Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Ellison on January 28, 2012, 10:28:59 PM
-
Hello all
Back on my sainted C/F pokerwork I thought I'd have a go at some morris tunes. Don't expect to be able to dance to them - I've never played for morris in my life, well a bit for northwest clog nearly forty years ago, I just love them.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118)
Cheers
Martin
-
Hello all
Back on my sainted C/F pokerwork I thought I'd have a go at some morris tunes. Don't expect to be able to dance to them - I've never played for morris in my life, well a bit for northwest clog nearly forty years ago, I just love them.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118)
Cheers
Martin
They're really great Martin. I think morris tunes acquire a new dimension when played without dancers, purely as music to listen to. Many times I've had to bite my lip when playing morris tunes in a pub session only to be told 'That's the wrong speed - you couldn't dance to that'. But nobody's dancing are they? Grrr!
-
Fab! (:)
-
Beautiful, and quite danceable too I'm sure.
I love the key change in the middle of Shooting - it never occured to me you could do that with that tune.
-
Oh, that is just lovely playing! I'm sitting here smiling to myself as I listen. It sound quite danceable to me, I don't know what you're apologising for. Some morris sides might like it a bit slower, but the tunes positively invite dancing, the way you play. Well done!
-
Beautiful playing as always Martin (:) That's the way to do it!
-
I love the key change in the middle of Shooting - it never occured to me you could do that with that tune.
Purely from (possibly faulty) memory - don't they change key in the middle of "Shooting" on "Morris On"?
-
Absolutely wonderful, Martin.
I do not need a CF, I do not need a CF, I do not need a CF.... :-[
-
Classic Ellison. Thanks for sharing. (:) (:) (:)
-
Lovely playing Ellison, I thoroughly enjoyed listening.....now to get my CF out (:)
-
Hello all
Back on my sainted C/F pokerwork I thought I'd have a go at some morris tunes. Don't expect to be able to dance to them - I've never played for morris in my life, well a bit for northwest clog nearly forty years ago, I just love them.
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118 (http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=81118)
Cheers
Martin
Lovely indeed, and an interesting case of parallel evolution on Shooting -- the same drone accompaniment I use when playing for the dance (at least, the first 3 times through), and even exactly the same harmony in the run up in the B music (though I play it all an octave lower).
Obviously a product of good musicianship then, not just playing for dancing ;-)
Ian
-
Sounds fantastic. Listened to that and remembered half the things I was wanting to learn to do on the box. Inspirational, thank you!
-
Nicely played Martin, good and steady and great for dance.
-
Halloo!
Thank you all for these lovely comments. Maybe I should look for a morris team to play for . . .
Martin
-
Do! Just slow down a bit. ;)
-
Thanks Martin - really enjoyed those.
About time for an album I'd say
Simon
-
Just lovely! William and Mary has aye been one of my favourite tunes, and I love your interpretation.
Thanks a million.
-
A lovely rendition, Martin. Crook Morris would love to dance to a slightly slower version of your rendition of William and Nancy. What a pity you don't live closer to Kendal. :(
-
Great playing! Really enjoyed these.
Snozz
-
a bit for northwest clog nearly forty years ago,
Was it really that long ago...?
lovely...
baz
-
OK Baz - 38 years. I did dance longer of course but I only played for about a year.
And while I'm here I'll thank you all again for the nice comments.
Cheers
Martin
-
(to Ollie)
Actually, you do need a CF.
Or possibly an AD or GC?
(must be screechy around your house, all those DG's)
-
(to Ollie)
...
(must be screechy around your house, all those DG's)
You've not heard his fabulous Bâ™/Eâ™ then?
-
I did not even know there was such a thing as a tex-mex 2 row!
-
A quick thread drift - Ollie's Bb/Eb box:
I did hear it when he posted the Bear Dance as a muzurka, and agreed it sounded lovely.
Why were such keys used?
... and also C/F?
I played a really old Erika with wooden sides a few weekends ago, in C/F that had Mr. Rowbotham's magic wand waved over it and I was stunned at the gorgeous sound from it.
But what to do with it in G/D land????.... apart from use it at home I presume.
Back on topic
Martin that was lovely renditions, from tunes I don't dance to, but if you were down here we could look up the dances....!!
nice playing.
Q
-
The Germans (especially Bavarians) and Austrians go in for flat keys because they play a lot with brass instruments (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iKu_9_nM7Rg&feature=related). Typical Steirische Harmonica tunings include G/C/F/Bâ™ and Bâ™/Eâ™/Aâ™/Dâ™/ for the same reason.
C/F are also good keys for many singing voices.
-
That makes sense....
it reminds me I once bumped into an anglo used in conjunction with the brass in the Helson brass band, that was in Bb/..F(?) .
But assumed it was an 'odd' mixture of reeds and brass, never realised it was common in Europe.
Singing to C/F, hmm perhaps that's why it sounded so nice.
Thanks Anahata!
cheers
Q
-
(to Ollie)
Actually, you do need a CF.
Or possibly an AD or GC?
(must be screechy around your house, all those DG's)
I have three DGs (all have different purposes), a Bb/Eb (pride and joy - by far my favourite box), and a GC.
I would love an old Hohner CF to sing with, as it suits my range perfectly, but alas, I am but a poor penniless student.
Donations welcome. ;)
-
(to Ollie)
Actually, you do need a CF.
Or possibly an AD or GC?
(must be screechy around your house, all those DG's)
I have three DGs (all have different purposes), a Bb/Eb (pride and joy - by far my favourite box), and a GC.
I would love an old Hohner CF to sing with, as it suits my range perfectly, but alas, I am but a poor penniless student.
Donations welcome. ;)
As a penniless student you have a difficult choice -- sell your melodeons or sell your body... ;-)
Ian
-
What's so difficult about this choice?
-
What's so difficult about this choice?
The relative value of Ollie's instruments and his body? >:E
Ian
-
Absolutely wonderful, Martin.
I do not need a CF, I do not need a CF, I do not need a CF.... :-[
oh yes you do, oh yes you do, oh yes you do...... ;D
We should start a movement to play in C and F !
-
I don't understand all this agonising between D/G, G/C, C/F, etc. Sell the lot and get a three row, twelve bass box with a D row, a G row and a row of accidentals. That way you can play in almost any key with appropriate basses, whilst retaining the diatonicity and distinctive punchy sound of the melodeon. Simples!
(ducks for cover as he senses the carpet bombing coming his way imminently!)
-
There's a CF Erika or two on ebay.de at the moment. I really must stay away.
That said, I may wait and see what my student loan can afford me. :P
I don't understand all this agonising between D/G, G/C, C/F, etc. Sell the lot and get a three row, twelve bass box with a D row, a G row and a row of accidentals. That way you can play in almost any key with appropriate basses, whilst retaining the diatonicity and distinctive punchy sound of the melodeon. Simples!
(ducks for cover as he senses the carpet bombing coming his way imminently!)
I've been thinking about this for a while, particularly since getting a 2.5 row.
What you say above just doesn't work. OK, you can play all the notes with (mostly) appropriate basses, but what you loose is style, and style is incredibly important with the melodeon. You keep the diatonicity of the home keys, but loose it with others. You loose the essence of what the melodeon is, and it just becomes a very complex chromatic system. You might as well get a CBA or a PA. I'm not saying cross rowing is bad, but too much certainly is.
-
What you say above just doesn't work. OK, you can play all the notes with (mostly) appropriate basses, but what you loose is style, and style is incredibly important with the melodeon. You keep the diatonicity of the home keys, but loose it with others. You loose the essence of what the melodeon is, and it just becomes a very complex chromatic system. You might as well get a CBA or a PA. I'm not saying cross rowing is bad, but too much certainly is.
It is now traditional for George Garside to appear at this point and reminds us that you get the best of both worlds with a B/C/C# + Stradella bass.
Having played such an instrument myself in the past, I can agree to some extent. Certainly a compromise with some of the advantages of both systems.
My conversion from Hohner Gaelic IV to Pokerwork D/G was driven by power-to-weight ratio, though. I've always preferred small(ish) boxes since then.
-
I think Anahata is on to something: the p/w ratio of boxes.
Now we have to get our engineers working: (and who can still remember the Rydberg contstant?)
ergs/kg?
joules/kg?
horsepower-hours/kg? <<<personal favorite
And what box should be the standard?
(I suggest that it be based on a D/G Lilly--ha ha)
-
What you say above just doesn't work. OK, you can play all the notes with (mostly) appropriate basses, but what you loose is style, and style is incredibly important with the melodeon. You keep the diatonicity of the home keys, but loose it with others. You loose the essence of what the melodeon is, and it just becomes a very complex chromatic system. You might as well get a CBA or a PA. I'm not saying cross rowing is bad, but too much certainly is.
It is now traditional for George Garside to appear at this point and reminds us that you get the best of both worlds with a B/C/C# + Stradella bass.
Having played such an instrument myself in the past, I can agree to some extent. Certainly a compromise with some of the advantages of both systems.
My conversion from Hohner Gaelic IV to Pokerwork D/G was driven by power-to-weight ratio, though. I've always preferred small(ish) boxes since then.
A point I always make when that point is made is that a B/C/C# is totally different instrument, and requires a D/G player to learn from scratch. It's a bit like someone recommending a tin whistle player take up the flute!
Plus, I like playing quint/quad boxes. (:)
-
I think Anahata is on to something: the p/w ratio of boxes.
Now we have to get our engineers working: (and who can still remember the Rydberg contstant?)
ergs/kg?
joules/kg?
horsepower-hours/kg? <<<personal favorite
And what box should be the standard?
(I suggest that it be based on a D/G Lilly--ha ha)
Black Pearl II (:)
Steve
-
I don't understand all this agonising between D/G, G/C, C/F, etc. Sell the lot and get a three row, twelve bass box with a D row, a G row and a row of accidentals. That way you can play in almost any key with appropriate basses, whilst retaining the diatonicity and distinctive punchy sound of the melodeon. Simples!
(ducks for cover as he senses the carpet bombing coming his way imminently!)
What you say above just doesn't work. OK, you can play all the notes with (mostly) appropriate basses, but what you lose is style, and style is incredibly important with the melodeon. You keep the diatonicity of the home keys, but loose it with others. You lose the essence of what the melodeon is, and it just becomes a very complex chromatic system. You might as well get a CBA or a PA. I'm not saying cross rowing is bad, but too much certainly is.
I don't accept your statement that it doesn't work, Ollie. It does! Of course, it depends on the 2.5 or 3 row layout you adopt, but my boxes are not chromatic, they are diatonic and remain so even when I play in keys other than G and D.
I can play in C or A minor entirely on the G row except for flicking onto the inside row for the F natural. This is a pulled note, so the sequence is pulled C, pushed D, pulled E, pulled F, pushed G, pulled A, pushed B, pulled C. (I can vary this a bit because of reversals for C, D and E.) The pattern may be different from the push, pull, push, pull, push pull, pull, push of playing along the row in G or D, but the push-pull quality remains and I can play in C in exactly the same style as in G or D. Diatonicity and that distinctive melodeon sound are preserved.
The same is true for A and F# minor, where I can play entirely on the D row, except for a flick across to the inside row for the G# (although on one box I have placed a G# at the dusty end of the D row). F and D minor are played on the G row, flicking onto the inside row for F natural and B flat, and so on.
-
I don't understand all this agonising between D/G, G/C, C/F, etc. Sell the lot and get a three row, twelve bass box with a D row, a G row and a row of accidentals. That way you can play in almost any key with appropriate basses, whilst retaining the diatonicity and distinctive punchy sound of the melodeon. Simples!
(ducks for cover as he senses the carpet bombing coming his way imminently!)
What you say above just doesn't work. OK, you can play all the notes with (mostly) appropriate basses, but what you lose is style, and style is incredibly important with the melodeon. You keep the diatonicity of the home keys, but loose it with others. You lose the essence of what the melodeon is, and it just becomes a very complex chromatic system. You might as well get a CBA or a PA. I'm not saying cross rowing is bad, but too much certainly is.
I don't accept your statement that it doesn't work, Ollie. It does! Of course, it depends on the 2.5 or 3 row layout you adopt, but my boxes are not chromatic, they are diatonic and remain so even when I play in keys other than G and D.
I can play in C or A minor entirely on the G row except for flicking onto the inside row for the F natural. This is a pulled note, so the sequence is pulled C, pushed D, pulled E, pulled F, pushed G, pulled A, pushed B, pulled C. (I can vary this a bit because of reversals for C, D and E.) The pattern may be different from the push, pull, push, pull, push pull, pull, push of playing along the row in G or D, but the push-pull quality remains and I can play in C in exactly the same style as in G or D. Diatonicity and that distinctive melodeon sound are preserved.
The same is true for A and F# minor, where I can play entirely on the D row, except for a flick across to the inside row for the G# (although on one box I have placed a G# at the dusty end of the D row). F and D minor are played on the G row, flicking onto the inside row for F natural and B flat, and so on.
The fact remains that playing in F on a box like that will not sound the same as playing in F on a CF; it won't, and doesn't, have the same style.
-
The fact remains that playing in F on a box like that will not sound the same as playing in F on a CF; it won't, and doesn't, have the same style.
I suppose that depends on your style of playing. For me, there is very little difference, other than not being able to play F natural basses on the push. If I thought that made a significant difference, I would change my basses so that I could. However, we are not going to agree on this one, so we will just have to disagree amicably and pursue our separate paths to Nirvana.
-
DTN's version of Secret Garden/The Newt is a great example of why everyone needs a CF.
Making a similar pitch to Bob Ellis, the old standby Hohner Corona GCF layout does provide a nice 2nd box to the DG.
-
A point I always make when that point is made is that a B/C/C# is totally different instrument, and requires a D/G player to learn from scratch. It's a bit like someone recommending a tin whistle player take up the flute!
Yes, but playing a D/G/accidentals box in keys other than D and G also has to be learned from scratch!
To stretch your analogy a little further, given a tin whistle in D and a requirement to play tunes in any key, do you learn to play the tin whistle in all those keys by half-holing (I know someone who can do this as a party trick) or switch to an instrument that was designed to be fully chromatic?
The melodeon player's usual approach to that is like the typical whistle player's of course: get instruments in more keys!
-
Now about that Bb/Eb.......
-
Blimey - I thought these tunes were more likely to attract the 'dance tunes should be played at dance speed even when they're not being played for a dance' purism (you can tell I heartily disagree with that can't you?).
The second tune of this set is played in Bb on the C/F 2 row, 8 bass. Granted there aren't many basses which fall naturally for this key but that isn't the reason I went for the drone - I just like it.
My opinion: I think I'm just about in Ollie's camp on this one. I've always wanted a box that does everything in every key and I'm sure one can get one but I think that's when it ceases to be a 'melodeon' (ooh, dangerous labelling I know). I've tried and found it uncomfortable and, for me, illogical. I enjoy the forays into the more exotic keys which can be squeezed out of a 2 row without going for that extra row and basses, it's a challenge. I do understand what Bob is saying and it's horses for courses I suppose but from what I've heard of larger, heavier, all bells and whistles boxes they lack the drive and core pure simplicity of a two row. I'm not suggesting that they are trying to be two rows with bits added on, they are different instruments and will be played differently and sound different.
Martin
-
It's very simple - If you want something that you can play in any key, with 'correct' basses, then don't get a melodeon, of any type.
Get a Piano accordion, or full chromatic button key accordion, with a full set of Stradella basses! ;D
-
No, it's not that simple! If you buy a PA or a CBA, you are buying a different instrument with different characteristics and you will be foregoing that distinctive, punchy melodeon sound.
I know it is not everyone's cup of tea, but some of us want to retain that distinctive melodeon sound, whilst playing in a range of keys without having to resort to several different instruments. One perfectly good way of doing that (but not the only one) is to invest in a D/G box with a third row of accidentals and twelve bass buttons.
To say "if you want something that you can play in any key, with 'correct' basses, then don't get a melodeon, of any type," ignores the fact that some of us play three row/twelve bass boxes for precisely that reason. It won't suit everyone, but it works for me and for others I know who have adopted this approach.
-
Brass Nuts in f# ? ;)
-
Brass Nuts in f# ? ;)
I will if you will! >:E
-
;D
-
I think Anahata is on to something: the p/w ratio of boxes.
Now we have to get our engineers working: (and who can still remember the Rydberg contstant?)
ergs/kg?
joules/kg?
horsepower-hours/kg? <<<personal favorite
And what box should be the standard?
(I suggest that it be based on a D/G Lilly--ha ha)
Black Pearl II (:)
Steve
I think you will struggle to beat the p/w of a well fettled Hohner Preciosa :)
Andy
-
To stretch your analogy a little further, given a tin whistle in D and a requirement to play tunes in any key, do you learn to play the tin whistle in all those keys by half-holing (I know someone who can do this as a party trick) or switch to an instrument that was designed to be fully chromatic?
My wife is a pretty good woodwind player and can play almost any tune in any key on a well made (Tony Dixon) D whistle. It's not easy at all but it can be done, and not as a party piece. Flute was her main instrument but she loves recorders too. Whistles she sees as the crippled children of proper musical instruments but delights in making them sing ...
-
Tradition = Nailing butterflies to a board
-
Tradition = Nailing butterflies to a board
Not so. Traditional music always moves on but the main theme remains. Nailing butterflies to boards is the province of the obsessed and has nothing at all to with the living tradition. It's a good analogy that proves that generation after generation of musicians appreciate a good tune and strive to keep it alive!