Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Simon T on January 25, 2012, 05:31:39 PM
-
Having been inspired by some lovely playing that I've heard recently, I am planning to buy a melodeon. My aim would be to use it for accompanying singing - both English folk and 'other' folk (ie American I guess if you really want to know). Possibly some Celeidh playing...
What key melodeon should I look for? It seems the English standard is D/G but is that only if you mainly want to play Morris? Can anyone help out this ignorant beginner....Thanks
-
If you plan to accompany singers then the starting point must be the keys that the singers are comfortable in. DG is too high for some singers, CF might better, or Bb/Eb.
-
Hello Simon, welcome to the forum.
Unless your voice is good enough to cope with the keys it will be forced into by a diatonic box, it may not be the best choice of instrument to use for singing with. B/C C#/D etc. boxes give a little more leeway as to key variation but then you lose out on the bass end, so why not play concertina. The other option is to use a BCC# three row with an accordion (stradella) bass, this gives you a lot more choice of useable keys. You, of course, can go down the road of multiple melodeons in different keys. Sorry to be so negative, but IMHO few people can use melodeons for singing to effectively (although a few are brilliant at it). Not an easy instrument for accompanying ones self though
-
Sorry to be so negative, but IMHO few people can use melodeons for singing to effectively (although a few are brilliant at it). Not an easy instrument for accompanying ones self though
There's a lot of truth in what you say, but on the other hand it's a great instrument for accompanying someone else singing. In the non-dance quartet I'm working with at the moment I use mainly the D/G, then the C/F and occasionally the Bb/Eb. And if you're likely to be working with other musicians for ceilidhs then D/G is probably your best bet (though I use a C 1-row quite a bit for dance tunes). Top and bottom is there's no simple answer - which is why so many of us suffer from MAD (you'll find out about MAD very soon, and probably fall prey to it yourself eventually..... ;D)
Welcome aboard
Graham
-
I agree with what's been said so far, apart from one point (by Theo): there are no keys that are generally "too high" or "too low" for a singer. Each singer has a particular range that they can sing with comfort, and each song has also a range of notes, but these vary with the song - it doesn't depend on the key. So I can find one song in the key of G too high (because its range is, say, from middle E to high G), while another song in G may be fine for me (because its range is from middle D to high D, which suits my voice).
The reason why a melodeon is not ideal for singing is that there's not enough choice of keys, and this will happen no matter what tuning you choose. For many songs, I'll find that G is too high (or too low if it's in the lower octave), while D is too low - the ideal key for a particular song for me might be C# or F or B flat, and I can't play accompaniments in thsoe because I don't have all the notes or chords for them. Choosing a different box would still mean that certain songs can be accompanied and others can't.
Another point is that some melodeons are quite hard to sing against - they may be either too loud and strident, or too "wet" and jangly, both of which may be tricky for some voices.
Having said that, I do sometimes sing with mine; but I only do this with a song that I know will work in D or G for me. My box has a choice of treble stops, which makes it easier to select a sound that will complement the singing and not drown it out. I really prefer to sing unaccompanied, and if I wanted to accompany myself for singing all the time I'd try to learn something like English concertina (except that i know I'd be rubbish at that!).
You're right that D/G is the favoured tuning for morris, but it's also by far the most common type used in sessions and ceilidh-band music. Most session tunes are played in G, D or E minor (which is also OK on a D/G box). Having a set of melodeons in different keys would solve most of the musical problems but create other crucial ones such as cost and convenience and storage space, and where on earth you put them all in a crowded pub ...
-
For singing folk songs you can't beat a guitar for accompaniment....all keys included. >:E
-
Thanks very much - its all helpful grist to the mill. I already play guitar, so agree re:accompaniment, but there is something about the quality of the melodeon which is drawing me - you all understand that no doubt...
-
PS - MAD ?
-
PS - MAD ?
Melodeon Acquisition Disease
-
If you want to hear some wonderful song accompaniment by melodeon just listen to Andy Cutting. He has worked extensively with Kate Rusby, June Tabor, Martin Simpson to name just three. I think that gives the lie to the suggestion that melodeon is not a good choice. He covers all the singers needs with just two boxes, a DG and a CF.
-
For tune playing in England you need a D/G box. Not just for morris, it's the industry standard for sessions and ceilidhs too.
You can also play Irish music on a D/G but most Irish music specialists play chromatic systems like B/C, C/C#, C#/D.
For songs, you need to think about what key you are singing in...
-
I know this might sound like heresy, but if you're doing song accompaniment, why not opt for a Continental Chromatic or Piano Accordion?
-
I know this might sound like heresy, but if you're doing song accompaniment, why not opt for a Continental Chromatic or Piano Accordion?
See Theo's post above :)
-
I know this might sound like heresy, but if you're doing song accompaniment, why not opt for a Continental Chromatic or Piano Accordion?
See Theo's post above :)
Well, yes, but Andy's rather good. ::)
-
I agree with what's been said so far, apart from one point (by Theo): there are no keys that are generally "too high" or "too low" for a singer. Each singer has a particular range that they can sing with comfort, and each song has also a range of notes, but these vary with the song - it doesn't depend on the key. So I can find one song in the key of G too high (because its range is, say, from middle E to high G), while another song in G may be fine for me (because its range is from middle D to high D, which suits my voice).
This is very true. However there are generalizations that can be made about which notes (ranges) are mostly used in songs in key X.
W
-
I know this might sound like heresy, but if you're doing song accompaniment, why not opt for a Continental Chromatic or Piano Accordion?
See Theo's post above :)
Well, yes, but Andy's rather good. ::)
And to do as well on chromatic or piano box you would also have to be rather good. The point is was trying to make is that the diatonic box has no shortage of potential.
-
I'm set to be accompanying song soon, something which is so far outside of my comfort zone so as to be practically invisible... but I'm sure it's possible :P
-
It would seem to me that a dry tuning would be strongly advisable if you're planning on singing along with your box, no?
-
It would seem to me that a dry tuning would be strongly advisable if you're planning on singing along with your box, no?
I'd say no.
My Beltuna is pretty much completely dry, and I find it really difficult to sing with. It tends to work for slower songs, but in the most part I find myself wanting something wetter. I find right hand chords sound really 'blocky' and unnatural, and usually revert to my Pokerwork! That's probably a bit much for some, but I'd suggest a light swing was as near to dry as you want to go.
-
It would seem to me that a dry tuning would be strongly advisable if you're planning on singing along with your box, no?
I'd say no.
My Beltuna is pretty much completely dry, and I find it really difficult to sing with. It tends to work for slower songs, but in the most part I find myself wanting something wetter. I find right hand chords sound really 'blocky' and unnatural, and usually revert to my Pokerwork! That's probably a bit much for some, but I'd suggest a light swing was as near to dry as you want to go.
I agree; chords on a box with a bit of tremolo do sound fuller and more - well, "natural", I suppose is probably the word.
-
It would seem to me that a dry tuning would be strongly advisable if you're planning on singing along with your box, no?
I'd say no.
My Beltuna is pretty much completely dry, and I find it really difficult to sing with. It tends to work for slower songs, but in the most part I find myself wanting something wetter. I find right hand chords sound really 'blocky' and unnatural, and usually revert to my Pokerwork! That's probably a bit much for some, but I'd suggest a light swing was as near to dry as you want to go.
Haha, I'm going to disagree with both opinions! :o
Like any other playing circumstances it depends only on what you and the singer (and the audience) like. I believe the only aspect of the wet/dry choice that most of us would agree on is that wet tuning is perceived as louder than dry, so is useful if you need maximum audibility without amplification. Aside from that it is a matter of personal choice.
For example:
swing tuned with voices (http://www.artemia.fr/en/modules/smartsection/item.php?itemid=18) see under Musical Extracts
wet tuned with voice (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QScMy2KWPHU)
In both these examples the box volume is kept in check so the voices are the main thing you hear.
-
For song accompaniment the volume and brightness of the sound are more important than the amount of tremolo.
For years I've used a Saltarelle Connemara III for song accompaniment and little else, and I often have it stopped down to a single reed. I've also used various 4-stop 1-rows, and usually take out the H reeds to dull the sound a little so the voice stands out better, in particular not to fight the consonants so the words are easier to hear. On both types, sometimes I use tremolo, sometimes I cut it out. I think the choice depends on the song.
My Oakwood is far too bright for singing with, my Dino Baffetti special is fine because it's easy to play quietly and the sound is bass-rich.
-
This is great!! What fantastic diversity and range of views!....but it is really helpful to get me thinking about the different aspects involved. I have to say if I could buy a D/G Hohner Pokerwork tomorrow I probably would - you've got to start somewhere and when I have scaled the heights of melodeon genius....well by then I wil no doubt have a selection...I think I have the madness in slumbering form.
-
I think the choice here depends on the singer's voice, skills and musical interests. Good singers will probably wish to choose a key precisely to best match their range, and a semitone out will make all the difference to them. Sure, if they are good singers, they will probably also be able to sing in a whole range of keys, but equally, if they're good they probably won't want to do that.
So you may be lucky in having the right box for a given situation, but often, you won't.
I agree with Theo that wet or dry can both work in different circumstances, but I do also feel that very wet is less easy to sing against effectively - the brash sound dominates. I've heard singers that turn this to great effect, but for most situations, I have to say that a drier sound tends to allow the singer more room for subtlety.
The right balance of bass and treble on the box is also very important - I would agree in general with Anahata that a bassier sound is often better, however this is a matter of subtlety of tone. I have two very similar boxes, but in one the bass end is much noisier in relation to the treble end than the other. The first one is usually the better box for dance music because of its punchiness, but the second is good for singing against because its less braying bass end sound fits much more readily with a voice.
You like American songs, as I understand it? This is of course covers a huge range of genres. I regularly attend a music session where new country music tends to be frequently played, with smatterings of trad English/Irish/Scottish for a bit of variety. I've never yet worked out how to play box with most of the songs they sing, I confess. But then of course there's Cajun and TexMex, where the box is in the forefront of songs. Many years ago I went to a bluegrass festival, where tight vocals/fiddle/banjo/double bass/guitar pickin' combos were the norm. I tried adding a simple box bass to the mix, and amazingly the steady bass sound really worked. (The comment was "Jesus! What in hell's name is that?")
And of course, there's lots of musical styles, still to be invented!
I think what I would do first in your situation is to work out what keys your singer is often going to sing in from their voice, and start from there.
-
Not wanting to gainsay Theo, but both examples say they have some tremolo - please be gentle with me, my sound card is not working. The human voice is not tied to any tuning pattern and is unlikely to use equal temperament! I feel that in "that other thread(s)" we have established that a degree of tremolo can overcome the inconsistencies of tuning, so probably makes it easier for the voice to fit in with it. I was struck by how certain phrases on the Lilly, being single voice made the tuning temperament apparent, sounding a little strident and discordant on certain intervals. Strangely I don't notice this on my LMM box which is very dry.
I don't like to hear a voice with a thin tone (screeching soprano) with a concertina like tone, or a bass getting muddled into the envelopping sound of a Pokerwork - some contrast is required to keep the instrument and voice as separate entities.
Not only does an accompanist need to match his singers range, pitch and tone, but as the singer ages you'll most likely need to drop from a D/G to a C/F anyway - or is that just years of smoking and drinking that does that?
-
Not wanting to gainsay Theo, but both examples say they have some tremolo -
Which is what I said! first example is swing - slow tremolo, second is wet - fast tremolo.
I just did a quick search and these were two contrasting example I found almost straight away.
For 'dry' there are may example of fine singers who use concertina accompaniment to great effect and by definition as single reeds there is no tremolo,
-
I don't think that dryness or wetness comes into it. Personally I sing with anglo concertina, Hohner one row four stops in both G and C generally with all the stops out, Saltarelle A/D/G and Hohner Club 3 in C/F. The choice is based on the key that I want to sing in and the style of the accompaniment I feel goes best with the song. Hence why most melodeon players do have MAD! Recently I have also been singing with the Roland FR18D but that is a different story!
-
For what it's worth, here's a recording of me accompanying a song on my Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G, which is tuned with what these days would be considered a fair degree of tremolo. I try to keep out of the singer's way (it's not me singing) and I was reasonably happy with the result.
http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse (http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse)
Graham
-
I was reasonably happy with the result.
I'm not surprised GPS, that's brilliant! Your box and the singer fit together perfectly - a lovely relaxed sound.
-
For what it's worth, here's a recording of me accompanying a song on my Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G, which is tuned with what these days would be considered a fair degree of tremolo. I try to keep out of the singer's way (it's not me singing) and I was reasonably happy with the result.
http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse (http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse)
Graham
That's exactly the sort of tremolo that, in my opinion, suits a voice perfectly. Very nicely done. (:)
Simon, to hear some of the best melodeon song accompaniment, go and get a copy of Penguin Eggs by Nic Jones, and listen to the masterful Tony Hall at work.
Incidentally, I've been asked to do a session for a well-known folk band, where I'll be accompanying singing. In this case, the Beltuna (with 3 voices) works perfectly, though that's mainly because it's in a full band context, rather than singer + guitar or other small set up.
-
Thank you chaps - your praise means a lot.
Graham
-
Oddly enough it was seeing Tony at a recent gig that inspired me...and Penguin Eggs has just arrived in the post today...
-
I was reasonably happy with the result.
I'm not surprised GPS, that's brilliant! Your box and the singer fit together perfectly - a lovely relaxed sound.
Chris - I'm really glad you said that; he and I had worked together on and off for years and had got to the point where we each knew instinctively what the other was going to do next. Sadly he died suddenly from an out-of-the-blue heart attack last year, so that recording is quite special to me. I'm glad to have shared it.
Graham
-
Haha, I'm going to disagree with both opinions!
Yes, I should have said drier rather than dry. Singing alongside a fully wet Pokerwork seems like a daunting task!
-
... the lie to the suggestion that melodeon is not a good choice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-1o8z4_DSo
-
... the lie to the suggestion that melodeon is not a good choice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-1o8z4_DSo
And that one is if anything wetter than a pokerwork!
-
Oddly enough it was seeing Tony at a recent gig that inspired me...and Penguin Eggs has just arrived in the post today...
Back in the day lots of us were inspired to play melodeon by listening to the fabulous Tony Hall. And in the UK pretty much the only decent box to buy back then was indeed a Hohner pokerwork. Lack of choice often seems a godsend in retrospect! ( ???) If I were you, I'd beg, borrow or steal (er...better not I s'pose) a Hohner in any key and just get playing and not worry too much about which key it's in - singing will follow if that's the way you want to go. :||: ;D
Edited in respect of obeying the law and not nicking off fellow squeezers. :|bl
-
For what it's worth, here's a recording of me accompanying a song on my Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G, which is tuned with what these days would be considered a fair degree of tremolo. I try to keep out of the singer's way (it's not me singing) and I was reasonably happy with the result.
http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse (http://soundcloud.com/mrkoilani/poor-old-horse)
Graham
Lovley! Thank you for sharing this with us.
-
... the lie to the suggestion that melodeon is not a good choice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-1o8z4_DSo
And that one is if anything wetter than a pokerwork!
Yes...I like my Club III with all the reeds for singing...but I'm into the blues and zydeco
-
Oddly enough it was seeing Tony at a recent gig that inspired me...and Penguin Eggs has just arrived in the post today...
Back in the day lots of us were inspired to play melodeon by listening to the fabulous Tony Hall. And in the UK pretty much the only decent box to buy back then was indeed a Hohner pokerwork. Lack of choice often seems a godsend in retrospect! ( ???) If I were you, I'd beg, borrow or steal (er...better not I s'pose) a Hohner in any key and just get playing and not worry too much about which key it's in - singing will follow if that's the way you want to go. :||: ;D
Edited in respect of obeying the law and not nicking off fellow squeezers. :|bl
That sounds like sound advice!
-
Really enjoyed your post, GPS! Thanks for that. Here's a young woman who has found a nice method of accompaniment:
http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw (http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw)
-
I think you'll have worked out, Simon, that there are few fixed rules when it comes to melodeons, and almost every firm opinion on this forum will be rebutted by another poster.
Overall, though, the consensus seems to be that if you do decide on a melodeon, you may as well start with a D/G, as that's the one tuning that you wouldn't want to be without. Then when you've made a start on playing some tunes, you can experiment with it as an accompaniment for the voice (yours or another's) and see how it sounds - it's probably the case that the wetnes/dryness/brightness and general pitch of the sound of an individual box will suit some voices but not others. Try a range of songs and you'll soon see what I mean about the limitations of the keys. Then you can decide whether you want to choose a different model, or a different instrument. Or a second melodeon.
-
Well, if you're un vrai valliant bougre like Zydeco Joe, I guess you can do whatever you want. That's not so much singing, more a cri de coeur. - truly impressive. And yes, that Hohner's as wet as the Louisiana bayou.
Using the bass to accompany the voice, as in Forrest's clip, seems like a workable option for those of us with a somewhat less commanding presence than Zydeco Joe. I have to admit that since I took up the melodeon, I haven't been much tempted to try singing along with it.
-
Really enjoyed your post, GPS! Thanks for that. Here's a young woman who has found a nice method of accompaniment:
http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw (http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw)
A lovely way to use what can be an overpowering instrument.
Earlier in the thread Andy and Tony were praised for their accompaniments, and very fine they are, but it's much easier to accompany someone other than yourself. Playing for self, for me anyway, tends to mix breathing with pushing and pulling. The few songs I do self accompany are bit like the above vid, very simple when I'm singing and more decoration in between. I agree with an earlier comment that guitars are usually better for accompanying folk songs.
-
I think you'll have worked out, Simon, that there are few fixed rules when it comes to melodeons, and almost every firm opinion on this forum will be rebutted by another poster.
Overall, though, the consensus seems to be that if you do decide on a melodeon, you may as well start with a D/G, as that's the one tuning that you wouldn't want to be without. Then when you've made a start on playing some tunes, you can experiment with it as an accompaniment for the voice (yours or another's) and see how it sounds - it's probably the case that the wetnes/dryness/brightness and general pitch of the sound of an individual box will suit some voices but not others. Try a range of songs and you'll soon see what I mean about the limitations of the keys. Then you can decide whether you want to choose a different model, or a different instrument. Or a second melodeon.
Yes this much is clear!
And
Really enjoyed your post, GPS! Thanks for that. Here's a young woman who has found a nice method of accompaniment:
http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw (http://youtu.be/eTVuJhNy0jw)
A lovely way to use what can be an overpowering instrument.
Earlier in the thread Andy and Tony were praised for their accompaniments, and very fine they are, but it's much easier to accompany someone other than yourself. Playing for self, for me anyway, tends to mix breathing with pushing and pulling. The few songs I do self accompany are bit like the above vid, very simple when I'm singing and more decoration in between. I agree with an earlier comment that guitars are usually better for accompanying folk songs.
I agree with the - the simple bass accompaniment plus embellishment between verses is lovely - I'd better get cracking!! Anyone want to sell me a D/G Erica?
Cheers, Simon
-
:||: Just in case anyone's following this, I am now the proud owner of a D/G Pokerwork, purchased from the Music Room in Clecky where Jon was really helpful. Now just got to keep going round that Mulberry bush.....yes I'm afraid that's the level at the moment.
Thanks for the help in making some sense of it all. (:)
-
Yay!
Congratulations and all the best!
-
Yay!
Congratulations and all the best!
;D Thanks - I'm loving it and feeling the dangerous desire for more melodeons growing within me. But maybe better get the hang of my lovely Hohner first.....
-
Good move! Shouldn't take too long to get it happening. I'd say you don't need to be that good - depends on where you're playing of course, and you get better if there are people listening on a regular basis.
I'm playing and singing Cajun, Irish, Scottish, American, and Reggae on a DG box. It is a compromise as it's no Cajun and the keys available for a Cajun feel are sometimes not ideal. Keeps the fiddlers happy though - terribly limited instrument the fiddle! I am using D, G, A and Em and I am starting to get C working.
The box is a 4th button start Hohner Preciosa with some useful accidentals. I don't really want to think of it as a compromise as that sounds just a wee bit negative. It is a lovely, powerful and very versatile instrument. Another great thing about these is that if I can get a CF and/or a GC one I'll still be carrying less than the two boxes I used to lug around. Then there are some who rave about BbEb of course.....
May I add my appreciation too, Graham, for the Poor Old Horse. Beautiful!
-
Good move! Shouldn't take too long to get it happening. I'd say you don't need to be that good - depends on where you're playing of course, and you get better if there are people listening on a regular basis.
I'm playing and singing Cajun, Irish, Scottish, American, and Reggae on a DG box. It is a compromise as it's no Cajun and the keys available for a Cajun feel are sometimes not ideal. Keeps the fiddlers happy though - terribly limited instrument the fiddle! I am using D, G, A and Em and I am starting to get C working.
The box is a 4th button start Hohner Preciosa with some useful accidentals. I don't really want to think of it as a compromise as that sounds just a wee bit negative. It is a lovely, powerful and very versatile instrument. Another great thing about these is that if I can get a CF and/or a GC one I'll still be carrying less than the two boxes I used to lug around. Then there are some who rave about BbEb of course.....
Encouraging words! It sounds great that you can play all those different styles on one DG box - is it because it has extra accidentals or the usual? I hope to try my hand(s) at cajun or zydeco style at some point, I just love the way it sounds.
Speaking of accidentals, I've accidentally bought a Hohner Club II in CF from ebay - I just put in what I thought was a stupidly low bid and I won it!! Now, having looked at various discussions on this site about the pros and cons of the Club layout I am thinking I might have been foolish, (especially since I only just got my first one!!) but never mind, the main thing is to get the hang of the Pokerwork and not worry about the other one for a while...
:-\
-
"Keeps the fiddlers happy though - terribly limited instrument the fiddle! I am using D, G, A and Em and I am starting to get C working."
Some of us can play more than three keys you know - it's only the same finger patterns moved up or down a bit, and unlike boxes, we can play micro (or out of tune as some people call it) and glissando. >:E
-
I think the main thing is that the tunes, riffs and right hand chords I'm doing while singing, or between verses or accompanying Joe if he's doing the singing, are mostly pretty simple. The Mariachi Melodeon sound when we do Ring of Fire seems to work and is not too hard to pull off live - Johnny Cash, there's simple but effective!
Fiddles are great. Hope nobody thought I had anything against fiddles and fiddlers. They have been known to moan about tuning down a tone so they can do all the two-strings at a time Cajun stuff properly in C and/or G. We've got two fiddlers now when they're both available and we wouldn't want to lose them.
-
Don't let them get idle. Work them hard and make them get their chops together. That'll stop them thinking only in 3 keys! :-*
-
Good move! Shouldn't take too long to get it happening. I'd say you don't need to be that good - depends on where you're playing of course, and you get better if there are people listening on a regular basis.
I'm playing and singing Cajun, Irish, Scottish, American, and Reggae on a DG box. It is a compromise as it's no Cajun and the keys available for a Cajun feel are sometimes not ideal. Keeps the fiddlers happy though - terribly limited instrument the fiddle! I am using D, G, A and Em and I am starting to get C working.
The box is a 4th button start Hohner Preciosa with some useful accidentals. I don't really want to think of it as a compromise as that sounds just a wee bit negative. It is a lovely, powerful and very versatile instrument. Another great thing about these is that if I can get a CF and/or a GC one I'll still be carrying less than the two boxes I used to lug around. Then there are some who rave about BbEb of course.....
Encouraging words! It sounds great that you can play all those different styles on one DG box - is it because it has extra accidentals or the usual? I hope to try my hand(s) at cajun or zydeco style at some point, I just love the way it sounds.
Speaking of accidentals, I've accidentally bought a Hohner Club II in CF from ebay - I just put in what I thought was a stupidly low bid and I won it!! Now, having looked at various discussions on this site about the pros and cons of the Club layout I am thinking I might have been foolish, (especially since I only just got my first one!!) but never mind, the main thing is to get the hang of the Pokerwork and not worry about the other one for a while...
This is what my last post was meant to look like, I seem to have bug****d it u in transmission :Ph
-
I'd suggest you mostly get the hang of the Pokerwork first, though if the Club's a good 'un it will have a better quality action. The Club system has advantages when playing in keys other than the fundamental tuning and using it occasionally will introduce you to ways of fingering a phrase which may prove useful on the standard quint-tuned box as well. If you don't get on with the Club, it is relatively cheap and simple to have it de-clubbed so that it plays the same as the Pokerwork and it then still offers you a new selection of keys. It is amazing how much more mellow a CF sounds when compared with a DG!
Rob.
-
I've accidentally bought a Hohner Club II in CF from ebay -
CF box is great for Gm and Dm both favourite keys for fiddle players.
-
Thanks re last two posts - I hadn't thought of having it de-clubbed, something to ponder. But yes for now I'll put it on a shelf (though the action is easier than the Pokerwork) and focus on learning the D/G.
I'm loving this forum by the way - very active, as you say Theo!