| FWIW IN yesterday's trip to Democcratic República S.Yorkshire, a local bagpipe maker got really inspired when I played a mazurka in the Sheffield session. He improvised for ages. It was great fun, and the others in the bar (including females >:E) seemed to enjoy it. No dancers, sadly. The session also played Orange and Blue, and Handsworth's calling on song, neither entirely à la tradition :P So there is still life in the old 'oss |
Wacky, but very much in the vein of Derek Jakobi's portrayal in the recent "Life With Bells On" film. If traditional teams are doing inviting the fair sex to participate (and did the same early in the last century) one wonders what 'tradition' these guys are actually upholding? However, a lot of my my own morris side members were also Freemasons, so there could be other factors in play.
Amazed that my little cartoon should catalyse such an alambic reaction. It was meant as a little light drollery on musical traditions, but I'm happy to discuss here, and hope it might keep the evolution thread purer. In this respect would like to take this opportunity to nominate Lester for "Drifter of the Year 2012" The cartoon incidentally has much chopped about characters from a Ring side webside cartoon - so our leaders are not without a sense of humour. :D
FWIW a bagpipe maker got really inspired when I played a mazurka in the Sheffield session yesterday. He improvised for ages. It was fun, and the others in the bar (including females >:E) seemed to enjoy it. No dancers sadly. We also did Orange and Blue, and Handsworth's calling on song, neither entirely à la tradition :P
The Morris Ring is an organisation of sides made up of male dancers. (...)
The Morris Ring is an organisation of sides made up of male dancers. (...)
Presumably any member side is aware of that fact... if that side subsequently (for whatever reason) changes to a mixed side then they effectively preclude further membership of the ring. To use a little modern parlance, end of!
Exactly!
Ollie
(ah, Lester, I see your Squireness and raise you) Squire of Cambridge Morris Men, a founding Ring side. ;D ;) Arguably, it's actually all our fault...
Exactly!
Ollie
(ah, Lester, I see your Squireness and raise you) Squire of Cambridge Morris Men, a founding Ring side. ;D ;) Arguably, it's actually all our fault...
But hopefully we won't have to revert to plan A :P
This is the second run in they've had with the Morris Ring, as I understand it the first one was because they had a woman musician (Eliza Carthy).
Steve
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?
Good luck with that ;)
On exclusion from the ring:
Hammersmith left (or were asked to leave/chucked out of) the Ring despite being at the time and remaining to this day an all-male team. Is that a unique achievement?
And on the subject of "tradition":
At a session on Sunday night someone asked what the proper traditional tune was for the Comberton Broom dance. Simon informed us that only the day before at the Ouse Washes Mark Jones Memorial Day of Dance, the broom dance had been done to the tune of the The Beatles' I Wanna hold Your Hand. Since that was a gathering of most of England's molly teams, by definition that was the correct tune for the dance, at least on that occasion...
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.
Strange how the stroppy politicians in the morris are the ones least interested in actually dancing, well.
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.Depends on your tradition Ollie...many traditional North West teams were mixed....my wife and I are currently researching the History of Mobberley Rose Queen festival, and Mobberley was danced as a mixed dance....and I'm sure it wasn't the only one
Baz
This is the second run in they've had with the Morris Ring, as I understand it the first one was because they had a woman musician (Eliza Carthy).
Steve
:D at least The Ring have come round on that subject ;D Last year's superbly organised Rutland Ring Meeting, where sides with female musicians were made very welcome, was one of the most enjoyable events I've been to :|||: :M :||:
Ho hum.
I'm saddened that the rules of the Ring seem unable to take into account a situation where local dancers are trying to keep alive a local tradition.
Steve
Only the dinosaurs of the Ring (who everyone ignores anyway) have bad things to say about mixed and female sides, whereas most members of Fed and Open teams seem to have something bad to say about the Ring; understandable, I guess.
[snip]
Similarly the atmosphere at a mixed side practice (I have danced with several mixed sides) is different from a Ring side practice (ditto) although I'd be hard pressed to explain in detail. Horses for courses - but I'd like to continue to choose my own horse.
[snip]
Mind you, if the Ring required acceptable standards of dancing music and music for membership, it would be the only one of the three organisations to do so, as far as I know, and there would then be accusations of elitism...
I'm not sure that everyone ignores them either; the story I heard from Colin Cater last year (who was still playing for Thaxted at the time) was that many inactive dinosaur members where wheeled out at short notice to vote on the gender issue.
Only the dinosaurs of the Ring (who everyone ignores anyway) have bad things to say about mixed and female sides, whereas most members of Fed and Open teams seem to have something bad to say about the Ring; understandable, I guess.
Unfortunately, the common view from outside is that those dinosaurs are the Ring.
I'm not sure that everyone ignores them either; the story I heard from Colin Cater last year (who was still playing for Thaxted at the time) was that many inactive dinosaur members where wheeled out at short notice to vote on the gender issue.
It's a shame that the subject of women dancing is the first thing that most people think of when the Ring is mentioned: its masks the arguably worse crime described by Ian, of publicly upholding appalling standards and thereby giving morris dancing a bad name.
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion
They were outvoted eventually, but as I understand it this would have happened years earlier if it hadn't been for that vociferous minority.
[snip]
Similarly the atmosphere at a mixed side practice (I have danced with several mixed sides) is different from a Ring side practice (ditto) although I'd be hard pressed to explain in detail. Horses for courses - but I'd like to continue to choose my own horse.
Surely you mean "different from an all-male side practice"? ::)
It takes a very good foreman indeed to keep a bunch of dancers, often with disparate backgrounds, who have been dancing for years and drifted into varying bad habits, to a common standard. It's much easier when teaching new dances, but breaking down the "I don't need to practise this, I've been dancing it for years" mindset is very hard.
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion
They were outvoted eventually, but as I understand it this would have happened years earlier if it hadn't been for that vociferous minority.
That's as maybe, but the point is it happened...
I don't think the Ring can be accused of upholding appalling dance standards. There's a difference between encouraging it (which isn't done, as far as I am aware) and not doing anything about it. If anyone can be accused of upholding bad dancing standards, it's the Open with their 'do what you like, as long as you have fun' attitude. Some of the worst sides I've come across (I won't mention names) have been Open sides. The vast majority of Ring sides are 'ok', very few are shockingly awful, and there are a few that are 'quite good'. This is the same for any of the three organisations.
Oh, and I should also point out before anyone thinks I'm some sort of Morris Ring fanboy; I dance/play for more Fed/Open sides than I do Ring sides, and generally enjoy them more too!
And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.
LOL Now you come to mention it, the only all-male sides I've danced with HAVE been Ring sides. But I take your point.
On the subject of standards, there is a difference between upholding good standards and enforcing them. As I understand it sides had to show a good standard to get into the Ring, but after that enforcement was not practicable. As discussed at great length on the MDDL...
It takes a very good foreman indeed to keep a bunch of dancers, often with disparate backgrounds, who have been dancing for years and drifted into varying bad habits, to a common standard. It's much easier when teaching new dances, but breaking down the "I don't need to practise this, I've been dancing it for years" mindset is very hard.
I don't think the Ring can be accused of upholding appalling dance standards. There's a difference between encouraging it (which isn't done, as far as I am aware) and not doing anything about it. If anyone can be accused of upholding bad dancing standards, it's the Open with their 'do what you like, as long as you have fun' attitude. Some of the worst sides I've come across (I won't mention names) have been Open sides. The vast majority of Ring sides are 'ok', very few are shockingly awful, and there are a few that are 'quite good'. This is the same for any of the three organisations.
Oh, and I should also point out before anyone thinks I'm some sort of Morris Ring fanboy; I dance/play for more Fed/Open sides than I do Ring sides, and generally enjoy them more too!
I agree completely about sides with low dancing standards; they exist in all three organisations, but maybe more so in Open Morris...
But there's no way of regulating/enforcing dancing standards, and it's debateable whther there should be -- if a side who don't know how to dance want to go out on the streets and whoop while waving sticks around nobody can stop them, regardless of whether they know how to dance or not, no matter how horrible some of us find the spectacle.
(yes this is a dig at the many appalling border teams around, the cr@p quotient seems to be larger than any other style)
What could (and should) be done is to find a way of encouraging such sides to dance better, and maybe educate them how to do it -- one problem seems to be that they obviously don't have anyone teaching them *how* to dance properly, never having had a foreperson with such skills. And this isn't elitist, there's space in the Morris world for a whole range of sides from ones who mainly want to have a good time (but ought to at least dance *adequately*) to the dance perfectionists, some of who don't seem to be having a good time at all judging by their faces...
(of course in an ideal world all sides would dance well *and* look like they're enjoying it, but don't hold your breath :-)
So an inclusive organisation whose real purpose was to advance the cause of Morris dancing could -- for example -- offer tutorial weekends for inexperienced forepeople to teach them these skills, aimed at various levels of competence and all dancing styles without looking down on or excluding anyone -- because everyone has to learn sometime. Or member teams with "associate status" (or whatever it's called) could be encouraged to have experienced teachers come along to their practices to help them improve.
And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.
Ian
And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.
This is a fascinating insight for me who's only contact with Morris is as an audience member. For years I thought, like a lot of the general public, that Morris was a bit of a joke. Generally overweight blokes with beards huffing and puffing in in not very interesting manner in between spells in the pub. It was only a few years ago that I became aware of some of the awe inspiring young sides who seemed to be doing something completely different, an athletic and spectacular performance that was actually really exciting to watch. Such performances still seem to be all to rare in my admittedly very limited experience.
Yes, there are several. I'm going to one in a couple of weeks, and went to another in December. I am very happy to do so, it will be good fun.
However sides do still have the option of organising men only meets (source - Squire's Capers, Issue 64 "The Morris Ring Circular"). I await with interest to see if any side takes this option.
Steve
So an inclusive organisation whose real purpose was to advance the cause of Morris dancing could -- for example -- offer tutorial weekends for inexperienced forepeople to teach them these skills, aimed at various levels of competence and all dancing styles without looking down on or excluding anyone -- because everyone has to learn sometime. Or member teams with "associate status" (or whatever it's called) could be encouraged to have experienced teachers come along to their practices to help them improve.
As you say, I think this is where a central organisation is needed. To be honest, there's no reason why the JMO can't do some of the things suggested above, now. The Ring's Jigs Instructional is a fantastic event, and I've seen several dancers standards improve dramatically after attending just one weekend as a novice; whilst it's a great "lad's weekend away", I'd love to see this event opened up to all organisations, as I think it would be really beneficial.
I understood it to be a mutual agreement. ??? They took the decision to let women dance (out of necessity), and therefore could no longer be member of The Morris Ring - the national organisation for Men's Morris & Sword clubs; I assume they were aware of this when they took the decision. For what it's worth, the Ring were very, very sad to see them go.
Besides, it's only an organisation, and the main reason people are members of one of the three is for insurance purposes. Not being a member of the Morris Ring doesn't (or at least, shouldn't) change the outlook, style, feel or anything of the team. To be honest, the bit that's upset the tradition is the fact they've gone mixed, not the fact they've left the Ring.
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?
Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.
Grow up. >:(
Eurgh, don't get me started on kit based Border (and Molly) sides. >:(
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?
Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.
Grow up. >:(
I wasn't blaming the ring for anything, but this sort of in-fighting is at best counter-productive, if not actually downright damaging!
Eurgh, don't get me started on kit based Border (and Molly) sides. >:(
As far as the latter is concerned, Pig Dyke Molly are well aware that we have problems with our standard of dancing. The team was founded as an "equal-opportunity" organisation and it would go against that to be too restrictive about who was allowed to dance when, but at the same time we are very concerned about how best to balance this with the need for a decent performance at festivals and similar. Let it not be imagined that we don't care about that - a huge amount of discussion has taken place at meetings and practices and will doubtless continue.
We do like to think our music isn't too bad though ;)
I've seen some of the border teams that fit the above descriptions, but of course can't speak for their recruitment or dance standards policies.
And so he should be! Discerning chap, JK.I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.
There's this early photo of the Upton-on-Severn dancers with a woman in the side:
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg)
This was printed in the insert to the vinyl edition of Plain Capers, I don't know if it's made it into the CD's notes. John K seemed more interested that it also shows an anglo concertina.
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.
There's this early photo of the Upton-on-Severn dancers with a woman in the side:
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg)
This was printed in the insert to the vinyl edition of Plain Capers, I don't know if it's made it into the CD's notes. John K seemed more interested that it also shows an anglo concertina.
I wasn't blaming the ring for anything, but this sort of in-fighting is at best counter-productive, if not actually downright damaging!Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?
Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.
Grow up. >:(
B'gg'r me!
Fourier analysis of morris dancing :Ph
My curiosity was aroused by Ian's account of Hammersmith's departure from the Ring. Can you remember, Ian, when this occurred?
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.
Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together? ;D
Is it something about London sides?
They also once danced in the sea on the Brighton nudist beach, clad only in bells. It's a good job they weren't full members.......... ::)
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.
Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together? ;D
Is it something about London sides? The anarchic and superb Blackheath MM (who I don't think have ever been Ring members), used to sing a little ditty that went 'Hark the Herald Angels Sing, B**locks to the Morris Ring' ;D
They also once danced in the sea on the Brighton nudist beach, clad only in bells. It's a good job they weren't full members.......... ::)
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.
Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together? ;D
I was there for the food fight with Bath...or a food fight with Bath...it was the same Ring meeting that got Bath into serious trouble for their accompanying musician (a lovely box player but a stranger to this house..) playing a piano on the back of a lorry...I saw no urination in a public place, m'lud...
Then again, it was my first Ring meeting and I may have strong drink taken.... :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug...
The food fights did used to get a bit out of hand sometimes, but we weren't always the guilty party. Hartley go so fed up that they tried to come up with a meal for the feast which couldn't be thrown (stew, mash, and salad), but were proved wrong -- not by us initially, we were the victims of a high-velocity low-trajectory tomato from across the room which landed in our bowl of stew and left us looking like the victims of an explosion in a pie filling factory -- after which it all went a bit pear-shaped...
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.
Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together? ;D
I was there for the food fight with Bath...or a food fight with Bath...it was the same Ring meeting that got Bath into serious trouble for their accompanying musician (a lovely box player but a stranger to this house..) playing a piano on the back of a lorry...I saw no urination in a public place, m'lud...
Then again, it was my first Ring meeting and I may have strong drink taken.... :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug...
The food fights did used to get a bit out of hand sometimes, but we weren't always the guilty party. Hartley go so fed up that they tried to come up with a meal for the feast which couldn't be thrown (stew, mash, and salad), but were proved wrong -- not by us initially, we were the victims of a high-velocity low-trajectory tomato from across the room which landed in our bowl of stew and left us looking like the victims of an explosion in a pie filling factory -- after which it all went a bit pear-shaped...
(yes, you *can* throw mash...)
I agree! (:)