Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on January 31, 2012, 11:41:18 AM
-
I've been remiss and haven't really practiced in a while now. Feel like I've plateaued again.
Any suggestions for making practice more interesting rather than just perfunctory?
Maybe its just that I've lost the feeling of 'challenge'?
-
Sounds completely normal to me. Give yourself a break, leave the box sitting around somewhere reasonably handy and listen to some great new melodeon music! You will soon be ready to pick up your instrument again (:)
-
Would agree to give yourself a break - don't beat yourself up over this. If you'd like a kickstart you could try just listening to music - any kind you enjoy - classical, blues,
G & S, hip-hop anything. Maybe some melodies will return to haunt you and you could try to pick them out, have fun adapting them etc.(And if they don't you will have enjoyed the listen!)
-
Don't think of it as practice.
-
Sarah, this may well not be the answer you are looking for but, you seem to be learning:
- melodeon
- anglo concertina
- fiddle
- clog dancing
- lindy hop
Plus you do sewing/garment design and are involved in a largish number of internet forums/facebook/etc.
Maybe you are spreading yourself to thinly and not achieving as much as you might wish in the individual pursuits. Maybe you need a smaller number of targets in your life?
Like I said not maybe the message you were looking for, but I have more life experience than some (ie I am on old git).
-
When I get fed up I switch to another style: Cajun, French, East Anglian. I find the different styles give different challenges. When I get REALLY fed up I go to the pub and play pool or shoot clay pigeons (not in the pub!). A complete rest from the box can sometimes be a good thing.
-
LdT: I've been remiss too
Both daughters been up to their eyes in various exams, whilst I'm chewing the end of the door itching to get playing.
I get ' not now dad, I'm working....' shouted from various parts of the house when a tune starts.
which is fair enough.... and ( working ) being a minor miracle in itself ::)
but it makes me kee to get back!
Q
-
Sometimes having a reason to practice or a target helps e.g. I need to have half a dozen tunes to play really well at the session on.... or I am going to lead the playing for a dance by..... arrange for a date to play a set of tunes some tunes with some friends etc. Practice for the sake of practice can easily become tedious.
-
Totally agree Ray.
I started a monthly acoustic music session in my local pub. It's well attended with a wide variety of instruments.
I'm one of the less accomplished musicians there, but everybody is very encouraging and supportive.
It makes me practice and think about what to play and how to play it.
Gets slightly easier everytime I play in public.
-
Pubic playing can be a very good incentive.
-
Yes it really is a good incentive to practice, but one has to keep a sense of perspective.
My take on it is, I try my best (which is very variable) but I don't let a less than perfect rendition worry me.
I'm just trying to play a tune to the best of my ability, not trying to cure cancer!
-
Pubic playing can be a very good incentive.
not when you get to my age
-
Pubic playing can be a very good incentive.
not when you get to my age
Or if you're Nick Walden, sitting on the edge of the bath ;-)
-
Pubic playing can be a very good incentive.
As well as recording yourself and listening to your playing! Makes you realize how good or bad your playing is, and what needs to be improved.
As Lester mentioned, sometimes trying to master too many things leads to not being good at any... It's nice to have your hands on many instruments or activities, but since there are so many hours one can dedicate to each activity, you may have to decide which instrument you would like to be "good" at playing, and stick to it.
-
I know I ought to know who Nick Walder is, but I don't. Please help repair my ignorance. :|bl
-
I am wary of using the word 'practice' as it has connotations of 'hard work' & is also associated with doing it on set days for set periods of time i.e ana hour on sunday. Grandma or Aunty FAnny comes to tea and that puts paid to practice untill next sunday and so on!
I think the notion of enjoying playing at every opportunity is far more encouraging
george ;D :|||: :||: and then :|glug
-
I am wary of using the word 'practice' as it has connotations of 'hard work' & is also associated with doing it on set days for set periods of time i.e ana hour on sunday. Grandma or Aunty FAnny comes to tea and that puts paid to practice untill next sunday and so on!
I think the notion of enjoying playing at every opportunity is far more encouraging
george ;D :|||: :||: and then :|glug
I'd agree, and the playing can take different forms. It could be a general bit of noodling and messing about, it might be exploring some musical conundrum to do with the basses or row crossing, it might be playing some new tunes that you're polishing up or a much more directed session learning specific things for a band, performance or session.
As for the main question. I have to say ... if you want the challenges, then you will create them for yourself. If you want to play, then you will find reasons and opportunity.
-
I draw a distinction between practicing and playing.
Playing is what I do for fun and yes mine is pretty plateaued out most of the time and I don't mind. Practicing is what I do when I have a specific goal in mind, not just "playing better" but, as in my current case, for example adding bass runs or learning blues scales. I play a lot more than I practice and whilst I try to keep accurate etc I'm not going to beat myself up and start again every mistake. In practice time I play with a drum machine and I do restart all the time. Different mindset, different goals.
Strange though, whenever I have a serious practice my playing seems to get a bit better as well (:)
Steve
-
I think there's an important point here.
I practise 'the new tune' I'm learning, whatever that is, then break away for a little while and play for enjoyment, retuning if time allows for another practise.
Sometimes I find I grab a few minutes, often quiet playing because it's later in the evening, which ends up noodling and I often discover things! I find occasional noodling is a useful distraction because you never know where it'll lead.
I often find a snatch of a tune simply happens and comes out of the box, which is often an indication of the next tune I should look at, cos there's a bit of it already been subliminally inserted in my head.
Q
-
Grandma or Aunty FAnny comes to tea and that puts paid to practice untill next sunday and so on!
george ;D :|||: :||: and then :|glug
I actually did have a Great Auntie Fanny, but I don't remember her ever coming to tea on a Sunday (she would have been at Chapel) so I didn't have that excuse! :D
-
Apologies for my ignorance over St Nick Walden! I didn't know his name (don't dance much outside Yorkshire) and thought he was a "Celebritee". My sincere apologies also to Nick Walden, sir! :Ph :|bl :|bl
-
[snip] I didn't know his name (don't dance much outside Yorkshire) and thought he was a "Celebritee".
Now you've REALLY done it! >:E
Malcolm
-
I agree with those who say just forget about practice for a bit. Just play whatever you really enjoy playing - new tunes, old tunes, tunes you know you're rubbish at ... There's nobody listening, so just have fun. Nothing you do is wasted - even playing old favourites helps to keep the finger-patterns in your brain, and some of those not combinations will crop up again in new tunes.
Then at some point you'll find yourself repeating a bit that keeps going wrong, or wondering about a different bass chord at some point, and before you know it you're actually moving on and learning new things again. But don't try too hard, just let it happen.
-
Try a new challenge - like playing Atholl Highlanders in A ! ;)
-
I Then at some point you'll find yourself repeating a bit that keeps going wrong, or wondering about a different bass chord at some point, and before you know it you're actually moving on and learning new things again. But don't try too hard, just let it happen.
And don't waste time agonising over playing the box/or a particular tune 'correctly' . Most traditional tunes have many so called 'correct' versions and the same goes for bass on what may haave started life as fiddle, pipe or whatever tunes. Same often goes for printed versions - they are frequently an individuals or bands arranagement of 'traditional' tunes . So use them if you partiularly want to play a particular version - otherwise feel free to experiment till you get it to sound 'good but not necessarily precisely 'correct'
Also don't agonise over 'correct' fingering there aint any! - some play with 3 fingers , others 4 and indeed many tunes can be played with only one! just find a way that works WELLfor you!
george - looking forward with interest/trepidation to the responses of those who disagree! ;)
-
Try a new challenge - like playing Atholl Highlanders in A ! ;)
I've always played it in A!
-
Try a new challenge - like playing Atholl Highlanders in A ! ;)
Playing in A on a DG box can be both interesting & satisfying & can sometimes give one the edge in smartarseness! Scottish pipe marches lend themselves well as they are G#less. Try easy ones eg cock of the north& 100 pipers One of my favourites is 79th farewell to Gibralter which I only play in A.
Roxburgh castle is useful to learn as the G shaarp needs attending to ( I substiture the G natural on G row). Winster gallop is more difficult to fake but can be 'sort of' faked by using the accidental G sharp on first button even though it is in the wrong octave. Those with a row of accidentals should be able to cope easily especialy if they have 2 G#'s available.
Pikey has called it a 'new challenge' beware it can develop into a 'lifelong challenge'!
george
-
Try a new challenge - like playing Atholl Highlanders in A ! ;)
I've always played it in A!
Me too, it sounds far better and fiddlers love it once they've cottoned on...
-
I don't like playing in A even on the fiddle...it gives me a headache. :P
-
With a standard 2 row, 8 bass box with accidentals, A is the only key you can play AH in properly. Sounds so much better though. The only people I've found it annoys is other melodeon players, who seem to insist on playing it in D. ???
-
you can annoy them even more with a BCC# by nipping into Ab - A rare but strangely enjoyable bit of smartarsing!
george ;D
-
With a standard 2 row, 8 bass box with accidentals, A is the only key you can play AH in properly.
You beat me to it Ollie.
-
Tune of Some Month? :-*
-
Pubic playing can be a very good incentive.
Wow! I don't think I'll try it though ;)
-
Hahaha! Am I the only person to notice the 'l' missing here, or is 'pubic playing' some sort of known practise strategy over there?
-
Hahaha! Am I the only person to notice the 'l' missing here, or is 'pubic playing' some sort of known practise strategy over there?
No, Ian's mention of Nick Walden was a cryptic reference to an incident in which Nick discovered the hard way that it's better to play a melodeon when fully clothed...
-
ah, glad to see that I am not the only dirty minded melnetter to have a joke about it then!
-
Hahaha! Am I the only person to notice the 'l' missing here, or is 'pubic playing' some sort of known practise strategy over there?
No, Ian's mention of Nick Walden was a cryptic reference to an incident in which Nick discovered the hard way that it's better to play a melodeon when fully clothed...
"...the hard way..." -- wish I'd thought of that ;-)
-
Naughty boy! :|bl
-
try playing behind your back, can be an interersting spectacle 8)
-
Try a new challenge - like playing Atholl Highlanders in A ! ;)
I've always played it in A!
Yes, I don't think I've ever heard (and certainly never played) The Atholl Highlanders played in anything other than A.
-
What do you play it in Pikey? ;)
-
And don't waste time agonising over playing the box/or a particular tune 'correctly' . Most traditional tunes have many so called 'correct' versions .................
george ;)
;D you must have heard the Whitby Scratch Morris Band, we only meet for the week of the Folk Festival ... :||: :|glug :M :|||: .... we all play the same tunes ...... but with slight variations depending on when, where and from which side we learnt it. The trick is to keep in time, in the same key and smiling, then the audience thinks it's a posh arrangement ;) ;D
-
What do you play it in Pikey? ;)
A pub........ ;)
-
And don't waste time agonising over playing the box/or a particular tune 'correctly' . Most traditional tunes have many so called 'correct' versions .................
george ;)
;D you must have heard the Whitby Scratch Morris Band, we only meet for the week of the Folk Festival ... :||: :|glug :M :|||: .... we all play the same tunes ...... but with slight variations depending on when, where and from which side we learnt it. The trick is to keep in time, in the same key and smiling, then the audience thinks it's a posh arrangement ;) ;D
Is Whitby Scratch contagious, and can you get a cream for it? >:E
-
When I get stuck I start noodling around with the blues scale that Chris Ryall introduced to. That usually relaxes me and gets my brain thinking and I find that I switch from there to alternative fingerings and back to traditional tunee. It also leads to some interesting diversions like a version of Canal in October where the only push notes are the "D"s.
Steve
-
Is Whitby Scratch contagious, and can you get a cream for it? >:E
It's not as bad as Boxcar Willy.
-
Is Whitby Scratch contagious, and can you get a cream for it? >:E
It's not as bad as Boxcar Willy.
;)