Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Owen Woods on February 13, 2012, 01:23:27 AM
-
I wrote a blog post the other day on this subject and it's generated some agreement and some criticism. At the risk of stirring up a hornet's nest, I'd be interested to know people's view of it.
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/10/guarding-the-tradition-part-1-what-is-folk-music/#more-122
:|bl
-
Folk music aside, I found your definition of classical music as 'something that professionals do' and that 'was written for people to listen to' very interesting! My husband is a classical musician who has never played a single note for anyone else or for money. He plays his grand piano (very well) for himself, and not for any other reason. He loves playing it and doesn't care if anyone else is listening. He comes from a family of people who also love 'classical' music and who play it for their own enjoyment. I have only ever met one composer of 'classical' type music and he wrote it because it was what he loved to do. Of course he wanted people to want to listen to it, but I think we could say the same of many musicians.
I hope brought a more open mind to your definition of folk music! (:)
-
The proportion of classical music played by professionals is probably about the same as the proportion of folk music played by professionals.
Steve
-
Haven't much time to write, but I think what constitutes 'folk' music is far more a question of context than of content. This definition is by no means watertight, but for me, if I'm paying to experience it, then it's showbiz, if it's being performed for free, it's folk. I was in a pub in Otley (Folk Festival) last year, where there was a sing/playaround/session. Everything from old standards like 'Liverpool Lou' to Everley Brothers, Eddie Cochrane, Buddy Holly and Donegan was being sung, and there were jazz piano solos along with some pop classical pieces, all chucked in with the usual Harper's Frolic etc. At first I thought, hmmm, thought this was a folk festival, then it dawned, hang on, this really IS folk - people performing the music they enjoy and sharing it with everyone else. It was a great evening, and the quality of performance very high. I listened to the BBC2 Folk Awards and found much of the singing (though not all) over produced, over accompanied and obviously created with a sales target in mind. Whether or not it becomes 'folk' would be a matter of whether or not it 'catches on', for whatever reason, like the pop songs I mentioned earlier. The idea of writing a folk song is, to me, like starting a tradition. It can't be so called until it has become absorbed into folks' subconsciousness and has become part of their lives. Like I suggested, this is probably far too slapdash and rushed-off before I start work - I'll run for cover in my workshop now!
-
What is folk music?....how long is a piece of string?.....
Whenever self-appointed guardians try to freeze it in time and think they're in control of it, it just pops up somewhere else and carries on doing it's own thing and whenever attempts are made to appropriate it for it's spirit and aesthetics you can always see right through it and the result doesn't ring true. It defies all attempts to define or categorise it but you know it when you hear it and it's unmistakeable.
-
And that, Andy, has got to be the best definition of Folk Music that I've heard. Thank you.
-
Always a dangerous subject...
Owen's hypothesis is interesting but not perfect.
I think of instrumental folk music as primarily dance music and don't see why that definition should be owned by pop music. Sessions may be for the players, but the tunes played at sessions were meant for dancing.
Folk song is a different matter. To say that it's at least as much for the the singers as for an audience is probably not so far from the truth, but that description also fits community choirs - is that folk music?
The suggestion that classical music is mostly played by professionals is plausibly refuted - but that really only applies in the UK, where we have a huge tradition of amateur classical music making. Go to any other European country and you won't find nearly so many amateur musicians playing classical music just for fun.
Context more than content? Yes - much safer, and also applicable to the equally endless debate about what's "traditional" and what isn't.
And yes to Andy! Very true, though you couldn't exactly say it was a definition, more of a statement that it's indefinable.
-
Amateur classical music playing is, relatively speaking, big in Australia. Darwin symphony orchestra is, apart from the concert master and conductor, entirely voluntary, and they have a volunteer learning orchestra as well. Here in Canberra (a city of only 300 000 people) there are a couple of orchestras entirely consisting of volunteers and many more classically trained musicians within the community. I think of classical music as pertaining to the type of learning and the musical style, rather than as having anything to do with employment.
By the way I like your blog Owen and respect the thoughtful effort you have made to discuss such a contentious subject (:)
-
"Man, all music is folk music. You ain't never heard no horse sing a song, have you?"
Now who said that!
-
Defining folk music is like herding cats - damn near impossible! But if something smells like folk music, then it probably is! Participation seems to be an important characteristic, whether it be through playing, singing, dancing or just listening in an intimate environment where there are no barriers between performer and listener. I was at a session in High Bentham a couple of weeks ago that illustrated what for me are some of the essential qualities of folk music. There was a group of people in a room sometimes initiating a song or a tune, sometimes joining in and sometimes just listening, but all feeling part of it. The new landlady, who knew nothing about folk music, said when I went to order a drink: "It's a great atmosphere. We feel part of it even though we are behind the bar!"
And what of the music? Well, eclectic is the best description I can find. Nobody would object to Speed the Plough and Soldier's Joy being defined as folk tunes, but what about Jenny Lind and Rochdale Coconut Dance, both of which began life in the music halls? Theme Vannetais and In Dreams were also played, the former having been written for a Breton TV programme and the latter for the film Lord of the Rings. The songs varied from Adieu Sweet Lovely Nancy and Thousands or More to Credence Clearwater Revival's Proud Mary and Lonny Donnegan's Putting on the Style - there was even a snatch of Deep Purple's Smoke on the Water! I think the important point is that all the music felt right - it felt as though it belonged and that it contributed to the atmosphere of an evening where a group of people had got together to make music.
Performances at concerts by professional folk musicians are somewhat different, but we should remember that these performers all began playing in small sessions and intimate folk clubs before progressing onto bigger things. I would remind those who say that big concerts are not folk music that the people who attend those concerts are many of the same people who go to folk clubs and sessions. Clearly there is a demand for folk music to be played in a concert environment. The ambience may be different and there is more of a barrier between the performers and the audience, but it is still folk music. Again, not all the tunes and songs are what purists might regard as folk, but they are what the audience want to hear and that is how the tradition evolves - and always has done. I am reminded of a concert at a festival (Sidmouth?) some years ago where Little Johnny England received the loudest applause of the night when they played Little Feat's Dixie Chicken. I bet that ruffled the feathers of the purists! ::)
-
"Man, all music is folk music. You ain't never heard no horse sing a song, have you?"
Now who said that!
Louis Armstrong, I believe.
-
My personal definition of what can be played in a 'folk music session' is anything that about a third of those present can & want to play!
george
-
This question is always an old chestnut which crops up on Mudcat Cafe with surprising regularity. In addition it's one of the most Googled terms in folk music - and basically it's all a waste of time attempting to come up with an answer. Folk Music is so diverse these days that it cannot be defined or classified and the discussion with rage on for many years yet.
-
I knew that this would happen :P I was making generalisations and people take them at face value. I'm not saying that nobody plays classical music for fun (I do for one!), I am saying that the purpose of classical music, inasmuch as you can give a genre a purpose, is to be listened to, whereas the purpose of folk music is participatory. Nor was I saying that all classical music is performed by professionals - what I was saying that amateur classical musicians tend to perform, not terribly contentious I think. What I was saying is that the concept of a professional folk musician is quite alien to the spirit of folk music, in that it somehow gives one greater license to perform than amateurs, which isn't what folk music is about. And I speak as someone who would love to earn my living from folk music :P I also wasn't saying that this is the only definition of folk music, merely that it is A definition of folk music which I think holds on a general level.
Anahata makes a good point, in that I glossed over the dance aspect of folk, ironically, given my earlier posts. In which case, what would the separation be between a live ceilidh band and a live ballroom dance band with someone instructing (i.e. someone calling ballroom dances)? The only difference is the music and the dances, I'd argue that the context would or could be quite similar. My definition only works if you consider the music before the setting, as I can't think of any other difference. So the definition only really applies to session playing, rather than dancing. I'll talk about the application to dance in my next post I think, which will be about this notion of tradition and will touch on what Bob says, which I agree with.
-
Anahata makes a good point, in that I glossed over the dance aspect of folk, ironically, given my earlier posts. In which case, what would the separation be between a live ceilidh band and a live ballroom dance band with someone instructing (i.e. someone calling ballroom dances)? The only difference is the music and the dances, I'd argue that the context would or could be quite similar. My definition only works if you consider the music before the setting, as I can't think of any other difference. So the definition only really applies to session playing, rather than dancing. I'll talk about the application to dance in my next post I think, which will be about this notion of tradition and will touch on what Bob says, which I agree with.
A called ballroom dance..now that I'd like to see. Although mum would tell me sequence is almost that as everyone dos the same moves at the same time. ;)
-
I knew that this would happen :P I was making generalisations and people take them at face value. I'm not saying that nobody plays classical music for fun (I do for one!), I am saying that the purpose of classical music, inasmuch as you can give a genre a purpose, is to be listened to, whereas the purpose of folk music is participatory. Nor was I saying that all classical music is performed by professionals - what I was saying that amateur classical musicians tend to perform, not terribly contentious I think. What I was saying is that the concept of a professional folk musician is quite alien to the spirit of folk music, in that it somehow gives one greater license to perform than amateurs, which isn't what folk music is about. And I speak as someone who would love to earn my living from folk music :P I also wasn't saying that this is the only definition of folk music, merely that it is A definition of folk music which I think holds on a general level.
The fact that most, if not all of us, in this forum play can blind us to the fact that there are many (possibly a large majority) who don't play and for them (my partner's one) folk music is about listening and seeing/hearing a performance just as much as to a "classical" concert.
To paraphrase Fine Art 101 - "What is folk music? Anything a folk musician is is folk music. Who is a folk musican? Anyone who says they are!" (:)
Steve
-
What I was saying is that the concept of a professional folk musician is quite alien to the spirit of folk music, in that it somehow gives one greater license to perform than amateurs, which isn't what folk music is about. And I speak as someone who would love to earn my living from folk music :P
Even that is questionable. ;) I believe there is ample historical precedent for some of the people we now think of as folk musicians having been professional or semi-pro way back in the mists of time. Musicians who earned some or all of their income from playing for dancing, busking and acting is itinerant musicians composers and teachers. Not that much different really from some of us on this forum, only now its known as a portfolio career!
-
I believe there is ample historical precedent for some of the people we now think of as folk musicians having been professional or semi-pro way back in the mists of time.
Not only that, but there are lots of folk musicians in Eastern Europe who are thoroughly professional. It may be government sponsored and part of the tourist industry, but their material is definitely folk music. I've had beginner lessons on a variety of Bulgarian instruments at one of the Balkanfolk seminars at Pamporovo, and though we didn't have much spoken language in common, the tutors all used written music (as well as being able to play anything by ear too), knew their stuff technically and were professors in the music departments of various academies and universities. The French clearly take teaching their traditional music seriously too. For these people, being a folk musician is as much a
serious profession as playing in an orchestra.
It will be a long time before the British (especially English) establishment takes its indigenous music that seriously.
-
I thought we'd settled this question back in the sixties - it's Bobby Dylan and The Settlers! >:E
Seriously though - it's one of those questions that will never be settled and quite frankly, I got bored with it a very long time ago. :(
-
I thought we'd settled this question back in the sixties - it's Bobby Dylan and The Settlers! >:E
Seriously though - it's one of those questions that will never be settled and quite frankly, I got bored with it a very long time ago. :(
.. but it's fun to watch Mudcat re-inventing the wheel ;D
Steve
-
Even that is questionable. ;) I believe there is ample historical precedent for some of the people we now think of as folk musicians having been professional or semi-pro way back in the mists of time. Musicians who earned some or all of their income from playing for dancing, busking and acting is itinerant musicians composers and teachers. Not that much different really from some of us on this forum, only now its known as a portfolio career!
Well true, but then there are some people who played and composed music which we now class as folk music who fitted much better with the classical paradigm of the time. There is a book on this which is around £50 from the university press shop, so I haven't got it. But that doesn't really engage with the question. Is the participatory element of folk music characteristic? I think that it is. The fact that there have been professional folkies and will continue to be is true, but does it contradict my point? If anything then the folk degree is more of a departure than increased professionalism.
-
I glossed over the dance aspect of folk, ironically, given my earlier posts. In which case, what would the separation be between a live ceilidh band and a live ballroom dance band with someone instructing (i.e. someone calling ballroom dances)? The only difference is the music and the dances, I'd argue that the context would or could be quite similar.
One of the issues I have begun to encounter in researching the dance music and tunes of the Yorkshire Dales (see another thread) is that musicians and dancers in this locality saw little or no distinction between ballroom dancing and folk dancing, at least during the first half of the 20th century. It was not uncommon for village dances to intersperse square eights, longways dances and circle dances with quicksteps and foxtrots. The waltz is a classic example of a dance that was (and is) equally at home in the ballroom and the village hall.
-
That is interesting and somewhat unsurprising I suppose. In fact one might say that the only difference between a called ballroom dance and a ceilidh is time!
-
I keep citing a definition penned in the 1920s at some international folk music convention, but it works for me:
'Folk music is music transmuted and transmogrified by the people'
In english, that means music that is spread and changed by the oral tradition. The really important words are 'By the people' . I've always taken that to mean the general public, not professionals.
Hence as soon as someone heard Tom Jones and sang 'Delilah' , it became folk music.
The theme from Trunmpton learned by ear and played on melodeon is folk music.
I 'faught the law' learned by eaar and played on melodeon is folk music.
In fact, anything you learn and play is folk music! It's more a state of mind than a strict definition ;D
-
Incredible how long this can be debated. I'm in favour of inclusive definitions, and in tunes being able to move between genres naturally. So for me the key word in this is 'folk' - rather than 'music'
-
Folk music, tunes and songs will always evolve from their original conception.
I think the main difference between now and the "Good old days" ( when ever they were), is that we now have a FOLK INDUSTRY.
The only reason that the Folk Industry exists is to make money.
It is not just the performers who are involved in this industry, there are a long list of other professions who have tagged on to and boosted the Folk Industry for example, Managers, Promoters, Presenters, Technicians, Teachers, Retailers, Historians, Critics and dare I say it University Professors and Lecturers, the list goes on.
Problems, (if any) will only occur if the Folk Industry gets too powerful and starts to dictate to others what the definition of folk music should be.
Judging by last weeks Radio 2 Folk Awards, it would seem that the Folk Industry will embrace almost any form as long as it generates a cash flow.
It will be interesting to see how the Folk Industry copes as the recession continues and the government cuts start to have an impact.
Terry (:)
-
Folk music is and always has been such a broad church that it amazes me when people say "Oh, I don't like folk music." It usually turns out they once saw The Spinners on the telly, or heard Steeleye's rendition of "All Around Mike Batt" and assumed that was "it".
I'd be surprised if other musical genres indulge in such self-analysis about what is and isn't "their" music.
Back in the '60s, a radio show called "Country Meets Folk" probably did more to associate the two (to me completely different) genres in the minds of many. But I don't like Country music. In fact, there's an awful lot of Folk music I can't stand, either!
-
It always fascinated me how clones of the Spinners appeared around the country, many of which had 'ers' in their name, and all had 4 bloeks, one of whom played the tin whistle, one an accordion or melodeon, and a couple of guitars - and they all seemed to have a very simimilar repertoire! Poverty Knock anyone?
Two groups spring to mind:
'The Blackpool Taveners' (from Blackpool, obviously!)
'The Foresters' (from Stockton on Forest, near York)
Can anyone name any more?
;D
-
Go on I player and listen to Stuart Maconie on last week's Radio 2 Folk Awards. That's what Folk Music is. The authentic voice of the people - the dispossessed, the marginalised, the down trodden, the abused.
-
Is the participatory element of folk music characteristic? I think that it is.
Ukebert, I think you're right about this, it is an important feature (and one that a few commercialised festival organisers have not really understood!)
I think the Armstrong/Broonzy quote is more than a clever response, isn't he saying that the words 'folk music' really do mean music concentrating on people producing it for themselves? Obviously others enjoy listening to the result, but that still counts, doesn't it? And because in a sense 'people producing it for themselves' could cover virtually all music, maybe we should say that folk or roots music means all music except where those involved decide they want to separate their own particular brand of music from it and call themselves something else?
I liked ladydetemps' comment about ballroom dancing - I was fortunate a couple of years ago to have been dragged along to some classes locally, and what I found completely changed my attitude towards it. I just couldn't see any difference between this and folk dancing - it was clearly traditional, people-orientated, rhythmic, and great fun. In fact it struck me just how well our enthusiastic and charismatic teacher would go down at a dance workshop at a 'Folk' Festival, if only people could get over their initial disapproval. It is a great shame that 'Strictly' seems to have comprehensively taken over the territory with its absurd celeb-based commercialism, so that the chances of ballroom ever being accepted as a traditional folk art are pretty remote.
-
Folk music is and always has been such a broad church that it amazes me when people say "Oh, I don't like folk music." It usually turns out they once saw The Spinners on the telly, or heard Steeleye's rendition of "All Around Mike Batt" and assumed that was "it".
By the same token I wonder how many people entered folk music via either the Spinners, Dubliners or Corries. For those of a certain age probably more than we'd care to admit (OK I'm one of them).
As far as the Folk "Industry" or "Business" is concerned, of course the people in it are there to make money and a living. No money, no living, no business, does that make what they do any less valid? Ask Pete Coe or JK, they are both in the business!
Steve
-
Go on I player and listen to Stuart Maconie on last week's Radio 2 Folk Awards. That's what Folk Music is. The authentic voice of the people - the dispossessed, the marginalised, the down trodden, the abused.
I would second that, Stuart Maconie's introduction for Ian Campbell was first rate. I was very surprised by it and happy about it (:)
-
Back in the '60s, a radio show called "Country Meets Folk" probably did more to associate the two (to me completely different) genres in the minds of many. But I don't like Country music. In fact, there's an awful lot of Folk music I can't stand, either!
They have more in common than you might suppose. Both started as music made by ordinary people to entertain themselves. When I listen to the harmonies of the Carter Family, I hear similarities to the Watersons. Nashville got hold of some of the better exponents of country music and commercialized it, but country music is still played by many people in certain parts of the US in the same way that folk music is played in Britain.
I stumbled on an example of this in the 1990s when I called into the Green Alligator Bar in Colorado Springs for some food. There were several people sitting around singing songs and playing tunes. As time went on the numbers of singers and musicians grew. It was just like a session in an English pub, except that the songs were C & W and gospel, some old, some newer and a few recent pop songs. A great night with a lovely atmosphere! I had only called in for a bite to eat, but I stayed all evening. A few days later, I came across the same sort of thing in a bar in Beaver Creek.
-
First song I ever learn't back in about 1977 was an Isle of Man song about a boat called Ellen Vannin (not sure how you spell that now) - but I think it was off a Spinners album. At the time without any family tradition of the music, the internet, or contacts within the folk revival, it seemed a really opaque world to get into as a sixteen year old, and the Spinners were my first accessible contact with it- the rest as they say is history and I went on to eventually co run a folk club myself in due course. It's obviously much much easier for a young person without any connections to the tradition to source material and find out what's happening now, and I think that's been a really fantastic development over time. (:)
-
I must be 'downtrodden'........
-
They have more in common than you might suppose. Both started as music made by ordinary people to entertain themselves.
I do actually like "Old Time Country" - it's really the contemporary stuff with the wailing lap steel guitars that I had in mind in my earlier post. I got into folk music via the local public library's record collection, when I bought my first guitar at the age of 15 in 1968 and had no idea of what to play on it. The first record I borrowed was "The Art of the Folk/Blues Guitar" by Jerry Silverman, followed by The New Lost City Ramblers, Hedy West, and a wide variety of other American folk performers.
It wasn't until I'd exhausted the U.S. section and came across Martin Carthy's first album, followed by the Waterson's "Frost & Fire", that I realised I preferred, on the whole, the native British and Irish folk music (and still do).
-
My first folk club was at school, Nunthorpe Grammar in York, which met once a month with a very eclectic mix of music - John Martyn, Blues, Pentangle, The New Seekers, self-penned singer songwriter stuff - all 'non traditional'. I went becasue I loved Blues, then my eyes opened to all of the other sorts of Folk music.
Then one night a bloke called Richard stood up and sang, unaccompanied and not always in tune or in time, "Spencer The Rover". That was it - I was hooked into 'traditional' folk music, but never lost my love for 'non traditional'.
Maybe that's the key - folk music doesn't have to be in-tune or in-time (although of course it can be as well), as long as it speaks to you.
-
My first introduction to folk music was in 1965 when working for the Liberal Party in North Herefordshire as a gauche 17-year-old. I visited the farmhouse home of one of the local party officials and heard her daughter singing a Joan Baez song. I was hooked - and the music was beautiful as well. She took me to Hereford Folk Club and the rest is history! So, it's all your fault, Jan Hamer! (I wonder what became of her...)
-
I know it's fashionable jsut now to blame the Libdems for everything .. but folk music ::) Have a heart :|glug
-
So we have Richard to blame for bringing you into the civilised world on this side of the river do we! I shall have words with him in a few years time! :-*
-
???
-
Sadly the man who hooked me into trad folk music is no longer with us :(
-
Some really interesting viewpoints here. And I rather like it that however long this thead goes on for, there won't be a definitive answer - I hope not at least.
There's not much I can add to the points already raised, but another aspect that came to mind is folk music's ability, in lyrical terms at least, to tell a story so much better than other forms of music - The misery, joy, complexities of life, ragamuffin-courting-a-lord's-daughter-ending-in-tragedy / happiness all round and so many other facets of the human character seem to be come across in a folk song that lasts a few minutes, but would take a few hours in the opera, or would not be touched on at all in some other forms of music. That the protaganists of these stories are so often ordinary, '"downtrodden" men and women is quite heartening too - coming back to the whole 'music by the people, for the people' thing (although that sounds like the kind of line a politican would use - Do any politicians like folk music? I can't see it myself).
-
Do any politicians like folk music? I can't see it myself.
I have no knowledge of the musical tastes of modern politicians, but when I worked for the Liberal Party in the late 1960s and early 1970s, Joe Grimond (party leader and MP for Orkney and Shetland) and Richard Wainwright (MP for Colne Valley) were both partial to traditional folk music. I even heard David Penhaligon (who went on to become MP for North Cornwall before dying young in a car accident) singing traditional Cornish songs in a folk club, harmonising nicely with his sister, Susan (who went on to become a well-known actress).
-
Do any politicians like folk music? I can't see it myself
Tony Benn
-
What a lovely vision - Susan Penhaligon singing folk songs :P
-
and Norman Buchan of course.
-
I hadn't been going to add to this thread, but listening to the Martin Simpson Trio on Tuesday got me thinking......
"Folk music" today is a genre or scene in the modern music world just like say heavy metal, early music, opera, pop...... It could be characterised by particular instrumentation, styles, themes, venues etc but what really defines it are the people, the musicians pro and amateur and the fans who think of themselves as in the folk scene. And its a very broad scene. Martin did traditional British ballads, american stuff, singer song writer stuff.... all presumably "folk"
Historically the folk genre can be traced to two roots. Firstly the early twentieth century folk song collectors, Everyone from Bartok to Vaughan Williams, who had a romanticised nationalistic agenda: find the essence of Hungarian (or any other nation) spirit, in the music of the "untutored common people"
Its other root is the so called folk revival of the 60s: Bert Lloyd and crew in England who had a left wing political agenda. They were looking for the music of the oppressed and poor working people, on the land, on the sea and in the factories. Martin Carthy says that the folk revival was also deeply bound up with the anti nuclear and anti apartheid movements.
But whatever its roots, the folk scene has taken on a life of its own that goes far beyond the self made music of working people. The nationalism (or in England County-ism) is still a strong theme as is inspiration taken from the so called traditional music, and an empathy with the people who are social deprived, but that is no longer the whole story.
To me what is important is simply the wealth of good music that continues to emerge from the folk scene,
So if you think of what you play or listen to as folk... then it probably is.
-
Used to work in a clean room, we all had separate cubicles and my mate and I would sing the most obscure songs we could remember from our grans. Most of them probably pre-dated stuff many are calling folk, but at that time would have been excluded as they were mostly music hall. But then, half of the stuff people call classical is just orchestrated folk music. Many composers never wrote a tune in their lives!
Rob.
-
Nick, those were good and highly perceptive comments!
The only thing I would add is that I'm not sure that leftism is always a feature of folk - there's lots of right-wing influences too - for example some of the highly jingoistic songs that were around in the Napoleonic wars, and dare I say it, very occasionally some traditional Morris material?
-
The only thing I would add is that I'm not sure that leftism is always a feature of folk - there's lots of right-wing influences too
That is a good point - Peter Bellamy famously suffered for not being sufficiently left-leaning to suit most folk club organisers back in the '70s. On the other hand, attempts by the BNP to hi-jack traditional English folk need to be resisted at all costs.
-
half of the stuff people call classical is just orchestrated folk music. Many composers never wrote a tune in their lives!
Slight exaggeration there. For one thing, I'm sure even the most folk-influenced composers wrote more tunes than they nicked from the folk tradition, and for another, the folk tradition's hands are not spotless either. Michael Turner's Waltz (from Mozart K536), The Huntsmen's Chorus (Weber: Der Freischutz? not sure) One of the Mittell Hornpipes (from a work by Arbel) Jack The Horse Courser's Hornpipe (from overture to Handel's Ottone) Heel and Toe Polka (Sultan's Polka by D'Albert)... I'm sure there are many more.
-
Huntmans' Chorus is indeed from the En'tracte to Webers Die Frieschutz ! Hence we always pair it with Beethovens 'Ode to Joy' theme from his 9th Symphony. (:)
-
The only thing I would add is that I'm not sure that leftism is always a feature of folk - there's lots of right-wing influences too
That is a good point - Peter Bellamy famously suffered for not being sufficiently left-leaning to suit most folk club organisers back in the '70s. On the other hand, attempts by the BNP to hi-jack traditional English folk need to be resisted at all costs.
Yet a decade later Strawhead went down a storm.
Steve
-
Folk music is open to all who have an interest, to listen, sing or play. Barriers are down, all can have a go and are often encouraged .So it does have a wide mix of content as mentioned already.So no definition from me, its way too varied !
I started listening to folk with the Spinners and being from Blackpool soon started to attend the folk club hosted by the Taverners, never saw them add the town name to their billing and they had Alan Bell playing concertina but no accordian. The door policy was in the early days a bit restrictive, Big Pete turned away Paul Simon and Maddy Prior( her Dad lived in Fleetwood writing Z car scripts ) which makes me wonder who did get to play?
-
Huntmans' Chorus is indeed from the En'tracte to Webers Die Frieschutz ! Hence we always pair it with Beethovens 'Ode to Joy' theme from his 9th Symphony. (:)
Known in the trade as "Beethoven Ix".
-
I keep citing a definition penned in the 1920s at some international folk music convention, but it works for me:
'Folk music is music transmuted and transmogrified by the people'
In english, that means music that is spread and changed by the oral tradition. The really important words are 'By the people' . I've always taken that to mean the general public, not professionals.
Hence as soon as someone heard Tom Jones and sang 'Delilah' , it became folk music.
The theme from Trunmpton learned by ear and played on melodeon is folk music.
I 'faught the law' learned by eaar and played on melodeon is folk music.
In fact, anything you learn and play is folk music! It's more a state of mind than a strict definition ;D
Glad someone mentioned 'Delilah' & 'Trumpton' - I was going to go on to mention 'Telstar', 'Rockin all over the world' and more recently 'Wallace & Gromit' but I'm sure we get the point.
-
The Archers, Nelly the Elephant, Brown Girl in the Ring, Bye Bye love, etc etc etc >:E
-
I do enjoy reading threads such as this. There was a time that I limited my concept of folk music to traditional vs. contemporary. Other forms of music were outside the realm of folk. A few days ago, when this thread started, I chanced upon a more inclusive idea. I now think that folk music is about communication through music. Somewhere on youtube one can see a performance of Beowulf with one individual speaking middle English with lyre accompaniment. This is the transmission of a story. Many folk songs are stories with adventure, or moral warnings, or perhaps celebrations. The list goes on. Many of these songs are with us today and are being sung in revivals. Many still contain lessons for the listener. For some listeners certain songs are not relevant. I might not understand a poaching song. Someone else might not be moved by a cowboy song. Anyhow, many of the trad songs we enjoy still communicate with us.
Every song is at some point contemporary and those that resonate will probably be sung years from now. Many of the contemporary songs I would probably dismiss as being "pop" and not about anything. But, still there is communication going on at some level. I must say that I thought of Twisted Sisters lyrics differently after hearing Martin Carthy sing "were not going to take it..." I'm rambling now. Some folk music does not have words. Those dance tunes that we live and love to play are communicating with our feet. All this music we love binds us with our friends and community through shared experience and enjoyment. Jazz and classical also communicate with the listener, although outside those pieces that are popular, it is perhaps communicating with a more abstract part of our brains. I have often felt that a folk musician can play any type of music and still consider him or herself as a folk musician. Paid or not the folk musician is transmitting the song or tune for their community of friends and listeners. Eric in Montana.
-
Somewhere on youtube one can see a performance of Beowulf with one individual speaking middle English with lyre accompaniment. This is the transmission of a story.
I'm guessing you mean "Old English" (aka Anglo-Saxon), as Middle English is the language of Chaucer (several centuries later). An interesting point nonetheless, as it highlights the way that folk performance can be appealing even when the listener may have little or no knowledge of the language being spoken or sung.
For example, I love a lot of Gaelic, French, Breton, Spanish and Italian roots music, without having much of an inkling about the literal meaning of what I'm hearing.
-
'Folk music is music transmuted and transmogrified by the people'
...
It's more a state of mind than a strict definition ;D
I like both of these. The first because it describes folk as a process - a verb rather than an adjective, something people do with music, not a type of music (especially in terms of origin) - the second because it echoes Andy's statement that you can't define it.
-
I do enjoy reading threads such as this. There was a time that I limited my concept of folk music to traditional vs. contemporary. Other forms of music were outside the realm of folk. A few days ago, when this thread started, I chanced upon a more inclusive idea. I now think that folk music is about communication through music. Somewhere on youtube one can see a performance of Beowulf with one individual speaking middle English with lyre accompaniment. This is the transmission of a story. Many folk songs are stories with adventure, or moral warnings, or perhaps celebrations. The list goes on. Many of these songs are with us today and are being sung in revivals. Many still contain lessons for the listener. For some listeners certain songs are not relevant. I might not understand a poaching song. Someone else might not be moved by a cowboy song. Anyhow, many of the trad songs we enjoy still communicate with us.
Every song is at some point contemporary and those that resonate will probably be sung years from now. Many of the contemporary songs I would probably dismiss as being "pop" and not about anything. But, still there is communication going on at some level. I must say that I thought of Twisted Sisters lyrics differently after hearing Martin Carthy sing "were not going to take it..." I'm rambling now. Some folk music does not have words. Those dance tunes that we live and love to play are communicating with our feet. All this music we love binds us with our friends and community through shared experience and enjoyment. Jazz and classical also communicate with the listener, although outside those pieces that are popular, it is perhaps communicating with a more abstract part of our brains. I have often felt that a folk musician can play any type of music and still consider him or herself as a folk musician. Paid or not the folk musician is transmitting the song or tune for their community of friends and listeners. Eric in Montana.
I like that. When I do the next instalment I might paraphrase that if you don't mind :P
-
Hi Ukebert,
You may use the ramblings if you desire. Thank you. Now I wish I had been more careful about placing some commas to clarify the thoughts. The communication idea has come about from my recent work as a sub. teacher in Montana middle schools. I've noticed that the kids really respond if I play a tune on my Kantele or on a Melodeon. I have used the Kantele in place of the clock to improve math scores on timed exams. Sometimes a melodeon tune helps students recall their grandparents playing a similar instrument. Once, at a wedding, we managed to get some oldtimers to dance and they told us that they had not jigged like that since the 1940's. Music is meaningful to so many people and we are lucky to be able to share our songs and tunes with anyone who will listen. I enjoy your writings and I wish you success in music and in school. Eric
-
Hence as soon as someone heard Tom Jones and sang 'Delilah' , it became folk music.
I don't think it's that simple. Just because a song enters the public consciousness and becomes widely known doesn't make if "folk music". The National Anthem isn't folk music. 'Jerusalem' isn't folk music.
I doubt whether anyone singing, or listening to, 'Delilah' is unaware of the Tom Jones version. It would only become 'folk music' if that connection with the original were to be lost, so that people learning the song anew were taking it from the singer they heard it from, without that reference back to an original definitive version.
It has been possible for that to happen with some modern compositions in the folk idiom, because the original versions weren't sufficiently widely circulated to provide that benchmark. I've heard countless versions of 'Fiddlers Green' but never, to my knowledge, John Connolly's original. I'd heard many versions of 'Dirty Old Town' before I heard Ewan McColl sing it. Those songs circulated on their own merits, as it were, rather than being taken from the composers' original versions.
There was a time when any popular song could become a folk song, by being passed from one singer to another. Ever since the advent of recorded music, it has been possible to refer back to the original source, and possible to say that there is a 'correct' version of the lyrics or tune. I think it will be very difficult in the future for popular songs to turn into folk songs.
This is of course taking a rather academic view of what is folk music. An alternative view is that it is simply a genre, defined (albeit rather vaguely) by certain styles of performance. The view that folk music is anything that 'the folk' plays may have a certain simplicity about it but doesn't really tell us anything, so I find it unhelpful.
The real problem is that there are so many alternative ways of interpreting the term 'folk music', and everyone is convinced that their's is right and everyone else's wrong :)
-
The view that folk music is
[insert preferred definition here]
may have a certain simplicity about it but doesn't really tell us anything, so I find it unhelpful.
You run up against the same difficulty trying to define any musical genre.
For me it music boils down to this: there are two types of music, the kind I like, and the kind I've not yet learned to like ;)
-
With respect, Theo, I think you've slightly misrepresented what I was trying to say with the quote you took. I was criticising the view that whatever the 'folk' plays is 'folk music', because it's simply too all-encompassing to be of any use. It often seems to be used by people wishing to perform their own brand of sub-pop in folk clubs, usually (one suspects) because they can't get to perform it anywhere else.
It's difficult to define musical genres in words, but I think I recognise 'folk' when I hear it. Where I do have difficulty is with modern material which neither reflects traditional lyrical or musical structures nor is performed in a recognisably 'folk' style - by what criteria is that considered 'folk'?
Ultimately, however, as you point out the real distinction is what I like and what I don't like. However I find that I'm more likely to find what I like under the label 'folk music', although I admit there's quite a lot there I don't like too.
-
Sorry Howard, I didn't mean to misrepresent you, just trying to lead on from what you were saying to suggest that any definition is likely to fall down in some way.
I do agree with you that labels like 'folk' are helpful in finding music that one likes, but there is always going to be overlap between labels.
-
I thought somebody was pulling my leg recently when they were talking about "Nu Folk", "Acid Folk" and "Wyrd Folk".
But it seems they weren't. :o
-
Sometimes I find that interpretation of a piece is an aid to "folkifying" the song or tune. I really like the Oysterband's version of Love Vigilantes by New Order. The feel of the piece is more anti-war than the musical prettiness of the original. For years I tried to find a way to interpret the song so it would be true to me. I finally succeeded on the ukulele of all things buy at least I found my way to the song. I have played that song (as a folk song) to people who have not heard the original or the Oysterband's version. Of course, I give credit to the songwriters so people can look for the original if they choose. Will the song stand the test of time? I would guess not due to the story being a bit abstract as compared to Arther McBride. Can I share the folkifyed, acoustic version on stage, at a house party, or around a campfire? Yes. Eric in Montana
-
'Folk music is music transmuted and transmogrified by the people'
I think all music is folk music but where there's room for improve ( for better or worse ) that makes it more folk like.
As opposed to classical where you play the music as written (I think). Why else would they need the sheet music in front of them? (:)
but I have no musical training so what do I know.
Michael
-
A listener to my one man box and song session last Wednesday commented that the pubs around his home near Burnley no longer had local singers or players just turning up for a session. He did not give the label Folk Music to this way of entertainment, to him it was just a social part of the pub scene. And he missed it. Made me think a bit more about what I am doing. I play for the fun and now realise that I am part of keeping a tradition alive.
-
Bob Pegg, in his book Folk, quotes the following definition of folk music promulgated by the International Folk Music Council in 1954:
"Folk music is the product of a musical tradition that has been evolved through the process of oral transmission. The factors that shape the tradition are: (i) continuity which links the present with the past; (ii) variation which springs from the creative individual or the group; (iii) selection by the community, which determines the form or forms in which the music survives."
While no definition can be all-encompassing, I think the IFMC made a pretty good stab at defining the indefinable. Recognizing some of the limitations of its own definition, the IFMC added the following codicils:
"(i) The term can be applied to music that has been evolved from rudimentary beginnings by a community uninfluenced by popular and art music and it can likewise be applied to music which has originated with an individual composer and has subsequently been absorbed into the living tradition of a community.
(ii) The term does not cover composed popular music that has been taken over ready-made by a community and remains unchanged, for it is the re-fashioning and re-creation of the music by the community that gives it its folk character."
With its emphasis on "the re-fashioning and re-creation of the music by the community", this, in my opinion, gets somewhere near the essence of what sets folk music apart from other kinds of music. Others, of course, may disagree, but what do they know? >:E
-
That rules out "Streets of London" then, apart for the punk version by the Anti-Nowhere League....... >:E
Plus Dylans' "The times they are a changing...."
-
Whatever. Some people say it isn't folk music unless you wrote it yourself...
-
Which rules out the old fiddler I listened to on Foula (outer Shetland) in 1971. His playing for the celidh consisted of a number of tunes, but the one he kept going longest was Rudolf the Red Nosed Reindeer.
So he was clearly a folk musician, and it didn't really matter what you thought of his material as long as you danced to it. I think the participation bit is quite important (dancing, singing, singing choruses, or playing, but what is in my view crucial is that however it might get played, it isn't folk music unless you can play it properly without electricity (even if most people don't or won't).
-
The question that Bob never really answered is what then is the status of "recovered" music (for want of a better description)? The tunes in the Village Music Project have mainly died, the fact that they are being played now is because they were written down, the continuity is not there.
You could almost make a better case that Streets of London or Times they are A'Changing are more in the oral tradition, because although we have access to the composer's music I suspect that the vast majority of us who play the songs have learnt them from other people. It can also be quite salutary to go back and listen to the original version and compare it to the version you sing. (:)
Steve
-
We did "Times" at our session on Friday. With (wait there for it!) Uillean Pipes, guitar, melodeons, fiddles, Piano Accordion, mouth-organ and possibly one or two instruments I missed. There was also a bodhran. All from memory, so it must have been folk. ::)
-
The question that Bob never really answered is what then is the status of "recovered" music (for want of a better description)? The tunes in the Village Music Project have mainly died, the fact that they are being played now is because they were written down, the continuity is not there.
Writing and reading printed (or handwritten) music was always an important part of the mechanism of dissemination when those tunes were first played. It's a myth that village musicians were all musically illiterate - obviously some of them will have learned by ear but there were many who had a musical training, in military bands or though the Church for example.
The important with the revived VMP manuscripts is what happens next. Those tunes are being played and learnt by musicians at sessions, included in the repertoire of working ceilidh bands and played for people to dance to. There's plenty of continuity now, and I'd say those tunes are very much alive.
The 19th century musician might have had his tunes in a fiddler's tune book in his pocket; Paul Burgess has his all in a smartphone where they can be recalled instantly on to the screen. Different technology, exactly the same idea.
-
The question that Bob never really answered is what then is the status of "recovered" music (for want of a better description)? The tunes in the Village Music Project have mainly died, the fact that they are being played now is because they were written down, the continuity is not there.
Writing and reading printed (or handwritten) music was always an important part of the mechanism of dissemination when those tunes were first played. It's a myth that village musicians were all musically illiterate - obviously some of them will have learned by ear but there were many who had a musical training, in military bands or though the Church for example.
The important with the revived VMP manuscripts is what happens next. Those tunes are being played and learnt by musicians at sessions, included in the repertoire of working ceilidh bands and played for people to dance to. There's plenty of continuity now, and I'd say those tunes are very much alive.
The 19th century musician might have had his tunes in a fiddler's tune book in his pocket; Paul Burgess has his all in a smartphone where they can be recalled instantly on to the screen. Different technology, exactly the same idea.
Don't disagree with you, what I'm pointing out is the flaw in the definition.
Steve
-
Don't disagree with you, what I'm pointing out is the flaw in the definition.
Steve
Point taken. You'd have to stretch "oral transmission" to include written and printed too. This is as true of songs as it is of dance music - a huge amount of trad song material was printed as broadsides. The tunes were sometimes specified as "to the tune of <something well known>" but in many cases seem to have been mostly made up by the singers. Certainly the research Mary's recently been doing on songs collected in Cambridgeshire finds new tunes (or variants on existing tunes) to go with words that you can already find in the broadside collection on the Bodleian Library web site or elsewhere.
You also have to bend the 1954 definition's idea of continuity and allow gaps, but if the material is picked up and comes back into regular circulation (not just as museum exhibits and pinned butterflies) that's OK.
-
With its emphasis on "the re-fashioning and re-creation of the music by the community", this, in my opinion, gets somewhere near the essence of what sets folk music apart from other kinds of music.
I like that bit in the definition. It could apply to all sorts of situations where people make music for each other; for example "my old man" or "roll out the barrel" could be thought of as folk music for the East End of London, though we wouldn't really think of them as folk songs. Similarly, it explains why Delila probably isn't folk, even if played on a melodeon, as no real "community" claims it. If it were played at a session, people may enjoy it, but they'd think "oh, there's that Tom Jones song".
Similarly, when people in this country listen to Sengalese or Colombian music it's "World music", whereas to the locals, it's probably "folk".
Just a few thoughts. I'm no expert, but I like threads like this.
David
-
Similarly, it explains why Delila probably isn't folk, even if played on a melodeon, as no real "community" claims it.
Other than Stoke City football fans (for some reason it's "their" song). ;D
-
"roll out the barrel" could be thought of as folk music for the East End of London
seehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Barrel_Polka (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Barrel_Polka)
-
"roll out the barrel" could be thought of as folk music for the East End of London
seehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Barrel_Polka (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Barrel_Polka)
Forever tainted in my memory for its association with a 1960s ad for Watney's Red Barrel (that dates me). :D
-
Some more thoughts, only mildly contradictory to what I wrote last time. Product of little sleep and littler sense :P
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/27/guarding-the-tradition-part-2-what-is-not-folk-music/
-
Quote: "What hope is there for folk music? Is it worth saving? Is there anything to save? Is the whole thing a waste of time?"
The early folk song and dance collectors assumed the material they noted down was in danger of being lost completely. They may or may not have been correct in that assumption. A deliberate attempt was made, via Sharp's introduction of folk song and dance into the school curriculum, to "keep the tradition alive". I've spoken to several people over the years, male and female, who have fond memories of singing folk songs or dancing Morris or what used to be known simply as "country dances" in their youth, regardless of whether or not they continued to be interested once leaving school.
The spread of firstly, almost universal literacy through the education system and secondly, the incredible access to material provided by the Internet, more-or-less guarantees the safety of folk song and dance for the future. Since the Second Revival of the 50s and 60s, traditional English song and dance has been deliberately fused with every other form you can think of from Early Music through jazz, world music, and hip-hop (vide the Daemon Barbers). As Martin Carthy (himself an agent for fusion music through his involvement with The Imagined Village) has said, the only thing that threatens traditional dance and song is not performing it.
So I think the answers to your four questions quoted above are: "Plenty", "Yes", "Yes" and "No".
-
For those of you that are interested, I have finally written the third part of this series (:)
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/09/18/guarding-the-tradition-part-3-what-might-folk-music-become/
The previous two posts are here:
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/10/guarding-the-tradition-part-1-what-is-folk-music/
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/27/guarding-the-tradition-part-2-what-is-not-folk-music/
-
For those of you that are interested, I have finally written the third part of this series
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/09/18/guarding-the-tradition-part-3-what-might-folk-music-become/
The previous two posts are here:
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/10/guarding-the-tradition-part-1-what-is-folk-music/
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/27/guarding-the-tradition-part-2-what-is-not-folk-music/
I missed the first parts of this being a newbie to the forum. I just started reading it and am enjoying it very much.
my favorite part so far has been this:
it is not about the notes that you play, it is about how you play them, where you play them, who you play them with and most importantly, why you play them and what you think of them.
-
For those of you that are interested, I have finally written the third part of this series (:)
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/09/18/guarding-the-tradition-part-3-what-might-folk-music-become/
Excellent exposé and thinking.
Reminds me of artists who compose music that is structured and sounds like "old traditional music". To me that's one way of giving tradition a boost. Heck, traditional tunes were once new tunes too!
Canadian (late) composer and singer Stan Rogers once wrote a song called "Barrett's Privateers" in 1976 that sounds just like a 18th century sea shanty, to the point that most people still think it is one! The story in the song is fictional but uses authentic historical facts and places. This is one way of extending tradition.
-
I'm reminded of the traditional song Bring us a Barrel (http://mudcat.org/@displaysong.cfm?SongID=937). Often thought "trad, anon" as it is so close to the genre of old drinking songs, it was penned by the late Keith Marsden, a traditional song writing genius ::) AFAIR at the time he was working in a bank in Bradford (which may or may not have stimulated any appetite for beer).
Stan Rogers was another one. Having been personally knocked off bike by a careless motorist on 1st October to spend the next year off work - his "Mary Ellen Carter" was a great comfort to me ... :|glug
-
I never knew that Keith wrote Bring us a Barrel! He was a great bloke and great singer, sorely missed.
-
Canadian (late) composer and singer Stan Rogers once wrote a song called "Barrett's Privateers" in 1976 that sounds just like a 18th century sea shanty, to the point that most people still think it is one! The story in the song is fictional but uses authentic historical facts and places. This is one way of extending tradition.
I have to say I don't know this piece. But however much skill and knowledge went into its composition, as described here it sounds to me exactly what folk music isn't. I don't see pastiche as being a very interesting way of extending a tradition.
-
I do know the song - it's excellent and not in any way a pastiche. While it springs from the Novascottian seafaring tradition it's rhythmic structure is more complex and .. extends it.
A similar example might be Cyril Tawney's songs - especially "Chicken on a Raft" :|glug
I never knew that Keith wrote Bring us a Barrel!
.. though you was a Yorkshireman like me ??? But point reinforced. I first heard it from Derek Elliott in Darlington, and certainly though it was "trad" until I met Keith!
-
Canadian (late) composer and singer Stan Rogers once wrote a song called "Barrett's Privateers" in 1976 that sounds just like a 18th century sea shanty, to the point that most people still think it is one! The story in the song is fictional but uses authentic historical facts and places. This is one way of extending tradition.
I looked this one up literally only yesterday. I was listening to the Blackbeard's Tea Party version and wondered if if was a 'real' one or not.
-
John Conolly always gets annoyed when Fiddler's Green is credited as Trad.
Steve
-
I have to say I don't know this piece. But however much skill and knowledge went into its composition, as described here it sounds to me exactly what folk music isn't. I don't see pastiche as being a very interesting way of extending a tradition.
Listen to the piece.
-
I have to say I don't know this piece. But however much skill and knowledge went into its composition, as described here it sounds to me exactly what folk music isn't. I don't see pastiche as being a very interesting way of extending a tradition.
Listen to the piece.
I was making a general point that it doesn't serve to extend, or even maintain, a tradition simply to create new pieces which replicate, and/or could be mistaken for, the old. Whether or not this piece is an instance of this, that is how it was described.
-
Sorry JB - the boundaries just aren't that rigid.
There are always people writing songs "in the tradition" in the sense of borrowing from its style. Some will be stylistically "entirely within" - we have several examples above. Some will overlap it, but extend into other musical genres. eg a lot of John K's music - "Gravedigger" "Dan the Dustman" use the same modal scales as jazz. "Vitamin Dance" edges on rock and roll!
I'm happy to see all of these as tradition extensions. Time will tell whether they have continue to have currency "amongst the folk" after their authors stop performing them. Real music evolves. A "tradition" that allows nothing new is a fossil. :|glug