Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Jack Humphreys on January 21, 2012, 04:13:14 PM

Title: Learning to use chords with the third at the bottom
Post by: Jack Humphreys on January 21, 2012, 04:13:14 PM
Celebrating a new little step in learning how to play with 12 basses.  (The rest of the message is translated into GD box fingering)

Three tunes recently needing the third at the bottom of the chord, as in  G/B = Chord of G with B bass note, and F/A =  Chord of F with A bass note .  Two tunes (L'Oushka and Salamanders) started with the note G going down to F  (or  D going down to C),   but I didn't like harmonising that with chords G to F (or D to C),  [and my old music teacher 50 years ago would mark WRONG  any consecutive parallel fifths, octaves or unisons >:(]

So the solution is for the bass line to go UP a note  (D-E) while the melody line goes DOWN (D-C),  but still play the C chord with that bass note E.

In Salamanders   I found that all this sounded best in the key of   E major  (GD- box-speak),   so the next chord was on the draw D/F#.   That's what you hear on the video http://youtu.be/TriqEVKd6tk (http://youtu.be/TriqEVKd6tk)   The D/F#  sounds good on my box, whereas some of the other  "thirds at the bottom" chords don't sound so good because of where the basses sit.

It's similar in Bruno LT's L'Oushka
http://youtu.be/7C2KHl7Eb1E (http://youtu.be/7C2KHl7Eb1E)   
which is in A minor and the second chord is G/B  (Though listening to the video I've touched some other chord). 

Notes and bassline  in G: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/05ec1e4b4f6ad4758ae2cdfe3a642e095aff8c2d (http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/05ec1e4b4f6ad4758ae2cdfe3a642e095aff8c2d)

Maybe it's specially nice to hear the third, when otherwise my ordinary chords don't have one.

Then a couple of tunes which have an interesting   F# to  F natural movement in the bass when you're playing in Aminor.
Giles Brown's "Hypogeum"  goes    D/F#,    D/Fnat    (not recorded yet, but it's here in notes in the wrong key

http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/a954c440ecd93d46e36e21d27cbafc2d39a6579e (http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/a954c440ecd93d46e36e21d27cbafc2d39a6579e)  )

and Decombel's Vappu:  http://youtu.be/KNfHn-RHX6Q (http://youtu.be/KNfHn-RHX6Q))                                           
(notes: http://www.maartendecombel.com/Userfiles/file/MAARTEN/download/bath10/Vappu_tabstandard.pdf (http://www.maartendecombel.com/Userfiles/file/MAARTEN/download/bath10/Vappu_tabstandard.pdf)

Well,  I hope that's interesting for someone else. I was pleased to learn it.
Title: Re: Learning to use chords with the third at the bottom
Post by: Nick Hudis on January 29, 2012, 07:57:25 PM
Stephane Delicq used this kind of harmony to good effect, e.g. Lubov and Vals pour Michel.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal