Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: OldJack on February 09, 2012, 07:22:49 AM

Title: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: OldJack on February 09, 2012, 07:22:49 AM
I'm new to the melodeon and while fiddling around with an Ariette's stops it occurred to me that maybe the stops could be set in different keys such as C, D, G, F, or whatever. Maybe that would just be faking a series of concertinas and I haven't a clue what to do with the bass. Just a thought from an Anglo concertina player trying to do a melodeon. I can't believe someone hasn't already tried, or done, this. I wonder at the result? ???

Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Anahata on February 09, 2012, 07:51:32 AM
First as you have observed the basses won't work in other keys.
Second, for me the whole point of a 1 row box is the sound of the LMMH four voice tuning. Most players keep all 4 stops out the whole time for that reason.

Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Theo on February 09, 2012, 08:14:50 AM
I have seen a small number of one-row boxes where one row is a third or a fifth above the rest so as to provide a kind of harmony.  Hohner even made a special model the Terzett which has one set of reeds a major third above the home key.  There is a recent example on ebay (http://www.ebay.de/itm/330684606195),
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2012, 09:30:22 AM
What about a 'digital' one row...then you could change tuning at touch of a button?
I've always said if someone did that I'd buy one.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: dahlberg on February 09, 2012, 12:54:13 PM
There are russian accordions who have a register a 5:th above, sounds a little strange. On the other hand, a lot of tekno synts use this and it sounds oki.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Anahata on February 09, 2012, 01:48:14 PM
What about a 'digital' one row...then you could change tuning at touch of a button?
I've always said if someone did that I'd buy one.

You might be able to persuade Steve Rouse to make a 1 row Streb...
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2012, 02:12:32 PM
What about a 'digital' one row...then you could change tuning at touch of a button?
I've always said if someone did that I'd buy one.

You might be able to persuade Steve Rouse to make a 1 row Streb...
I *like* that comment.

Although if it had half the rows would it be half the price? lol!
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Anahata on February 09, 2012, 02:33:57 PM
Although if it had half the rows would it be half the price? lol!
No, so you might as well get the standard 2.5 row, use a MIDI patch that sounds like a 4 stop one-row and ignore the extra keys.

(Question for Streb owners: does it have a 4-top 1-row sound available?)
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: ladydetemps on February 09, 2012, 02:37:53 PM
Although if it had half the rows would it be half the price? lol!
No, so you might as well get the standard 2.5 row, use a MIDI patch that sounds like a 4 stop one-row and ignore the extra keys.

(Question for Streb owners: does it have a 4-top 1-row sound available?)

I want it to *be* a one row in shape not just sound like a one row. ;) 2.5rows really doesn't appeal to me.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Lester on February 09, 2012, 02:46:35 PM
Although if it had half the rows would it be half the price? lol!
No, so you might as well get the standard 2.5 row, use a MIDI patch that sounds like a 4 stop one-row and ignore the extra keys.

(Question for Streb owners: does it have a 4-top 1-row sound available?)


Mine had a Hohner 1 Row sample sound, but unfortunately it was the least convincing, not I think due to the sample but to the dynamics of the box. John Spiers had a two row 4 voice  Saltarelle which should have sounded like two 1 rows but it just didn't. Think it is to do with the size of the bellows etc?
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Morrisbox on February 09, 2012, 05:08:58 PM
Quote
Mine had a Hohner 1 Row sample sound, but unfortunately it was the least convincing, not I think due to the sample but to the dynamics of the box. John Spiers had a two row 4 voice  Saltarelle which should have sounded like two 1 rows but it just didn't. Think it is to do with the size of the bellows etc

I got my brand new Streb just before Christmas, and I'd have to agree with Lester's comments, doesn't somehow have single row "bite".   That said, it's a fun instrument; I'm currently using it to play along with my wife's Northumbrian bagpipes in their "original" F#-ish tuning.  Fantastic!   ;D
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Matthew B on February 09, 2012, 06:26:40 PM
Back to the OP: Here's the thread that leads to (some of?) the other threads where this is discussed http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5890.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5890.0.html)
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Andy in Vermont on February 10, 2012, 11:02:25 AM
I'm new to the melodeon and while fiddling around with an Ariette's stops it occurred to me that maybe the stops could be set in different keys such as C, D, G, F, or whatever. Maybe that would just be faking a series of concertinas and I haven't a clue what to do with the bass. Just a thought from an Anglo concertina player trying to do a melodeon. I can't believe someone hasn't already tried, or done, this. I wonder at the result? ???

There was a Cajun builder who did something like that -- he built a one-row with 6 stops, so he got 3 voices in each of two keys.  (At which point, why not have two rows of buttons so at least all the notes are accessible at once? Oh, that's just a two-row, three voice box...)  He actually got a patent, which has, I believe, expired by now.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Ash on February 10, 2012, 01:04:24 PM
I'm new to the melodeon and while fiddling around with an Ariette's stops it occurred to me that maybe the stops could be set in different keys such as C, D, G, F, or whatever. Maybe that would just be faking a series of concertinas and I haven't a clue what to do with the bass. Just a thought from an Anglo concertina player trying to do a melodeon. I can't believe someone hasn't already tried, or done, this. I wonder at the result? ???

There was a Cajun builder who did something like that -- he built a one-row with 6 stops, so he got 3 voices in each of two keys.  (At which point, why not have two rows of buttons so at least all the notes are accessible at once? Oh, that's just a two-row, three voice box...)  He actually got a patent, which has, I believe, expired by now.

Was it made by Hyde, the Australian box maker? I seem to recall something made by them. Though I might be confused...
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Matthew B on February 10, 2012, 02:53:51 PM
There was a Cajun builder who did something like that -- he built a one-row with 6 stops, so he got 3 voices in each of two keys. 

Randy Falcon, of Duson, LA.  He's a heck of a nice guy, and a good Cajun builder.  I have a very nice one-row he made me about 20 years ago.  His son Wade posts here sometimes. The crowd-sourced wisdom of Melnet seems fairly consistently to be that dual-key melodeons are a bit of a waste of time.  Certainly for English players the solution to the two-key problem seems to be the two-row melodeon.  However, if I recall correctly Randy's boxes were intended to address the question of trickier key combinations, at least they'd be trickier for quint system two-row players.  He built quite a few two-key one-rows that allowed players to switch between C and Bb, or C and D.  Apparently these key switches are popular amongst Cajun players.  When I ordered my box from him he tried hard to convince me to let him build me a two-key instrument.  Or a left-handed instrument.  Or anything out of the ordinary.  I get the impression that he likes to color outside the lines a bit.  And while his innovations may not suit the needs of this community, I think it's great that there are builders out there who are experimenting with the instrument.

Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Quebecois on February 10, 2012, 06:21:50 PM
I'm new to the melodeon and while fiddling around with an Ariette's stops it occurred to me that maybe the stops could be set in different keys such as C, D, G, F, or whatever.
You just realized that the 1-row is a limited instrument! So, the next step would be to learn to make the most of it, instead of imagining ways to "improve" it.

Listen to those 1-row players, Cajun, Québécois, and others, and you will have a sense of what can be done with only 10 buttons, and how to squeeze (pun intended) tunes played in other keys, playing "backwards" or using scales in different modes.

Have fun!



Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: melodeon on February 11, 2012, 04:47:40 AM
Falcon I believe is of Spanish linega, not Cajun.
The patent ran out.
I spoke with the patent office ,and the very same official who approevd the patent. He said, had he known the facts about key switching and that it predated Falcon, the patent would not have been issued. What has not been made public is that Falcon's patent actually included the very basic 10 button accordeon. Yup. In  spite of its original patent around 1829.
They had many calls from accordeon builders objectingto the issuance of the patent. Some from very animated Cajun builders.
Falcon's patent was pushed by and co authored by a Louisiana university. One of the reasons for the approval.
According to sources, Falcon;s attorney's were very aggresive in defending the patent.

The patent office said that they would have initiated a process toward reversal of the patent had someone come up with the approximate $2355 filing fee. As fate would have it.. the 2 approving officials retired before that happened.

All the above, FYI

I have a copy of the patent in front of me.


Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: old geezer on February 11, 2012, 06:18:07 AM

     just realized that the 1-row is a limited instrument! So, the next step would be to learn to make the most alter some of it,


here are pics of 2 HA114's that have been converted to 2 keys of G & D MM voice.

the first pic is manual key change by operating the stops at either end
the treble middle 2 'stops up' with the outside '2 stops down' and the bass 'stop down' has the "G" reeds selected
whilst the treble outside '2 stops up' with the middle '2 stops down' and the bass 'stop up' has the "D" reeds selected

the 2nd and 3rd pics are the internals of another HA114 and have the same keys (G or D) MM reeds, key change is by 2 levers, one on the edge of the treble keyboard and the other above the 'air spoon', these are operated by either thumbs
(I seem to have deleted the pics of the levers of this melodeon)
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Theo on February 11, 2012, 02:36:55 PM
Very ingenious, but what is the point exactly?  Why not just get a two row?
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 11, 2012, 02:47:28 PM
Very ingenious, but what is the point exactly?  Why not just get a two row?
Just what I was thinking...
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Quebecois on February 11, 2012, 02:58:37 PM
Very ingenious, but what is the point exactly?  Why not just get a two row?
Just what I was thinking...
Back to my point! One row: learn to live with it!
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Christopher K. on February 11, 2012, 05:26:15 PM
Very ingenious, but what is the point exactly?  Why not just get a two row?
Just what I was thinking...

Going back to what Lester mentioned earlier, I've found the tone and response from the HA-114, in all keys, even the lower ones, is different than a one-row or two-row 'Vienna' style accordion. You can handle the thing differently, and the open-faced design just pours the sound right out in the open. It's very powerful with mucho character. 

So the big question: Instead of trying to cram two one-row accordions into a single one-row accordion, is there a 'German' style two-row accordion that handles and sounds like a 'German' style one-row? For instance I've seen old two-row 'German' style Hohners and Internationals -- they look like your typical one-row but have two rows. I've never played one that old, but I'd like to know how they compare. I think Eric Martin is building something similar? The other alternative is to make a better gasket or method of bellows attachment so changing reed blocks for a new key is fast and easy without compromising the seal. I think the old method of transverse screws, or those latch mechanisms like Koch was using, was a better idea which lapsed in favor of bellows pins which do nothing to maintain the pressure of the cabinet against the bellows. Maybe a topic for another thread.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: OldJack on February 12, 2012, 04:51:41 AM
I do appreciate all the comments, they really help me learn. So, what about a one and a half row? I saw one on the Internet. The builder is, I think, in Quebec. A really pretty machine. The extra half row gives the accidentals. I think that's good, for me. I don't recall the voices, or stops. It never occurred to me that two rows would diminish the sound. On the other hand, maybe a BC would be good for blues. Anyone do blues on a BC?

Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: Mike Hirst on February 14, 2012, 02:31:02 AM
I'd love to have a go on one of these:

http://youtu.be/1TtwSPU5pCk (http://youtu.be/1TtwSPU5pCk)

From the diagram below the vid it looks like the layout has mixolydian scales in G, C, F, Bb and Eb. I figure with this tuning you could play pipe tunes in five keys.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: blafleur on February 15, 2012, 02:08:06 AM
A bit of new trivia on Mr. Falcon.  He is now making a 3 key 6 stop box that sounds amazingly like it has at least 3 voices, but I can't figure out how.  Practical purpose? No idea, other than Randy likes a challenge.
Title: Re: One Row, different keys on each stop
Post by: falcanary on February 20, 2012, 04:05:57 AM
Hey Bryan and others,...

Yes, he has finished his 3-key, 6 stop, 1-row accordion sometime back.  He's had some success and some awkwardness with the 3 key in a 1-row design.  Mainly with working on even volume and tone.  While it's not for every player, he realizes some may request having one.    No, there is no patent on this 3-key configuration.

Yes, the 2-key, 1-row (dual pitched melodeon: http://www.google.com/patents/US5111726) U.S. patent expired some time back ago, with several experimenters duplicating his design so far. 

If you have any questions, let me know and i'll try to answer what I can.

WF
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal