Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: MandoC on January 23, 2012, 12:12:14 AM

Title: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: MandoC on January 23, 2012, 12:12:14 AM
I know I run the obvious risk comparing apples to oranges or worse.  But I was wondering if anyone could list some pros and cons of the two systems.  The biggest pro for me is that the Streb looks like a melodeon and looks stylishly functional. I have fooled around for an hour or so with an FR-18 in a store.  It is plastic plastic plastic to the max. I am under the impression that the Roland probably has more possibilities for different sounds and nano-adjustments to functions. But I don't know that for sure. I own my house and can play any time I want so I would not be getting one to play with headphones (at least not now). Here are some comparisons I would like:

Cost
Need an amplifier to hear.
The system(s) they use to produce sounds (sampled? midi?)
playability adjustments (air, button pressure, bellows feel)
ability to change set up keys (I play BC)

Any information that could be provided would be appreciated  Thanks Charlie
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Lester on January 23, 2012, 12:32:30 PM
As an ex-Streb owner I can answer some of your questions

The Streb:

- is self contained, ie it has it's own amp and speakers built in
- has both midi and proper melodeon samples, mine had Hohner pokerwork, club and 1 row and Castagnari Mory
- the playability was infinitely adjustable, there were a number of bellows curves (the dynamics of volume v pressure), on/off pressure was adjustable, the amount of air leakage was also ajustable
- it had a number of keyboard layouts ( some of my own design) so 3rd/4th button start, accidentals/low notes, different 1/2 row layouts.
- it played in all the normally available 5th apart keys pairs (D/G, C/F, A/D, Eb/Bb, G/C) plus C/C# and B/C but if ou wanted any thing else you just had to ask
- if you play with awkward cusses it was possible to adjust the whole tuning +/- half a step so Db/Gb if it takes your fancy.
- batteries are internal and using rechargeables I could play for 2/3 hours
- great fun but sold it to buy a big Saltarelle
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: streb on January 24, 2012, 07:16:14 PM
"Stylishly functional". I like that, can I have it as a tag line?  ;)

You can't nano-adjust everything on a Streb but there are more than enough parameter adjustments to make it playable. It has the advantage that it has been developed from the viewpoint of a melodeon player so it is easy to configure, small, light, plays like a melodeon, has its own built-in amp and is made of plastic wood!

I intend to make some more of them so if you are interested PM me and I will send you more details.

Steve
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Morrisbox on January 24, 2012, 07:38:33 PM
I got my new Streb just before Christmas, and I'd agree with all Steve and Lester have said, it's a great instrument to have and is immense fun.  Light, playable and more than enough things to adjust and fiddle with to keep you amused for hours

The only thing I can't understand is why Lester parted with his!

Trevor
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Clive Williams on January 24, 2012, 11:24:20 PM
For me, the two killer features of the Streb - the built in batteries/speakers, which makes it completely self-contained, and the range of different melodeon sample banks. The fact that it's not much heavier/bigger than a pokerwork is pretty amazing too.

The main thing about the FR-18 that appeals; the 3 full rows and 18 basses. You could set that up as a B/C/C#, as a continental chromatic, as a Pignol/Milleret layout box, etc, etc. Those extra buttons wouldn't add much weight to a Streb, Steve... just saying, you know!  :D
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 11:30:55 PM
Squeezy has a 3-row Streb, does he not? Can't remember if it was 12 or 18 bass though.
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Owen Woods on January 24, 2012, 11:50:58 PM
I think his was a custom job...
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Lester on January 24, 2012, 11:54:51 PM
I think his was a custom job...

Indeed, I beleive it is really just a melodeon shaped midi controller which wirelessly links to a midi computer thingy (sorry about the techy language)
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 25, 2012, 12:22:56 AM
Squeezy has a 3-row Streb, does he not? Can't remember if it was 12 or 18 bass though.
Having been in contact with Steve Rouse recently, I can confirm that a three-row is an option for a Streb (standard one is 2.5 rows).
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: MandoC on January 26, 2012, 05:57:35 PM
Thanks to all those who responded to my luddite questions and worse orange comparisons.  Special thanks to Streb who sent me a personal message and explained some missing information.  I wonder if you would even get an email from Roland when asking about the FR-18? Just wondering.  Charlie
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 26, 2012, 06:04:13 PM
I'd like a Streb, although other members of the band would be likely to object - traditionalist lot, but then very few current production concertinas have anything like the sound of the old Lachenal.  The only improvements I've seen were the rather smart case that Niel (ex-Hobgoblin) had made for his - slightly smaller and polished solid wood - really smart!

Rob.
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Martin J on January 26, 2012, 06:53:45 PM
Quite the reverse  for me.  I got rid of my Roland and now have a FANTASTIC Streb.

Yes the sampled sounds are great, particularly through PA, and no one would notice in the band mix if they were a tad different.  But these are the main advantages for me.
1)  Silent practice / self entertainment
2)  A fantastic range of different sounds which used sparingly enhance the band performance.
3)  Wonderful for song accompaniment
4)  A midi controller to do whatever you are capable of (techie wise that is)  The rest is down to your midi device
5)  Wood
6)  A screen to tell you where you are (Roland owners would kill for this)
7)  Built in amp and battery.  Sounds great acoustically (?) or through headphones.
8)  Can be run from mains with supplied wall wart [what 'append 'ere then, 8+)=smilie? Thats not good for lists]
9)  More layouts than most people can play  (would like Organetto Steve)

The list could go on.  To bang my own personal opinion drum again, I have plenty of real melodeons.  Neither the Roland or the Streb are to replace those.  The Streb gives me all the things real melodeons don't, and it's dead easy to use.  The depth and complexity of the FR18 thread tells it's own story.
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Stiamh on January 26, 2012, 07:00:46 PM
Additional options...
     [X] Don't use smileys

8)  K:D  (:) ;) :D ;D  >:(  :o   :-[ :P :-X :-* :-\ :'( >:E

Could finding this option be a test to see if you are the type that would prefer a Roland over a Streb?  <grin>

Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: FREED on February 01, 2012, 01:11:55 PM
I do love my FR18 its great fun -  just three issues I have with it-
   1. It is very plastic - a bit of perspiration and I'm hanging on for grim death
   2. It is big and quite heavy - RSI is gradually creeping up my arms and threatening to numb my whole upper torso
   3. It is a bit complicated - perhaps a measure of its versatility - as you say a screen would be a godsend.
However it does make switching to the old Pokerwork for a blast a real joy!!

How much is a Streb ?
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Martin J on February 01, 2012, 02:48:03 PM
I do love my FR18 its great fun -  just three issues I have with it-
   1. It is very plastic - a bit of perspiration and I'm hanging on for grim death
   2. It is big and quite heavy - RSI is gradually creeping up my arms and threatening to numb my whole upper torso
   3. It is a bit complicated - perhaps a measure of its versatility - as you say a screen would be a godsend.
However it does make switching to the old Pokerwork for a blast a real joy!!

How much is a Streb ?
About the same price but has screen and built in amp and speakers, made of wood and similar weight to a pokerwork.  Yes, Roland is more plastic, heavier and complicated/versatile although the extras were of no use to me.
Quote
Could finding this option be a test to see if you are the type that would prefer a Roland over a Streb?  <grin>
Failed, didn't read the manual** and in any case the screen was hidden until I pressed another button, guess that makes me a strebophile  ;D

** says it all really, don't like reading manuals, do like intuitive.
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: sine labore on February 29, 2012, 05:39:39 PM
Squeezy has a 3-row Streb, does he not? Can't remember if it was 12 or 18 bass though.
Having been in contact with Steve Rouse recently, I can confirm that a three-row is an option for a Streb (standard one is 2.5 rows).


i have just caught this thread.  I had never heard of a Streb.  Where can I find out about a B/C or B/C/C# chromatic capable box of this type?
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: Morrisbox on March 01, 2012, 05:17:55 PM
Quote
i have just caught this thread.  I had never heard of a Streb.  Where can I find out about a B/C or B/C/C# chromatic capable box of this type?

I haven't tried it, but I'm fairly certain that the Streb is B/C capable, and I suspect a 3 row Streb would be capable of B/C/C#.  If you email Steve Rouse he would certainly confirm this, he's an excellent person to deal with, absolutely top class.  He goes under the name of "streb" on this forum I believe if you wanted to mail him.
Title: Re: Streb vs Roland FR-18
Post by: sine labore on March 01, 2012, 10:42:43 PM
Quote
i have just caught this thread.  I had never heard of a Streb.  Where can I find out about a B/C or B/C/C# chromatic capable box of this type?

I haven't tried it, but I'm fairly certain that the Streb is B/C capable, and I suspect a 3 row Streb would be capable of B/C/C#.  If you email Steve Rouse he would certainly confirm this, he's an excellent person to deal with, absolutely top class.  He goes under the name of "streb" on this forum I believe if you wanted to mail him.

I thank you for your reply. Having found little information I began to guess that Streb and Steve Rouse might be one and the same and I fired off a message to his forum address this evening and I hope to receive a response. I have now heard from Streb, and I shall continue to watch this thread.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal