Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Stiamh on January 26, 2012, 09:21:00 PM

Title: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 26, 2012, 09:21:00 PM
For years now I have thought that the Wikipedia article on our type of squeezebox (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_button_accordion) desperately needed rewriting.

In my opinion, its main faults are that it is very sketchy, some of the writing is substandard, and above all the content is highly geared towards what goes on in England. (Nothing wrong with what goes on in England, but the balance of coverage should reflect the rest of the DBA world a bit more strongly.)

I've shied away from tackling the job until now, but for whatever reason I started on it today. I'm now at the point where I need help. I think it would be better to get feedback from all the knowledgeable people here before replacing the current article with my ideas.

So could you have a look at the attached document and give me your opinions, suggestions, comments etc. I am sure there are sections I have not thought of.

Bear in mind my idea is to be as informative as possible, while striking a neutral tone as befits an encyclop(a)edia. The article should be geared to people who know nothing about the subject rather than aficionados, in my view. For that reason we should not, I think, go into excessive detail regarding e.g. styles of play, why BCC# is so very logical,  ;) and other arcane matters that we love to squabble about on here, etc.

Anyway, over to you. Thanks in advance for any comments, criticisms, rewrites, demolition jobs... go for it. That's what Wikipedia is about. Oh, and volunteers to tackle the missing sections would be very welcome.

Cheers
Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 27, 2012, 02:07:51 AM
Steve - you've done a very fine job there. Well done! Hopefully someone will help you with the missing bits (I don't feel sufficiently confident of my own knowledge to help personally). The only other thing I would suggest is a link to the melodeon.net home page: (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php.)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 27, 2012, 08:37:27 AM
Steve, that is a great service you are doing for us.

**Here seems to be a typo:

Quote
===Fourth-apart systems===
Fourth-apart systems are the most widespread form of multi-row instrument. Starting from the outside of the keyboard moving in, each row is pitched one-fourth lower than its neighbour.

should read "each row is pitched one-fourth lower higher than its neighbour

**Not sure if "In England, since the 1950s, the D/G configuration has become the standard "  it may have been a little later.  

**Semitone systems:   could add a mention for D/D# which is a less common system used in Ireland

**
Quote
Unisonoric instruments therefore require twice as many reeds as equivalent bisonoric instruments, making them larger and considerably heavier.

could be extended/qualified to:

"Unisonoric instruments therefore require twice as many reeds as equivalent bisonoric instruments, making them larger and considerably heavier, though the difference is progressively less as more diatonic rows are added because of the duplication of notes between rows."

**Alpine/Steirische should have a mention, but I see they have their own Wikipedia page, so a link should be sufficient
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 27, 2012, 08:55:43 AM
Agree- some of the Meldodiaspora deserve their own pages and a link.  Its pretty hard to improve on, doesn't really need to be longer, and even links to this site  :D
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 27, 2012, 12:12:33 PM
Steve, that's a superb piece you've written!  I have a few suggestions to for your consideration, but they are more questions or issues that occurred to me when reading it, rather than opinions - I'd be quite happy if you rejected them all!:

1.  Is the use of the word 'diatonic' appropriate, when it encompasses so many hundreds of different keyboard layouts?  There have been lots of arguments about this as you know, and I think it sort of ended up with this position:  It's a convenient concept;  accepted that only one row BA's are truly diatonic, but each row of a multi-row box is sometimes diatonic.    However, there are various snags with this position such as:  a) almost everyone on a multi-row box uses cross-rowing to some extent to get the odd note that's non-diatonic, and many players these days are going towards larger boxes and use lots of non-diatonic notes (even to the extent that the original concept is pretty much superseded);  b) accidental rows are not usually diatonic;  c) it's not true of the bass end in a multi-row;  d) it's not true of the end 'accidental' notes in many boxes;  e)  it's a much-misunderstood term, and so many people think it means 'bisonoric' that arguably that has become a new shade of meaning, through usage.   I accept that there may not be many other useful ways to describe the essential concept, and I have argued in the past that it's become so convoluted a concept that it's really not much use.  But it seems to me that the nub of the distinction, if we do want to make one at all, lies in the concepts of either fourth or semitone gaps between the 'main' rows.  Many players nowadays with larger boxes are freely playing chromatic notes on a system which originally started life as a fourth apart layout, and it could reasonably be said that the sense in which the instrument is 'diatonic' has become more and more esoteric.   I have no fixed ideas of where this all leads, but I think the general message is that definitions have become globally confused, and one term may not be recognised by everybody.

2.  Do you want to include something about the French term 'diato'?  And perhaps the German 'Handharmonika'?

3.  In para. 1, do you think you should say 'major (or sometimes minor) triad.'?  And I don't know, but aren't there thirdless-bass boxes made?

4.  In the terminology para, you use the terms 'Britain' and 'Ireland'.  What's the usage in Northern Ireland, do we know?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 27, 2012, 01:24:16 PM
Yes, much confusion.  The article should have a brief glossary area

  Diatonic   The notes available from each row of buttons correspond to a 'major' scale (eg in 'C' this would be the white notes of a piano).  Small variations, eg to play a harmonic rather than 'relative' minor are occasionally seen, and still regarded as 'diatonic'
  Bisonoric  Notes controlled by a button are different on pull or push of the bellows. This contrasts with piano or CVA accordion which play same note both ways. Bisonority accounts for much of the 'punch' of the diatonic melodeon, stemming from its relative lightness, and rhythmic use of bellows in play.

.. or  something similar.  Anything else? C

Theo/Clive: What's happened to table layout? The words in column 1 are vertical centering to mid box on this kit -MSIE 7. Didn't used to!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 27, 2012, 01:42:50 PM
Thanks for the encouragement, corrections and ideas, everybody.

@Steve FR: I'm quite sure you know at least as much about this subject as I do and can write at least as well too. But since you posted at 2am was it your time, your passing up the opportunity to dive in is quite understandable.  :|glug

@Theo, I actually meant one-fourth lower - that is, before moving on to the next row inwards. Will reword to remove the ambiguity - I think your idea of moving in is better. Thanks. Your other comments duly noted.

@Chris Brimely: you are right to point up the grey area of the "diatonicity" of many of the instruments in use today. But I don't think a different title for the article is in order: can you imagine anyone searching for "bisonoric button accordion"? I can't anyway. I think the best way of dealing with this is in a paragraph, or a section with a heading, dealing with modern developments and highlighting the grey terminological area. Of course, if we were writing for a purely English audience, the article could be titled "melodeon" - but we aren't, and shouldn't be IMO.

I'm glad you thought of the German and French terms, too and in fact I had thought of that after posting the draft. Could add Italian, and other languages, with links to the relevant Wikipedia articles.

I had also written a sentence about the common misconception of taking diatonic to mean bisonoric, but deleted it because it ended up sounding very convoluted and silly. Might try again.

@Chris R: will consider changing "Terminology" to "Glossary" and adding items, thank you.

You'll all get a chance to edit the article after it has been posted, don't forget. I have other stuff to get finished today and will probably return to the draft hopefully with a clear head over the weekend. In the meantime, keep the comments and suggestions coming.

PS One idea I had this morning was to have separate sections, or even separate articles, on the history of the DBA's use in the various genres and traditions. I'd like to write such a section on the Irish tradition, for example, and some of you lads and lasses could do a good job on England, Scotland, France, etc. etc. Separate articles might almost be better, since otherwise the entry on what is really a rather simple and humble instrument could get excessively long and complex - like all those unjustifiably long mega-entries on rock stars of dubious importance in the grand scheme of things. :)

PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 27, 2012, 01:51:09 PM
Would these be the Mclodeons of Tanockbrae, or the Mclodeons of Fife that yourself is talking about? ;)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: baz parkes on January 27, 2012, 02:24:27 PM
Thanks for the encouragement, corrections and ideas, everybody.


PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?


The first 4 stop I ever saw was in a music shop in Edinburgh when I was on holiday in 1971...they told me it was a melodeon....

A true labour of love Steve  :-*well done 

Baz
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Ray Langton on January 27, 2012, 04:03:26 PM
Brilliant article-well done
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrel on January 27, 2012, 05:36:00 PM
Steve, In France a mélodéon is a one-row box as well.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pbsalt on January 27, 2012, 09:35:35 PM
PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?


Stuart Eydmann's article "As Common as Blackberries : the First Hundred Years of the Accordion in Scotland ,1830 - 1930 " in the EFDSS Folk Music Journal Vo l7, No 5 1999 has quotes to suggests that the instruments were also known as melodeons in Scotland. My favourite quote from the  article  was one  from someone writing of Dundee in the late 19th century that "Concertinas and melodeons were as common as blackberries and the twilight hours are filled with their melody poured forth by the enamoured youths at the stair foot of his senorita's seven-floor tenement" - which might suggest that  melodeons wouldn't have been universally popular amongst those having their rest  disturbed by such activities.  
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 27, 2012, 10:48:13 PM
Thanks everyone. I'll venture to lump Scotland in with England regarding the use of "melodeon" - unless Bill or someone else howls in protest. Might as well include Wales too. Haven't a clue about Norn Ireland - I'll ask user Ptarmigan.

I'll have a new draft to run by you all again, in a more readable format, by Monday noon I hope.

Cheers
S

Forgot to add: I remembered that there is another technical term besides the hateful "bisonoric" to describe the push-pull effect. A box that produces two-notes per key has a "single-action" keyboard, while PAs and CBAs are "double-action."

unisonoric - comes from unison, meaning sounding as one.
ergo bisonoric comes from bison, meaning a large bovine of North America. Buffaloric would be just as good.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Bill Young on January 27, 2012, 11:16:57 PM

PPS What does the term "melodeon" mean in Scotland?

In Scotland the term "melodeon" can be applied to any 1- or 2-row button accordion with limited basses. A 1-row will almost always be referred to as a "melodeon", but a 2-row could equally well be called a "wee button accordion".
The Royal National Mod has separate competitions for accordion and melodeon; the latter class allows 2-row instruments. The last melodeon competition I witnessed was won by a young lad playing a 2-row Hohner Gaelic IV with 8 basses.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 28, 2012, 12:17:13 AM
Forgot to add: I remembered that there is another technical term besides the hateful "bisonoric" to describe the push-pull effect. A box that produces two-notes per key has a "single-action" keyboard, while PAs and CBAs are "double-action."
Oh... I find that definition confusing.  :-\
Seeing the words "single-action" keyboard rather gives the impression that a single note is produced by each button regardless of bellows direction (i.e. equating 'single' here with the 'uni' prefix), and similarly "double-action" could imply that two different notes are produced by each button.

I would prefer to see the terms unisonoric and bisonoric retained, because (a) they are already in reasonably common use, and (b) the prefixes 'uni' and 'bi' are pretty much self-explanatory.

I'm sorry you don't like the word 'bisonoric' with it's unwanted connotation of large American plains animals, but that had never occurred to me  ;) .  If it's any help, perhaps consider hyphenating the words: uni-sonoric and bi-sonoric. I agree they are not the most elegant of words, whether hyphenated or not, but I think they're the best compromise so far.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 28, 2012, 04:07:05 AM
o bisonoric comes from bison, meaning a large bovine of North America. Buffaloric would be just as good.

Bison and Buffalo are very different things here in Britain  ;)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 28, 2012, 07:47:47 AM
o bisonoric comes from bison, meaning a large bovine of North America. Buffaloric would be just as good.

Bison and Buffalo are very different things here in Britain  ;)
Indeed. Especially in London. Have you ever tried washing your hands in a buffalo?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 28, 2012, 10:17:20 AM
'Two-tone'?

'Bi-tonic'?

'Di-tonic'?

'Duotonic'?

'Gin mixer'?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 28, 2012, 10:27:52 AM
Shhhhhhh .....  (:)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 28, 2012, 10:40:47 AM
Ha!  Mini-revelation (for me, you probably all know this already!):

'Dia' does not mean 'two', it's a Greek word meaning 'through'.  In other words, 'diatonic' sort of means 'through the tones'.

'Ditonic' or 'bitonic', if they existed as words, would mean 'two-tone'.

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 28, 2012, 10:44:56 AM
In other words, 'diatonic' sort of means 'through the tones' - 'ditonic' or 'bitonic', if they existed as words, would mean 'two-tone'.
Nah... 'two-tone' refers to colours, surely? You know - like when you send someone down to the stores for a tin of red and white striped paint. ;D
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 28, 2012, 10:47:14 AM
I know, Steve, I was thinking of those fancy boxes Flaco plays!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Martin J on January 28, 2012, 11:34:29 AM
An excellent article Steve.  Terminology seems to be the most disputed item.  Through following ebay I have found terms such a Knobf Akkordeon, Accordion Diatonic etc.  Perhaps a general appeal to all mel-neters of every nation could give a lexicon of international terms.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2012, 12:01:06 PM
Ha!  Mini-revelation (for me, you probably all know this already!):

'Dia' does not mean 'two', it's a Greek word meaning 'through'.  In other words, 'diatonic' sort of means 'through the tones'.

'Ditonic' or 'bitonic', if they existed as words, would mean 'two-tone'.



The world of diatonic accordions already has so many words used in inconsistent ways, :o we really don't need any more. ;D  pleeeeease! :'(
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 28, 2012, 05:08:58 PM
So how should it be avoided, Theo?  That's the tricky one!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2012, 05:49:26 PM
I don't think we can avoid the confusing and inconsistent terminology that we are lumbered with.  Language is such a dynamic thing, even if we came up with a well thought out and logical box taxonomy there is no way we could make it a standard that everyone uses.   And if it doesn't become a near universal standard then it just makes things worse! 

I'm reminded of the quote about the interview with a senior IT industry figure being asked why they don't have a standard system so that different types of kit are compatible. The reply was "We love Standards… …that’s why we have so many of them."
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on January 28, 2012, 05:57:51 PM
Steve,
I'm so glad that you are working on this! Great project.
-Andy
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 28, 2012, 07:14:41 PM
OK, I'm going to withdraw any suggestion that 'diatonic' is an unfortunate word to use.

(My original concern was based on the idea that if you have lots of accidentals, which seems to be a future direction in the box world, it's just a partial concept of button layout, rather than a future-proof defining characteristic of the instrument itself, so I see 'along-the-row diatonic' layouts as just some among very many button layouts for button accordions.  However 'diatonists' in general do seem to have a strong sense of their separate culture, so let it be.)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: nfldbox on January 28, 2012, 08:22:01 PM
As to bisonoric. Seems to me it should be avoided because I don't think anyone uses it outside the accordion world.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 29, 2012, 10:46:48 AM
As to bisonoric. Seems to me it should be avoided because I don't think anyone uses it outside the accordion world.

Except that there is no unambiguous synonym, AFAIK.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 29, 2012, 01:38:21 PM
Second draft, in Google docs this time. I've tried to take into account most of your comments and have added some other stuff. A few sections remain to be completed. Volunteers still welcome!

Thanks for all your help so far and keep it coming. I'm not looking for pats on the back - plenty of those above , grazie tanto - but suggestions for improvements -- including minor edits, typos, and nit-picky points of detail as well as structural considerations.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1iSSwTdi6C0gBEI0AJKoSCdP3SBZRGVFKg4qikf2OoU4/edit

I don't know if you'll be able to edit or comment on the document in Google docs - I tried to specify not, because I don't want to work in Google docs. I'd prefer to read your feedback and comments here.

Note: bits between asterisks are notes to the reader and not part of the article.

Cheers
S
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 29, 2012, 02:12:48 PM
Steve - it's looking good!

Three comments:
1. If you possibly feel able to, please, please, ditch the 'single action/double-action' keyboard thing. I find it extremely confusing and counter-intuitive. (But perhaps it's just me ....)

2. At present, there's no reference to the Club system with its Gleichton. Quite a few players in the UK do use it and in Germany I believe it is quite commonplace still. Historically it is important and there are still many instruments available, both second-hand and new.

3. In your 'International terms' section, perhaps add the Dutch name 'Trekharmonica'. Also in Italy, the generic term for a diatonic button accordion is 'Fisarmonica diatonica'. The term 'Organetto' refers to the more specialised one row or one-and-a-half row instruments, where the half-row consists of 3 or 4 buttons (often slightly smaller diameter) which give reversals of some of the main row buttons.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Lester on January 29, 2012, 02:21:13 PM
1. If you possibly feel able to, please, please, ditch the 'single action/double-action' keyboard thing. I find it extremely confusing and counter-intuitive. (But perhaps it's just me ....)

100% agree with Steve especially as, from reading his comment, I guessed thd single action would be "same note both ways" and double action "different notes" but found your interpretation was the other way round ???
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 29, 2012, 03:22:46 PM
Thanks, Steve. Regarding bisonoric etc., I think it is important to use established terminology rather than, or at least as well as, jargon used within a small coterie such as the melodeon/DBA world - as Terry pointed out earlier.

Not "my" interpretation. I took "single-action" and "double-action" from a paper written by Australian ethnomusicologist Graeme Smith. I confess I don't know how widely used these terms are by musicologists or instrument specialists. Will research books and the web a little later.

Similarly the only evidence I have for "bisonoric/unisonoric" is this forum and the existing Wikipedia article. I'll do some more searching on those terms too. In the meantime, do you have any evidence of their wider use? Who first promulgated them, and when?

Cheers
S
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pgroff on January 29, 2012, 03:54:15 PM
Hi Steve and all,

I remember seeing the "single action" and "double action" terms in the article on free-reeds in this book from 1966:

http://www.classicbooksandephemera.com/shop/classic/001728.html

Unfortunately, my copy (like most of the books I have left) is in storage at the moment so I can't give you the author and title of that chapter.  From memory, that article had a good few errors, lapses, and ommissions, but was still very interesting.

Stephen Chambers and Wim Wakker would definitely be two of many contributors to the current internet forums who have very well-informed and interesting perspectives on these subjects.

PG
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 29, 2012, 05:49:18 PM
Thanks Paul. I was thinking of contacting Steve Chambers about a number of points: maybe I'll ask him to vet the article just before going to press as it were.

Googling "single action accordion" (with the quotes, to avoid returning pages that happen to have these three words on them) returns 13,700 results. "bisonoric accordion" (without quotes) returns 12,500 (with quotes, under 1000). It is interesting to note that the first result returned for "single-action accordion" is from Encyclopaedia Britannica.

Clearly, then, "single-action" is an established term and one which, judging from the types of article returned by each search, is used by people outside our little world. For that reason, I propose to continue using it. I have given "bisonoric," despite my lack of enthusiasm for the term, almost equal billing in the article in an attempt to cover all bases.

Those of you who can't get your head around single-action = bisonoric (one = two) might try looking at it another way. Bisonoric focuses on sound, single-action focuses on, well, action. One action = one note. Whereas on a "unisonoric" box, two different actions produce one note. Double-action = two reeds per note. Hope this helps.   
:|glug

Now back to the drafting.
Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 29, 2012, 06:12:48 PM
2. At present, there's no reference to the Club system with its Gleichton. Quite a few players in the UK do use it and in Germany I believe it is quite commonplace still. Historically it is important and there are still many instruments available, both second-hand and new.

How does this addition to an existing paragraph strike you?

Quote
Accidentals are sometimes placed on two or extra buttons, or a shorter third row of four or more buttons, close to the bellows. The “Club” system developed by Hohner in the 1950s is a well-established example of this approach. Using the accidentals, and with the added modification of a “Gleichton” (unisonoric second-octave tonic in the middle of the middle row), this system allows players to obtain a fully chromatic scale – albeit in one direction only (draw). For an in-depth discussion of the Club system, see (x-ref to http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/intro.html).

3. In your 'International terms' section, perhaps add the Dutch name 'Trekharmonica'. Also in Italy, the generic term for a diatonic button accordion is 'Fisarmonica diatonica'. The term 'Organetto' refers to the more specialised one row or one-and-a-half row instruments, where the half-row consists of 3 or 4 buttons (often slightly smaller diameter) which give reversals of some of the main row buttons.

Done. Incidentally it's trekharmonika (no capital necessary, and with a k).

Quote
•   In Italy, a diatonic button accordion is generally a fisarmonic diatonica, while an organetto is a specific type of one-and-a-half-row instrument (discussed below).
•   The Dutch term is trekharmonika.

I'm sure this list could get quite long.

PS The Wikipedia article on concertinas labels bisonoric/unisonoric as "American jargon!"
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on January 29, 2012, 06:54:52 PM
Hi Steve good on you for taking on the task, I'd always understood the terms single action and double action with melnet being the only place I'd found the other terms in use frequently the thing I really wanted to mention though was the other week Wiki was off air and a discussion (I think on BBC Radio 2) started about inaccuracies, anyway it ended with the guy from Wiki P coming on and stating that they only keep stuff on if it verifies with info they find on line and nowhere else, IE if there is info say from the British archives but it cant be verified on line they scrap it There was a guy on who has written several books accepted by the scientific community using archive material that Wiki have taken off because they cant confirm the info on line, which is a real travesty and contributes to the dumbing down of the info out there. don't know if its relevent Steve but thought it worth a mention. All the Best mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pgroff on January 29, 2012, 07:19:42 PM

PS The Wikipedia article on concertinas labels bisonoric/unisonoric as "American jargon!"

Hi Steve,

Again I plead unavailability of my library to check . . . but the first time I remember reading those terms was in Hugh Blake's article describing his invention, the "Diatonion," in an article in Concertina & Squeezebox.  Could he possibly have coined the terms, or this dichotomous usage of them to differentiate between two groups of free reed instruments?

PG

Terminology that covers the whole range of free-reed instruments is tricky, because there are some free-reed instruments, like reed organs and some bass english concertinas (possibly some accordions?), that only have reeds operating in a single direction of air flow for each button or key; with these instruments there might be a single "note" (maybe a single reedtongue, or maybe multiple voices sounding together) corresponding to each key. . . but differing from "double action" instruments such as a typical piano accordion, english concertina, or CBA which also have one "note/voices" corresponding to each button or key -- produced by duplicate reeds for the two bellows directions.  Both those different designs considered together differ from the "two different notes produced by the same button or key, selected by different bellows direction" of our typical melodeons/diatonic button accordions/anglo concertinas etc.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 29, 2012, 09:18:49 PM
Mory, what you say about Wikipedia taking down what they cannot find online confirmation of is alarming... incredible, really. But given their modus operandi and financial resources, I suppose it's hardly surprising.

Paul, I had noted that the Wikipedia article on concertinas uses "single action" for instruments that only produce notes in one bellows direction - such as certain low-pitched English concertinas - and decided to ignore it :) In a sense, though, it doesn't conflict with the way I'm proposing to use the term. The concertina in question works in exactly the same way as a melodeon - it just lacks a second reed for the other direction.  ;D 

I don't have any authoritative offline sources to refer to until I can get to a major library. Until then, I'm going to rely on what seems to be a consensus among online sources that use the terms single/double action (Wikipedia's concertina entry notwithstanding).

Surely we cannot hope to clear up all this potential for confusion, nor issue any kind of  prescriptive statement. If we can define our terms, and use them consistently, as far as possible in accordance with the way most other sources are doing, then we'll have done our job.

I'm going to try to get time to put my version online sometime tomorrow. After that, it will be there for anybody to edit. Until then, all comments and suggestions still gratefully received. 

Thanks again.
Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2012, 12:52:39 AM

Quote
Accidentals are sometimes placed on two or extra buttons, or a shorter third row of four or more buttons, close to the bellows. The “Club” system developed by Hohner in the 1950s is a well-established example of this approach. Using the accidentals, and with the added modification of a “Gleichton” (unisonoric second-octave tonic in the middle of the middle row), this system allows players to obtain a fully chromatic scale – albeit in one direction only (draw). For an in-depth discussion of the Club system, see (x-ref to http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/intro.html).
It looks OK apart from the date of the Club system development. I don't know exactly when this layout came into use, but it must have been before the 1950s; I have a Hohner Club III which dates from the 1930s.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 03:18:27 AM
Posted! (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_button_accordion) It could be improved, and I hope it will be, but at least I think it's now a more balanced article than it was.

The "Notable players" section could do with more balance - if anyone doesn't do Wikipedia editing, please tell me your suggestions and I'll be happy to add them. Same goes for any other suggestions, assuming I agree with them :)

SteveFR: I changed what I had written in response to your suggestion about organetto/fisarmonic diatonica after perusing http://www.organetto.info/  Obviously they are happy to refer to yer common-or-garden 2-row 4th apart system as an "organetto".

Thanks again to everybody for suggestions and encouragement.
S
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2012, 08:01:03 AM
Excellent! Well done indeed, Steve. You have successfully navigated the stormy waters of our prior suggestions!  ;)

I still strongly disagree with the single-action/double-action thing, and just because another website/publication describes it in one way doesn't mean to say that it is the correct or best definition. Language evolves. However, I have no intention of editing this on the Wikipedia page just because I don't agree with what you have written; I am (I hope) more professional in my approach than to do that.  But as I think there are several of us on melnet who disagree with the definition, perhaps one option would be to remove all references to SA/DA altogether - there is sufficient explanation of how the buttons work anyway without invoking SA/DA.

I have added Brian Peters to the list of notable English players, with a link to his external website; I think many of us here on melnet would be happy with that.

Well done again!

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on January 30, 2012, 08:34:57 AM
Well done Steve. Takes Wiki 3months to get to an edit according to the radio piece, there was also someone talking about the game they and their friends play with adding nonsense trivia particularly to new articles and deceased famous people, so don't be surprised! Good Job Steve AtB mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 08:57:45 AM
I'm inclined to agree with Steve_freereeder's comment about SA/DA - I hadn't come across it before, but I immediately imagined it meant the opposite to the definition:  i.e. in DA, each button acts to produces two notes, and in SA only one.  So it's easy to confuse and best dropped, I would suggest.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 30, 2012, 10:40:43 AM
Me too- single/double action intuitively means to me exactly the opposite of the definition given.  It's not a term I've ever come across in connection with boxes; steam-engines, yes, but not accordions.........

Incidentally, unless it's changed since I looked at it early this morning, both unisonoric and bisonoric are defined in the Glossary as producing two notes per key.

Graham
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: summerstars on January 30, 2012, 10:55:11 AM
Steve,

Unless I am reading it wrong there is a conflict in the second and third bullet points under the heading "Glossary"

"Glossary

The following definitions will assist understanding of this article.

    DBA: abbreviation for diatonic button accordion
    single-action or bisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes; see the section on Action below.
    double-action or unisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes
    reversal: on a single-action instrument, a button or key which produces a note available elsewhere on the keyboard, but obtained by using the opposite bellows direction
    accidental: any note of the chromatic scale outside the diatonic scale(s) of a DBA’s “home” key(s)"
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 11:56:32 AM
Steve,

Unless I am reading it wrong there is a conflict in the second and third bullet points under the heading "Glossary"

"Glossary

The following definitions will assist understanding of this article.

    DBA: abbreviation for diatonic button accordion
    single-action or bisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes; see the section on Action below.
    double-action or unisonoric: refers to an instrument on which each key or button produces two notes
    reversal: on a single-action instrument, a button or key which produces a note available elsewhere on the keyboard, but obtained by using the opposite bellows direction
    accidental: any note of the chromatic scale outside the diatonic scale(s) of a DBA’s “home” key(s)"


Mega-oops! Thank you _very much_. Have corrected that. Made a bit of a mockery of the whole SA/DA controversy, didn't it? ;D

I appreciate your professionalism Steve. I did consider removing all references to both single or double action and bisonoric and unisonoric as well. One can always work around things, but I thought it would make things awkward. Might have ended having to say "push-pull action" all the time instead. The current effort is an attempt to balance between what does seem to be established terminology and the jargon used in the DBA community.

For those of you who are only familiar with the jargon, I would say, do please bear in mind that language is used in many ways we personally are unfamiliar with and that seem strange, counterintuitive or from outer space. Doesn't mean those ways are "wrong". Learned that _very early on_ in my career as a publisher's editor, in both technical and nontechnical contexts.

Having said that I will try to keep an open mind on the subject, look for more confirmation (or refutations) of the "established terminology" and (in a day or two, need to get other stuff done) return to the article to see if I can't make everybody happy. Mwahahaha!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Howard Jones on January 30, 2012, 12:56:37 PM
In many of the references I've seen "single-action" is applied to instruments where the air flow to sound a note is only one way, and "double-action" where it flows both ways.  This is how Neil Wayne, an authority on concertinas, uses the term.  I've seen it applied not only to concertinas, but also to bandoneons, harmoniums (harmonia?) and other free-reed instruments. 

However I've also seen "single-action" used to mean "push-pull", and I must admit that is how I'd always understood the term, which I've known for many years.  I don't think I'd come across "bisonoric" until I started frequenting melnet.

Whichever term may originally have been correct, both meanings now seem to be widely used across the free-reed family of instruments.  I don't think "single/double action" should be ignored just because a particular subset of players (ie those who use melnet) favours the alternative.  However it should be made clear which of the two meanings is meant.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 02:07:22 PM
Quote
Whichever term may originally have been correct, both meanings now seem to be widely used across the free-reed family of instruments.  I don't think "single/double action" should be ignored just because a particular subset of players (ie those who use melnet) favours the alternative.  However it should be made clear which of the two meanings is meant.

I don't think this is really to do with a particular groups of players - it's just a question of trying to promote commonsense through the widest (as far as I'm aware) forum there is in this field.  Wikipedia works as some sort of 'paradigm' establisher - if a sizable body of others were to say they disagree, they would have every opportunity to move it on and develop to a new common understanding.  I believe Steve J is quite right (and brave!) to put his head above the parapet, because he has allowed this debate to take place, and hopefully some consensus on a hitherto very grey area to emerge. It is inherent in any such attempt that historical contradictions may be challenged by discussion, I would say.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pgroff on January 30, 2012, 02:12:54 PM
In many of the references I've seen "single-action" is applied to instruments where the air flow to sound a note is only one way, and "double-action" where it flows both ways.  This is how Neil Wayne, an authority on concertinas, uses the term.  I've seen it applied not only to concertinas, but also to bandoneons, harmoniums (harmonia?) and other free-reed instruments.  

However I've also seen "single-action" used to mean "push-pull", and I must admit that is how I'd always understood the term, which I've known for many years.  I don't think I'd come across "bisonoric" until I started frequenting melnet.

Whichever term may originally have been correct, both meanings now seem to be widely used across the free-reed family of instruments.  I don't think "single/double action" should be ignored just because a particular subset of players (ie those who use melnet) favours the alternative.  However it should be made clear which of the two meanings is meant.

Hi Howard,

I've seen the first usage you mention also ("single action" to describe e.g. english-system basses that have only one reed for each button), and also seen such instruments described as "half action."  

Although confusing, there's some logic here.

To me, the notion of "double action" implies that the same note sounds in two directions of airflow, thus there might be twice as many reeds (but what about instruments that operate like the sheng etc in which one reed sounds in both directions?).

To me, the notion of "unisonoric" implies that there is only a single note keyed by each button or piano key. ("bisonoric" means that 2 different notes, selected via bellows direction, are played by each button or key).

If I am right (leaving aside misapplications of the term in some cases), the terms "double action" and "unisonoric"  might not really be synonyms.  They overlap a lot, but are really focusing on slightly different aspects of the relationship of notes/keys/bellows.

PG
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 02:25:35 PM
This terminological question seems set to remain contentious. I would like to get to the bottom of it, so keep the opinions coming.  

However please don't allow it to overshadow all other aspects of the article that need improving. The Notable players section clearly needs more players from France, Italy and other countries.

A section outlining, or providing references to, historical development of DBAs would also be a valuable addition.  

I've already noticed a few words omitted and little points needing tidying up, but am saving them up for another edit soon.

Also, let's have more pix of typical or interesting specimens of DBA. If anyone is willing to upload their own photographs to the Wikimedia commons, please do, and let me know so that I can add them to the article. Photos of a club, an organetto, a 4-stop one-row, an 18-bass Handry or similar, and a fully loaded BCC#  would be of interest, I think.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 02:45:20 PM
Can anyone give a source for the reference to the source of 'single-action' being used to mean 'push-pull'?  It does seem at first sight a rather odd use of the words.  I wonder whether it perhaps describes a mechanism, rather than a type of button accordion.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 03:02:50 PM
Can anyone give a source for the reference to the source of 'single-action' being used to mean 'push-pull'?  It does seem at first sight a rather odd use of the words.  I wonder whether it perhaps describes a mechanism, rather than a type of button accordion.

Here's where I got the term from. This paper used to be available for free download, so I'll just quote a bit here. You can download it for a small fee from Jstor http://www.jstor.org/pss/852759

Quote from:  Graeme Smith
The single-action diatonic accordion is a child of nineteenth-century capitalism and Western tonality. As such, it was a product of the expanding capitalism and modernization which transformed traditional societies and brought the ascendance of new economic and class relations and massively increased material production. Accordions transformed the musical world of many groups, creating new relations between musicians and audiences, displacing other instruments, and becoming the sound of the new metropolis (Giannatassio 1979, Pella 1985).

The diatonic accordion has a rectangular bellows which links two wooden ends, in each of which are set metal free reeds which can be sounded via valves opened by buttons. As a European-style free reed will only speak when air passes through it in a particular direction, different sets of reeds are required to sound on the press and draw of the bellows. In single-action instruments, these reeds are tuned to different pitches, and so in general each pitch requires a unique combination of button and bellows movement. Double-action instruments, such as the familiar piano accordion and various "continental style" button accordions, have equally-tuned reed pairs so that bellows direction has no influence on the pitch produced.

There are a number of single-action free reed instruments, and these generally preserve the system of arrangement of pitches presented on the "Akkordion" patented by the Austrian instrument maker Cyril Demian in 1829. On present-day single-action accordions, the right-hand end of the instrument has one or more rows of ten or eleven buttons, which produce two and a half octaves of a single major scale, arrayed on the press and draw of the bellows like the pitches in a mouth organ. A row is thus said to be in a particular key, and multi-row accordions may be referred to as B/C, D/ D#, and so on, according to the tuning of the rows. In the single-action system a wide range of pitches can be spanned in any hand position, and diatonic melodies are easily played on a single row, as the ear quickly becomes attuned to the distinction between the press and draw pitches. The left-hand end of the instrument can be either single action or double action. The ten-key melodeon has two single-action bass buttons which play the root and triad of the tonic on the press, and on the draw play those of the dominant. Larger instruments may have a slightly expanded repertoire of chords similarly arranged to coincide with the harmonies which might be demanded by notes chosen from the right-hand end. More sophisticated instruments have a double action left-hand end, with a full chromatic range of chords and roots laid out according to the pattern used in piano accordions.

                                    ETHNOMUSICOLOGY, VOL. 41, NO. 3, FALL 1997

It reads a lot better than my Wikipedia article!  ;D Will add a reference to it in the article, and not just for the single-action bit.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 30, 2012, 03:03:04 PM
This terminological question seems set to remain contentious. I would like to get to the bottom of it, so keep the opinions coming.  

Don't impose one. Acknowledge the diversity.  Provide a glossary?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 03:05:15 PM
Provide a glossary?

Read the article?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 04:25:10 PM
It seems that the Jstor paper (thanks Steve) may be referring to earlier definitions of SA/DA, and certainly I've just found many other references which go along with your definition, Steve.

But not all, it seems!  For example this one seems slightly different:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concertina.

And this one has the directly opposite sense:

http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=untabCgOVkgC&pg=PA3&lpg=PA3&dq=single-action+accordion&source=bl&ots=jPq09jBmEs&sig=xocrcjcYO_coaod9edI28qcUpd0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=nr8mT4ySFojx8QPh0NX1AQ&ved=0CCcQ6AEwADgU
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 04:49:17 PM
Chris, I noted in an earlier reply to Paul Groff that I had seen the use of single-action in the Wikipedia concertina article, and decided to ignore it ! Paul and Howard both bring up this use, too, so we are aware of it. 

As for the google books result: if you read the definition of single-action provided, it's pretty clear the author doesn't have a clue, er sorry, good grasp of the technical aspects of accordion sound production ("reeds that make the same tone whether played by pushing or drawing air through them"), so I wouldn't ascribe much authority to that use of "single-action" based on that evidence.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 05:17:58 PM
This looks like being an early reference, by Charles Dickens, in his book 'Household Words', Vol. 8:

http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=cZ04AAAAYAAJ&pg=PA402&dq=single-action+accordion&hl=en&sa=X&ei=McgmT-rNJ8bN8QPZmLjKBw&ved=0CGYQ6AEwCDgU#v=onepage&q=single-action%20accordion&f=false

According to Dickens (who may of course have been completely wrong!) the esteemed Professor Wheatstone designed his amazing new concertinas so that each button had either one spring ('single action'), so that you could play a note on the push only, or two springs, so that you could play the sound push or pull ('double action').  (I don't really understand that, but did those buttons have two positions, one for push, one for pull?)  He makes no mention of the sound being different, suggesting that it was not.  That does make some sense of how the terms SA and DA originated, and it seems to match the Wikipedia/concertina reference I mentioned earlier.

So the next question is, how on earth did it come to be adapted to mean 'SA = two notes, DA = one note', by the time the Encyclopaedia Britannica got hold of it?

I'm just speculating, but could this have something to do with the subsequent development of valves?  Perhaps DA 'unisonoric' accordions first became standard, as they would clearly have technical advantages, but then manufacturers invented a more sophisticated system with reeds and valves, so paradoxically had to call it SA to distinguish it?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 05:19:28 PM
Steve, I think the concertina article must somehow have come from this Dickens source.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 30, 2012, 05:37:55 PM
each button had either one spring ('single action'), so that you could play a note on the push only, or two springs, so that you could play the sound push or pull ('double action').  (I don't really understand that, but did those buttons have two positions, one for push, one for pull?)  

By 'spring' he meant what we now call a reed tongue.  Does that help to make more sense?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 05:45:02 PM
Steve, I agree the ACM source is unreliable, but it does indicate the potential for confusion.   Also, in the early development of free-reed instruments, for all I know, bi-directional reeds may have been tried- I have seen a document suggesting that it would be wrong to say that reeds intrinsically work only in one direction.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 05:48:54 PM
Theo, if what you say is true, and that is what Dickens meant, then surely in his mind DA must have allowed two notes, and SA only one?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 06:28:32 PM
Wheatstone's early concertinas were all "English", were they not? So on his double-action models, one button would sound the same note in both directions of the bellows. 
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 30, 2012, 06:46:27 PM
And in reply to Chris,  I think there may have been some very early Wheatstones that had only one reed per button, you would need to talk to Stephen Chambers for a well researched answer to that one.  I'm sure however that Wheatstone referred to reeds as springs and later as vibrators.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 07:23:18 PM
Quote
Wheatstone's early concertinas were all "English", were they not? So on his double-action models, one button would sound the same note in both directions of the bellows.

Hence my suggestion above that if that became the norm, anyone subsequently deciding to give the buttons different notes in each direction might not have been able to call them 'double action' - the term had already been coined with a different meaning.  And that is a different meaning to what we are now talking about.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Howard Jones on January 30, 2012, 07:29:14 PM
I don't think this is really to do with a particular groups of players - it's just a question of trying to promote commonsense through the widest (as far as I'm aware) forum there is in this field. 

I intend no disrespect to melnet or its esteemed members.  You may well be correct to say it's the widest forum in this field.  However I think it could be dangerous to assume that we are representative of anglophone melodeon players, or even of those in the UK.  I suspect the players who are not members far outnumber those who are.

To me at least the term "bisonoric" is fairly new, and one I only came across several decades after I heard the term "single action".  I don't claim to be an expert, and I don't particularly favour one usage over the other.  However the single/double action usage, in both its meanings, is well established across the family of free-reed instruments.  It seems to me that a comprehensive article should at least recognise the term rather than ignore it.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 30, 2012, 07:36:26 PM
I don't think this is really to do with a particular groups of players - it's just a question of trying to promote commonsense through the widest (as far as I'm aware) forum there is in this field. 

I intend no disrespect to melnet or its esteemed members.  You may well be correct to say it's the widest forum in this field.  However I think it could be dangerous to assume that we are representative of anglophone melodeon players, or even of those in the UK.  I suspect the players who are not members far outnumber those who are.

To me at least the term "bisonoric" is fairly new, and one I only came across several decades after I heard the term "single action".  I don't claim to be an expert, and I don't particularly favour one usage over the other.  However the single/double action usage, in both its meanings, is well established across the family of free-reed instruments.  It seems to me that a comprehensive article should at least recognise the term rather than ignore it.

Indeed, single and double action were always the terms that I knew of, not bi/unisonoric.

Also, isn't Wikipedia meant to be descriptive rather than directive?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 30, 2012, 10:15:08 PM
I've tracked this down - it's a patent/description by Wheatstone for his concertinas, dated 1848:

 http://www.concertina.com/pricelists/wheatstone-english/Wheatstone-Pricelist-1848-C824.pdf

In it he does clearly describe 'single action' as meaning notes produced in one direction only, and 'double action' as notes being produced on both push and pull.  So it looks very much as if Charles Dickens' description was right, and that was the original meaning. 

How this changed over the years to a quite different meaning, in the case of accordions at least, is still baffling.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on January 30, 2012, 10:27:33 PM
Good sleuthing, Chris! I would imagine that "double-action" has continued to mean the same thing as it did on Wheatstone's English-system concertinas: the same note on press and draw. Over the years, single-action instruments of the kind described there became a rarity. Perhaps single-action was transferred onto push-pull instruments to contrast them from double-action i.e. unisonoric ones.

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 31, 2012, 02:12:13 AM
Yes, Steve, that's my speculation too.  It might be useful if we could find Uhlig's patent of 1834, to see if his two-note buttons were referred to as 'single-action' at the time, or only later. 
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 01, 2012, 12:02:23 PM
I've just found a copy of this earlier 1844 Wheatstone patent, again through the excellent concertina.net website (the third page is the relevant one):

http://www.concertina.com/wheatstone/Wheatstone-Concertina-Patent-No-10041-of-1844.pdf

(Praise and thanks to the many listed contributors for the huge amount of work they've put into this resource, which assists us accordionists too.  In particular I believe, Stephen Chambers?)

This patent adds more to our understanding, because it clearly shows that in his use of the terms 'single-action' and 'double-action', Wheatstone did not mean the notes are the same on push or pull in 'double-action' (although in his 'English' system they happened to be);  instead he was specifically referring to the use of two reeds (which he did indeed call 'springs', and they had one-way valves too), so that each button ('peg') could create sounds on both push and pull.  In 'single-action' instruments of that time, there was only one reed, and the button could only sound in one direction.

Wheatstone's description is remarkably clear, and his concept, for that time, seems to be straightforward and completely sensible.  He is using the word 'action' to describe simple mechanics.

In terms of the mechanics of producing sounds this 'double-action' principle seems to be essentially the same as in today's button accordions, both 'bisonoric' and 'unisonoric'.

I'm afraid that it very much looks as if whoever it was that originally decided to call bisonoric button accordions 'single-action', misunderstood all this.   I hope we can get to the bottom of this change, but I have to say I doubt it, because presumably nobody noticed at the time it happened, so it's going to be even more difficult to trace that change today.

Whether language has moved on so that we should adopt a different definition today is a separate matter, but my only comment on this would be that the later usage makes little sense and is counter-intuitive.


Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 01, 2012, 01:38:40 PM
Chris, having trawled the forums at concertina.net, I can say with certainty that the members of that community on the whole use the term single-action in the way that Wheatstone did. Occasional posters have ventured to say that they understood the terms single- and double-action as I have used them in the Wikipedia article, but clearly the majority of respondents did not.

I can also say with a similar degree of certainty that in the world of diatonic accordions (certainly as represented on the web, and from the evidence of Howard and others) single-action means push-pull.

So the question is, is it better to avoid single-action because it is confusing or counterintuitive to some? These reasons were why it was thought necessary to replace the word "inflammable" with "flammable" on safety warnings and data sheets. There at least, lives were at stake :)

Right now I feel that the article is very clear about how it is using the terms, and that the terms are widely used in the same way with reference to push-pull accordions and same-note types.

I am going to leave the article as it is for the time being. At some point in the future I may edit it to try to remove or alleviate the confusion you and some others feel. Anybody, of course, is free to do edit the article as they wish. If the edits are badly done, disrupt the flow of the article or end up creating confusion themselves, they risk being undone, however.   (:)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 01, 2012, 02:28:33 PM
Steve, I completely respect your decision, but the troubling factors for the future will be (as you no doubt fully appreciate!):

1)  Wheatstone looks as if he originally invented the terms;
2)  They make complete sense in his context;
3)  The more recent usage doesn't seem to have an accepted or properly established origin - we have yet to find a reliable historical source for it;
4)  At the time Wheatstone wrote it, the distinction between concertinas and button accordions hadn't been invented, he was just describing a mechanism, which is still common to both.
5)  Is the newer usage actually used all that widely anyway?

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 01, 2012, 02:43:39 PM
3)  The more recent usage doesn't seem to have an accepted or properly established origin - we have yet to find a reliable historical source for it;
5)  Is the newer usage actually used all that widely anyway?

3) Well, keep looking if you have the courage to do so... and please report back.
5) Not in this forum, perhaps. But elsewhere, based on other evidence, I would say very probably.

For my part:

a) I am keeping an open mind.
b) I dislike "bisonoric"  >:E 

Cheers
Steve

PS As I said earlier, what I think the article really needs now to make it more interesting to readers is not this kind of terminological debate, but more photos.


Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 01, 2012, 03:55:45 PM
I never liked 'bi-sonoric' either. If concertina.net are using a different terminology - this is getting silly.

Could some mebers of both forums plese advise
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 01, 2012, 04:51:41 PM
Quote
3) Well, keep looking if you have the courage to do so... and please report back.

Lack of courage isn't a problem! - it's just that I don't know what I'm looking for, and my research so far has drawn a blank.   Other early inventors didn't seem to use the terms SA or DA, it was just Wheatstone's own explanation.  Perhaps the original source for the newer usage could be explained by one of its supporters?

(I must say I don't much like the word 'bisonoric' either, though I have found it seems to crop up regularly in different countries.)

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 01, 2012, 05:12:13 PM
Great work Steve lets not detract from the intent eh guys, Quote from The Box by David Hanrahan "The pedecessor of our present instrument was the Melodeon. The Melodeon had one row of ten keys and with its single action it had a unique sound" which made me think how the Irish/Scottish Button Accodion 2/3 row and English Melodeon 2/3 row (with all partys in union on 1 row Melodeon) had survived as equal but different, a sentiment useful to all. I googled all the differing terms sing.. doub.. biso.. etc they all lead nicely to Wiki Diatonic etc which is good All the Best to All mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 01, 2012, 06:05:27 PM
Warning - thread drift but just for a quick aside comment for English Concertina players...

I've just found a copy of this earlier 1844 Wheatstone patent, again through the excellent concertina.net website (the third page is the relevant one):

http://www.concertina.com/wheatstone/Wheatstone-Concertina-Patent-No-10041-of-1844.pdf

Thanks, Chris!
Very interesting read - for example the bit about CW's method for tuning reeds on the fly, with an adjustable slider. I don't think it was particularly successful, as it never caught on.

However, one especially interesting snippet occurs on page 3, line 15, where CW states that the finger rest on an English concertina is intended to accommodate both 4rd and 3rd fingers (ring and little). This makes a lot of sense when one considers the shape and dimensions of the EC finger rest. Most players these days use only their little finger on the rest, which for some of us can be quite painful after a while, especially with a heavier concertina such as an Aeola.

Just an observation...

OK - it's safe to go back to melodeons now  ;)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 01, 2012, 06:14:55 PM
OK - it's safe to go back to melodeons now  ;)

You mean single-action diatonic button accordions....

Hey, I've just realized what we should all be called - never mind melodeonista. We are

SADBAstards!

You read it here first...
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 01, 2012, 07:13:14 PM
Warning - thread drift but just for a quick aside comment for English Concertina players...

I've just found a copy of this earlier 1844 Wheatstone patent, again through the excellent concertina.net website (the third page is the relevant one):

http://www.concertina.com/wheatstone/Wheatstone-Concertina-Patent-No-10041-of-1844.pdf

Thanks, Chris!
Very interesting read - for example the bit about CW's method for tuning reeds on the fly, with an adjustable slider. I don't think it was particularly successful, as it never caught on.

However, one especially interesting snippet occurs on page 3, line 15, where CW states that the finger rest on an English concertina is intended to accommodate both 4rd and 3rd fingers (ring and little). This makes a lot of sense when one considers the shape and dimensions of the EC finger rest. Most players these days use only their little finger on the rest, which for some of us can be quite painful after a while, especially with a heavier concertina such as an Aeola.

Just an observation...

OK - it's safe to go back to melodeons now  ;)

I think you should post that snippet on C net Steve f I bet it would run and run as a thread AtB mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 01, 2012, 09:27:36 PM
Coming to this from bandoneons it is clear that -

Bisonoric means a push/pull instrument where the note is diferent on each (OK there are some notes where this doesn't happen but the reed beds are set up as if were)

Unisonoric means that, without exception, the same note is played whatever the direction bellows ala a piano accordion.

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Owen Woods on February 02, 2012, 12:58:19 PM
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 02, 2012, 01:20:28 PM
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.

Absolutely; philologically sound and completely unambiguous. I simply can't see the logic of a "single action" producing two notes while a "double action" produces only one............ 

     I fully accept that others may see no confusion and that the terms, even though they are new to me in this context (though you'd think in 40+ years of box-playing I'd have come across them somewhere!), may be in wide and general use elsewhere; personally I shall continue to use "bi/unisonoric" because they seem to me to be the best available choices.  Other terminology is available..........

Graham
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 02, 2012, 04:39:51 PM
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.

Absolutely; philologically sound and completely unambiguous. I simply can't see the logic of a "single action" producing two notes while a "double action" produces only one............ 


Probably needs someone to write a note to go with the Wikipedia article explaining the singe/double action and bi/unisonoric terminology complete with the history of both.   Then readers can make up their own minds which to use.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 02, 2012, 05:12:13 PM
What is wrong with bisonoric and unisonoric? ??? The advantage with those terms is that the meaning is immediately obvious.

Absolutely; philologically sound and completely unambiguous. I simply can't see the logic of a "single action" producing two notes while a "double action" produces only one............ 


Probably needs someone to write a note to go with the Wikipedia article explaining the singe/double action and bi/unisonoric terminology complete with the history of both.   Then readers can make up their own minds which to use.

As always, the voice of reason!  ;D
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 02, 2012, 06:40:24 PM
OK, here's my latest SA/DA hypothesis, and I'm now pretty much convinced it's probably true: 

It's all a cock-up by the Encyclopedia Britannica!

If you look at the (no longer copyright) 11th version of the Encyclopedia Britannica, published in 1911, it said this:

'The English concertina, invented and patented by Sir Charles Wheatstone in 1829, the year of the reputed invention of the accordion (q.v.), is constructed with a double action, the same note being produced on compressing and expanding the bellows, whereas in the German concertina or accordion two different notes are given out.'

The 11th edition is known to be riddled with errors.

The words quoted are strictly true, but seriously misleading;  yes, most of Wheatstone's concertinas at that time were 'double action', being playable in and out - and yes, the same note was produced in and out by his English system - and yes in the 'German' system in and out played different notes.  The trouble is that because of the author's poor understanding of the technology, he/she wasn't aware (or was trying to cover his/her ignorance by deliberate ambiguity) that the clause that begins 'whereas....' merely relates to the clause 'the same note being produced on compressing and expanding the bellows', not also to the previous clause containing the words 'is constructed with a double action'.  He/she probably simply didn't understand that that wasn't what Wheatstone was talking about at all, when he wrote his patents.

I'm pretty convinced that this rubbish document is at the root of the misunderstanding, because everything comes back to it, and it's plainly wrong in its implications, because that wasn't what Wheatstone said at all.  If you bear in mind that the popularity of concertinas waned after the 1920's, it's easy to see why any of the later revivalists who went back to this source (or later versions of it such as still exist) without understanding the original mistake, would no doubt think that's what SA/DA meant.

Nobody has yet responded to my query about other sources for the belief that SA meant bisonoric, but I'm now becoming pretty much convinced there aren't going to be any. I find it significant that this obviously misleading wording relates to the Wheatstone concertina, so do we really need to look any further?

OK, I'm going to stick my neck out now:

Sorry everyone, but the idea that 'single-action' means 'bisonoric' is crap.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 02, 2012, 07:52:51 PM
I hereby nominate Chris Brimley to add the history of the singe/double action and bi/unisonoric terminology to the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons! ;D
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 02, 2012, 08:11:59 PM
Theo, you are very kind, but although this has been an interesting little exercise for me on a minor matter of terminology, Steve has done all the work on the main wiki stuff, and deserves all our credit and support.

Besides which, I'm not sure Mr Assange allows the word 'crap' on his website.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 02, 2012, 08:16:24 PM
It's also original research.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: jb on February 02, 2012, 08:24:31 PM
Besides which, I'm not sure Mr Assange allows the word 'crap' on his website.
you got the wrong guy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiLeaks) there.
Here's the relevant one (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Wales).
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 02, 2012, 08:32:24 PM
Oops, you're quite right!  Just goes to show the effectiveness of associative advertising, I guess!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Curamach on February 02, 2012, 09:20:49 PM
Assange?? We don't want leaks in our wikis anymore than in our bellows! >:E
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Curamach on February 02, 2012, 09:22:01 PM
PS I hit post too soon. Thanks, Steve, for a nice job on the article!

Dan
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 02, 2012, 10:16:39 PM
Yes I agree Steve has done a great job and I think a footnote on terminology would not detract from what he has done.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 02, 2012, 11:04:30 PM
Hmmm, mine was a sort of "drive by" comment earlier on so people probably didn't recognise what I was getting at.

Wikipedia is not the place for original research or propounding theories and suchlike.

See:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_publisher_of_original_thought
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 02, 2012, 11:06:10 PM
It seems that single-action is not the only matter we need to substantiate, clarify or refute. The article has just been marked up by a bot of some kind which has specified a couple of dozen "citations needed."

Chris, what you makes you so sure that "single action" with reference to accordions is all the fault of the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica? Does the article even use the term? How do you know it wasn't in use 50 years before that? How do you know that people started using "single action" on the authority of the article you quote (esp. if it doesn't mention the term)?  
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 03, 2012, 12:10:44 AM
How would a bot know where to put the citation needed tags?   ???    :D
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 03, 2012, 02:15:41 AM
It seems that single-action is not the only matter we need to substantiate, clarify or refute. The article has just been marked up by a bot of some kind which has specified a couple of dozen "citations needed."  
I've removed the obvious overzealous 'citation needed' markups (not touched the SA/DA ones though!) but whether they will reappear or not remains to be seen. I believe there is a way of disabling certain Bot tasks, probably including the one which adds these 'citation needed' tags, but I haven't worked out how to do it yet; I'm not sure I understand all the nomenclature/vocabulary well enough.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 03, 2012, 09:31:19 AM
Quote
Chris, what you makes you so sure that "single action" with reference to accordions is all the fault of the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica? Does the article even use the term? How do you know it wasn't in use 50 years before that? How do you know that people started using "single action" on the authority of the article you quote (esp. if it doesn't mention the term)?  

Like I said, I'm not sure, I'm just sticking my neck out, because it all fits so well with the resultant muddle, and it is likely to have been regarded as a very good (probably the best) source for information at the time.

I checked to see if there were any earlier versions of the EB available online, but I don't think there are.  There were certainly some published in the intervening period between 1829 and 1911, in separate volumes (and also before 1829).  The author of these particular words may well have written them for one of the earlier versions, and they were just reproduced - I entirely agree with that, which is why I chose to blame the EB generically.

The article mentions the words double action, and by contrasting the two systems in the way the author does, most people would immediately assume 'single action' refers to the other.  The fact that SA is not mentioned, only clearly implied, is of course my argument.

Reading the earlier background to the EB, it is notable that the publishers were in it for profit.  It is likely that if a writer could avoid too much research on a subject, he/she would want to do so, because the cost and time involved in that could easily become prohibitive.  Therefore if they're not sure about something, one way round finding out would be to write it cleverly so that a meaning is suggested, without being actually stated.  This allows the author a get-out clause for the future (Oh no, I didn't mean that!), and this is of course the standard con- trick of journalists and even barristers the world over.

It may not be good enough for Wikipedia.  But of course if the thirsty horse doesn't find the water drinkable, he needs to find at least some evidence of another pond!  ;)

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 03, 2012, 09:48:33 AM
Re Andrew's pertinent point, the Wikipedia test of Original Research (OR) seems to be:

Quote
To demonstrate that you are not adding OR, you must be able to cite reliable, published sources that are directly related to the topic of the article, and directly support the material as presented.

Which I think is all I was trying to do - no original thinking, I'm afraid, just looking for reliable sources, such as the Wheatstone patents.   The test does of course equally affect both sides of the debate.

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 03, 2012, 01:42:54 PM
How would a bot know where to put the citation needed tags?   ???    :D

Good question, but I'm not making it up: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:AnomieBOT
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 03, 2012, 05:39:18 PM
SteveFR: thanks for stepping up to curb the excessive zeal of "AnomieBot", whatever it is.

Ongoing improvements dept.:

Notable players:
I have little familiarity with continental DBA players. Would some of you that do care to look at the following list and suggest four or five names from France and Italy and other countries for the above section? Thanks.

Add them directly, or just give your suggestions here.

Link to article in Fr Wikipedia (http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_des_accordéonistes_diatoniques_remarquables)


2. Photos.
C'mon, lads and lasses. The article could really use some decent pics, esp. of: a big beautiful BCC, and nice one-row four-stop, and an organetto, and maybe a classic Club.

Upload them here: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page

It's easier if you upload your own photos, because then you can declare them as "own work" and grant what rights you wish to them. If I upload people's pix, it's awkward, because I don't have the right to assign the rights.

You have to create a Wikipedia account, but that opens lots of wonderful possibilities to you. :-)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 04, 2012, 05:33:00 PM
Similarly the only evidence I have for "bisonoric/unisonoric" is this forum and the existing Wikipedia article. I'll do some more searching on those terms too. In the meantime, do you have any evidence of their wider use? Who first promulgated them, and when?

I believe these terms were used in the "Planet Squeezebox" book that accompanied the CD set.  I had a conversation with one of the authors of the notes in that book, who told me that they expressly decided to use those terms instead of "single action/double-action."  I don't recall the exact reason, but I believe it was because of the confusion caused by "double action" -- which refers to the _same_ note in both directions.

Apologies if this was covered in other posts above; I'm responding to Steve's post, having not yet found time to read the entire thread (my Civil Procedure book is currently higher up in priority!).
-Andy
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 05, 2012, 10:16:54 AM
Similarly the only evidence I have for "bisonoric/unisonoric" is this forum and the existing Wikipedia article. I'll do some more searching on those terms too. In the meantime, do you have any evidence of their wider use? Who first promulgated them, and when?

It's used extensively throughout this site, http://www.inorg.chem.ethz.ch/tango/band/band_node13.html#930 (http://www.inorg.chem.ethz.ch/tango/band/band_node13.html#930)

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 05, 2012, 12:29:43 PM
Further thought.  Logically a single action box would be something like a contra-bass concertina which only sounds on the push, ie under pressure.

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 05, 2012, 01:42:54 PM
Further thought.  Logically a single action box would be something like a contra-bass concertina which only sounds on the push, ie under pressure.

Steve

That point has been discussed earlier in this thread.

Wikipedia itself uses the bisonoric/unisonoric terms exclusively in the entry for Accordions (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accordion)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 05, 2012, 02:14:43 PM
I've added to the list of Scottish players:
Will Starr, Fergie MacDonald, Graeme Irvine
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 05, 2012, 02:18:14 PM
Further thought.  Logically a single action box would be something like a contra-bass concertina which only sounds on the push, ie under pressure.

Steve

That point has been discussed earlier in this thread.


Oops, sorry, where's the blushing smiley?

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Bill Young on February 05, 2012, 02:22:20 PM
I've added to the list of Scottish players:
Will Starr, Fergie MacDonald, Graeme Irvine
It's GRAHAM Irvine (but Graeme Mackay).
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Howard Jones on February 05, 2012, 02:42:08 PM
Here's an authority for single/double action: an ICA article quoting George Grove’s Article on the 'Concertina' in the first edition of 'A Dictionary of Music and Musicians' (1878)

http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878 (http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878)

Uni/bisonoric appears quite widely in internet searches, but I'm not sure if the sites carry sufficient authority to be cited.  For what it's worth, here's a link to Webster's Online Dictionary, again about concertinas:

http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina (http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina)

Scroll down to the extended definition.  This seems to use "sonoricity" to describe the different notes provided by the keys, and "action" to refer to whether sound is produced in one or both directions of the bellows .  A subtle distinction.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 05, 2012, 03:23:42 PM
I've added to the list of Scottish players:
Will Starr, Fergie MacDonald, Graeme Irvine
It's GRAHAM Irvine (but Graeme Mackay).

Thanks Bill.  Now corrected.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pgroff on February 05, 2012, 04:24:50 PM
Here's an authority for single/double action: an ICA article quoting George Grove’s Article on the 'Concertina' in the first edition of 'A Dictionary of Music and Musicians' (1878)

http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878 (http://www.concertina.org/ica/index.php/pica/subject-index/39-historical-documents/93-george-groves-article-on-the-concertina-in-the-first-edition-of-a-dictionary-of-music-and-musicians-1878)

Uni/bisonoric appears quite widely in internet searches, but I'm not sure if the sites carry sufficient authority to be cited.  For what it's worth, here's a link to Webster's Online Dictionary, again about concertinas:

http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina (http://www.websters-online-dictionary.org/definitions/concertina)

Scroll down to the extended definition.  This seems to use "sonoricity" to describe the different notes provided by the keys, and "action" to refer to whether sound is produced in one or both directions of the bellows .  A subtle distinction.

Hi Howard,

I'm close to agreeing with your last point (see my post on p. 3 above):  unisonoric vs bisonoric refers to whether 1 or 2 notes are produced per key -- but in the case of bisonoric free reed instruments, the term does seem to imply that bellows direction selects between the 2 notes.  On the other hand, double action refers to a sounding of the same note in 2 different directions of airflow -- not exactly a synonym for unisonoric.

Has anyone had a chance to check Hugh Blake's article on his "Diatonion" from Concertina & Squeezebox magazine (probably late 1980s or early 1990s)?  As I mentioned above, on p. 2 of this thread, from a dim memory I think there is a chance that article may be an early use (or even the coining) of the unisonoric / bisonoric dichotomous terms.

PG
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 05, 2012, 05:53:31 PM
Just some points on the 2009 comments by Allan Atlas on Sir George Grove's interesting article of 1878:

Allan Atlas in his point (2) suggests that Grove created confusion about the meaning of 'double action' by his reference to the two notes being the same.  Allan Atlas says:  'He thus uses the ‘single/double’ terminology in two different ways: first to distinguish the English treble from the Anglo, on which the buttons produce different pitches depending on the direction of the bellows, and then to identify instruments that sound only when the bellows are being pressed in. It is a confusing use of the ‘single/double’action terminology, one that persists even today.'

However Allan Atlas also earlier notes that Gove nowhere mentions the existence of the Anglo or Duet, he was just talking about the Wheatstone English, and so his comment in (2) seems somewhat inconsistent.  It does not necessarily mean Gove was 'confused', or trying to use two meanings. (In saying the two notes were the same he was merely adding more information to his sentence, he was not necessarily using that as an alternative meaning) - the confusion might only arise in the mind of a more modern reader who was familiar with the difference between the two alternative systems.

Two other points in support of Gove's account here - first, if he had been trying to use the term to distinguish the English from the Anglo, surely in that context he wouldn't have tried to use 'double' and 'single' that way round, he would have used the opposite?  And second, Gove is relating the history of the Wheatstone patents, with which he was clearly very familiar, and which are very clearcut as to Wheatstone's original meaning.  Gove also knows very well about 'single-action' English system concertinas.  I do not see that this document establishes that Gove was himself responsible for the later confusion, given the context, and I would have thought it unlikely that he was trying to widen the meaning.  Others may well inadvertently have subsequently interpreted 'the two notes being the same' as constituting an alternative interpretation for 'double action', but again I would have thought they just didn't understand the context of Gove's document.

However, it may well be that there is more evidence in the notes, the links to which unfortunately are not available to us.  Is Allan Atlas contactable at all, does anyone know?

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 05, 2012, 06:07:52 PM
It may be worth remembering that Grove was looking at classical music rather than music in general.  In this context he would be concerned with the English concertina as it pertained to classical music rather than the anglo or duet which were not.

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 05, 2012, 11:49:22 PM
Thanks for pointing out that little Freudian, jb, it took me ages to work out what I'd done wrong - but that just made it all the funnier when I did!  And I managed to get it wrong all the way through, too!  (Definitely Freudian.)  Damn, and there was me trying to be all scholarly and that.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 06, 2012, 02:58:34 PM
Update: have provided at least some kind of reference for almost all the [citations needed] tags - most of which popped up again despite Steve FR's taking an axe to them. The three that remain all concern - you guessed it, single/double action and bisonoric.

I am ruminating on the wording for a concise note on the ambiguity and controversy, with references, such as Wheatstone & Grove for the action business (thank you sleuths) and others (not sure which would be best) for bison/unison-oric. My hope being that this will acknowledge the different interpretations yet still give place to both the old-established-but-confusing and the newer-but-inelegant terminologies. Happiness of everyone is too much to aim for; perhaps I can achieve the grudging consent of most.  :|glug

Thanks to Theo for populating the lists of foreign exponents.  

Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Theo on February 06, 2012, 03:04:26 PM
Update: have provided at least some kind of reference for almost all the [citations needed] tags - most of which popped up again despite Steve FR's taking an axe to them. The three that remain all concern - you guessed it, single/double action and bisonoric.

I am ruminating on the wording for a concise note on the ambiguity and controversy, with references, such as Wheatstone & Grove for the action business (thank you sleuths) and others (not sure which would be best) for bison/unison-oric. My hope being that this will acknowledge the different interpretations yet still give place to both the old-established-but-confusing and the newer-but-inelegant terminologies. Happiness of everyone is too much to aim for; perhaps I can achieve the grudging consent of most.  :|glug

Thanks to Theo for populating the lists of foreign exponents.  



Steve, you might of missed my brief mention a few posts back that the Wikipedia page for  Accordion (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accordion) uses unisonoric/bisonoric exclusivly.   For consistency should not the DBA page be the same?   Then the single/double action terminology can be left for the instruments like some types of concertina where Chris has established that it more than likely originated.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 06, 2012, 03:46:01 PM
I think Theo makes a good point. 

As I understand the situation, the main worry about 'bisonoric' and 'unisonoric' is that they don't seem to exist in any authoritative dictionary, nor it seems does the word 'sonoric'.  (AFAIK?)  The word 'sonority', from which these words may be thought to derive, refers to the quality of a sound, which is not necessarily the same as its pitch.  I'm also not entirely sure whether the terms, useful though they certainly are, are thought to refer to the buttons, or to the design of the whole instrument.

Of course, one simple way out of our remaining concerns about these words might simply be to say something like:

Some instruments are designed with most buttons playing two pitches (one for each bellows direction), a design which is increasingly referred to as 'bisonoric'.  Other types of instruments have buttons playing the same pitch in each direction ('unisonoric').

Would we all be happy with that, including authors of the Accordion page?

I suppose one of the difficulties (or maybe advantages?) of global encyclopedias is that they can cross national boundaries, when the use of the English language by different countries is no doubt diverging?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 03:47:25 PM
Its not all about consensus anyways Steve, wasn't long ago that some would have had us believe a majority view was being held regarding what to call the sound board on a box, but when it came down to it we were only hearing a few persistant voices out of nearly a couple of thousand available on this site alone. So stand up that man (that's you Steve) and take a bow for what your doing, I note you've continuously been open to the relative descriptions and I think (for whatever that's worth) it's important not to discount what is obviously a term in use.All the Best mory

Incidentally on this thread so far you have posted 23 times Chris Brimley 28 times with 24 people in total posting with support for both terms with a total of 119 replies and 1732 views, which I believe supports my point above
Title: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 06, 2012, 04:12:44 PM
First of all, I should like to pass on my thanks and congratulations to Steve Jones for setting the whole Wikipedia entry for diatonic button accordions into motion. It's a good and valuable piece of work.

However, the single action/double action (SA/DA) section remains unsatisfactory. Over the last week or so I think we've aired the SA/DA debate quite extensively now. The following points made in earlier posts are becoming quite clear:

1. The SA/DA definition is confused. Whether through error or changing usage over time, SA/DA has meant different things at different times by different authors.

2. To many melodeon players (aka diatonic button accordion players) used to the push-pull nature of the instrument, the definition of SA/DA promoted by Steve Jones in the Wikipedia article is completely counter-intuitive.

3. 'Single action' means something quite specialised in terms of bass concertinas and the like, where notes are produced in one bellows direction only (the other direction is silent).

4. As Theo has pointed out a couple of times, the companion Wikipedia entry for 'Accordion' contains no reference to SA/DA at all.

5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities. 

In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:

All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.

Removal of the SA/DA terms simplifies and clarifies the Wikipedia entry and in no way implies any criticism of Steve Jones who has done a great job in compiling the page.

All those in favour say 'aye'.

Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Lester on February 06, 2012, 04:19:45 PM

All those in favour say 'aye'.


Aye!
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 04:36:22 PM
think the high jacking of this thread and attempt at rail roading your viewpoint is most improper and uncomfortable 
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Ollie on February 06, 2012, 04:37:11 PM
think the high jacking of this thread and attempt at rail roading your viewpoint is most improper and uncomfortable 

 ??? I don't think this has been done at all...
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 06, 2012, 04:45:38 PM
think the high jacking of this thread and attempt at rail roading your viewpoint is most improper and uncomfortable  
Whoah! I don't think attempting to summarise what has gone before and putting a proposition to help clarify things counts as hi-jacking and railroading, and I'd like to know why it is improper.

Please re-read what I have written:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8735.msg109694.html#msg109694

Have I been rude? Have I been disrespectful to anyone?  >:(
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: ladydetemps on February 06, 2012, 04:46:28 PM
Oi! *all* of you play nice or I'll come round and play my fiddle at you.  :P ::)

Everyone is free to summerise the notable points. Mory if your that worried do a summery yourself how you see it.
Discussion not argument.

BTW IMO  Why not draw a diagram and leave out the special technical terms save all this arguing?
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Owen Woods on February 06, 2012, 04:59:00 PM
Aye. Well put Steve.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 06, 2012, 05:13:45 PM
Aye.  It's probably best, all in all.  Well done both Steves.

And if there are masses of dissenters out there, do say so now, so that everybody knows your views.

(29 now? ;) )
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 05:15:27 PM
First of all, I should like to pass on my thanks and congratulations to Steve Jones for setting the whole Wikipedia entry for diatonic button accordions into motion. It's a good and valuable piece of work.

However, the single action/double action (SA/DA) section remains unsatisfactory. Over the last week or so I think we've aired the SA/DA debate quite extensively now. The following points made in earlier posts are becoming quite clear:

1. The SA/DA definition is confused. Whether through error or changing usage over time, SA/DA has meant different things at different times by different authors.

2. To many melodeon players (aka diatonic button accordion players) used to the push-pull nature of the instrument, the definition of SA/DA promoted by Steve Jones in the Wikipedia article is completely counter-intuitive.

3. 'Single action' means something quite specialised in terms of bass concertinas and the like, where notes are produced in one bellows direction only (the other direction is silent).

4. As Theo has pointed out a couple of times, the companion Wikipedia entry for 'Accordion' contains no reference to SA/DA at all.

5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities. 

In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:

All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.

Removal of the SA/DA terms simplifies and clarifies the Wikipedia entry and in no way implies any criticism of Steve Jones who has done a great job in compiling the page.

All those in favour say 'aye'.


I think the sudden appearence of a new thread and title in the middle of Steves is at least rude and certainly provocative surely the appropriate action would have been to start a new thread and as I said here
Its not all about consensus anyways Steve, wasn't long ago that some would have had us believe a majority view was being held regarding what to call the sound board on a box, but when it came down to it we were only hearing a few persistant voices out of nearly a couple of thousand available on this site alone. So stand up that man (that's you Steve) and take a bow for what your doing, I note you've continuously been open to the relative descriptions and I think (for whatever that's worth) it's important not to discount what is obviously a term in use.All the Best mory

Incidentally on this thread so far you have posted 23 times Chris Brimley 28 times with 24 people in total posting with support for both terms with a total of 119 replies and 1732 views, which I believe supports my point above
this we vote so that decides it is twadle AtB mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 06, 2012, 05:15:43 PM
It's not up to people to decide here. That's not how Wikipedia works.

These discussions ought to be on the talk page of the article.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 06, 2012, 05:24:58 PM
It's not up to people to decide here. That's not how Wikipedia works.

These discussions ought to be on the talk page of the article.
There's no reason why discussion shouldn't take place on the Wikipedia talk page, although you do have to register first to be able to contribute.

Nevertheless, discussions have taken place here on melnet, principally because the main author of the Wikipedia article posted his initial drafts here in the first place; something which has been much appreciated (he could have just gone ahead and done it without reference to the rest of us at all). Whatever the outcome of the discussions here, it then goes on to Wikipedia and is then open to anyone to discuss, edit, amend, delete, etc., which is how Wikipedia works. We're just in a preliminary stage here.
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 06, 2012, 05:31:11 PM
I think the sudden appearence of a new thread and title in the middle of Steves is at least rude and certainly provocative
Please calm down. It's the same thread, not a new one. Anyone can amend the title of their post within an existing thread to highlight something specific, which was my only reason for doing so. I've no intention of being rude or provocative.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 06, 2012, 06:25:46 PM
I have to say I don't see anything rude or provocative in Steve Fr's posts; a firmly expressed and equally firmly held opinion, yes, but entirely germane to the subject, and not in any way that I could see derogatory or inflammatory.
Title: Re:Thread renaming mid thread
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 06:29:39 PM
I think the sudden appearance of a new thread and title in the middle of Steve's is at least rude and certainly provocative
Please calm down. It's the same thread, not a new one. Anyone can amend the title of their post within an existing thread to highlight something specific, which was my only reason for doing so. I've no intention of being rude or provocative.
I am glad, I apologise if I have misconstrued your actions. mory

GPS I was not aware that it was ok to change the title of someones thread albeit for making your own specific point
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 06:43:25 PM
Qoute from Steve Free reeder "All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained" All those in favour?? what about those that already use those terms that you are in favour of removing completly? this really doesn't feel comfortable Steve F and I have good reason to feel that way which I won't air here mory
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Ollie on February 06, 2012, 06:45:14 PM
FFS, it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip, people!  ::)
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 06, 2012, 06:52:17 PM
Qoute from Steve Free reeder "All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained" All those in favour?? what about those that already use those terms that you are in favour of removing completly? this really doesn't feel comfortable Steve F and I have good reason to feel that way which I won't air here mory
It's a proposal - no more, no less. People can agree with it, or not, as they wish, as Chris Brimley has already said:

Aye.  It's probably best, all in all.  Well done both Steves.

And if there are masses of dissenters out there, do say so now, so that everybody knows your views.

Mory - I think you have made your viewpoint abundantly clear.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 06, 2012, 06:55:58 PM
Qoute from Steve Free reeder "All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained" All those in favour?? what about those that already use those terms that you are in favour of removing completly? this really doesn't feel comfortable Steve F and I have good reason to feel that way which I won't air here mory

If there are good citations for either set of terms then they should be included.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: mory on February 06, 2012, 06:59:10 PM
 
FFS, it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip, people!  ::)
But its not Ollie, its about one view being imposed over another, something quite different, to even suggest that the terms in question should be removed in deference to the other terms demands a way of thinking that is questionable in the context of equality of human beings to each other so, FFS it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip people! doesn't really encapsulate the reality, if only it were as simple as you indicate. All the Best mory  

Lastly I'd like to see the Article survive and for it to be all inclusive so any research that helps that will help us all
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 06, 2012, 07:02:30 PM
FFS, it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip, people!  ::)
But its not Ollie, its about one view being imposed over another, something quite different, to even suggest that the terms in question should be removed in deferance to the other terms demands a way of thinking that is questionable in the context of equality of human beings to each other so, FFS it's a discussion about some technical language! Get a grip people! doesn't really encapsulate the reality, if only it were as simple as you indicate. All the Best mory  



You're correct, and it is entirely inappropriate in terms of Wikipedia as well since neither term has been adequately referenced in any case.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Ollie on February 06, 2012, 07:21:06 PM
Mountain. Mole hills.


I suggest we all go and play some tunes... that's what it's all about.
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Howard Jones on February 06, 2012, 09:02:10 PM

5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities. 

In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:

All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.

All those in favour say 'aye'.


I say "No".

Whilst I agree that the terms SA/DA may be counter-intuitive, and moreover their precise meaning has become confused and perhaps corrupted over time, these terms are also widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities.  I'm not trying to argue that they should be preferred over Bisonoric/unisonoric.  However the terms SA/DA are by no means redundant, and in my opinion a comprehensive article should not ignore them.
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 06, 2012, 09:31:35 PM

5. The terns unisonoric and bisonoric, although possibly unattractive as words to some people, are nevertheless much more intuitive and clear in their meaning, and are widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities. 

In the light of the above and for those reasons I therefore PROPOSE that:

All references to SA/DA should be removed and the terms unisonoric and bisonoric be retained.

All those in favour say 'aye'.


I say "No".

Whilst I agree that the terms SA/DA may be counter-intuitive, and moreover their precise meaning has become confused and perhaps corrupted over time, these terms are also widely used among the melodeon/DBA/concertina playing communities.  I'm not trying to argue that they should be preferred over Bisonoric/unisonoric.  However the terms SA/DA are by no means redundant, and in my opinion a comprehensive article should not ignore them.

The problem is that there appears to be an error in one of the sources which makes the relationship between a nonsense.

As I understand it (without use of sources) the term SA/DA refers to the bellows movement whereas the the Uni/Bisonoric refers to the sound that the key makes.

So - Single action - one movement of the bellows (usually push) creates the pressure to sound a reed (harmonium, shruti box, bass concertina, sheng  (OK it's blown)) and by definition one note is produced by the key so unisonoric ie one sound/note.

Double action- pressure is  produced by the bellows being either pushed or pulled.  The key however may produce one note when depressed (PA, English/Duet concertina) and is unisonoric or may produce a different note (Anglo, diatonic accordion, mouth organ (yes I know it's blown)) and as such is bisonoric.

Now I know that there are sources that say different, a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!

Now I also know that Wikipedia in it's efforts to clean up it's act is demanding on-line sources,  I'm sorry but that is a nonsense.  Not all knowledge resides on-line and to demand that is to devalue Wikipedia (and sow the seeds of it's own destruction).

Steve
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Howard Jones on February 07, 2012, 12:16:27 AM
The problem is that there appears to be an error in one of the sources which makes the relationship between a nonsense.... a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!

I think you are correct.  The terms do not describe the same thing, and used in their original sense the distinction is clear.  However somewhere along the way it seems to have been misinterpreted to mean SA=bisonoric and DA=unisonoric.  However I don't think it's a case of one source being wrong - this alternative meaning seems to have become widespread (and was how I'd understood them, until I started digging into it to respond to this thread).

Like it or not, there are two well-established but contradictory meanings to SA/DA.  I don't believe that means we should ignore them both, rather we should be aware of them both, and if we use them we should be aware of the alternative meanings.
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on February 07, 2012, 12:24:11 AM
Now I also know that Wikipedia in it's efforts to clean up it's act is demanding on-line sources.

Sorry, that's not true. I wish that people would read the Wikipedia help pages rather than rely on hearsay and guesswork. It's all there.
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: oggiesnr on February 07, 2012, 05:52:10 AM
Now I also know that Wikipedia in it's efforts to clean up it's act is demanding on-line sources.

Sorry, that's not true. I wish that people would read the Wikipedia help pages rather than rely on hearsay and guesswork. It's all there.

Sorry but that semed to be the import of your earlier post.

Steve
Title: Re: Time for action on SA/DA?
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 07, 2012, 12:15:57 PM

The problem is that there appears to be an error in one of the sources which makes the relationship between a nonsense.

As I understand it (without use of sources) the term SA/DA refers to the bellows movement whereas the the Uni/Bisonoric refers to the sound that the key makes.

So - Single action - one movement of the bellows (usually push) creates the pressure to sound a reed (harmonium, shruti box, bass concertina, sheng  (OK it's blown)) and by definition one note is produced by the key so unisonoric ie one sound/note.

Double action- pressure is  produced by the bellows being either pushed or pulled.  The key however may produce one note when depressed (PA, English/Duet concertina) and is unisonoric or may produce a different note (Anglo, diatonic accordion, mouth organ (yes I know it's blown)) and as such is bisonoric.

Now I know that there are sources that say different, a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!

Steve

Now that is as clear and sensible an explanation of the whole mess as I have ever seen - thank you.

Graham
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Chris Brimley on February 07, 2012, 01:48:33 PM
Quote
a wrong source does not become right just because it is old!

I'm slightly hesitant to add anything more (so as not to be told off again for talking too much), but for me perhaps one of the most interesting aspects of this debate has been how on earth so many people have apparently come to believe something that was plainly incorrect, without it having been questioned many times before (I exclude concertina history experts from this, because it looks as if many did indeed understand the terms.)  Such misapprehensions and wrong beliefs have led to wars in the past, so I suppose we shouldn't be surprised that people sometimes become heated now!

In the absence of some intervening sources (and I believe it is relevant that no-one has so far put forward any), my hypothesis has been that the Encyclopedia Britannica (or derivative documents) was relied upon as a source by many, in particular those looking at the history of boxes during the 1960's revival of interest.  I also suspect that because of the lack of modern internet search facilities, few people before the 1980's would have been able to track down such things as the Wheatstone patents to check sources for themselves.  But there is a big time gap here in our knowledge for the first half of the twentieth century, and it would still be of great interest to know of important relevant opinion-forming documents during this time, which might help us to understand how an incorrect interpretation came not to be effectively challenged.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 07, 2012, 02:44:05 PM
Well I don't think any of this is a big deal. Terms and words that have come to mean something different over years or centuries of use? Our language is chock-full of them.

Look, the fact is that both terms are widely used and understood. Let the article reflect this fact and just relax everybody. Wikipedia's function is not to be prescriptive or rewrite history.

If the matter exercises you so much, why not write an article for inclusion on melodeon.net? I find it a little amusing that everyone here has been quite content to let the previous totally crappy Wikipedia article sit there for years and do nothing about it, nor provide any comprehensive information about what a melodeon is on this site, and then some of us to get our knickers in a Gordian knot about this small point, completely ignoring all my other pleas for assistance, and all other aspects of the article.

If any of you really want to help, provide citable references for the use of both single/double action (yes, references that you consider to be wrong), and for unisonoric/bisonoric.   (:)

Cheers
Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 07, 2012, 06:35:32 PM
Well, having burst out with the above outburst - apologies for dumping on you all - back to the search for references:

Ongoing terminology citation research department:

Paul Groff has suggested that old issues of Concertina & Squeezebox magazine might yield some references.  I haven’t found the article by Hugh Blake that he mentioned, but a few pages into the first issue I dipped into I found the extract quoted below.  It is a translator’s note prefacing an article entitled “The Free Reed: a History, Part One” published in C& S issue no. 12 from 1986. The article in question is a translation of an extract from a book entitled Das Akkordeon from East Germany (the former GDR).  The translator, Stuart Frankel, is defining some of the terms he used:

Quote
There is a great deal of confusion in English, but not German, about the following terms which I have used as indicated: single-action (the German is wechseltönig or literally, “changing-toned”) – different note on the push and draw, such as most Anglos nowadays.  I have not used this term to mean the very early instruments that sounded in only one direction. Double-action (German gleichtönig literally, same-toned) – sounding the same note on the push and the draw, such as most English concertinas nowadays.

This would indicate that the term “single-action” to mean “changing-toned” was common currency among concertina players (despite the way the term is used in the current WP article on tinas) in the days before the emergence of “bisonoric”.
To be continued….
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: pgroff on February 07, 2012, 10:34:12 PM
Well, having burst out with the above outburst - apologies for dumping on you all - back to the search for references:

Ongoing terminology citation research department:

Paul Groff has suggested that old issues of Concertina & Squeezebox magazine might yield some references.  I haven’t found the article by Hugh Blake that he mentioned . . .

Hi Steve,

My apologies if I sent you and others on a wild goose chase.  I have a memory of seeing the bisonoric / unisonoric terms somewhere for the first time in the late 1980s or early 1990s, and thought it might be in Blake's "Diatonian" article.  Well, onward!

Thanks for the great idea to improve this part of wikipedia, and thanks to all who have made constructive suggestions!

PG
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Stiamh on February 07, 2012, 10:39:03 PM
Well, having burst out with the above outburst - apologies for dumping on you all - back to the search for references:

Ongoing terminology citation research department:

Paul Groff has suggested that old issues of Concertina & Squeezebox magazine might yield some references.  I haven’t found the article by Hugh Blake that he mentioned . . .

Hi Steve,

My apologies if I sent you and others on a wild goose chase.  I have a memory of seeing the bisonoric / unisonoric terms somewhere for the first time in the late 1980s or early 1990s, and thought it might be in Blake's "Diatonian" article. 

What you don't mention is that (after you pointed me to the correct issue of C&S) I discovered that Hugh Blake uses "change-tone" and "same-tone" on the German model - which is very similar to something Chris B suggested in an earlier reply!

Anyway, we are still on the hunt for the first use of "bisonoric".

And thanks Paul for the suggestion to look in C&S. Some of the articles are great reading even after nearly 30 years. Internet forums are great, no doubt about it, but the disappearance of the small print enthusiasts' publications like C&S is a great loss.
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: oggiesnr on February 07, 2012, 11:42:55 PM
Can't pin down the first use of the word but throughout Wikipedia on accordions, gamoshka, chemitzer, bandoneon, uni and bisonoric are used as I exampled above.  Likewise the US chemnitzer site has the same usage.

I'll hit a (physical) music library next week to see if I can find early exemplers.

Steve
Title: Re: Help me rewrite the Wikipedia article on DBAs/melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 08, 2012, 08:54:27 AM
Sorry everyone. I am unwell at the moment and not really up to taking part in the discussions and research. I'm glad to see that decorum has been restored. Good luck to all with the article.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal