Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Michael Eskin on January 14, 2012, 04:41:42 PM

Title: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Michael Eskin on January 14, 2012, 04:41:42 PM
Any have a recommendation for a way to keep the strap buckles on my Saltarelle from scratching the instrument? 

After a few minor scrapes, I finally decided to just cover the edge of the keyboard in clear packing tape where the buckle might slide against the wood, but this seems like it would be a common issue and I'm curious how others solve it.

Thanks for any suggestions,

Michael
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Lester on January 14, 2012, 05:02:39 PM
Try this recent thread

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8613.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8613.0.html)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Michael Eskin on January 14, 2012, 05:20:22 PM
Perfect, thanks!
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 14, 2012, 07:19:32 PM
When you've had your Saltarelle for as long as I have you won't worry about a few scratches - they'll be part of its character. Mine's WELL worn, scratched, scuffed,dented - and I wouldn't willingly part with it.

Graham
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Bryson on January 17, 2012, 12:43:59 PM
I just cut a cylinder from an old bicycle inner tube and slide that over the buckles.
Recycled material... as it were :)

Sorry I'll get my coat
Bryson
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Prestidigitator on January 17, 2012, 12:56:37 PM
I just cut a cylinder from an old bicycle inner tube and slide that over the buckles.
Recycled material... as it were :)

Sorry I'll get my coat
Bryson

That's what I feel like doing whenever I get a puncture!

I buy a thick ribbed elastic material, 3 inches wide, of the sort that  nurses' belts were made of in the Hattie Jacques era, from a haberdashers. It costs about £3 per yard.

Then I amuse myself by sewing cylindrical buckle protectors, which look similar to the ones that Bernard Loffet supplies with his instruments. If I'm feeling inspired, I make two out of different colours and sew them together, so I have a two-tone protector.

Sad, isn't it?
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Larry on January 17, 2012, 01:21:47 PM
I find the bicycle tube works great.
someone said to me that it was in poor taste
but I played rather better then him so who knows.? ;)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Albert on January 17, 2012, 02:10:14 PM
The Button Box in the U.S. (www.buttonbox.com) has leather strap covers that work well and are inexpensive.

Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 17, 2012, 02:41:33 PM
I've used 1"-wide double-sided Velcro strips most effectively for several years. You need a strip about 8" or 9" long for each buckle. The strip is wrapped around the buckle in a spiral fashion, covering all the sharp edges. The double-sided velcro sticks to itself and with the soft, furry side of the velcro outermost, gives quite adequate protection for your instrument. it is also easy to remove and reposition whenever you wish to adjust the buckles.

I used to sell a kit of strips for a small sum (about £5 for 6 strips, sufficient for two straps), but I'm afraid I'm out of stock at the moment. If there was sufficient interest, I'd get a new supply in and offer the kit for sale again.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: JD on January 17, 2012, 08:15:19 PM
I don't want to wreck your business Steve but Maplin sell suitable velcro cable ties at just over £6 for a pack of six. As someone who used to work in the electronic installation business £1 for a cable tie sounds horrendous but £1 for a buckle protector sounds quite reasonable!

When I bought a box from Bernard Loffet there was a pair of the elastic buckle protectors included. They weren't tight enough so they kept slipping back from the buckles. I'm not sure I would have bothered if they hadn't been a freebie.

Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: pete /acorn on January 17, 2012, 10:20:09 PM
Hi
I've been testing out a design in leather,have just ordered leathers in black and light tan,will post when first batch complete.

Pete
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 17, 2012, 10:31:54 PM
I've plugged this before, but it still works. I use those soft crash belt covers which you can get from Pound Shops (other similar outlets are available), which are designed to stop the belt from cutting into delicate shoulders. I did have a lovely pink "Hello Kitty" one which was demonstrated at Sidmouth this year, but unfortunately the head of the household decided it suited her more than me and, as good things go, it went. They work very well though and are removeable when one (note the grammar!) wishes to adjust the straps.  :||:  :|glug
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Cooper on January 18, 2012, 12:34:00 AM
you could also stop caring ;-)
W
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Lester on January 18, 2012, 12:50:47 AM
you could also stop caring ;-)
W

 ;D
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Anahata on January 18, 2012, 07:58:27 AM
I can't find it now, but didn't someone (in another thread) suggest heatshrink sleeving?
A hairdryer is hot enough to shrink it, and it should stay in place reliably - only snag might be that you have to destroy the protector if you ever want to undo the buckle.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 18, 2012, 09:29:57 AM
I don't want to wreck your business Steve but Maplin sell suitable velcro cable ties at just over £6 for a pack of six. As someone who used to work in the electronic installation business £1 for a cable tie sounds horrendous but £1 for a buckle protector sounds quite reasonable!
I tried them. They are not wide enough nor long enough to go round the full extent of a single buckle. On some of the padded straps, the buckle assembly is quite large, especially the rear strap buckle. If left unprotected, these often cause damage to the keyboard and grille when the straps are folded to put the instrument away in a hard case.

My price covered the cost and risk of buying a 25 metre reel of 1" velcro plus postage/packing to the recipient. I made a few pence on each sale, which I thought was justified.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: JD on January 18, 2012, 11:14:37 AM
I don't want to wreck your business Steve but Maplin sell suitable velcro cable ties at just over £6 for a pack of six. As someone who used to work in the electronic installation business £1 for a cable tie sounds horrendous but £1 for a buckle protector sounds quite reasonable!
I tried them. They are not wide enough nor long enough to go round the full extent of a single buckle. On some of the padded straps, the buckle assembly is quite large, especially the rear strap buckle. If left unprotected, these often cause damage to the keyboard and grille when the straps are folded to put the instrument away in a hard case.

My price covered the cost and risk of buying a 25 metre reel of 1" velcro plus postage/packing to the recipient. I made a few pence on each sale, which I thought was justified.

I take your point. Glad to see the entrepreneurial spirit alive and well. It is possible to buy reels of velcro that are 50mm wide which may do an even neater job.

I also take the point about buckles damaging the box in the case. I got round this by wrapping the cleaning cloth supplied with my BP3 round the two buckle straps whenever the box was put away.

For me the most damage was always done by my belt buckle hitting the back of the bellows. Middle age (ok, time for the truth, old age) spread has supplied a large buffer that seems to prevent this quite effectively.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve C. on January 18, 2012, 01:15:04 PM
If you can get some concertina leather scraps, they are nice and stretchy, and when sewn into an "inside out" tube, make super covers.

In US Button Box sells their concertina scraps, perhaps others do also.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Prestidigitator on January 18, 2012, 01:22:04 PM
If you can get some concertina leather scraps, they are nice and stretchy, and when sewn into an "inside out" tube, make super covers.

In US Button Box sells their concertina scraps, perhaps others do also.

Great idea.

A while ago I bought a large bag (about 2 kilos) of mixed leather scraps or offcuts from the leather merchants and makers Pittards in Somerset for about £10. Some of it has gone into melodeons, some into other things, and a good bit is left over. There was some stretchy glove leather in there which would be just the job.

Now where the ???? did I put it?
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Noodle on January 19, 2012, 02:58:11 AM
With all this talk of velcro, I'm quite surprised no one's mentioned anything or developed shoulder straps that are fastened by velcro, or something as equally kind to wood instead of metal buckles. It's already used for left hand straps.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Anahata on January 19, 2012, 08:33:50 AM
A while ago I bought a large bag (about 2 kilos) of mixed leather scraps or offcuts from the leather merchants

Now there's an idea. I have a piece of soft leather (cut off a discarded garment, I think) which would be perfect for this. A little weekend project coming up...
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 19, 2012, 08:42:48 AM
With all this talk of velcro, I'm quite surprised no one's mentioned anything or developed shoulder straps that are fastened by velcro, or something as equally kind to wood instead of metal buckles. It's already used for left hand straps.
Left hand straps don't support the weight of the instrument. Shoulder straps have a different purpose. I'm not sure I'd want to trust the suspension of my instrument to a couple of inches of velcro. If it snagged on something (e.g. clothing) and came undone inadvertently, the results could be disastrous.  :o
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 20, 2012, 06:56:22 AM
Apparently NASA helmets have a Velcro patch inside for use as a nose-scratcher.......maybe a melodeon-related use?  ;D (sorry - late night last night!!)

Graham
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Michael Eskin on February 01, 2012, 04:11:23 PM
I picked up a couple of the fabric buckle covers being sold out of France on eBay. They are wonderful. Ordering two more for the top buckles as well as two more sets for another instrument.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: playandteach on May 09, 2013, 10:10:20 PM
Any have a recommendation for a way to keep the strap buckles on my Saltarelle from scratching the instrument? 
I've just bought a set of finger supports for basketball players. There are lots of different makes on Amazon - I bought the longest (42mm). They are a nice tight fit - seem to be made of spandex, nylon and elastic. Cost £3.12 with free postage (for 10).
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Bill Young on May 09, 2013, 11:00:22 PM
Those look really neat - better than the insulating tape I have used. I take it it's these ones? (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Basketball-Fitness-Neoprene-Support-Protector/dp/B00ARBRCLM/ref=sr_1_7?ie=UTF8&qid=1368136359&sr=8-7&keywords=Finger+supports+basketball).
I've just ordered a set.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: playandteach on May 09, 2013, 11:12:04 PM
Those are the ones - though the packet that arrived looked like it might have been from a different batch (just in terms of the packet). If you find out they're no good, PM me and I'll post you a couple of mine.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve C. on May 10, 2013, 02:01:05 AM
Another useful item: sailors tape, not used to repair sails but the tape used to cover turnbuckles.  It is stretchy vinyl with no adhesive, it sticks to itself.  Many colors.  Not expensive.  Take a look on Amazon if you don't have a sailing store nearby.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 10, 2013, 02:08:08 AM
The buckle was carving a groove into my van der Aa, which arrived Christmas Eve, at a rate of knots!

I have wound it with an old, and lonely shoelace found in a cupboard. It was of suitable hue, is undo-able, Planet friendly and is utterly disposable.  Any bets it'll still be there in ten years?  ;)

[edit] Should add that it no longer knots! ::)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Prestidigitator on May 10, 2013, 09:44:29 AM
Inspired by the black elastic protectors which came with my Loffet, I located some wide (3"), patterned and ribbed elastic at a haberdasher's in Norwich. It comes in red with a "wove" pattern and in ribbed black, and I think is intended for nurses' belts.

It's easy to sew into tubes, and a pair takes about 10 minutes to make. The elastic costs about £3 a metre.

I also bought some narrower elastic, and made a few sets of 2-tone protectors. The colour range is much greater, so it would be possible to get even more fancy and have striped protectors in, for example, your national colours. It just needs a bit more needlework.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: dunlustin on May 10, 2013, 09:58:55 AM
At least some Roland straps come with loops at the bottom to keep buckles well away and velcro at the top.
Perhaps these are available independently?
Is JIMD the man to ask?
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: ACE on May 10, 2013, 10:02:10 AM
A pack of ten protectors for a quid. Small size ladies rubber gloves, also comes in many colours. Or you can even find free ones from the cupboard under the sink.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Prestidigitator on May 10, 2013, 11:26:48 AM
........ Or you can even find free ones from the cupboard under the sink.

Not if I value my life, I can't!
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 10, 2013, 04:58:07 PM
I had some black cord material after cutting off some new cords to make breeches for  :M
My seamstress wife has sewn velcro along the lengths so that it closes around the lower end of both straps from bottom buckle to just above the main mid strap buckle.
The MkII version consists of adding some black tape material sewn into the lower end to tie it onto the bottom strap fixing to stop it riding up whilst playing.
Works a treat!
Q
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve C. on May 10, 2013, 05:21:28 PM
Were these the dimensions:
Each one: 5.3cm long, 2.6cm wide?
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: TomB on May 10, 2013, 06:22:14 PM
Another useful item: sailors tape, not used to repair sails but the tape used to cover turnbuckles.  It is stretchy vinyl with no adhesive, it sticks to itself.  Many colors.  Not expensive.  Take a look on Amazon if you don't have a sailing store nearby.

Sounds like "Vet Wrap". Get it from equine supliers. Added bonus of lots of pretty colours.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: 911377brian on May 10, 2013, 07:36:02 PM
Use sport bag shoulder straps; they've got strong plastic clips that wont scratch. Some of the straps I see holding up quite small boxes look like crane strops.... ::)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: tekyinblack on May 11, 2013, 07:53:55 AM
I've suffered from the same problem, scratches from strap buckles, which doesn't change a box much, but is a real irritation and a put off to future buyers should you want to sell.
But why are straps supplied that can?
I've bought replacement straps made of fabric and plastic (Hohner) which have worked very well, including being secured with velcro on the top end, but generally got the impression from the vendor I was buying an inferior product. (or was maybe just an inferior customer?)
Equally I've been able to buy straps with metal buckles, where the metalwork has been rounded off and there are no sharp edges.

So, would there be a market for someone making/selling good quality straps, secure, plenty of adjustment, that didn't scratch either your £2500 (insert mortgage figure here) pride and joy or £100 favourite?
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 11, 2013, 08:29:51 AM
Use sport bag shoulder straps; they've got strong plastic clips that wont scratch. Some of the straps I see holding up quite small boxes look like crane strops.... ::)

I've bought replacement straps made of fabric and plastic (Hohner) which have worked very well, including being secured with velcro on the top end, but generally got the impression from the vendor I was buying an inferior product. (or was maybe just an inferior customer?)
Equally I've been able to buy straps with metal buckles, where the metalwork has been rounded off and there are no sharp edges.

Plastic clips and rounded-off metal buckles can still cause damage: grooves, indentations and bruising of wood casework, perhaps, rather than scratches which cut through a varnished finish into the underlying wood. Don't forget that damage can be caused while the instrument is in its case being transported if the buckles rub against the woodwork.

All of these can be avoided by using one or other of the soft protective sleeve designs as described in previous posts. It's a no-brainer really.

Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Gandy on May 11, 2013, 08:23:42 PM
Another useful item: sailors tape, not used to repair sails but the tape used to cover turnbuckles.  It is stretchy vinyl with no adhesive, it sticks to itself.  Many colors.  Not expensive.  Take a look on Amazon if you don't have a sailing store nearby.

Called self-amalgamating tape (or Scotch 23).   Be aware that it's softer than normal pvc insulating tape, more rubbery and more likely to get snagged.  When we used it at work to insulate underwater joints we always covered it with pvc tape to protect it.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: ButtonBox21 on May 12, 2013, 12:49:04 PM
I recently bought a new Dino Baffetti 19 button/8 bass organetto in Black. I don't want any scratches on the bellows or body caused by the buckles. And I use two straps. Check with your local accordion dealer. There are covers made to protect the accordion from scratches caused by the buckles. I have seen two styles. One has Velcro and you fold it over the buckle and press the Velcro together. The other is an elastic tube which slips over the buckle after you attach the strap to the accordion. I have used both and prefer the elastic one. They are very reasonably priced. If you can't locate them locally then try The Button Box (www.buttonbox.com) in Sunderland, MA USA. They sell the Velcro style. The elastic style is sold by Emillio Accordions (www.emillioaccordions.com) from Stamford, CT USA. Good luck. :||:
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: MR Q on May 12, 2013, 01:19:33 PM
Hi I play three different melodeons,and have never experienced buckle damage to bellows,as I am very carefull to set the straps so this does not happen,perhaps the problem is because players are sitting on a chair with the instrument resting on thier thigh,and not having the straps adjusted for this.
      I would politely suggest that if you set your straps for playing standing up so your instrument is close to your body without slack in the straps and you use both straps whilst sitting if you have a heavy instrument,you will not have the problem.
      If you find your melodeon is too heavy for you to play standing up,there are melodeons made that are quite light, especially the Italian ones.
   I do know that in most pub sessions players sit to play,but I have found by using two straps whilst sitting it stops the buckles fouling the bellows,and you need to set them close to the brackets to achieve this.         So I hope my input to this discussion is of some use.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve C. on May 12, 2013, 01:28:14 PM
Gandy--

I think that is the stuff.

I usually wrap it a few times with a slight stretch so it sticks.

If you warm it very slightly it sticks even better.

Another is "Coban" a self-adhesive medical tape, kind of brown and krinkly, does not look that bad.  Does tend to "unstick" though, similar to the "sailors tape".
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 12, 2013, 08:20:34 PM
1. Go to Geldrop, near NL/German border
2. Winge to Frans van der Aa that his buckles scratch his lovely paint job
3. Show him your "shoelace solution"
4. Watch him replace it with some nice black nylon fabric tubing

 ;)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Prestidigitator on May 12, 2013, 09:52:23 PM
Another useful item: sailors tape, not used to repair sails but the tape used to cover turnbuckles.  It is stretchy vinyl with no adhesive, it sticks to itself.  Many colors.  Not expensive.  Take a look on Amazon if you don't have a sailing store nearby.

Called self-amalgamating tape (or Scotch 23).   Be aware that it's softer than normal pvc insulating tape, more rubbery and more likely to get snagged.  When we used it at work to insulate underwater joints we always covered it with pvc tape to protect it.
I have used this stuff a lot as a commercial fisherman, and it is indeed good. I wouldn't use it for this, though. It grabs on to whatever it is wrapped around, and the outer surface (on the UK product)has a soft yet sticky surface. It also hardens with age, and has to be cut off with a very sharp scalpel.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 13, 2013, 10:12:03 AM
Another useful item: sailors tape, not used to repair sails but the tape used to cover turnbuckles.  It is stretchy vinyl with no adhesive, it sticks to itself.  Many colors.  Not expensive.  Take a look on Amazon if you don't have a sailing store nearby.

Called self-amalgamating tape (or Scotch 23).   Be aware that it's softer than normal pvc insulating tape, more rubbery and more likely to get snagged.  When we used it at work to insulate underwater joints we always covered it with pvc tape to protect it.
I have used this stuff a lot as a commercial fisherman, and it is indeed good. I wouldn't use it for this, though. It grabs on to whatever it is wrapped around, and the outer surface (on the UK product)has a soft yet sticky surface. It also hardens with age, and has to be cut off with a very sharp scalpel.
I've used self-amalgamating tape on a number of occasions too, but only for protecting electronic groundwater monitoring gubbins inserted down wells and boreholes. It can indeed be quite gooey and sticky at first - a bit like gaffer tape covered in black tar, and like Prestidigitator, I wouldn't recommend its use for covering melodeon strap buckles.
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Strigulino on May 13, 2013, 01:07:45 PM
I wrap mine in teatowels when they're in their cases. 
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 13, 2013, 01:39:56 PM
I wrap mine in teatowels when they're in their cases.
I hope they are dry  ::)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: Strigulino on May 13, 2013, 04:37:32 PM
They are a pair of matching Ireland "Wacky Woolies" souvenier teatowels with many different types of sheep on, and were completely unused when they were pressed into service as melodeon protectors.  I would not sully them by drying dishes with them.  :)
Title: Re: Any solution for keeping strap buckles from scratching my instrument?
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 13, 2013, 06:35:59 PM
"Wacky Woolies" souvenier teatowels

Ah, not for Border then.  ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal