Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: smiley on January 30, 2012, 10:02:13 PM
-
I know I need to lose weight, but I've got this other problem that I hope will be much easier to solve:
My D/G Sandpiper has a disconcerting habit of popping a button off the G row sometimes when I'm playing energetically. Not just the one button but any random button which will suddenly fly off during a session. It gets a good laugh, but last weekend it happened in a big session and I was lucky to retrieve it in the darkness.
I'm thinking about using superglue to stick them on permanently, but I'd like to ask if this could be a problem in the future. Is there a scenario where I might need to take the buttons off for repairs etc?
-
How are the buttons attached? Screw in, glue on, or on the end of a steel rod?
-
The buttons are pushed on to steel rods. I just push them back on again after they've popped off.
-
Castagnari do the same - we spent quite a bit of last Friday's session trying to find one white button on the floor. Though this might have been in revenge for searching for my right hearing aid the week before, which I'd never actually had in that night. :|bl
-
I would use Gorilla glue or Epoxy. Just a tiny bit. SuperGlue does not "fill" and may not work well.
-
With epoxy it will definitely never come off, even with heat!
-
Is that a good thing or a bad thing Theo ?
Roland
-
Obviously depends on whether they need to come for for any reason. I would favour something less permanent, pva, contact adhesive or superglue for example.
-
How long have you had it? It may be worth taking it back to where you bought it.
Even if this is a common trait among Sandpipers (I've no idea if it is or not) the fact that the buttons pop off means that the instrument could be deemed unfit for purpose.
-
How long have you had it? It may be worth taking it back to where you bought it.
Even if this is a common trait among Sandpipers (I've no idea if it is or not) the fact that the buttons pop off means that the instrument could be deemed unfit for purpose.
Unfortunately I live about 17,000 kms away from where I bought it, which rules out dropping in for a chat (:)
I did ask that nice fellow Jon Loomes via email if he could send over a spare button to me, but that didn't happen.
Looks like a dab of superglue might be the best option now.
-
Another option may be some PTFE tape wrapped around the rod which the button sits on. It might make the fit a bit tighter and wouldn't involve glue. You could try it on just one first and see if it worked.
-
Didn't someone once recommend Loctite?
Baz
-
I would be careful using super glue as it could react with the button and turn out to be a disaster
I would research this further. ???
-
Your best bet would be a semi-permanent "breakable" wood glue, such as is used on violins.
-
Your best bet would be a semi-permanent "breakable" wood glue, such as is used on violins.
Violin glue needs heat to undo it. If it's a plastic button you need to compare the melting points of button and glue...
-
I would be careful using super glue as it could react with the button and turn out to be a disaster
My experience of superglue is that it is much less likely to cause serious damage to plastics than is a solvent based glue where the solvents can cause softening. In any case I would not worry because the quantity of glue you need is minute, it should get nowhere near the visible surface of the button and I'll repeat my advice to basically just use whatever is handy, but preferably not epoxy unless you want the joint to be completely permanent.
Your best bet would be a semi-permanent "breakable" wood glue, such as is used on violins.
Can't agree with that either. Hide glue does not bond well with non-porous materials like metal or hard plastic. It might help if you have nothing else available.
-
Didn't someone once recommend Loctite?
Loctite make a number of different "glues" for different purposes, but many of them fall within the superglue family.
Rob.
-
Hide glue does not bond well with non-porous materials like metal or hard plastic. It might help if you have nothing else available.
I don't really think this is entirely true. It binds so well to glass it will chip it.
-
If you glue your buttons on make sure you don't take them all off and get them mixed up, or individual differences in buttons will result in a row of buttons of varying heights. Of course any sensible person would only work on one button at a time. Please don't ask me how I know this.
-
If you have patience, chewing gum may work! It sticks well to most surfaces, it can fill gaps, it is not permanent, but it needs a few days to harden...
-
No! That's only for bomber petrol tanks! :|bl
-
If you have patience, chewing gum may work! It sticks well to most surfaces, it can fill gaps, it is not permanent, but it needs a few days to harden...
But does it lose it's flavour in the bed post overnight? ;D
-
Well our Sandpiper buttons have popped off quite a few times and on my mates Sandpiper too. Took ours back to the Music Room who applied superglue. Now the metal wire under the air button has snapped, this is after two years of intensive playing , shared between two people playing pretty much every day. Gonna phone the Music Room tomorrow. Love the Sandpiper but could do without these issues...
-
shared between two people playing pretty much every day. Gonna phone the Music Room tomorrow. Love the Sandpiper but could do without these issues...
The Sandpiper may have been commissioned by the Music room but It`s still a Chinese box made from Chinese bits which costs much the same as a Chinese made Erica , I`d say it`s done very well given the hammer its had over that period . I`d bet a Chinese Erica or pokerwork wouldn`t have held up any better .
-
Yeah, it's been hammered allright (in the best possible way) Last time we took it to Cleckheaton we were told it was the most played Sandpiper he'd ever seen, due to the large patch of erased varnish on the bass cabinet were hands had rubbed it away. Was quite proud of that actually...
-
Interesting that you're losing varnish. My best box (a Castagnari) has a semi-matt finish and the points where my hands are always touching it have become highly polished! Actually, a lot of open canoeists insist that a paddle grip should not be varnished, it only causes blisters and the hand polishes it anyway.
Rob.
-
contact adhesive +1 from me (:)
-
There are a LOT of different types of "super glue" available now days. Hobby stores should have several available. I recommend the thick "gap filling" type as it won't run, and fills in imperfections in the joint. You can release it later from the metal arm by heating the arm with a soldering iron while you pull the button if you need to. Give it about 20 min to fully set.
I ran into a lot of these glues in the 80's when I worked for Seagate doing hard drive testing.
There is even a black rubberized flexible version.