Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on January 10, 2012, 08:00:04 PM
-
Just wondering......
for no logical reason, I prefer open keyboards as on my tommy as opposed to a closed one like on -say- a Hohner or a lot of other boxes. To me open ones look aesthetically nice.
Is there any constructional differences/benefits to either?
I presume on anything other than a 2 row, the third or half row's levers would get in the way if open?
Any thoughts?
Q
-
Just wondering......
for no logical reason, I prefer open keyboards as on my tommy as opposed to a closed one like on -say- a Hohner or a lot of other boxes. To me open ones look aesthetically nice.
Is there any constructional differences/benefits to either?
I presume on anything other than a 2 row, the third or half row's levers would get in the way if open?
Any thoughts?
Q
The levers on an open keyboard box like the Tommy are made of wood and are a close fit in the keyboard slots. Rarely (as has been reported on here) changes in temperature and humidity can cause the wood to swell resulting in the levers binding in the keyboard slots. This is not a problem on closed keyboards where the action is made from metal levers (usually steel or aluminium) and which are not housed in a keyboard slot.
I've owned several open keyboard instruments over the years and never once have experienced any problems with binding/sticking.
-
Does anyone know what wood is used for the levers and mechanisms?
-
Usually the same as for the rest of the casing.
-
changes in temperature and humidity can cause the wood to swell resulting in the levers binding in the keyboard slots
As can accidental ingress of beer.
Please don't ask me how I know this.
-
Ditto, PVA glue :o
Ditto, don't want to reiterate the detail :|glug
-
Or cider -- at least it wasn't *my* cider...
(but I poured it out again and all was well after it dried out -- maybe Oakwoods are cider-proof?)
-
An open keyboard can suffer from atmospheric influences, but thanks to their broad pivots, they tend to have quite a good action on even quite a cheaply made box. Of course, this is helped by the fact that wood banging against wood is reasonable quiet, too.
Closed keyboards, being mad of thin strip metal have small pivot areas so can easily wobble and clatter around. They vary from total c**p, Hohners being at the lowest acceptable end of the range, to brilliantly fast and near silent actions, such as my Casta Trilly. Although, being closed, they are not usually vulnerable, should any component become bent, it can be the devil's own job getting them working properly again - at least at DIY level.
The other issue often cited as deciding which is preferrable is the choice between flat and stepped keyboards. Open keyboard are traditionally stepped and closed ones flat, but whilst many Irish players swear they cannot abide a stepped keyboards as they can't slide, others (notably Sharron Shannon) don't find it a problem either way. I just realised that I couldn't think whether the Trilly is a flat keyboard even though I was playing it in a session last night. Unfortunately it doesn't mean I can play like Ms Shannon, just proves the last G&T really hit the spot.
Rob.
P.S. Just looked, the Trilly has a very slightly stepped closed keyboard.
-
flatties for me, today yesterday and tommorow, nuff said!, e'rr did anyone mention stepped?. sf
-
Call me old fashioned, but I seem to have an alternative receptacle for beer and cider :|glug
....but pva ??? hope it doesn't get stuck half way down :Ph
I like the stepped keyboards too, as well as open, so perhaps I'm a bit strange.
Mind you in my limited playing life I've 0nly really played my open stepped one!
Just borrowed a larger size melodeon off a friend. That's open and stepped too.
I live a sheltered life.. :|bl
:D