===Fourth-apart systems===
Fourth-apart systems are the most widespread form of multi-row instrument. Starting from the outside of the keyboard moving in, each row is pitched one-fourth lower than its neighbour.
Unisonoric instruments therefore require twice as many reeds as equivalent bisonoric instruments, making them larger and considerably heavier.
| Diatonic | The notes available from each row of buttons correspond to a 'major' scale (eg in 'C' this would be the white notes of a piano). Small variations, eg to play a harmonic rather than 'relative' minor are occasionally seen, and still regarded as 'diatonic' |
| Bisonoric | Notes controlled by a button are different on pull or push of the bellows. This contrasts with piano or CVA accordion which play same note both ways. Bisonority accounts for much of the 'punch' of the diatonic melodeon, stemming from its relative lightness, and rhythmic use of bellows in play. |
Thanks for the encouragement, corrections and ideas, everybody.
PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?
PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?
In Scotland the term "melodeon" can be applied to any 1- or 2-row button accordion with limited basses. A 1-row will almost always be referred to as a "melodeon", but a 2-row could equally well be called a "wee button accordion".
PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?
Forgot to add: I remembered that there is another technical term besides the hateful "bisonoric" to describe the push-pull effect. A box that produces two-notes per key has a "single-action" keyboard, while PAs and CBAs are "double-action."Oh... I find that definition confusing. :-\
o bisonoric comes from bison, meaning a large bovine of North America. Buffaloric would be just as good.
Indeed. Especially in London. Have you ever tried washing your hands in a buffalo?o bisonoric comes from bison, meaning a large bovine of North America. Buffaloric would be just as good.
Bison and Buffalo are very different things here in Britain ;)
In other words, 'diatonic' sort of means 'through the tones' - 'ditonic' or 'bitonic', if they existed as words, would mean 'two-tone'.Nah... 'two-tone' refers to colours, surely? You know - like when you send someone down to the stores for a tin of red and white striped paint. ;D
Ha! Mini-revelation (for me, you probably all know this already!):
'Dia' does not mean 'two', it's a Greek word meaning 'through'. In other words, 'diatonic' sort of means 'through the tones'.
'Ditonic' or 'bitonic', if they existed as words, would mean 'two-tone'.
As to bisonoric. Seems to me it should be avoided because I don't think anyone uses it outside the accordion world.
1. If you possibly feel able to, please, please, ditch the 'single action/double-action' keyboard thing. I find it extremely confusing and counter-intuitive. (But perhaps it's just me ....)
2. At present, there's no reference to the Club system with its Gleichton. Quite a few players in the UK do use it and in Germany I believe it is quite commonplace still. Historically it is important and there are still many instruments available, both second-hand and new.
Accidentals are sometimes placed on two or extra buttons, or a shorter third row of four or more buttons, close to the bellows. The “Club†system developed by Hohner in the 1950s is a well-established example of this approach. Using the accidentals, and with the added modification of a “Gleichton†(unisonoric second-octave tonic in the middle of the middle row), this system allows players to obtain a fully chromatic scale – albeit in one direction only (draw). For an in-depth discussion of the Club system, see (x-ref to http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/intro.html).
3. In your 'International terms' section, perhaps add the Dutch name 'Trekharmonica'. Also in Italy, the generic term for a diatonic button accordion is 'Fisarmonica diatonica'. The term 'Organetto' refers to the more specialised one row or one-and-a-half row instruments, where the half-row consists of 3 or 4 buttons (often slightly smaller diameter) which give reversals of some of the main row buttons.
• In Italy, a diatonic button accordion is generally a fisarmonic diatonica, while an organetto is a specific type of one-and-a-half-row instrument (discussed below).
• The Dutch term is trekharmonika.
PS The Wikipedia article on concertinas labels bisonoric/unisonoric as "American jargon!"
It looks OK apart from the date of the Club system development. I don't know exactly when this layout came into use, but it must have been before the 1950s; I have a Hohner Club III which dates from the 1930s.QuoteAccidentals are sometimes placed on two or extra buttons, or a shorter third row of four or more buttons, close to the bellows. The “Club†system developed by Hohner in the 1950s is a well-established example of this approach. Using the accidentals, and with the added modification of a “Gleichton†(unisonoric second-octave tonic in the middle of the middle row), this system allows players to obtain a fully chromatic scale – albeit in one direction only (draw). For an in-depth discussion of the Club system, see (x-ref to http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/intro.html).
Steve,
Unless I am reading it wrong there is a conflict in the second and third bullet points under the heading "Glossary"
"Glossary
The following definitions will assist understanding of this article.
DBA: abbreviation for diatonic button accordion
single-action or bisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes; see the section on Action below.
double-action or unisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes
reversal: on a single-action instrument, a button or key which produces a note available elsewhere on the keyboard, but obtained by using the opposite bellows direction
accidental: any note of the chromatic scale outside the diatonic scale(s) of a DBA’s “home†key(s)"
Whichever term may originally have been correct, both meanings now seem to be widely used across the free-reed family of instruments. I don't think "single/double action" should be ignored just because a particular subset of players (ie those who use melnet) favours the alternative. However it should be made clear which of the two meanings is meant.
In many of the references I've seen "single-action" is applied to instruments where the air flow to sound a note is only one way, and "double-action" where it flows both ways. This is how Neil Wayne, an authority on concertinas, uses the term. I've seen it applied not only to concertinas, but also to bandoneons, harmoniums (harmonia?) and other free-reed instruments.
However I've also seen "single-action" used to mean "push-pull", and I must admit that is how I'd always understood the term, which I've known for many years. I don't think I'd come across "bisonoric" until I started frequenting melnet.
Whichever term may originally have been correct, both meanings now seem to be widely used across the free-reed family of instruments. I don't think "single/double action" should be ignored just because a particular subset of players (ie those who use melnet) favours the alternative. However it should be made clear which of the two meanings is meant.
Can anyone give a source for the reference to the source of 'single-action' being used to mean 'push-pull'? It does seem at first sight a rather odd use of the words. I wonder whether it perhaps describes a mechanism, rather than a type of button accordion.
The single-action diatonic accordion is a child of nineteenth-century capitalism and Western tonality. As such, it was a product of the expanding capitalism and modernization which transformed traditional societies and brought the ascendance of new economic and class relations and massively increased material production. Accordions transformed the musical world of many groups, creating new relations between musicians and audiences, displacing other instruments, and becoming the sound of the new metropolis (Giannatassio 1979, Pella 1985).
The diatonic accordion has a rectangular bellows which links two wooden ends, in each of which are set metal free reeds which can be sounded via valves opened by buttons. As a European-style free reed will only speak when air passes through it in a particular direction, different sets of reeds are required to sound on the press and draw of the bellows. In single-action instruments, these reeds are tuned to different pitches, and so in general each pitch requires a unique combination of button and bellows movement. Double-action instruments, such as the familiar piano accordion and various "continental style" button accordions, have equally-tuned reed pairs so that bellows direction has no influence on the pitch produced.
There are a number of single-action free reed instruments, and these generally preserve the system of arrangement of pitches presented on the "Akkordion" patented by the Austrian instrument maker Cyril Demian in 1829. On present-day single-action accordions, the right-hand end of the instrument has one or more rows of ten or eleven buttons, which produce two and a half octaves of a single major scale, arrayed on the press and draw of the bellows like the pitches in a mouth organ. A row is thus said to be in a particular key, and multi-row accordions may be referred to as B/C, D/ D#, and so on, according to the tuning of the rows. In the single-action system a wide range of pitches can be spanned in any hand position, and diatonic melodies are easily played on a single row, as the ear quickly becomes attuned to the distinction between the press and draw pitches. The left-hand end of the instrument can be either single action or double action. The ten-key melodeon has two single-action bass buttons which play the root and triad of the tonic on the press, and on the draw play those of the dominant. Larger instruments may have a slightly expanded repertoire of chords similarly arranged to coincide with the harmonies which might be demanded by notes chosen from the right-hand end. More sophisticated instruments have a double action left-hand end, with a full chromatic range of chords and roots laid out according to the pattern used in piano accordions.
ETHNOMUSICOLOGY, VOL. 41, NO. 3, FALL 1997
This terminological question seems set to remain contentious. I would like to get to the bottom of it, so keep the opinions coming.
Provide a glossary?
each button had either one spring ('single action'), so that you could play a note on the push only, or two springs, so that you could play the sound push or pull ('double action'). (I don't really understand that, but did those buttons have two positions, one for push, one for pull?)
Wheatstone's early concertinas were all "English", were they not? So on his double-action models, one button would sound the same note in both directions of the bellows.
I don't think this is really to do with a particular groups of players - it's just a question of trying to promote commonsense through the widest (as far as I'm aware) forum there is in this field.
I don't think this is really to do with a particular groups of players - it's just a question of trying to promote commonsense through the widest (as far as I'm aware) forum there is in this field.
I intend no disrespect to melnet or its esteemed members. You may well be correct to say it's the widest forum in this field. However I think it could be dangerous to assume that we are representative of anglophone melodeon players, or even of those in the UK. I suspect the players who are not members far outnumber those who are.
To me at least the term "bisonoric" is fairly new, and one I only came across several decades after I heard the term "single action". I don't claim to be an expert, and I don't particularly favour one usage over the other. However the single/double action usage, in both its meanings, is well established across the family of free-reed instruments. It seems to me that a comprehensive article should at least recognise the term rather than ignore it.
3) The more recent usage doesn't seem to have an accepted or properly established origin - we have yet to find a reliable historical source for it;
5) Is the newer usage actually used all that widely anyway?
3) Well, keep looking if you have the courage to do so... and please report back.
I've just found a copy of this earlier 1844 Wheatstone patent, again through the excellent concertina.net website (the third page is the relevant one):
http://www.concertina.com/wheatstone/Wheatstone-Concertina-Patent-No-10041-of-1844.pdf
OK - it's safe to go back to melodeons now ;)
Warning - thread drift but just for a quick aside comment for English Concertina players...I've just found a copy of this earlier 1844 Wheatstone patent, again through the excellent concertina.net website (the third page is the relevant one):
http://www.concertina.com/wheatstone/Wheatstone-Concertina-Patent-No-10041-of-1844.pdf
Thanks, Chris!
Very interesting read - for example the bit about CW's method for tuning reeds on the fly, with an adjustable slider. I don't think it was particularly successful, as it never caught on.
However, one especially interesting snippet occurs on page 3, line 15, where CW states that the finger rest on an English concertina is intended to accommodate both 4rd and 3rd fingers (ring and little). This makes a lot of sense when one considers the shape and dimensions of the EC finger rest. Most players these days use only their little finger on the rest, which for some of us can be quite painful after a while, especially with a heavier concertina such as an Aeola.
Just an observation...
OK - it's safe to go back to melodeons now ;)
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.
Absolutely; philologically sound and completely unambiguous. I simply can't see the logic of a "single action" producing two notes while a "double action" produces only one............
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.
Absolutely; philologically sound and completely unambiguous. I simply can't see the logic of a "single action" producing two notes while a "double action" produces only one............
Probably needs someone to write a note to go with the Wikipedia article explaining the singe/double action and bi/unisonoric terminology complete with the history of both. Then readers can make up their own minds which to use.
Besides which, I'm not sure Mr Assange allows the word 'crap' on his website.you got the wrong guy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiLeaks) there.
It seems that single-action is not the only matter we need to substantiate, clarify or refute. The article has just been marked up by a bot of some kind which has specified a couple of dozen "citations needed."I've removed the obvious overzealous 'citation needed' markups (not touched the SA/DA ones though!) but whether they will reappear or not remains to be seen. I believe there is a way of disabling certain Bot tasks, probably including the one which adds these 'citation needed' tags, but I haven't worked out how to do it yet; I'm not sure I understand all the nomenclature/vocabulary well enough.
Chris, what you makes you so sure that "single action" with reference to accordions is all the fault of the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica? Does the article even use the term? How do you know it wasn't in use 50 years before that? How do you know that people started using "single action" on the authority of the article you quote (esp. if it doesn't mention the term)?
To demonstrate that you are not adding OR, you must be able to cite reliable, published sources that are directly related to the topic of the article, and directly support the material as presented.
How would a bot know where to put the citation needed tags? ??? :D
Similarly the only evidence I have for "bisonoric/unisonoric" is this forum and the existing Wikipedia article. I'll do some more searching on those terms too. In the meantime, do you have any evidence of their wider use? Who first promulgated them, and when?
Similarly the only evidence I have for "bisonoric/unisonoric" is this forum and the existing Wikipedia article. I'll do some more searching on those terms too. In the meantime, do you have any evidence of their wider use? Who first promulgated them, and when?
Further thought. Logically a single action box would be something like a contra-bass concertina which only sounds on the push, ie under pressure.
Steve
Further thought. Logically a single action box would be something like a contra-bass concertina which only sounds on the push, ie under pressure.
Steve
That point has been discussed earlier in this thread.
I've added to the list of Scottish players:It's GRAHAM Irvine (but Graeme Mackay).
Will Starr, Fergie MacDonald, Graeme Irvine
I've added to the list of Scottish players:It's GRAHAM Irvine (but Graeme Mackay).
Will Starr, Fergie MacDonald, Graeme Irvine
Here's an authority for single/double action: an ICA article quoting George Grove’s Article on the 'Concertina' in the first edition of 'A Dictionary of Music and Musicians' (1878)
http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878 (http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878)
Uni/bisonoric appears quite widely in internet searches, but I'm not sure if the sites carry sufficient authority to be cited. For what it's worth, here's a link to Webster's Online Dictionary, again about concertinas:
http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina (http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina)
Scroll down to the extended definition. This seems to use "sonoricity" to describe the different notes provided by the keys, and "action" to refer to whether sound is produced in one or both directions of the bellows . A subtle distinction.
Update: have provided at least some kind of reference for almost all the [citations needed] tags - most of which popped up again despite Steve FR's taking an axe to them. The three that remain all concern - you guessed it, single/double action and bisonoric.
I am ruminating on the wording for a concise note on the ambiguity and controversy, with references, such as Wheatstone & Grove for the action business (thank you sleuths) and others (not sure which would be best) for bison/unison-oric. My hope being that this will acknowledge the different interpretations yet still give place to both the old-established-but-confusing and the newer-but-inelegant terminologies. Happiness of everyone is too much to aim for; perhaps I can achieve the grudging consent of most. :|glug
Thanks to Theo for populating the lists of foreign exponents.
All those in favour say 'aye'.
think the high jacking of this thread and attempt at rail roading your viewpoint is most improper and uncomfortable
think the high jacking of this thread and attempt at rail roading your viewpoint is most improper and uncomfortableWhoah! I don't think attempting to summarise what has gone before and putting a proposition to help clarify things counts as hi-jacking and railroading, and I'd like to know why it is improper.
First of all, I should like to pass on my thanks and congratulations to Steve Jones for setting the whole Wikipedia entry for diatonic button accordions into motion. It's a good and valuable piece of work.I think the sudden appearence of a new thread and title in the middle of Steves is at least rude and certainly provocative surely the appropriate action would have been to start a new thread and as I said here
However, the single action/double action (SA/DA) section remains unsatisfactory. Over the last week or so I think we've aired the SA/DA debate quite extensively now. The following points made in earlier posts are becoming quite clear:
1. The SA/DA definition is confused. Whether through error or changing usage over time, SA/DA has meant different things at different times by different authors.
2. To many melodeon players (aka diatonic button accordion players) used to the push-pull nature of the instrument, the definition of SA/DA promoted by Steve Jones in the Wikipedia article is completely counter-intuitive.
3. 'Single action' means something quite specialised in terms of bass concertinas and the like, where notes are produced in one bellows direction only (the other direction is silent).
4. As Theo has pointed out a couple of times, the companion Wikipedia entry for 'Accordion' contains no reference to SA/DA at all.
5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities.
In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:
All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.
Removal of the SA/DA terms simplifies and clarifies the Wikipedia entry and in no way implies any criticism of Steve Jones who has done a great job in compiling the page.
All those in favour say 'aye'.
Its not all about consensus anyways Steve, wasn't long ago that some would have had us believe a majority view was being held regarding what to call the sound board on a box, but when it came down to it we were only hearing a few persistant voices out of nearly a couple of thousand available on this site alone. So stand up that man (that's you Steve) and take a bow for what your doing, I note you've continuously been open to the relative descriptions and I think (for whatever that's worth) it's important not to discount what is obviously a term in use.All the Best morythis we vote so that decides it is twadle AtB mory
Incidentally on this thread so far you have posted 23 times Chris Brimley 28 times with 24 people in total posting with support for both terms with a total of 119 replies and 1732 views, which I believe supports my point above
It's not up to people to decide here. That's not how Wikipedia works.There's no reason why discussion shouldn't take place on the Wikipedia talk page, although you do have to register first to be able to contribute.
These discussions ought to be on the talk page of the article.
I think the sudden appearence of a new thread and title in the middle of Steves is at least rude and certainly provocativePlease calm down. It's the same thread, not a new one. Anyone can amend the title of their post within an existing thread to highlight something specific, which was my only reason for doing so. I've no intention of being rude or provocative.
I am glad, I apologise if I have misconstrued your actions. moryI think the sudden appearance of a new thread and title in the middle of Steve's is at least rude and certainly provocativePlease calm down. It's the same thread, not a new one. Anyone can amend the title of their post within an existing thread to highlight something specific, which was my only reason for doing so. I've no intention of being rude or provocative.
Qoute from Steve Free reeder "All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained" All those in favour?? what about those that already use those terms that you are in favour of removing completly? this really doesn't feel comfortable Steve F and I have good reason to feel that way which I won't air here moryIt's a proposal - no more, no less. People can agree with it, or not, as they wish, as Chris Brimley has already said:
Aye. It's probably best, all in all. Well done both Steves.
And if there are masses of dissenters out there, do say so now, so that everybody knows your views.
Qoute from Steve Free reeder "All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained" All those in favour?? what about those that already use those terms that you are in favour of removing completly? this really doesn't feel comfortable Steve F and I have good reason to feel that way which I won't air here mory
FFS, it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip, people! ::)But its not Ollie, its about one view being imposed over another, something quite different, to even suggest that the terms in question should be removed in deference to the other terms demands a way of thinking that is questionable in the context of equality of human beings to each other so, FFS it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip people! doesn't really encapsulate the reality, if only it were as simple as you indicate. All the Best mory
FFS, it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip, people! ::)But its not Ollie, its about one view being imposed over another, something quite different, to even suggest that the terms in question should be removed in deferance to the other terms demands a way of thinking that is questionable in the context of equality of human beings to each other so, FFS it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip people! doesn't really encapsulate the reality, if only it were as simple as you indicate. All the Best mory
5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities.
In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:
All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.
All those in favour say 'aye'.
5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities.
In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:
All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.
All those in favour say 'aye'.
I say "No".
Whilst I agree that the terms SA/DA may be counter-intuitive, and moreover their precise meaning has become confused and perhaps corrupted over time, these terms are also widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities. I'm not trying to argue that they should be preferred over Bisonoric/unisonoric. However the terms SA/DA are by no means redundant, and in my opinion a comprehensive article should not ignore them.
The problem is that there appears to be an error in one of the sources which makes the relationship between a nonsense.... a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!
Now I also know that Wikipedia in it's efforts to clean up it's act is demanding on-line sources.
Now I also know that Wikipedia in it's efforts to clean up it's act is demanding on-line sources.
Sorry, that's not true. I wish that people would read the Wikipedia help pages rather than rely on hearsay and guesswork. It's all there.
The problem is that there appears to be an error in one of the sources which makes the relationship between a nonsense.
As I understand it (without use of sources) the term SA/DA refers to the bellows movement whereas the the Uni/Bisonoric refers to the sound that the key makes.
So - Single action - one movement of the bellows (usually push) creates the pressure to sound a reed (harmonium, shruti box, bass concertina, sheng (OK it's blown)) and by definition one note is produced by the key so unisonoric ie one sound/note.
Double action- pressure is produced by the bellows being either pushed or pulled. The key however may produce one note when depressed (PA, English/Duet concertina) and is unisonoric or may produce a different note (Anglo, diatonic accordion, mouth organ (yes I know it's blown)) and as such is bisonoric.
Now I know that there are sources that say different, a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!
Steve
a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!
There is a great deal of confusion in English, but not German, about the following terms which I have used as indicated: single-action (the German is wechseltönig or literally, “changing-tonedâ€) – different note on the push and draw, such as most Anglos nowadays. I have not used this term to mean the very early instruments that sounded in only one direction. Double-action (German gleichtönig literally, same-toned) – sounding the same note on the push and the draw, such as most English concertinas nowadays.
Well, having burst out with the above outburst - apologies for dumping on you all - back to the search for references:
Ongoing terminology citation research department:
Paul Groff has suggested that old issues of Concertina & Squeezebox magazine might yield some references. I haven’t found the article by Hugh Blake that he mentioned . . .
Well, having burst out with the above outburst - apologies for dumping on you all - back to the search for references:
Ongoing terminology citation research department:
Paul Groff has suggested that old issues of Concertina & Squeezebox magazine might yield some references. I haven’t found the article by Hugh Blake that he mentioned . . .
Hi Steve,
My apologies if I sent you and others on a wild goose chase. I have a memory of seeing the bisonoric / unisonoric terms somewhere for the first time in the late 1980s or early 1990s, and thought it might be in Blake's "Diatonian" article.