Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ray Langton on February 12, 2012, 02:09:34 PM

Title: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Ray Langton on February 12, 2012, 02:09:34 PM
At Cheltenham Fest this weekend I picked up a Black Diamond G/D melodeon from the Black Diamond stall and was very pleasantly surprised. made in China but with Italian reeds it handled well and sounded great. At £400.00 this looks seriously good value. My only gripe is the stand had their full set of accordeons in tasteful black finish, but the melodeon was red finish. Why do they do that? If you are interested their website is www.blackdiamondaccordeons.com (http://www.blackdiamondaccordeons.com)
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Lester on February 12, 2012, 02:20:46 PM
At Cheltenham Fest this weekend I picked up a Black Diamond G/D melodeon from the Black Diamond stall and was very pleasantly surprised. made in China but with Italian reeds it handled well and sounded great. At £400.00 this looks seriously good value. My only gripe is the stand had their full set of accordeons in tasteful black finish, but the melodeon was red finish. Why do they do that? If you are interested their website is www.blackdiamondaccordeons.com (http://www.blackdiamondaccordeons.com)

The link is bust try this one

http://www.blackdiamondaccordions.com/ (http://www.blackdiamondaccordions.com/)
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Mike Hirst on February 14, 2012, 02:47:09 AM
Good looking accordions + attractive prices. Put me in mind of the Guy Clark song Black Diamond Strings (http://youtu.be/og7dMS-nyqA).
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: derekw on February 14, 2012, 09:04:40 AM
the stand had their full set of accordeons in tasteful black finish, but the melodeon was red finish. 



Their site says red only a prototype. Stock will be black
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: dahlberg on February 14, 2012, 11:34:01 AM
Looks like Aidi. Propaply same.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: TomB on February 14, 2012, 01:33:32 PM
Looks like Aidi. Propaply same.

Thought they were dogs?
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: dahlberg on February 14, 2012, 01:49:38 PM
http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTE_z4jhMmpV74_HgB8iJy3sCbKNh6o0xTSByt7mIfxzfqeuGtS (http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTE_z4jhMmpV74_HgB8iJy3sCbKNh6o0xTSByt7mIfxzfqeuGtS)
What do i know?
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Theo on February 14, 2012, 02:17:26 PM
http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTE_z4jhMmpV74_HgB8iJy3sCbKNh6o0xTSByt7mIfxzfqeuGtS (http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTE_z4jhMmpV74_HgB8iJy3sCbKNh6o0xTSByt7mIfxzfqeuGtS)
What do i know?

They look like the generic Chinese two row box that appears under a whole range of brand names.   Italian reeds will be an improvement, but what about the typical Chinese stiff bellows and stodgy mechanisms?
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Andrew Culwell on February 14, 2012, 11:55:14 PM
Excalibur is one that supposedly has Italian reeds, haven't heard anything about them but see them on ebay all the time.  It won't be long before the Chinese are manufacturing nice accordions, I have some late model Chinese watches by Seagull that are fine pieces particularly for the money, while they don't have the Swiss detailing they are nice watches. 

Perhaps the Chinese will take the Japanese path of taking a design and doing it better for cheaper.  Not saying that this is good but it's inevitable.  I don't think they will rival Castelfidardo but they will try!
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pipives on February 18, 2012, 07:58:38 PM
Excalibur is one that supposedly has Italian reeds, haven't heard anything about them but see them on ebay all the time.  It won't be long before the Chinese are manufacturing nice accordions, I have some late model Chinese watches by Seagull that are fine pieces particularly for the money, while they don't have the Swiss detailing they are nice watches. 

Perhaps the Chinese will take the Japanese path of taking a design and doing it better for cheaper.  Not saying that this is good but it's inevitable.  I don't think they will rival Castelfidardo but they will try!

I've seen inside two excaliburs and both have had cagnoni reeds in them. Actions and bellows were very stiff though. I'm sure it's only a matter of time......
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Mike Averill on June 24, 2012, 09:18:46 PM
I played one today at Leigh on Sea. Quite a respectable box, not stiff in any way. Tuning was middle of the road, not swing but not Hohner wet. It played well and in tune over the whole range including the upper octaves.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Martyn on July 08, 2012, 10:31:03 PM
I spent some time putting one to the test at ECMW and I must say for the price I was very impressed. The keyboard had a nice feel, the action was light, the Cagnoni reeds were very responsive and the bellows not at all stiff. Generally the box felt like it was well put together. My only criticism is with the left hand which seemed a little bit rattly to me... although nothing that couldn't be easily remedied.
I currently have a Black Diamond 30-key anglo concertina in the workshop for appraisal and a 72-bass piano accordion visiting some time next week.

Martyn

PS The melodeon I tried was black.. 
Title: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Black Diamond on July 25, 2012, 11:23:48 AM
Thank you for that, Martyn et al. Thought it was high time we joined mel.net, assuming you'll have us, coming over from the dark side of chromatics!

Reaction to our G/D box has been universally favourable when it has been played at festivals, but I thought it would be helpful to answer some of the questions higher up this thread.

Firstly, the colour! Yes, the prototype came in red, which made us groan, but strangely it delivered differing opinions. Our mission was to set out as the Henry Ford of the budget accordion market, but when we reluctantly pulled it out from under the counter at Cheltenham, a bit like Lance Corporal Jones' sausages, the morris players loved it, but demanded we also supplied it in red! So we put in an order on the strength of reaction at that one festival, 75% in black, 25% in red. Those instruments are now in stock, and selling worryingly fast, as new orders take ages to manufacture and ship, and we're worrying about stocks lasting through Sidmouth and Whitby.

About the 'generic' Chinese manufacture of accordions, whilst it was an opinion I subscribed to, since I have visited the country and talked to different manufacturers, it became obvious to me that quality varies, and to generalise would be the same as describing Italian cars as 'generic', and whilst most Chinese free reed manufacturers could be judged to be at the Fiat end, and we haven't found a Lamborghini yet, we are confident we have found the Alfa (hopefully without the breakdowns!).

As Martyn alluded, we are looking at a G/C anglo concertina at the moment, and an initial order looks imminent, so hopefully we'll have that model in during the autumn.

Other than that, we're at Warwick (with its forecast for rain  :( ) this weekend, we'll be at Sidmouth all week if anyone would like to drop by and have a play of the G/D melodeon, and we also have some B/C boxes on order, expected in mid September. As I am currently chairman of Mersea Week regatta, we can't make Whitby, which runs concurrently, but my old mate Bill Sables has agreed to run our BDA stand there (Do you remember me buying that little 60 bass Hohner from you, Theo, it was Bill that broked that deal!)

Hopefully, we'll see you somewhere!

All the best
Greg Dunn
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pgroff on July 25, 2012, 06:15:35 PM

Reaction to our G/D box has been universally favourable when it has been played at festivals, but I thought it would be helpful to answer some of the questions higher up this thread.

[. . .]

As Martyn alluded, we are looking at a G/C anglo concertina at the moment, and an initial order looks imminent, so hopefully we'll have that model in during the autumn.

Other than that, we're at Warwick (with its forecast for rain  :( ) this weekend, we'll be at Sidmouth all week if anyone would like to drop by and have a play of the G/D melodeon, and we also have some B/C boxes on order, expected in mid September. As I am currently chairman of Mersea Week regatta, we can't make Whitby, which runs concurrently, but my old mate Bill Sables has agreed to run our BDA stand there (Do you remember me buying that little 60 bass Hohner from you, Theo, it was Bill that broked that deal!)

Hopefully, we'll see you somewhere!

All the best
Greg Dunn

Hi Greg,

Many years ago when I was doing graduate work in Wales (and learning about free-reed instruments) it was explained to me that the standard terminology to describe common layouts of melodeons lists the keys of the melody rows from "outside inwards" -- from the thumb edge of the keyboard inward toward the grille.  Thus the D/G is a common variety of melodeon, with the inside G row tuned a fourth above the outside D row. I've heard about boxes made in the keys of G/D (inside D row tuned a fifth above the outside G row) but that's a rare system that would finger differently from a D/G. 

On the other hand, I was told that 3-row anglo-chromatic concertina layouts are usually described starting with the middle row and then the inside row.  So anglos in C/G, G/D, Bb/F are common layouts; I've heard of rare D/G concertinas being made but I'm not sure I've come across a G/C.  D/G or G/C concertinas would be non-standard layouts that finger differently from a G/D or G/C.

I know some folks just list the keys of their instruments in no particular order and obviously what they call them doesn't matter much, if they have the instrument they need for the music they play.  But since rare examples of those "reversed" concertina and melodeon systems do exist, as an instrument dealer you might find it will help your communication with customers if you standardize your descriptions of layouts.

With that in mind, in the post I quoted above I have a feeling that only your B/C box is described in the way I was advised to name these layouts, and that your "G/D melodeon" and your "G/C concertina" may be the types more usually described as a D/G melodeon and a C/G concertina.

Best of luck with this venture!

PG

Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pipives on July 31, 2012, 11:16:33 PM
Thank you for that, Martyn et al. Thought it was high time we joined mel.net, assuming you'll have us, coming over from the dark side of chromatics!

Reaction to our G/D box has been universally favourable when it has been played at festivals, but I thought it would be helpful to answer some of the questions higher up this thread.

Firstly, the colour! Yes, the prototype came in red, which made us groan, but strangely it delivered differing opinions. Our mission was to set out as the Henry Ford of the budget accordion market, but when we reluctantly pulled it out from under the counter at Cheltenham, a bit like Lance Corporal Jones' sausages, the morris players loved it, but demanded we also supplied it in red! So we put in an order on the strength of reaction at that one festival, 75% in black, 25% in red. Those instruments are now in stock, and selling worryingly fast, as new orders take ages to manufacture and ship, and we're worrying about stocks lasting through Sidmouth and Whitby.

About the 'generic' Chinese manufacture of accordions, whilst it was an opinion I subscribed to, since I have visited the country and talked to different manufacturers, it became obvious to me that quality varies, and to generalise would be the same as describing Italian cars as 'generic', and whilst most Chinese free reed manufacturers could be judged to be at the Fiat end, and we haven't found a Lamborghini yet, we are confident we have found the Alfa (hopefully without the breakdowns!).

As Martyn alluded, we are looking at a G/C anglo concertina at the moment, and an initial order looks imminent, so hopefully we'll have that model in during the autumn.

Other than that, we're at Warwick (with its forecast for rain  :( ) this weekend, we'll be at Sidmouth all week if anyone would like to drop by and have a play of the G/D melodeon, and we also have some B/C boxes on order, expected in mid September. As I am currently chairman of Mersea Week regatta, we can't make Whitby, which runs concurrently, but my old mate Bill Sables has agreed to run our BDA stand there (Do you remember me buying that little 60 bass Hohner from you, Theo, it was Bill that broked that deal!)

Hopefully, we'll see you somewhere!

All the best
Greg Dunn

Hi Greg

Was a pleasure to meet you and the new boxes at warwick (and it didn't rain too much, did it). See you friday in sidmouth,
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Ray on August 01, 2012, 05:13:24 PM
Tried one of these box's at Warwick, it wasn't half lovely, very, very, much worth the money. The couple manning the stall were equally as lovely too!
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: GuyWyatt on August 01, 2012, 08:40:26 PM
I have also played one (at Shepley, I think) and I was impressed.  Very good value for money. 
G
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pikey on August 23, 2012, 08:19:43 PM
i road tested a black d/g in Whitby today. It's a superb box, very fast action, good and easy sounding reeds, and the mechanism is much better than on the chinese Primos that Music Room sell. It has a thumb groove on the fingerboard, which is a great feature.

Imho it's a superb box, much better than other similarly priced boxes.

The only thing I noted is that the air button spring is a tad too strong, and the edges of the air button need rounding off a bit more.

Plus it lacks a push 'b' on the low end of the G row, so you can't play Delilah! But that would be easily fixed by any of the repairers.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Adam-T on August 23, 2012, 08:33:03 PM
I wonder of anyone we know roadtested the 72 bass PA (wrong forum I knopw but this is a BlackDiamond thread  ;D
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: xgx on August 23, 2012, 08:43:23 PM
had a look at the CBA ...the second reed wasn't sounding on one of the buttons, didn't look much beyond that.
Couldn't identify what but for me, it didn't have the same feel and appeal as the equivalent Weltmeister....
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2012, 08:53:57 PM
The only thing I noted is that the air button spring is a tad too strong, and the edges of the air button need rounding off a bit more.

That was the thing that I noticed as well. But even taking that into account, they are very cheap for what you get.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Adam-T on August 23, 2012, 08:54:56 PM
This is OT but ......

The prob is that the 72 bass Welty PA (the ACHAT) vastly overpriced in this country and used ones are rare.. I have to say though that the little CBA has shown me that Weltmeister are now in the running and I`d choose an ACHAT over a 72 bass hohner Bravo (I tried the Nova CBA and the Welty had better treble action and a better, clearer sounding bass end, the nova won on bass mech though)

What has put me off the B.Diamond 72 PA so far is the weight, it`s 1.5 Kilos more than the equivalent Hohner or Weltmeister - you can stick Italian reeds and improved mechs in but the BD's are still a generic chinese box at heart and they`re behind the times weight wise. I`m still curious to how people rate them.

Good on B/D for getting a very playable sub £400 2 row melodeon to the market.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Theo on August 23, 2012, 09:28:21 PM
I tried the Black Diamond melodeon and found it virtually identical to the DG Primo with Italian reeds as sold by the music room.  I think they are also pretty much the same price.  Decent boxes for the price but not a unique must buy for a beginner, and I'd still recommend a beginner to start with a Hohner if the budget stretches that far.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Martyn on August 23, 2012, 10:12:33 PM
I wonder of anyone we know roadtested the 72 bass PA (wrong forum I knopw but this is a BlackDiamond thread  ;D

I had one in the workshop recently for a bit of minor tweaking and I must say they are very good value for money, even with the recent price increase. I found the sound quite warm and mellow unlike the punchier sound of a Hohner Concerto or a Weltmeister 72 bass.

Going back to the melodeon though, the Black Diamond is the most playable and the nicest sounding of the 'Chinese Cheapies' I've tried so far.

Martyn 
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pikey on August 24, 2012, 12:34:08 AM
i agree with Theo ref Hohner if you have the budget, but IMHO the BD has a better button action than the primo - the buttons on the primo seem to disappear into the holes at an angle, but not on the bd. Plus the bd seems to be less stiff from new.

Btw - I thought Ray Langton, Dierdres ex, perished in the Corry builders yard accident with Len Fairclough?  :-)


Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Owen Woods on August 24, 2012, 12:38:02 AM
Personally I would choose the BD over a pokerwork/erica. But then I've never liked them very much. The Morgane is a different animal though.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: george garside on August 27, 2012, 07:38:54 PM
I tried the black ciamond DG boxes at Whitby  and was  quite impressed , taking into consideration the price .    It is pointless (and unfair) to compare them with boxes at double  or more the price  and  I found them surprisingly pleasant to play when compared  with other similarly priced chinese offerings. The two I tried   had good reed response, a   nice feel to the bellows  and smooth action.

It remains to see as to whether they depreciate rapidly in Chinese fashion but this  would be of   of  less consequence to anybody who intends to keep one for 5 years or maybe much more.  Should also make a good 'morris box'  for those sensible enough not to play  £3000 quids worth of costalottii in the rain!

I have spoken to Greg Dunn of Black Diamond  and he  is going to look  into the possibility of having the next batch  of DG's made as 4th button 'do' with both low notes and accidentals, presumably without an adverse effect on the price.
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 09, 2012, 02:40:12 PM
Well I bought one at Whitby, and as I'm only a rank beginner, I could be wrong, but I think that for the price, they sound lovely. I tried others, and nothing in the price range sounded nearly as good.
All I have to do now is learn to play it  :Ph

John
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: Ray Langton on September 09, 2012, 06:46:25 PM
Btw - I thought Ray Langton, Dierdres ex, perished in the Corry builders yard accident with Len Fairclough?  :-)


He did - I didn't and wife's name is Bev
Title: Re: Black Diamond Melodeon
Post by: pikey on September 10, 2012, 09:31:15 AM
 ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal