Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: TedK on January 16, 2012, 05:55:00 PM
-
Hello,
I'm considering getting a 1 row melodeon, I currently play D/G 2 row.
I love the sound of the Hohner 4 stops and the East Anglian style (I am a Suffolk boy in exile discovering his roots!) and as they're fairly reasonably priced I think this is what I'm likely to go for. However I am unsure what key would be most useful to get. Obviously one in either D or G would fit a fair chunk of English tunes (which is what I mostly play), but does either confer any particular benefits, or is it just a case of pick one and accept its limitations?
-
C would be the authentic East Anglian tuning.
-
I've a Hohner 4 stop 1 row in G - the first box I ever purchased - fantastic sound but its hard work to play - suspect the D box would be easier.
-
why would a D box would be easier to play than i G box ???
-
The higher the pitch the easier it is to play. The HA114G takes a hell of a lot of air and tires the arms very quickly. Even the C box if played with gusto leaves the shoulders and arms aching after a single dance - the D would be just a touch easier.
As the years rolled by I bought a Castgnari Max in C to make life easier - it has a much faster action, takes less air and the reeds sound quicker. I really do miss the Hohner growling bass and the fairground organ sound though.
Rob.
-
So which would be the lowest pitch, I would have expected G to be higher than D?
-
The Hohner G is Low G , octave down on the normal G row of a DG and then you have the low octave reeds another octave bellow.
The D is pitched as the D row of a DG.
I have both keys (although the D is a Saltarelle). The D gets most use. You can play a fairly good G and A on it as well as D.
-
I have Hohners in C and G; the C I play quite a lot, and very enjoyable it is; the G sounds wonderful, but is so air-hungry that I rarely get it it out and work myself into a state of collapse playing the thing for more than 15 minutes or so. Also, for some perverse reason, my G has 2 fewer bellows folds than my C, which compounds the difficulty (yes, I know I could just swap the bellows over, but......) I sometimes use it without the bottom voice, which makes it easier to play but it loses that glorious grunt (now that's a good name for a ceilidh band or a 1-row album - my idea, so I get first use of it!!). If you're playing with others, particularly in sessions, I'd guess G would be the key to go for. As far as I can see, 1 rows in D are not all that thick on the ground.
Graham
-
If you're playing with others, particularly in sessions, I'd guess G would be the key to go for.
Except in Suffolk where you would need C.
-
Thanks everyone for the advice, I think on balance I will go for one in C.
I can already play in D and G on my current 2 rows, so it would seem a bit silly to duplicate this, and if C is the authentic East Anglian tuning so much the better! ;)
There is one for sale on the Music Room website for £380, do you think this is a reasonable deal?
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_486/products_id/5014 (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_486/products_id/5014)
-
If you're playing with others, particularly in sessions, I'd guess G would be the key to go for.
Except in Suffolk where you would need C.
I think (but am willing to be proven wrong) that's a bit of a false statement.
As far as I'm aware, most sessions in Suffolk are just like any other sessions; it's only those that set out to play East Anglian music (which I would guess are connected to EATMT) that play a lot of stuff in C.
-
If you're playing with others, particularly in sessions, I'd guess G would be the key to go for.
Except in Suffolk where you would need C.
I think (but am willing to be proven wrong) that's a bit of a false statement.
As far as I'm aware, most sessions in Suffolk are just like any other sessions; it's only those that set out to play East Anglian music (which I would guess are connected to EATMT) that play a lot of stuff in C.
I don't know about that - I can't recall ever having been to Suffolk - but TedK does say he's "in exile", so it's a fair bet his local sessions, wherever he is, will tend to play in D & G, with maybe the odd excursion into A or C. I usually take two boxes to a session - either the D/G and a C 1-row or the D/G and the C/F. In most sessions up and down the country melodeon players are likely to be playing D/G boxes.
-
As far as I'm aware, most sessions in Suffolk are just like any other sessions; it's only those that set out to play East Anglian music (which I would guess are connected to EATMT) that play a lot of stuff in C.
I've only been to Suffolk for EATMT events, so I'm biased in that direction, a lot of C tunes are played in those, but when doing repair work for E Anglian based players I am asked to work on a high proportion of boxes that include a C row, so I think the C tendency is not exclusively an EATMT thing.
-
I'm in London as a matter of fact (not literally in exile, no crimes were commited) (:). Anyway, I have definately decided to go for one in C now, I find it quite a good key for singing in as well so the instrument could potentially be used for accompaniment at some point.
-
I'm in London as a matter of fact (not literally in exile, no crimes were commited) (:). Anyway, I have definately decided to go for one in C now, I find it quite a good key for singing in as well so the instrument could potentially be used for accompaniment at some point.
Good choice going for a C box. G is too low and air hungry and the D is almost impossible to find, unless you go for a new Chinese model.
If you are in no rush to get one. It might be best to hold out for one of the older models with the red and silver bellows tape. These usually have either 16 or 17 folds on the bellows, unlike the ones with red and gold tape which usually only have 14 folds. It makes them much easier to play.
Martyn
-
As far as I'm aware, most sessions in Suffolk are just like any other sessions; it's only those that set out to play East Anglian music (which I would guess are connected to EATMT) that play a lot of stuff in C.
I've only been to Suffolk for EATMT events, so I'm biased in that direction, a lot of C tunes are played in those, but when doing repair work for E Anglian based players I am asked to work on a high proportion of boxes that include a C row, so I think the C tendency is not exclusively an EATMT thing.
I think that Ollie is mostly correct and that playing in C is sadly becoming less common even in East Anglia, despite the best efforts of EATMT to keep C sessions going. I just hope that there are a sufficient number of players who keep the tradition going to enable it to survive.
If you haven't yet tried playing on a C box, especially in a session setting, I do assure you it is a most delightful experience. Just that extra tone lower down from D makes a huge difference (in my opinion anyway). The music instantly becomes richer, more sonorous and definitely less squeaky.
-
The "C" one row would also be ideal if you ever fancied having a go at Cajun. I think the box in the Music Room is a Hohner Arriette, worth checking American sites in particular for reviews, they seem very mixed!
-
As far as I'm aware, most sessions in Suffolk are just like any other sessions; it's only those that set out to play East Anglian music (which I would guess are connected to EATMT) that play a lot of stuff in C.
Also the music of Old Glory Molly (E. Suffolk) is all in C. At least 5 Hohner 1-rows when they're all there.
-
I'm in London as a matter of fact (not literally in exile, no crimes were commited) (:). Anyway, I have definately decided to go for one in C now, I find it quite a good key for singing in as well so the instrument could potentially be used for accompaniment at some point.
Good choice going for a C box. G is too low and air hungry and the D is almost impossible to find, unless you go for a new Chinese model.
If you are in no rush to get one. It might be best to hold out for one of the older models with the red and silver bellows tape. These usually have either 16 or 17 folds on the bellows, unlike the ones with red and gold tape which usually only have 14 folds. It makes them much easier to play.
Martyn
Seconded - my C is one of those, with a 16-fold bellows, and much nicer to play than the 14-fold G.
-
Every time I've been to East Anglia, I've not been allowed through customs without a C melodeon.
-
Every time I've been to East Anglia, I've not been allowed through customs without a C melodeon.
Still making people buy one just to get out, then?
-
Every time I've been to East Anglia, I've not been allowed through customs without a C melodeon.
Says Rees "Here's one I made earlier..."
Rob.
-
Well, I'm pleased to say that I didn't have to wait too long, I've just won this one on ebay for what I think is a reasonable price (if the condition is as good as it seems):
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/280812578649?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1069 (http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/280812578649?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1069)
Hope it arrives before the weekend!
(:)
-
Scuse the ignorance, I've got a Hohner 1row 4 stop in C ,had it many years now it was marketed a "cajun" model, Black body, black bellows tape 16 fold bellows. Is there any difference to the normal Honer version besides the colour ?
-
Scuse the ignorance, I've got a Hohner 1row 4 stop in C ,had it many years now it was marketed a "cajun" model, Black body, black bellows tape 16 fold bellows. Is there any difference to the normal Honer version besides the colour ?
In theory, a Cajun box should be tuned in just temperament rather than equal temperament, though I've no idea if that's the case with the Hohner Cajun or if it's just a cosmetic selling job.
Graham
-
Slighty better bellows was the only difference I noticed.
-
I bought one from Mameloks in Manchester c.1986. It was cool cos it was black, otherwise no difference. I enjoyed playing it. Don't know what happened to it in the end. Maybe I gave it away.
-
Scuse the ignorance, I've got a Hohner 1row 4 stop in C ,had it many years now it was marketed a "cajun" model, Black body, black bellows tape 16 fold bellows. Is there any difference to the normal Honer version besides the colour ?
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4235.msg53532.html may give you a little more info if yours looks like the picture. 114B, reinforced bellows, normal tuning.
I still have mine.
-
Thanks Anahata , yes that's the beast indeed, as I say I've had it from new but not seen another one in my neck of the woods, good old box though.
-
I've got a German-made 114C with the "Goldbrand" finish and red/gold/silver bellows, but have never before seen a model in black, and certainly not out being played anywhere.
I'd wrongly supposed that Anahata's black model, which I greatly admire (along with his playing), was a "customised" article, but now I know better. Whatever, I think the black one looks terrific, and, as we say in Suffolk, I'd like to "fang on" to the next one I see for sale; if one should so present itself.
If I do, it'll be full steam ahead for colour-coded music - cheerful stuff on the coloured one and the dolefuls on the black one.
-
Here's the beast in question, I've still got the grille but prefer it without it !
-
Very nice Huw! Now, who's got one in C gathering dust?? Bob. :||:
-
The old G Hohner 4 stop I bought ebay a couple of weeks ago needed so work. It's is much easier to play now that a couple of holes (strap brackets?) are filled and a few other repairs have been made. It has a 17 fold bellows that seems fairly airtight now. My question is, what else can I do to it to make it easier to play?
-
My question is, what else can I do to it to make it easier to play?
Ask the lady who asked the way to Carnegie Hall.... (:) (:) >:E
Baz
-
My question is, what else can I do to it to make it easier to play?
What exactly is making it hard to play?
The Hohner 1-row 4-stop in G is fairly notorious for being rather air-hungry and its large reeds rather slow to respond, compared with the generally more responsive similar models in C and D which have smaller reeds.
One thing you can do is check the valves: are they all lying flat on the reed plates? If not, replace them. You need to check the valves on the underside of the reed plates too, which will involve removal of the reed plate and then re-waxing afterwards. Overall, if your instrument has not been overhauled for some time (if at all) it is worth considering re-valving and re-waxing all the reeds as a matter of course. At the same time you can check the set (gap) of the reed tongues. If the gap is too high, the reed will sound breathy and slow to start. You will probably need to check the tuning too, but no point in doing that until the re-valving and re-waxing is done.
-
My question is, what else can I do to it to make it easier to play?
What exactly is making it hard to play?
The Hohner 1-row 4-stop in G is fairly notorious for being rather air-hungry and its large reeds rather slow to respond,
Just shutting off the stop for the lowest reed will be a big help.
-
or shutting a mid if you don't mind loosing wet sound AtB mory
Joe Derranes sound is LM and quite a heavy sound still, very fast to play in comparison to all 4 in
-
My question is, what else can I do to it to make it easier to play?
What exactly is making it hard to play?
The Hohner 1-row 4-stop in G is fairly notorious for being rather air-hungry and its large reeds rather slow to respond,
Just shutting off the stop for the lowest reed will be a big help.
Yes - but you lose that deep, growly sound which I love.
-
Just shutting off the stop for the lowest reed will be a big help.
Yes - but you lose that deep, growly sound which I love.
Playing a 1 row with less that all the stops open is equivalent to driving around on a sunny day in a convertible with the top up.
When I am King it will be a capital offence :o
-
Playing a 1 row with less that all the stops open is equivalent to driving around on a sunny day in a convertible with the top up.
Not if the alternative is drowning out a singer's voice, but otherwise I fully agree!
-
top down, stop up is that right Lester? ;D
-
Many thanks for all the great advice. I have Italian reed wax, but where can I buy the new valves? Some of the existing valves are the old leather kind, and one or two are bent. What sort of glue should I use to attach the valves to the plates?
This box was dropped on its bass side at some point before I bought it. It rattled badly when it arrived. The bass sound board was cracked so I glued the crack on the inside, and sanded the outside before covering it with a new piece of silver paper. I put a new leather gasket on the bass "keyboard" and waxed it after installation. I also added leather pads to the spoons on the bass side. I was going to replace the gaskets between the frames and the bellows but it already seems tight.
Let me know if I am missing something.
-
Valves and parts can be found here http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html he will post to States
-
Many thanks for all the great advice. I have Italian reed wax, but where can I buy the new valves? Some of the existing valves are the old leather kind, and one or two are bent. What sort of glue should I use to attach the valves to the plates?
Charlie Marshall is your man.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html
Excellent service and products. He ships overseas too.
Charlie recommends 'all purpose clear Bostik' - an impact adhesive - for sticking valves to reed plates.
http://www.bostik.co.uk/diy/product/bostik/All-Purpose/17
Not sure if this exact product is available in the US but I'm sure you could find a similar alternative. Just be sure to test it first before using on vinyl valves. The solvents in some adhesives will dissolve with the plastic!
-
I do have to interject and say that I love the MMH sound and it's one that you don't hear often enough. But then I don't have a four stop yet, so feel free to ignore me :P
-
Which packet of valves should I order off Charlie's web site? I emailed him, but haven't heard back. He might be out climbing Munros. The box is much easier to play since I made the repairs to the bass side. I think putting leather pads in the spoons really tightened it up. Looking forward to getting the valves sorted out.
Thanks again for the advice.
-
In the past I have ordered both a pack of assorted "4 types" plastic valves, and one of "7 types" assorted leather, which covered most of my needs. Before installing a valve I punch a 2mm or 3mm hole in its base with a leather punch (same as the one we use for belts, etc) which ensures a good fit around the reed rivet.
-
Thank you very much, Quebecois.
-
M.A.D. strikes again....
I've just bought this HA114 in C to go with my HA114 in G.....
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/251003102000?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649
It was a bargain! ;D
Now I can go on holiday to East Anglia and get past border control.....
-
I've just bought this HA114 in C to go with my HA114 in G.....
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/251003102000?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649
It was a bargain! ;D
Not a bad price at all. It looks well used, but even if it needs £100 worth of work to make it properly playable you've still got a good deal.
-
With two, surely you have a "family ticket"?
Rob.
-
;D
-
It's in good nick for an old box, needing new spoons (ordered from Theo), a spot tune, 3 broken treble reeds replacing, and the bass reeds cleaning and re-waxing.
But how do you get the reed blocks off? They appear to be glued to the fondo!
-
But how do you get the reed blocks off? They appear to be glued to the fondo!
That's because they are glued to the fondo. You will have to learn the art of lifting the suck reeds by the Italian or German method. Some photos by Theo
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=3 (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&type=3)
-
Yes glued in, and the register slides are built in there too so tricky to try and separate the glued joints without damage.(I've tried). But it is quite possible to take reeds off and re-wax without taking the blocks out. It is tricky mind you, and you have to use gravity to run the new wax down between the reed plates.
-
ta! Once I've worked out which reeds I need I'll give you a bell.
Cheers!
Pikey