers and the out row levers have slightly different geometry and if you want the same travel for both then the wooden strip has to be relieved slightly more under the inner row levers, and it takes quite a bit of trial and error adjustment to get it right. I can't see how to accomplish that if there is a leather strip in place, or to allow for adding it after making the adjustments. Just use a nice soft timber and you can avoid all that.
-
The only modification I like to make to Theo's method is to glue a thin leather strip on top of the buffer bar. It cuts down the noise even more.
Yes you can do that. It will also make the feel of the action softer.
Yes it does, but only slightly and I actually quite like it. It's similar in feel to the mushroom-style buttons which have a felt washer underneath the head.
The main reason I don't like to use the added strip is that it make it very difficult to get the exact distance of travel you want. The inner row levers and the out row levers have slightly different geometry and if you want the same travel for both then the wooden strip has to be relieved slightly more under the inner row levers, and it takes quite a bit of trial and error adjustment to get it right. I can't see how to accomplish that if there is a leather strip in place, or to allow for adding it after making the adjustments.
It's no more difficult to achieve than getting the travel right with just the wooden strip. Once I've made an impression of the lever arms on the wood by pressing them down, I then use a small diameter rat-tailed file to make a shallow tapering U-shaped groove perhaps about 2 mm wide and deep on the forward edge, tapering off somewhat towards the rear (photo 08). The groove slopes downwards slightly from rear to front in order to accommodate the slightly different travel required for inside and outside rows.
I then glue a thin leather strip along the length of the wooden strip, taking care to press it firmly into the filed grooves (photos 09 and 10). However, before gluing the leather strip finally into place, it is worth doing a 'dry run' test assembly with the leather strip temporarily held in place with a bit of masking tape; this will soon allow you to see whether the grooves in the wood are deep enough. In practice, slight discrepancies in the pallet travel and the resting height of the buttons along the rows can be subsequently adjusted by bending the lever slightly using thin round-nosed pliers - something which you would probably need to do anyway, even without the leather strip.
Edited to add photos of modification to Hohner C/F Erica
-
Just to clarify, is this the right thickness to use to quiet the bass & treble buttons of Pokerworks?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#3
-
I used it on all of my old boxes and it works fine! Sometimes it comes with red felt.
-
Just to clarify, is this the right thickness to use to quiet the bass & treble buttons of Pokerworks?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#3
Yes, that's the stuff, but remember this is for pallet facing renewal, not for a felt/leather buffer under the key lever arms.
-
I have the felt/leather from Charlie Marshall. Couple of questions:
I take it it's a good idea to remove the existing palette facing before adding the new stuff?
What glue do people use to reattach the palettes to the rods?
Thanks!
-
I take it it's a good idea to remove the existing palette facing before adding the new stuff?
Yep! I slide a blade in between the leather and the wood of the pallet which will remove the bulk of the leather and finish off using a sheet of 80 grit wet-n-dry on a flat board to remove ny remaining. I then use Copydex to attach the new facing, others use PVA.
What glue do people use to reattach the palettes to the rods?
I use a hot glue gun as it is a good fix and is removable if needed, others have reported using PVA and even reed wax.
-
We found that soaking the pallets in a shallow dish of methylated spirits (as suggested somewhere here - sorry, can't find where now) for a few minutes worked really well for removing the old facings - they peeled off easily, taking most of the old glue with them.
And planning to use a hot glue gun, as Lester says, to re-attach the pallets to the levers - I think another benefit of this is that it is slightly flexible so that it allows adjustment of the pallets so that they sit flat over the holes through to the reed blocks (I'm sure there's a technical term for this bit of the melodeon...) if they are not positioned perfectly on the levers when you re-attach them, which sounded very reassuring for a novice.
-
I think that was me who put up the original post.
If you do use methylated spirit make sure you don't leave the pallet facing to soak, 10 seconds is plenty otherwise the pallet will 'dish'. I would only use this method if the facings are really difficult to remove, otherwise as Lester says, peel off the facings and remove what's left with coarse abrasive paper on a flat board.
Personally I would never use hot glue for attaching pallets, It's a right pain if you ever want to remove them. Far better (in my opinion) to use a 6mm dot of linen cut out with a leather punch and glued on with pva. These can then be easily adjusted or removed but will last for years...many 1930s Hohners still have the originals.
Martyn
-
Martyn,
Have to disagree about the difficulty of removing hot glue fixed pallets. The stuff always peels of cleanly when I've had to remove it. I only place the glue as a pat over the pallet with the arm already in place. If you place the hot glue and then press the arm into it then I agree about the difficulty, but that applies to any glue placed into the groove below the arm.
If there is a difficulty with hot melt it is in learning to apply it cleanly, but that is something that comes quickly with a bit of practice.
-
If there is a difficulty with hot melt it is in learning to apply it cleanly, but that is something that comes quickly with a bit of practice.
Yes. You can end up with a melodeon full of 'cat whiskers'.
-
Personally I would never use hot glue for attaching pallets, It's a right pain if you ever want to remove them. Far better (in my opinion) to use a 6mm dot of linen cut out with a leather punch and glued on with pva. These can then be easily adjusted or removed but will last for years...many 1930s Hohners still have the originals.
Au contraire, a hot glue gun works very well, as Theo and others pointed out. I have updated pallets of half a dozen instruments already without any problem.
As for the original "discs" I believed they were glued with animal hide glue, and one has to be careful when removing them as sometimes bits of the pallet will follow!
-
I use an aliphatic resin glue (also, I believe, sometimes known as "yellow glue", but I'm open to correction); it holds really firmly but it's easy to break the bond between the glue and the metal of the arm to remove the pallet. The wood then cleans up very quickly with a small sharp (and I mean SHARP) chisel and non-clog abrasive.
Graham
-
I rebuilt the keyboard of one with pallet assemblies from Weltmeister, the thing was REALLY quiet. The pallets have rubber wrists that slide on the old arms ,with aluminium pallets faced with felt and leather. Worked great on a old Hohner Carmen too. made it nearly as quiet as a new Borsini I have in the shop.
-
My vintage Hohner 12 bass has little screws holding the palettes on, with a bit of glue. They are unscrewing pretty easily. I'll add a dab of white carpenter's glue when I screw them back on.
-
Leave the screws slightly loose when you glue the pallets back on. If you snug down the screws it will cause the pallet to try to lign up with the flat bit on the end of the arm, odds are that the flat on the arm is not perfectly parallel with the deck. White glue/PVA will hold the arm around the screw ,and allow the pallet just enough flex to deal with things.
-
I have the impression that a dab of glue is just to prevent the screw from unscrewing rather than to attach the arm to the palette.
-
The glue does a couple of things, It keeps the pallet from rotating, and it "fixes" the pallet from tilting.
I found if I put a flexible joint on the triangular bass valves that the pallet appeared to be able to tilt under bellows compression ,and allow leaks. It appears that it is important that the pallet be held firmly flat.
-
I just completed the work on the basses of my BbEb vintage Hohner. Actually a bit of a tricky job getting the tiny screws back into their tiny holes with the palette arms in the way. And yes, the glue is essential for holding the palettes in position - the tiny screws not being at all sufficient.
I would say that 80% of the noise is gone now, even without tackling the treble palettes. I have a feeling my Pokerworks have a little more treble palette noise than the old Hohner though.
-
Those tiny screws are fun, I use a bit of reed wax on the tip of the driver to hold them on, it makes it a lot easier to maneuver.
Kimric