Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Ebor_fiddler on January 23, 2012, 03:58:49 PM

Title: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 23, 2012, 03:58:49 PM
Our good friends The Goathland Plough Stots were asked (though very nicely indeed, as they are a proper traditional team) to leave The Sacred Morris Ring, as they have committed the unforgiveable crime of letting girls dance in the junior side. The Plough Stots have a much longer history than have the Ring, yet it seems that they must change their rules to suit the latter's. It doesn't seem right somehow to upset tradition for the sake of old prejudices.
This is NOT an anti-Ring post, because the separation has been very amicable on both sides. It just seems to me that there must be some way round the problem, though I can't imagine what.  :(

Love and Fishes,

Chris.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 23, 2012, 04:08:09 PM
I understood it to be a mutual agreement. ??? They took the decision to let women dance (out of necessity), and therefore could no longer be member of The Morris Ring - the national organisation for Men's Morris & Sword clubs; I assume they were aware of this when they took the decision. For what it's worth, the Ring were very, very sad to see them go.

Besides, it's only an organisation, and the main reason people are members of one of the three is for insurance purposes. Not being a member of the Morris Ring doesn't (or at least, shouldn't) change the outlook, style, feel or anything of the team. To be honest, the bit that's upset the tradition is the fact they've gone mixed, not the fact they've left the Ring.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 23, 2012, 04:57:36 PM
Wacky, but very much in the vein of Derek Jacobi's characterisation in the recent "Life With Bells On" film.  If traditional teams are inviting the fair sex to participate (and indeed did the same early in the last century) one wonders what "Tradition" these guys are actually upholding?  However, a lot of my my own morris side members were also Freemasons, so there could be other factors in play?

Amazed that my little cartoon might catalyse such an alambic reaction. It was meant as a little light drollery on musical traditions, poking as much fun at me as at purists. I'm happy to discuss here, and hope it might keep the evolution thread purer. In this respect would like to take this opportunity to nominate our friend Lester as "Drifter of the Year 2012"  ;) The cartoon incidentally has much chopped about characters from a Ring side webside cartoon - so our leaders are not without a sense of humour. :D

   FWIW IN yesterday's trip to Democcratic República S.Yorkshire, a local bagpipe maker got really inspired when I played a mazurka in the Sheffield session. He improvised for ages. It was great fun, and the others in the bar (including females >:E) seemed to enjoy it. No dancers, sadly. The session also played Orange and Blue, and Handsworth's calling on song, neither entirely à la tradition :P So there is still life in the old 'oss
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 23, 2012, 05:06:44 PM
Wacky, but very much in the vein of Derek Jakobi's portrayal in the recent "Life With Bells On" film.  If traditional teams are doing inviting the fair sex to participate (and did the same early in the last century) one wonders what 'tradition' these guys are actually upholding?  However, a lot of my my own morris side members were also Freemasons, so there could be other factors in play.  

Amazed that my little cartoon should catalyse such an alambic reaction. It was meant as a little light drollery on musical traditions, but I'm happy to discuss here, and hope it might keep the evolution thread purer. In this respect would like to take this opportunity to nominate Lester for "Drifter of the Year 2012"   The cartoon incidentally has much chopped about characters from a Ring side webside cartoon - so our leaders are not without a sense of humour. :D

   FWIW a bagpipe maker got really inspired when I played a mazurka in the Sheffield session yesterday. He improvised for ages. It was fun, and the others in the bar (including females >:E) seemed to enjoy it. No dancers sadly. We also did Orange and Blue, and Handsworth's calling on song, neither entirely à la tradition  :P


I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.

Arguably, the tradition the Morris Ring is upholding is one of its own invention. That said, traditions all have to start somewhere, and there are still plenty of teams out there who wish to dance in an all-male environment, which is why the Ring continues to exist.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: oggiesnr on January 23, 2012, 11:11:07 PM
This is the second run in they've had with the Morris Ring, as I understand it the first one was because they had a woman musician (Eliza Carthy).

The junior team is comprised of children from the local primary school and because of the balance in the school they decided to let girls dance in order to have the numbers to keep a team going.  It is part of keeping the local tradition alive by using local dancers.  I didn't get this year but last year they were foreseeing a different problem when the girls who had learnt the dance at scholl became eligble and wanted to dance with the intermediate team.

I'm saddened that the rules of the Ring seem unable to take into account a situation where local dancers are trying to keep alive a local tradition.

Steve
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 23, 2012, 11:27:40 PM
Right...

The Morris Ring is an organisation of sides made up of male dancers. Therefore, a mixed gender side cannot be a member of the Morris Ring. They can, however, be a member of the Morris Federation, or the Open Morris.

It's not like the Ring have thrown them out and damned them to hell, as Ebor_fiddler said, it was an amicable split, and probably one that both sides didn't want to happen. They're still dancing, aren't they? They're just a member of a different organisation now. Sides leave the Ring because they have to go mixed in order to survive all the time.

I should, of course, reiterate that the Ring does not disapprove of women dancing; it exists as a focal point for sides that wish to dance in an all male environment; if these sides did not exist, then the Ring wouldn't.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Lester on January 24, 2012, 12:25:37 AM
Wot he said   ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Lester Bailey, Squire of Aldbury Morris, a Ring Side
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: xgx on January 24, 2012, 12:27:46 AM
The Morris Ring is an organisation of sides made up of male dancers. (...)

Presumably any member side is aware of that fact... if that side subsequently (for whatever reason) changes to a mixed side then they effectively preclude further membership of the ring.  To use a little modern parlance, end of!

Lumpy leaping forms with overblown breeches straining to contain over forties excess cellulite is never a pretty sight... there again, one man's meat...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 12:35:52 AM
The Morris Ring is an organisation of sides made up of male dancers. (...)

Presumably any member side is aware of that fact... if that side subsequently (for whatever reason) changes to a mixed side then they effectively preclude further membership of the ring.  To use a little modern parlance, end of!

Exactly!

Ollie

(ah, Lester, I see your Squireness and raise you) Squire of Cambridge Morris Men, a founding Ring side.  ;D ;) Arguably, it's actually all our fault...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Owen Woods on January 24, 2012, 12:40:45 AM
Exactly!

Ollie

(ah, Lester, I see your Squireness and raise you) Squire of Cambridge Morris Men, a founding Ring side.  ;D ;) Arguably, it's actually all our fault...

But hopefully we won't have to revert to plan A :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 12:42:54 AM
Exactly!

Ollie

(ah, Lester, I see your Squireness and raise you) Squire of Cambridge Morris Men, a founding Ring side.  ;D ;) Arguably, it's actually all our fault...

But hopefully we won't have to revert to plan A :P

 ;D

Oh, I don't know, could be fun... I'm sure Johns or Kings can seat 300+ for the Pheast.  :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Keithypete. on January 24, 2012, 06:53:25 AM
 Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: AnnC on January 24, 2012, 08:06:28 AM
This is the second run in they've had with the Morris Ring, as I understand it the first one was because they had a woman musician (Eliza Carthy).

Steve

   :D at least The Ring have come round on that subject  ;D Last year's superbly organised Rutland Ring Meeting, where sides with female musicians were made very welcome, was one of the most enjoyable events I've been to  :|||: :M :||:

  
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Anahata on January 24, 2012, 08:31:32 AM
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?

Good luck with that  ;)

On exclusion from the ring:
Hammersmith left (or were asked to leave/chucked out of) the Ring despite being at the time and remaining to this day an all-male team. Is that a unique achievement?

And on the subject of "tradition":
At a session on Sunday night someone asked what the proper traditional tune was for the Comberton Broom dance. Simon informed us that only the day before at the Ouse Washes Mark Jones Memorial Day of Dance, the broom dance had been done to the tune of the The Beatles' I Wanna hold Your Hand. Since that was a gathering of most of England's molly teams, by definition that was the correct tune for the dance, at least on that occasion...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Keithypete. on January 24, 2012, 10:03:02 AM
http://www.englandsglory.org.uk/

 Fascinating stuff, especially the Ilmington reference!!
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 24, 2012, 10:10:59 AM
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?

Yup, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maud_Karpeles - that was the 'non male' morris I was thinking of in the 1920's. I tried to google her but spelt it wrongly. But AFAIR her experiments related mainly to sides decimated by the 14-18 war.

For myself I can see good reason to dance in an all male or all women side - it's an important style issue after all. But for for women to set up any manner of umbrella organisation that specifically excludes men  ;) or vice versa   ???

That's very unmodern and so probably a dead end in the 'though the ages' evolution of this art form over the course of the present century. We already have evidence above that even important 'source sides' are dropping out as a result.  I think that's "writing on the wall".   Culture has always had to adapt to its era or go extinct.  As an observer I personally feel the 'life force' of the Morris tradition presently resides in the cultural explosion that we saw in the 80's and 90's. There are thousands of these sides, not hundreds!  It will be interesting to see where that goes, though (late 50's) I may not live long enough to see the end of that process. :|glug
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Nige Rivers on January 24, 2012, 10:21:30 AM
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?

Yes, and I bet she didn't have public liability insurance :) though she did form a club that I don't think men danced with :D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 10:57:19 AM
Does the name 'Maud Karpelese' mean anything to anyone here?

Good luck with that  ;)

On exclusion from the ring:
Hammersmith left (or were asked to leave/chucked out of) the Ring despite being at the time and remaining to this day an all-male team. Is that a unique achievement?

And on the subject of "tradition":
At a session on Sunday night someone asked what the proper traditional tune was for the Comberton Broom dance. Simon informed us that only the day before at the Ouse Washes Mark Jones Memorial Day of Dance, the broom dance had been done to the tune of the The Beatles' I Wanna hold Your Hand. Since that was a gathering of most of England's molly teams, by definition that was the correct tune for the dance, at least on that occasion...


We left, there was (and probably still is) no mechanism for sides being ejected from the Ring if they're all male. To clear up any misunderstanding...

The reason we left was that we were hacked off with the hypocrisy of an organisation claiming to uphold the standards of Morris dancing -- including vetting sides for admittance, and rejecting some new young enthusiastic ones for being of "insufficient standard" -- while having some long-standing member teams whose dancing was, to be frank, rubbish. The fact that the organisation claiming to represent Morris had member teams who were painful to watch (but told the public that this is what Morris was all about) got right up our noses, and we were feeling somewhat bolshy after a few acrimonious encounters with dyed-in-the-wool Ring teams.

Our officers went to the Ring AGM with the instruction to submit two motions, and to resign from the Ring if both were rejected. The first was that the Ring should drop the pretence of maintaining dance standards and admit any team (all-male, obviously) who wanted to join -- which was rejected. So the second one was that all teams in the Ring should have a regular reappraisal of dancing standards the same as teams applying to join, and that they be expelled if they failed to meet this (or failed to improve to meet this) -- which was rejected. This was all done jokingly before hurrying off to lunch, not taking the motions seriously at all -- which was not our intent. So our officers handed in our resignation and left.

Roy Yarnell (who was squire of the Ring, and a really nice guy) asked us to rejoin, and when we refused he actually came down to one of our practices and spent a couple of hours talking to us about the reasons we'd resigned. Once he understood that this wasn't simply a "piss off the Ring" stunt he was genuinely sympathetic, but said that given the current membership, attitudes and standards of many Ring teams there was little chance of them taking our suggestions seriously and even less of approving them. We parted on good terms -- with Roy, at least -- and joined the Fed.

All of which is a shame, if the Ring had adopted either idea then it would probably be a larger and healthier organisation than it is today -- just look at what the John Gasson jig competition has done for the standard of jig dancing, and DERT for rapper. Of course we were accused of trying to turn the Ring into something it wasn't -- but actually, we just wanted them to either do what they claimed (upholding dancing standards) or admit that they weren't doing this and drop it as a requirement for admission.

And if they'd also dropped the ban on women we'd have one strong unified organisation in the UK to promote the interests of all flavours or Morris dancing, which would also have been better for everyone. Nowadays the officers of the three Morris organisations seem to get on quite well with each other, but this is still fragmentation since there still isn't one clear public face for Morris, and there is still some needless bickering and bad feeling between teams in the three organisations -- just look back at the "Morris is dying out" headlines a couple of years ago and the ensuing comments ("we're not dying out", " the Ring is a dinosaur"...) which hardly did a lot to make Morris look good in the public eye.

Ian Dedic

(writing from my personal recollections and viewpoint, not as an official Smiffs spokesman)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: jonm on January 24, 2012, 11:32:15 AM
I remember the Hammersmith incident - I have always thought the Ring lost one of the better and, er, liveliest, ahem, dancing sides. The only step forward (as some of the teams have just aged twenty years in the last twenty years and changed not a jot) is that at least at Ring meetings it is no longer a given to be invited to perform spots in the massed shows at the discretion of the Squire, although that is not formally stated anywhere to avoid upsetting the politickers.

Strange how the stroppy politicians in the morris are the ones least interested in actually dancing, well.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: baz parkes on January 24, 2012, 11:41:17 AM

I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.



Depends on your tradition Ollie...many traditional North West teams were mixed....my wife and I are currently researching the History of Mobberley Rose Queen festival, and Mobberley was danced as a mixed dance....and I'm sure it wasn't the only one

Baz

ex Squire Giffard Morris...also a Ring side in their day
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 11:59:18 AM
That's very interesting, Ian; not the same story I've heard from other sources, though I expect yours is probably more accurate.

I believe Albion Morris were asked to leave; something to do with being loud and offensive at a feast somewhere - can't remember the details.

There was a bit of a hoo-ha about standards at last year's ARM, as there was a motion to ammend that part of the constitution. Unfortunately, although everything the chap was saying was excellent (basically the first proposal mentioned above), it wasn't actually about the matter being discussed, so he was shouted down.

Interesting, most of the bickering and bad feeling I've experienced between the three JMOs has been from Open or Fed sides about the Ring. Only the dinosaurs of the Ring (who everyone ignores anyway) have bad things to say about mixed and female sides, whereas most members of Fed and Open teams seem to have something bad to say about the Ring; understandable, I guess.

I hope and fully expect to see a National Morris Association (or some such organisation) in my life time. I'd like to think that if this were to happen, the best bits of all the organisations would be taken into account:
- The fellowship of the Ring (sorry, had to be done) - one thing I love about the Ring is the meetings. They're not weekends of dance organised by sides that only invite their friends, which is what tends to happen in other organisations, they're weekends you apply to go to, and always meet up with different sides each year.
- The standards of the Fed - to be honest, they have the best sides.
- The inclusiveness of the Open - whilst I'm not all for the 'anything goes' line, I don't think sides should be discriminated against due to their standard.

Strange how the stroppy politicians in the morris are the ones least interested in actually dancing, well.

Indeed. I don't think I've ever seen a 'certain person' dance, at all.

I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.
Depends on your tradition Ollie...many traditional North West teams were mixed....my wife and I are currently researching the History of Mobberley Rose Queen festival, and Mobberley was danced as a mixed dance....and I'm sure it wasn't the only one

Baz

Ahh, yes, good point. I need to stop being so Cotswold-centric. :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 12:29:12 PM
This is the second run in they've had with the Morris Ring, as I understand it the first one was because they had a woman musician (Eliza Carthy).

Steve

   :D at least The Ring have come round on that subject  ;D Last year's superbly organised Rutland Ring Meeting, where sides with female musicians were made very welcome, was one of the most enjoyable events I've been to  :|||: :M :||:

  

Indeed it was fantastic. I think the lady playing for Redcar Sword proved the point that gender really doesn't matter when it comes to playing for dancing - one of the best Morris musicians I've come across.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 24, 2012, 12:54:10 PM

I'm saddened that the rules of the Ring seem unable to take into account a situation where local dancers are trying to keep alive a local tradition.

Steve
Ho hum.
The Morris Ring is an association of independent sides who choose to dance in all-male format. The Ring doesn't make decisions - its member sides do. The Ring (nor its members) doesn't stop other people dancing in whatever format they wish (the historical views of some past individuals notwithstanding), nor does it stop women forming all-female sides or umbrella organisations, ditto mixed, if they choose. Why does that seem so difficult to grasp, or so contentious?
If you have an all-female assocation, you can't have blokes in it otherwise it ain't an all female association.
If you have an all-male association lots of people get funny about it...

My personal views largely align with Ollie's. In particular, the atmosphere at an (all-male) Ring event is quite different from any other event I've been to and IMO worth preserving. I'm sure the same could be said of all-female events (I'll have to seek advice on that! ::)). I have yet to attend a Ring event with female musicians, which seem to be increasing in number now. I'll let you know...
Similarly the atmosphere at a mixed side practice (I have danced with several mixed sides) is different from a Ring side practice (ditto) although I'd be hard pressed to explain in detail. Horses for courses - but I'd like to continue to choose my own horse.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Anahata on January 24, 2012, 01:42:20 PM
Only the dinosaurs of the Ring (who everyone ignores anyway) have bad things to say about mixed and female sides, whereas most members of Fed and Open teams seem to have something bad to say about the Ring; understandable, I guess.

Unfortunately, the common view from outside is that those dinosaurs are the Ring.

I'm not sure that everyone ignores them either; the story I heard from Colin Cater last year (who was still playing for Thaxted at the time) was that many inactive dinosaur members where wheeled out at short notice to vote on the gender issue.

It's a shame that the subject of women dancing is the first thing that most people think of when the Ring is mentioned: its masks the arguably worse crime described by Ian, of publicly upholding appalling standards and thereby giving morris dancing a bad name.

Mind you, if the Ring required acceptable standards of dancing music and music for membership, it would be the only one of the three organisations to do so, as far as I know, and there would then be accusations of elitism...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 01:45:43 PM

[snip]
Similarly the atmosphere at a mixed side practice (I have danced with several mixed sides) is different from a Ring side practice (ditto) although I'd be hard pressed to explain in detail. Horses for courses - but I'd like to continue to choose my own horse.

Surely you mean "different from an all-male side practice"?  ::)

In which case I'd agree, as would many of my female morris dancing/playing friends. As a generalisation, men take much better to direct personal criticism even if it's couched in friendly insults, which can make practices more effective -- a forewoman might say " Some people are still doing this wrong..." as opposed to a foreman saying "xxxxxx, you're dancing like a flat-footed zombie, get up on your toes and...".

(based on comments from and discussions with forewomen and musicians, as well as personal experience playing for a mixed side)

The direct version can work better, because the people who are doing it wrong often ignore the "some people..." comments because *they* think they're doing it right  (:)

Ian
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 02:08:49 PM

[snip]
Mind you, if the Ring required acceptable standards of dancing music and music for membership, it would be the only one of the three organisations to do so, as far as I know, and there would then be accusations of elitism...


Well, that's what they claimed they used to do  ;)

Since there's no law regulating Morris dance standards, any all-inclusive organisation would have to admit novice (or just bad) teams -- but there's nothing stopping the organisation encouraging good dancing, possible via an "associate member" status vs. "dancing member" status. Though who does the "Morris MOT" and approves a team for full membership would be an interesting question, to say the least...

This is no different to how teams decide who to let join a team and dance out. Some sides (the "all-inclusive" ones) allow anyone to join, and dance out pretty much as soon as they can do a step without actually falling over. Some sides (the "exclusive" ones) only allow people to join who are seen to be already good enough dancers (or sometimes "best mates"). Neither of these seem right for obvious reasons; we allow anyone to join at any time, but they don't get to dance out until the foreman and squire say they're good enough, which seems like the best of both worlds -- and I know other teams who operate the same way who also seem to manage to both enjoy themselves *and* dance well.

If a poor team wants to dance out you can't stop them, but you can try and encourage them to improve and try and discourage them from telling the public that this is what morris dancing ought to look like -- and without a Morris Police, this is all such an organisation can do. The approval of peers (other good teams) can be quite powerful as pressure to improve, especially if it includes (for example) invites to enjoyable weekends with good dancing.

Ian
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: jonm on January 24, 2012, 02:44:44 PM
The question of who arbitrates and assesses the standard of dancing has been the crux of the failure of proposals to measure and act upon dancing standards. Interestingly, some of those sides most strongly supporting sanctions for cr@p dancing at the last ARM were among those most likely to be sanctioned.

I'm not sure that everyone ignores them either; the story I heard from Colin Cater last year (who was still playing for Thaxted at the time) was that many inactive dinosaur members where wheeled out at short notice to vote on the gender issue.

That issue was fascinating. One individual did the "wheeling out" to get his own way over the issue of female musicians, within a club with a long history of having had female musicians, before, at and following the formation of the Ring. He won the club vote but lost all credibility and several friends.

Incidentally, I am told that the issue with Goathland and their (famous) female musician related not to the fact they they had a female musician in contravention of Ring policy (and arguably constitution), since many other sides were in the same position, but that they were seeking to make significant publicity capital from her, which would have embarrassed the Ring and those other clubs.

One thing not mentioned in this discussion is the Ring's vast archive of morris material, to which the other organisations contribute, and the massive amount of unpaid and thankless work which goes into maintaining and updating such an archive for posterity.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 02:59:08 PM
Only the dinosaurs of the Ring (who everyone ignores anyway) have bad things to say about mixed and female sides, whereas most members of Fed and Open teams seem to have something bad to say about the Ring; understandable, I guess.

Unfortunately, the common view from outside is that those dinosaurs are the Ring.

I'm not sure that everyone ignores them either; the story I heard from Colin Cater last year (who was still playing for Thaxted at the time) was that many inactive dinosaur members where wheeled out at short notice to vote on the gender issue.

It's a shame that the subject of women dancing is the first thing that most people think of when the Ring is mentioned: its masks the arguably worse crime described by Ian, of publicly upholding appalling standards and thereby giving morris dancing a bad name.

But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion; as one member said upon announcing the results of the second vote "Gentlemen, I am extinct."  :D

I don't think the Ring can be accused of upholding appalling dance standards. There's a difference between encouraging it (which isn't done, as far as I am aware) and not doing anything about it. If anyone can be accused of upholding bad dancing standards, it's the Open with their 'do what you like, as long as you have fun' attitude. Some of the worst sides I've come across (I won't mention names) have been Open sides. The vast majority of Ring sides are 'ok', very few are shockingly awful, and there are a few that are 'quite good'. This is the same for any of the three organisations.


Oh, and I should also point out before anyone thinks I'm some sort of Morris Ring fanboy; I dance/play for more Fed/Open sides than I do Ring sides, and generally enjoy them more too!
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Anahata on January 24, 2012, 03:20:02 PM
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion

They were outvoted eventually, but as I understand it this would have happened years earlier if it hadn't been for that vociferous minority.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 03:24:14 PM
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion

They were outvoted eventually, but as I understand it this would have happened years earlier if it hadn't been for that vociferous minority.


That's as maybe, but the point is it happened...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 24, 2012, 03:29:56 PM

[snip]
Similarly the atmosphere at a mixed side practice (I have danced with several mixed sides) is different from a Ring side practice (ditto) although I'd be hard pressed to explain in detail. Horses for courses - but I'd like to continue to choose my own horse.

Surely you mean "different from an all-male side practice"?  ::)


LOL Now you come to mention it, the only all-male sides I've danced with HAVE been Ring sides. But I take your point.

On the subject of standards, there is a difference between upholding good standards and enforcing them. As I understand it sides had to show a good standard to get into the Ring, but after that enforcement was not practicable. As discussed at great length on the MDDL...

It takes a very good foreman indeed to keep a bunch of dancers, often with disparate backgrounds, who have been dancing for years and drifted into varying bad habits, to a common standard. It's much easier when teaching new dances, but breaking down the "I don't need to practise this, I've been dancing it for years" mindset is very hard.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 03:32:19 PM
It takes a very good foreman indeed to keep a bunch of dancers, often with disparate backgrounds, who have been dancing for years and drifted into varying bad habits, to a common standard. It's much easier when teaching new dances, but breaking down the "I don't need to practise this, I've been dancing it for years" mindset is very hard.

God, tell me about it! That's one of the reasons I started doing Oddington this year with CMM - about the only tradition they've never done in their 88 year history, and it's still bloody impossible.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: oggiesnr on January 24, 2012, 03:39:01 PM
But, as both votes (one for female musicians, and the other for the culling of the Advisory Council) at the ARM goes to show, these dinosaurs were ignored. They fought hard, and had very loud voices for a minority opinion

They were outvoted eventually, but as I understand it this would have happened years earlier if it hadn't been for that vociferous minority.


That's as maybe, but the point is it happened...

However sides do still have the option of organising men only meets (source - Squire's Capers, Issue 64 "The Morris Ring Circular").  I await with interest to see if any side takes this option.

Steve
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 03:43:48 PM

I don't think the Ring can be accused of upholding appalling dance standards. There's a difference between encouraging it (which isn't done, as far as I am aware) and not doing anything about it. If anyone can be accused of upholding bad dancing standards, it's the Open with their 'do what you like, as long as you have fun' attitude. Some of the worst sides I've come across (I won't mention names) have been Open sides. The vast majority of Ring sides are 'ok', very few are shockingly awful, and there are a few that are 'quite good'. This is the same for any of the three organisations.

Oh, and I should also point out before anyone thinks I'm some sort of Morris Ring fanboy; I dance/play for more Fed/Open sides than I do Ring sides, and generally enjoy them more too!

I agree completely about sides with low dancing standards; they exist in all three organisations, but maybe more so in Open Morris...

But there's no way of regulating/enforcing dancing standards, and it's debateable whther there should be -- if a side who don't know how to dance want to go out on the streets and whoop while waving sticks around nobody can stop them, regardless of whether they know how to dance or not, no matter how horrible some of us find the spectacle.

(yes this is a dig at the many appalling border teams around, the cr@p quotient seems to be larger than any other style)

What could (and should) be done is to find a way of encouraging such sides to dance better, and maybe educate them how to do it -- one problem seems to be that they obviously don't have anyone teaching them *how* to dance properly, never having had a foreperson with such skills. And this isn't elitist, there's space in the Morris world for a whole range of sides from ones who mainly want to have a good time (but ought to at least dance *adequately*) to the dance perfectionists, some of who don't seem to be having a good time at all judging by their faces...

(of course in an ideal world all sides would dance well *and* look like they're enjoying it, but don't hold your breath :-)

So an inclusive organisation whose real purpose was to advance the cause of Morris dancing could -- for example -- offer tutorial weekends for inexperienced forepeople to teach them these skills, aimed at various levels of competence and all dancing styles without looking down on or excluding anyone -- because everyone has to learn sometime. Or member teams with "associate status" (or whatever it's called) could be encouraged to have experienced teachers come along to their practices to help them improve.

And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.

Ian
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: jonm on January 24, 2012, 03:51:08 PM
+1   ;D ; :||: :M
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Theo on January 24, 2012, 03:56:17 PM
And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.

This is a fascinating insight for me who's only contact with Morris is as an audience member.   For years I thought, like a lot of the general public, that Morris was a bit of a joke.  Generally overweight blokes with beards huffing and puffing in in not very interesting manner in between spells in the pub.   It was only a few years ago that I became aware of some of the awe inspiring young sides who seemed to be doing something completely different, an athletic and spectacular performance that was actually really exciting to watch.  Such performances still seem to be all to rare in my admittedly very limited experience.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 03:57:02 PM

LOL Now you come to mention it, the only all-male sides I've danced with HAVE been Ring sides. But I take your point.

On the subject of standards, there is a difference between upholding good standards and enforcing them. As I understand it sides had to show a good standard to get into the Ring, but after that enforcement was not practicable. As discussed at great length on the MDDL...

It takes a very good foreman indeed to keep a bunch of dancers, often with disparate backgrounds, who have been dancing for years and drifted into varying bad habits, to a common standard. It's much easier when teaching new dances, but breaking down the "I don't need to practise this, I've been dancing it for years" mindset is very hard.

Funny, none of the all-male sides I've danced with have been Ring sides...

Yes being a good foreman is difficult, especially with that kind of attitude. And so long as the side's attitude is that it's OK to dance out even if you're rubbish that won't change. So the solution is to instil a sense of pride in the team's dancing into the dancers (which of course means the dancing has to be at least OK in the first place), so that people who can't do it any more either become "social members" or musicians (if they can play OK, which is another story...) -- but they do it of their own accord, or at most after a quiet word from the foreman. Part of the job of the foreman *is* to tell "the old guys" that they're doing it wrong, just as with new learners. And if they don't listen you keep on telling them, just like new learners.

Over the years we've had many people stop dancing -- effectively taking themselves "out of kit" -- but I don't think we've ever had to force anyone to do it, and we still see many ex-dancers and are friends with them. Maybe that's because we take pride in what we do and believe it should be done well, maybe it's because we've been fortunate to have knowledgeable teachers and good musicians, but any side can set their own standard (even if not quite so high), make sure that everyone reaches it, and aspire to improve it.

Ian
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 03:59:16 PM

I don't think the Ring can be accused of upholding appalling dance standards. There's a difference between encouraging it (which isn't done, as far as I am aware) and not doing anything about it. If anyone can be accused of upholding bad dancing standards, it's the Open with their 'do what you like, as long as you have fun' attitude. Some of the worst sides I've come across (I won't mention names) have been Open sides. The vast majority of Ring sides are 'ok', very few are shockingly awful, and there are a few that are 'quite good'. This is the same for any of the three organisations.

Oh, and I should also point out before anyone thinks I'm some sort of Morris Ring fanboy; I dance/play for more Fed/Open sides than I do Ring sides, and generally enjoy them more too!

I agree completely about sides with low dancing standards; they exist in all three organisations, but maybe more so in Open Morris...

But there's no way of regulating/enforcing dancing standards, and it's debateable whther there should be -- if a side who don't know how to dance want to go out on the streets and whoop while waving sticks around nobody can stop them, regardless of whether they know how to dance or not, no matter how horrible some of us find the spectacle.

(yes this is a dig at the many appalling border teams around, the cr@p quotient seems to be larger than any other style)

What could (and should) be done is to find a way of encouraging such sides to dance better, and maybe educate them how to do it -- one problem seems to be that they obviously don't have anyone teaching them *how* to dance properly, never having had a foreperson with such skills. And this isn't elitist, there's space in the Morris world for a whole range of sides from ones who mainly want to have a good time (but ought to at least dance *adequately*) to the dance perfectionists, some of who don't seem to be having a good time at all judging by their faces...

(of course in an ideal world all sides would dance well *and* look like they're enjoying it, but don't hold your breath :-)

So an inclusive organisation whose real purpose was to advance the cause of Morris dancing could -- for example -- offer tutorial weekends for inexperienced forepeople to teach them these skills, aimed at various levels of competence and all dancing styles without looking down on or excluding anyone -- because everyone has to learn sometime. Or member teams with "associate status" (or whatever it's called) could be encouraged to have experienced teachers come along to their practices to help them improve.

And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.

Ian

Wish there was a 'like' button on this site sometimes.  (:)

Eurgh, don't get me started on kit based Border (and Molly) sides.  >:(

As you say, I think this is where a central organisation is needed. To be honest, there's no reason why the JMO can't do some of the things suggested above, now. The Ring's Jigs Instructional is a fantastic event, and I've seen several dancers standards improve dramatically after attending just one weekend as a novice; whilst it's a great "lad's weekend away", I'd love to see this event opened up to all organisations, as I think it would be really beneficial. Tell you what, why don't we just start our own organisation, see what happens then?  >:E

Whilst we're on the subject of standards, I remember being pretty appalled at the standard of booked sides for Shrewsbury a few years ago (can't remember which year). I mean, they weren't bad, but they certainly weren't festival display standard. I remember writing a long, rambly response to one of the questions on the feedback form about how festivals are one of the best exponents of Morris to those who are likely to want to do Morris in the future, and therefore organisers are almost duty bound to book decent sides. Interestingly, the year after, they booked Smiffs, Western, Nonesuch and the Outside Capering Crew.  ::)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 24, 2012, 04:09:40 PM
And instead of teams sniping at each other they could recognise that in the end we're all in favour of dancing and playing for an English tradition which is sadly underappreciated by the general public, and that it would be better if we all strove together to improve this situation.

This is a fascinating insight for me who's only contact with Morris is as an audience member.   For years I thought, like a lot of the general public, that Morris was a bit of a joke.  Generally overweight blokes with beards huffing and puffing in in not very interesting manner in between spells in the pub.   It was only a few years ago that I became aware of some of the awe inspiring young sides who seemed to be doing something completely different, an athletic and spectacular performance that was actually really exciting to watch.  Such performances still seem to be all to rare in my admittedly very limited experience.

Unfortunately true, which I'd like to see improve -- but youth isn't all that it's about, there are also older sides who also really know how to dance and look great doing it, though many of them also have younger members to keep the flame burning. Dancing experience, knowledge and skill are what also makes a good side, not solely how high they can jump -- I've seen fit young sides who certainly know how to jump, but don't really know how to *dance* as a team...

For example, both Great Western and Hammersmith have an age range from the teens to the fifties/sixties, but certainly none of them dance like old men :-)

(not meaning to bang the Smiffs drum, but I had to pick a couple of familar examples)

Ian
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 24, 2012, 04:20:06 PM

However sides do still have the option of organising men only meets (source - Squire's Capers, Issue 64 "The Morris Ring Circular").  I await with interest to see if any side takes this option.

Steve
Yes, there are several. I'm going to one in a couple of weeks, and went to another in December. I am very happy to do so, it will be good fun.
Some sides will, I'm sure, continue to hold all-male events and I will continue to attend them. Some may decline events with female musicians, but I won't.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ellie on January 24, 2012, 05:19:41 PM
So an inclusive organisation whose real purpose was to advance the cause of Morris dancing could -- for example -- offer tutorial weekends for inexperienced forepeople to teach them these skills, aimed at various levels of competence and all dancing styles without looking down on or excluding anyone -- because everyone has to learn sometime. Or member teams with "associate status" (or whatever it's called) could be encouraged to have experienced teachers come along to their practices to help them improve.

Quote from: Ollie
As you say, I think this is where a central organisation is needed. To be honest, there's no reason why the JMO can't do some of the things suggested above, now. The Ring's Jigs Instructional is a fantastic event, and I've seen several dancers standards improve dramatically after attending just one weekend as a novice; whilst it's a great "lad's weekend away", I'd love to see this event opened up to all organisations, as I think it would be really beneficial.

Hear hear! I've been wishing for at least a year now that there was similar organisation of stuff from the Fed. Or the JMO. However, I can't help thinking (from my own, limited, experience), that there really is a difference between sides that are effectively social groups, and those that have a certain level of performance. Certainly I joined my second side in an attempt to get into the latter. But if they are all performing in public, what can you really do about the impression they (we?  :-[) give?
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 24, 2012, 05:44:05 PM
I understood it to be a mutual agreement. ??? They took the decision to let women dance (out of necessity), and therefore could no longer be member of The Morris Ring - the national organisation for Men's Morris & Sword clubs; I assume they were aware of this when they took the decision. For what it's worth, the Ring were very, very sad to see them go.

Besides, it's only an organisation, and the main reason people are members of one of the three is for insurance purposes. Not being a member of the Morris Ring doesn't (or at least, shouldn't) change the outlook, style, feel or anything of the team. To be honest, the bit that's upset the tradition is the fact they've gone mixed, not the fact they've left the Ring.

The Plough Stots have had the occasional 'non male' dancer for many years, usually with their hair tucked up into the cap so you couldn't tell.   ;D So they haven't 'gone mixed', to some extent they always were! And it never affected the outlook, style, feel , or anything. I think it was a pragmatic way to get a team up when they were a man or two down for a gig.

Maybe Goathland have sussed that you can be an associate of the Ring and get all of the benefits of full membership apart from voting (big deal....) and attending Ring Meetings (yawn....)

Note I'm not advocating mixed teams for the Morris Ring - I personally don't like mixed teams, but I don't consider Goathland to be in any way mixed.

BTW - I know of at least two thriving and well respected sides who have been in existence for over 35 years who have never been elected to the Morris Ring, but who have continued to uphold the traditions without all the pallaver of being invited to join the ring, getting a bit of wood that is meant to be a 'staff of office' , and toasting the Queen.....

Rant over  (:)
Pikey

 
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 06:32:37 PM
A few corrections, Pikey...

1) Associate members can attend Ring Meetings
2) You're not invited to join the Ring - you have to apply.

With reference to the staff of office... I like it. I will be part of a side (hopefully) dancing into the Ring later this year. We will attend a weekend of dance, get to meet other sides and get to know them, then be able to display our dancing to the masses, before being formally welcomed into the organisation. We will be able to attend Ring events and generally join in with the wonderful fellowship that makes the Ring what it is.
I am also part of a side that joined the Open last year. We paid our money, our name and contacts got put on the website, and that was that. Apart from insurance, what's the point?
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Keithypete. on January 24, 2012, 06:43:08 PM
 Of course there are really bad dancing sides in all 3 organisations. What really hacks me off is ANYONE banging on about dance standards who can't bloody well dance. I've seen Ring sides where the total combined height of all their capers wouldn't amount to the thickness of a single rizla paper. I'd like to see them caper at least as high as the pile of laurels on which they're resting!!!

 Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 06:57:09 PM
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?

Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.

Grow up.  >:(
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Lester on January 24, 2012, 07:08:13 PM
My 2d worth

I am currently Squire and Foreman of a morris side that is known locally as a Care in Community side. We have the cast offs/failures from other sides and various waifs and strays. The standard of our dancing measured against Bacon's Book or whatever is poor but we are entertaining. The crowds seem to  really enjoy what we do, both the dancing and the après, tunes/songs. I for one really like it that way round I have seen sides that dance exquisite morris but are really boring. Most of the consumers/ crowd don't know/care what foot you should be on or which way you should be going but he want to see something that is fun to watch.

Ps we are a Ring Side  ;D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: oread_uk on January 24, 2012, 07:11:07 PM
I think it was pretty clear at last years JMO that the standard of dancing in all three organisations is variable.  Although when some of my non-morris friends have attended events, they are naturally attracted to the sides that look like they're enjoying what they're doing as they have no idea whether the dance is accurate- I'm not a great fan of watching Cotswold, yet I could watch Hammersmith or Berkshire Bedlam for many an hour - it's not just technique is it?  It's the energy and enthusiasm that goes into the performance.  You may have a side who are technically perfect, but who lack that 'ooomph'.  Who could judge that?

I dance for a Border side (Boggarts) who work hard to raise our standards as high as we can, whilst allowing anyone to join our side.  Some of our best dancers took the longest to learn to step and needed encouragement and support to get to where they are now.  We have a lot of younger members, for many of them joining the side was the first step into the 'folk' world.  Some of them have even learned to play the melodeon so that they can keep on going once their knees pack in  ;D  It would never be possible to 'police' standards, but, as Ian suggested, having the opportunity to attend events where the focus was on sharing and improving practice in a supportive, rather than judgemental, fashion would be good...

I just think it's a shame that Morris is so full of people bickering.  It kind of helps to perpetuate the image that Morris dancing has, which, in my fairly limited experience, is not a good indication of what a lovely pastime it actually is.

And we may not be invited to appear at the Olympics in our own country, but at least Morris will be well represented in Oman in February  ;D

And the squire of the Ring was very nice to us at JMO  :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Howard Jones on January 24, 2012, 07:53:30 PM
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.

There's this early photo of the Upton-on-Severn dancers with a woman in the side: 

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg)

This was printed in the insert to the vinyl edition of Plain Capers, I don't know if it's made it into the CD's notes.  John K seemed more interested that it also shows an anglo concertina.

Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Keithypete. on January 24, 2012, 08:00:26 PM
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?

Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.

Grow up.  >:(


 I wasn't blaming the ring for anything, but this sort of in-fighting is at best counter-productive, if not actually downright damaging!
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Anahata on January 24, 2012, 10:01:38 PM
Eurgh, don't get me started on kit based Border (and Molly) sides.  >:(

As far as the latter is concerned, Pig Dyke Molly are well aware that we have problems with our standard of dancing. The team was founded as an "equal-opportunity" organisation and it would go against that to be too restrictive about who was allowed to dance when, but at the same time we are very concerned about how best to balance this with the need for a decent performance at festivals and similar. Let it not be imagined that we don't care about that - a huge amount of discussion has taken place at meetings and practices and will doubtless continue.
We do like to think our music isn't too bad though  ;)

I've seen some of the border teams that fit the above descriptions, but of course can't speak for their recruitment or dance standards policies.

Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Owen Woods on January 24, 2012, 10:22:21 PM
Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?

Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.

Grow up.  >:(


 I wasn't blaming the ring for anything, but this sort of in-fighting is at best counter-productive, if not actually downright damaging!

I have to say that your previous post did clearly give the impression that you were blaming the Ring personally for not getting Morris at the Olympics by the poor dancing of some of their sides.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 10:33:52 PM
Eurgh, don't get me started on kit based Border (and Molly) sides.  >:(

As far as the latter is concerned, Pig Dyke Molly are well aware that we have problems with our standard of dancing. The team was founded as an "equal-opportunity" organisation and it would go against that to be too restrictive about who was allowed to dance when, but at the same time we are very concerned about how best to balance this with the need for a decent performance at festivals and similar. Let it not be imagined that we don't care about that - a huge amount of discussion has taken place at meetings and practices and will doubtless continue.
We do like to think our music isn't too bad though  ;)

I've seen some of the border teams that fit the above descriptions, but of course can't speak for their recruitment or dance standards policies.

Just to be clear, I wasn't referring to Pig Dyke; I thought you danced very well on Saturday. :)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 24, 2012, 10:35:03 PM
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.

There's this early photo of the Upton-on-Severn dancers with a woman in the side: 

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg)

This was printed in the insert to the vinyl edition of Plain Capers, I don't know if it's made it into the CD's notes.  John K seemed more interested that it also shows an anglo concertina.
And so he should be! Discerning chap, JK.

It is interesting to see and hear of early female dancers, but to me they are still scarce enough to be the exception that proves the rule. Were they commonplace the references would have been extremely well aired by now, and they just haven't been.

But we should not forget that we are looking at different times with different rules. The day to day social customs by which people live are often transparent to them and to contemporary commentators, so everyday as to not be worth recording. And the idea that people had their places, some things you did and some you didn't, was pretty ingrained.

It seems pretty clear that women didn't do public dancing. The idea, despised today, that a women's place was in the home was most likely a day to day necessity and pretty constant day to day. The thought of a woman - especially a young married woman - dancing with a group of men at organised - or worse, un-organised events - just wasn't on. It's widely held that women who did perform in public were considered in the same brackets as prostitutes - actors and dancers - and while that may be overstated in the context of a country village bash, it just doesn't seem to have the done thing.
But I expect the girls would have known the dances as well as the boys, and there are records (somewhere) of girls dancing but ceasing upon marriage.
You can put paganism and whatever to one side, peer pressure and social pressure are far more powerful and they don't usually get reported. Men had periods when work was scarce and they didn't do housework (apparently) so dancing and practicing were viable, also of course a way to earn a few bob or a few beers.

The industrial revolution mixed that all up, with women's roles changing from home to factory workers, and the rules changed. Cotswold, as we know it, still seems to remain in the country with other dance styles appearing in the factory towns  - stave and what we now call north-west styles - with women heavily involved.
Throw in a few wars, and attitudes have changed to our present mindset with the pendulum going the other way, and it's difficult for us to see the world through the eyes of people fifty, a hundred, two hundred years ago.

So  - the above just my opinion, of course - I consider that Cotswold Morris probably was mostly all male, by custom rather than perhaps by tradition, for reasons that no longer exist. Revival exclusively all male dancing may be based on a less than totally accurate view, but it has a 75+ plus year tradition behind it now, and it's a perfectly valid option in a pluralist society.

That's not why we dance it of course, we dance it because it's bloody good fun and were it not so then nobody would bother. And there would be a lot fewer melodeon players.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 24, 2012, 10:38:01 PM
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.

There's this early photo of the Upton-on-Severn dancers with a woman in the side: 

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_fCTvxTGhgLA/TQdXaAws2WI/AAAAAAAAAKA/ePbPI1G6yZQ/s1600/08+Morris+Border+upton+on+severn+no+blackface+2.jpg)

This was printed in the insert to the vinyl edition of Plain Capers, I don't know if it's made it into the CD's notes.  John K seemed more interested that it also shows an anglo concertina.

Thanks for that, not seen that before.  (:)

Is it any wonder that there WON'T be any morris dancing as part of the opening or closing ceremonies of the Olympic games?

Oh, something's gone wrong in the Morris world. I know, let's blame the Ring.

Grow up.  >:(
I wasn't blaming the ring for anything, but this sort of in-fighting is at best counter-productive, if not actually downright damaging!

It certainly sounded like it. I agree; please stop provoking it then.  ::)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 24, 2012, 10:44:44 PM
Amazingly I've missed this thread so far......

Hanging on my wall is a picture of my wife's Great Grandmother and Great (Great?) Grandfather.
He is stood top hatted, high waisted britches and various ribbons, and fiddle in hand.
Sat all around him are a load of young women in mop caps and dresses arraged in a team photo.
It's labelled " Morris Dancers, June 19th 1909 Spon End"
An area in Coventry where my wife hails from. Whatever people say, women have always danced the morris, and if you are ever fortunate to talk with Roy Dommett or attend an instructional, he can quote times, dates, sides etc verbatum of when they danced.

IanD: thank you kind sir for the kind comment about Great Western. We do seem to egg each other on on occasions. All good fun, and it must be done  :M
On occasions one of our elder statesman occasionally dances, still dances well, and is in his late 70's!
He does pick his dances but is utterly inspirational, especially when doing a jig with son and grandson.......
Though at a Dommett workshop in April, after dancing friday night, all day and evening on  saturday, we progressed to Longborough on sunday morning,ending up with Swaggering Boney, and 12 minutes later , a touch breathless, I realised our elder statesman had also done it. Age is in the mind.  It just hurts more now.....

Sometimes standards of performance and standards of dance are mixed up.
There are times when a side can perform really well, maybe not dance technically that well, but engage and perform for an audience who go away feeling really up, having enjoyed the experience.
Other times a side can dance technically very well but not engage at all, so the audience goes away uninspired or bored even, not really knowing what it was all about.
To maintain a good standard of dance *and* perform well for an audience is our goal.
Well, we try, as do our good mates the Smiffs!
Anyway, must off to bed.
Night all
Q
zzzzzzzz
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Anahata on January 25, 2012, 08:30:54 AM
While I don't support the extremist view that women shouldn't dance morris, I do think there's something to be said for at least some single-sex teams and accepting that we are different.
Stroud had (still have?) a women's and men's team that operate together, with many couples involved in both. The two team's dances are different and their kit is different but with a common colour scheme.
Similarly Shropshire Bedlam and Martha Rhoden's Tuppenny Dish, but without the common colour scheme. Very different dances.
Old Glory Molly have strictly men dancing and women playing, with totally different kit for each.
All of the above exploit the natural differences between male and female in their dancing style, and I think it's good that at least some of us are doing that.

Yes, I'm playing for a mixed team, but Pig Dyke's dancing style has been designed to be gender neutral. And I love Boggart's Breakfast who are mixed border, but they do it well and look fantastic. There's room for all of us...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: jonm on January 25, 2012, 09:11:52 AM
My main issue with mixed (Cotswold) morris is the bits which bob up and down.

Men tend to dance buttocks forward, shoulders back and stomach prominent. Women tend to have the bottom back, knees together, leaning forward and often more round-shouldered. Basically, the two stances (and associated anatomical components) create different frequencies and amplitudes of simple harmonic motion when dancing. :D

The only mixed teams who look half decent IMHO have a distinct degree of androgyny.

I agree with the comments on Boggart's Breakfast - hadn't come across them until recently with youtube links from here, but the dancing is high-precision with complex figures. Good stuff, and entertaining. Totally gives the lie to the (generally true) maxim that the better the kit, the worse the dancing with border / molly teams! ::)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 25, 2012, 11:23:02 AM
 
  B'gg'r me!
  Fourier analysis of morris dancing  :Ph 
  Amazing what has spun off a little cartoon ..  :|glug
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 25, 2012, 11:26:17 AM
 
  B'gg'r me!
  Fourier analysis of morris dancing  :Ph 


Presumably, were it Fluffy Morris under examination, one might use Furrier Analysis?
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 25, 2012, 01:06:24 PM
In the late 1960s and early 1970s, I undertook quite extensive reseach into Cotswold and Border Morris dancing and longsword dancing at Cecil Sharp House, the British Library, the Public Record Office (since rebranded as the National Archives) and various regional archives and libraries. One of the things for which I looked (at the request of my sister, who was dancing with Cardiff Ladies at that time) was evidence of women dancing with traditional sides. Unfortunately, I lent my notes to someone several years ago and they were never returned, so I am writing this from a somewhat hazy memory.

The oldest reference I found was of women making up depleted numbers in a Cotswold side during the last years of the Napoleonic War. I came across a similar reference to a Cotswold side during the Crimean War and one pertaining to a Border side during the Second Boer War. Unfortunately, I can't remember the names of these sides, but I think the one in the Napoleonic War was in Oxfordshire, possibly Stanton Harcourt. In at least one of these cases, a newspaper article stated explicitly that this was a temporary situation caused by the war. I found two or three similar references to women dancing during the First World War.

Clearly, these were isolated examples and were short term expedients to enable the sides to survive a temporary shortage of men, but they illustrate what must have happened throughout Morris history - that sides adapted to social, economic and cultural circumstances, as they continue to do nowadays.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 25, 2012, 01:31:42 PM
My curiosity was aroused by Ian's account of Hammersmith's departure from the Ring. Can you remember, Ian, when this occurred?

My own recollection of events was somewhat different, but it may be that Hammersmith left the Ring on more than one occasion, having rejoined in the intervening period. I attended three or four Ring meetings when dancing with Hammersmith in the late 1960s and early 1970s. I can't recall the precise dates and details, but I think the last two Ring meetings we attended were at Thaxted and Ludlow. We received sustained hostility from some members of some sides at these events, culminating in vituperative abuse and a slanging match at an evening meal that led us to walk out of the meal. While I wasn't directly involved in the acrimony, I did not see or hear any member of Hammersmith do anything to provoke the hostility we experienced, although some did react to it robustly. Shortly afterwards, Hammersmith received a letter from the Ring demanding that we apologise for our behaviour. Feeling that we were not the culprits, we refused and this led directly to our expulsion or resignation (I forget which).

Before anyone accuses me of having an antipathy towards the Ring, I do not. I have many friends among Ring sides and I was careful to point out that the hostility came from some members of some sides, not the sides themselves and not the Ring itself. While the request for an apology came from the Ring hierarchy, this was more likely to have been due to the events having been misrepresented to them than to any anti-Hammersmith sentiment on their part. In any case, all this happened about 40 years ago and life is far too short to harbour grudges.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 25, 2012, 02:10:49 PM
Reminsicent of the Dwarf (Alberich Morris Men, it sez 'ere) being taunted by the Rhinemaidens!

  One can now see why Tolkein staged his manifestation of Hobbitry in 'the Shires'  >:E
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 03:25:38 PM
My curiosity was aroused by Ian's account of Hammersmith's departure from the Ring. Can you remember, Ian, when this occurred?


I heard it was racing in kit in supermarket trolleys that raised a few eyebrows!
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Owen Woods on January 25, 2012, 03:28:02 PM
And I'd heard that it was drunk and disorderly behaviour :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 03:29:42 PM
In supermarket trolleys  !  ;D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 25, 2012, 03:45:39 PM
I'd heard it was because a certain Fr Loveless took exception to the fool cutting off a dancer's britches with a cut-throat razor during a show dance (Lass of Richmond Hill) at a Ring Meeting.  :P
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Davy R on January 25, 2012, 04:09:20 PM
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.

Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together?  ;D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 25, 2012, 04:17:49 PM
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.

Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together?  ;D

Maybe :-)

The incident Bob referred to was an earlier one -- this was when the Ring tried to throw us out and then discovered there was no constitutional mechanism to do so. It was many years later that we left voluntarily.

The ones about the cut-throat razor and the shopping trolleys are news to me -- however if they did happen I'd expect them to be part of the great Smiffs word-of-mouth archive of apochryphal tales, and they're not.

Though I was present at the Hartley ring meeting where we held the Ring officers (and everyone else) to ransom with pump-action water pistols to extract money from them for a worthy cause (an aid convoy to Bosnia) which caused some resentment -- though I do remember that said officers paid up handsomely, most of the indignation coming from others present...

Ian

Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Owen Woods on January 25, 2012, 04:33:22 PM
Probably the incidents mentioned relate in some way to the first instance that Bob referred to.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 04:45:27 PM
Is it something about London sides? The anarchic and superb Blackheath MM (who I don't think have ever been Ring members), used to sing a little ditty that went 'Hark the Herald Angels Sing, B**locks to the Morris Ring'   ;D

They also once danced in the sea on the Brighton nudist beach, clad only in bells.  It's a good job they weren't full members.......... ::)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ollie on January 25, 2012, 05:03:29 PM
Interesting. I heard about the razor incident from someone who claimed to have been there.  ??? Not that it really matters, anyway.  ::)

Is it something about London sides?

Nahh, there's the superb (in a very different way) Westminster Morris Men, who have been stalwarts of the Ring for years; I believe they've attended every Thaxted Ring Meeting for the past 50+ years.
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 25, 2012, 05:23:18 PM
Why does work get in the way of interesting debate?

Bob: Earlier post about women.
I think you are on the mark, I've heard similar stories from Roy woh also was based in London and delved into similar archives.
He also pointed out that then sides were usually family run, with 6 men and a musician so the collecting was split 7 ways. The whol reason for dancing was to collect money, so if a family male was out fighting for King and Country, his sister probably knew the dances too * and it kept the money in the family*

Smiffs: I rememer first meeting them at the ( oh god no....) Cardiff Instructionals, and vaguely remember food fights and Bath being mentioned. Presumably in Tubby Reynold's era at Bath? cos Tubby was a complete one man full on riot. Absoluetly lovely bloke and daft as a brush., food fights sound quite restrained for him!!!!!!!
Q
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Davy R on January 25, 2012, 07:20:10 PM

They also once danced in the sea on the Brighton nudist beach, clad only in bells.  It's a good job they weren't full members.......... ::)

Was Byron Daniels somehow involved? Bet he was!  >:E
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 08:07:03 PM
You bet he was!  He kept his cap on as well  ;D 

Late lamented and sorely missed. I can hear him now singing his version of Blue Suede Shoes , interspersed with the libe ' I wish, I wish I'd never been born, I wish I was a girl again'  :D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: baz parkes on January 25, 2012, 08:11:49 PM
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.

Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together?  ;D

I was there for the food fight with Bath...or a food fight with Bath...it was the same Ring meeting that got Bath into serious trouble for their accompanying musician (a lovely box player but a stranger to this house..) playing a piano on the back of a lorry...I saw no urination in a public place, m'lud...

Then again, it was my first Ring meeting and I may have strong drink taken.... :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug...
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 09:30:35 PM
Goathland 1, Morris Ring 0......... (:)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 25, 2012, 09:56:07 PM
In '91 I attended a Ring AGM in Cheddar, I was asked being a relatively local Squire ( of Great Western, not a village  :D ) if I'd represent the Morris Federation. They were invited to send a rep. for the first time, which was the start of the now healthy alliance between all churches of the morris.
I sat 2 places along from Lional Bacon, then an elderly gentleman, and it was lovely to see him and briefly chat. We were treated to 2 hours of bickering and Urination in the Hall was the final topic of discussion. Do I detect a theme here?
The Squire of the Ring was a very nice chap, and made known to me he was equally unimpressed, I was made very welcome and invited to the feast etc. after the meeting, but my taxi had finished her shopping in Bath and was awaiting, so I missed any opportunity for what could have been a genuine Bun Fight  ;D
Q
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 25, 2012, 10:13:06 PM
The late and much lovd Rev Ken Loveless went as a guest to the Grimsby/Alford weekend of dsance one year, many years ago.

He watched Ebor Morris dance a set before the pubs opened, sitting on his shooting stick, and didn't say a word.

He then saw us about 3 hours later, came up to our Squire, and said ' that was much better then earlier today, well done. Why is that?'.

To which our Squire replied ' That's because we've all had 5 pints'....... ;D

Rev Ken then said 'why is that man there not wearing a hat?' , which was met with the response ' because he hasn't got one'.
So Ken said ' That's alright then, I thought it was some form of cultivated scruffiness.....'  ;D

The next Morris Ring newsletter had a diatribe letter from the Rev, complaining about 'a form of cultivated scruffiness' in teams...... 'The wearing of metal badges on baldricks is not to be tolerated'.....' Tankards should not be worn on belts'......'Teams should process onto the site, not just gather together'.....'At the end of each dance, teams should process off the site, not just wander off'......

Ebor Morris's moment of fame....... Hence our soubriquet, 'The Slightly Notorious Ebor Morris'   >:E
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 25, 2012, 10:49:29 PM
Is it something about London sides? The anarchic and superb Blackheath MM (who I don't think have ever been Ring members), used to sing a little ditty that went 'Hark the Herald Angels Sing, B**locks to the Morris Ring'   ;D

They also once danced in the sea on the Brighton nudist beach, clad only in bells.  It's a good job they weren't full members.......... ::)

Surely *real* anarchists would have danced on said beach fully clothed ?

Ian

(who remembers being directed around Blackheath in the car for about 10 minutes between pubs, ending up at the infamous Dog and Bell a hundred yards round the corner from the pub we'd set off from)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 25, 2012, 10:55:23 PM
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.

Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together?  ;D

I was there for the food fight with Bath...or a food fight with Bath...it was the same Ring meeting that got Bath into serious trouble for their accompanying musician (a lovely box player but a stranger to this house..) playing a piano on the back of a lorry...I saw no urination in a public place, m'lud...

Then again, it was my first Ring meeting and I may have strong drink taken.... :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug...

The food fights did used to get a bit out of hand sometimes, but we weren't always the guilty party. Hartley go so fed up that they tried to come up with a meal for the feast which couldn't be thrown (stew, mash, and salad), but were proved wrong -- not by us initially, we were the victims of a high-velocity low-trajectory tomato from across the room which landed in our bowl of stew and left us looking like the victims of an explosion in a pie filling factory -- after which it all went a bit pear-shaped...

(yes, you *can* throw mash...)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 25, 2012, 11:25:01 PM
The food fights did used to get a bit out of hand sometimes, but we weren't always the guilty party. Hartley go so fed up that they tried to come up with a meal for the feast which couldn't be thrown (stew, mash, and salad), but were proved wrong -- not by us initially, we were the victims of a high-velocity low-trajectory tomato from across the room which landed in our bowl of stew and left us looking like the victims of an explosion in a pie filling factory -- after which it all went a bit pear-shaped...

 .. Any ladies who might still wish to apply for this 'elite' hegemony - please contact:

  The Morris Ring,  35 - 37 Main Street,  North Anston,  Sheffield,  S25 4BD
.. as per Web site (http://www.themorrisring.org/about-mr/elected-officers) .  Was it Groucho who said "I'd never join any club that would have me as a member"  ???
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 26, 2012, 12:24:36 AM
I often wondered why we were Slightly Notorious  ...  .... .. .     :M
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Bob Ellis on January 26, 2012, 01:02:37 AM
At the time of the incident to which I referred earlier, Hammersmith were not involved in any chasing around in supermarket trolleys, urinating in the hall or cutting of clothing with razor blades. I was there and I am sure I would have remembered if such things had happened.

Food fights with Bath City and other daft behaviour when Hammersmith and Bath City got together were de rigeur, but they didn't happen at the Ring meeting that caused the Ring hierarchy to try to expel us. I am not even sure that Bath City were at that Ring meeting.

Talking of the late great Tubby Reynolds, my favourite memory of him was at Bromyard Festival in the early '70s. We got up a side of mixed Bath and Hammersmith men to dance in the dark at what must have been around 1.00 or 2.00 a.m. All involved had been drinking heavily, including Tubby. He was leaning against the back of a van playing pipe and tabor, while we danced. After a while, we realised that he was gradually sliding down the back of the van, but he continued playing until his backside reached the ground, when he promptly fell asleep in mid-tune. Happy days!
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 26, 2012, 09:34:00 AM
And I'd heard it was a combination of 1. A food fight with Bath University MM and 2. Urination in a public place.

Is there more folklore associated with the Smiffs than with all other London Morris sides put together?  ;D

I was there for the food fight with Bath...or a food fight with Bath...it was the same Ring meeting that got Bath into serious trouble for their accompanying musician (a lovely box player but a stranger to this house..) playing a piano on the back of a lorry...I saw no urination in a public place, m'lud...

Then again, it was my first Ring meeting and I may have strong drink taken.... :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug...

The food fights did used to get a bit out of hand sometimes, but we weren't always the guilty party. Hartley go so fed up that they tried to come up with a meal for the feast which couldn't be thrown (stew, mash, and salad), but were proved wrong -- not by us initially, we were the victims of a high-velocity low-trajectory tomato from across the room which landed in our bowl of stew and left us looking like the victims of an explosion in a pie filling factory -- after which it all went a bit pear-shaped...

(yes, you *can* throw mash...)

As a young lad in Ebor Morris, I amde us a 'staff of office' using a bicycle pump with ribbons attached. It was much more functional than a Morris Ring Staff, because when  the food fights started at the Alford  feast you could use it to fire peas at Grimsby/Gorton/Brighton/Alford/Black Cap/Isca and whover else happend to be there!

That's also where we invented the infamous Ebor 'Hat Tower' as somewhere to put the top hats during the meal. It also provided a good target for bread roll chucking.....

 ;D
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: baz parkes on January 26, 2012, 09:49:23 AM
Can I just say I think Theo's being ramarkably tolerant here.... (:)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 26, 2012, 09:51:05 AM
I agree!  (:)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: IanD on January 26, 2012, 10:37:56 AM
I agree!  (:)

Well it is general discussion, and we're STILL following the thread title faithfully... ;)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: pikey on January 26, 2012, 11:56:15 AM
I once saw Blackheath do 'Skirmish' , throwing the sticks acroos a huge set, to be followed by musicians throwing melodeons !

(I had to get a melodeon mention in somewhere........)
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 26, 2012, 07:30:31 PM
I remember being at the Cardiff Instructional with Tubby in attendance, and Hammersmith insisted on attaching a *huge* flag of hammer and anvil in Smiffs colours to the  roof trusses of the drill hall where we were practising.
Tubby decided he wanted to just 'singe it a bit.....' whereuppon there was a huge 'whuff', flames, smoke, etc etc.... the Cardiff Squire was remarkably tolerant in telling us off. We later realised it happened under the fire sprinklers.....
At breakfast next morning, Tubby told me he only wanted to 'singe it a bit to get 'em going.....' instead it got going in flames!
In an attempt at a mid-hangover polite breakfast converstaion, I remarked on how much I enjoyed a song from the night before. Tubby innocently said he didn't know that one.... and  reminded him he sang it!!!!!!!!!!
His war wound was interesting too.....won't tell you where  :|bl
Yep, sound bloke. Great fun, and a wonderful mate for Roy to have fun with......
Q
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 27, 2012, 07:03:23 PM
How do we pile up our top hats on melnet anyway?  >:E
Title: Re: Further to Lester's Thread Drift, but STILL not Morris Dancing
Post by: Tufty on February 16, 2012, 03:32:07 PM
I'd be interested to see your evidence of mixed gender dancing in traditional teams in the early 20th century, Chris.

Arguably, the tradition the Morris Ring is upholding is one of its own invention. That said, traditions all have to start somewhere, and there are still plenty of teams out there who wish to dance in an all-male environment, which is why the Ring continues to exist.
[/quote]
Some interesting quotes from William Kimber in conversation with the Squire of the Ring in 1951 (no I was not present!).
"but let me tell you there was some dancers there as would whack half the men at dancing jigs. Certainly old Jem (Jemima) Smith, she'd challenge any of 'em".

"Let me tell you there, they dances a damn sight neater than half of you do".

"Now who started the Morris in London in the first place and would there have been any Morris at all in London if it hadn't a-been for the ladies?"
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal