Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Skipy on September 17, 2008, 06:45:16 PM
-
Hhhmmm,
Here is a section of an email just received from 'The Button Box' regarding the above melodeon that they have advertised:
"This accordion was made with a "backwards" mechanism, that is the
C-row buttons work the upper row of pallets and the B-row
buttons work the lower row of pallets. This is the way Saltarelle
made all of their Irish-style boxes until a couple of years ago. The
result is a C-row with a very big, open sound."
So am I correct in thinking this is the reverse of my Hohner Morgane B/C? i.e outer row C inner row B.
If so, wouldn't this be a mini nightmare to play?
Skipy
-
No, the C row is still the inside row of buttons, so its exactly the same to play as any other B/C box.
They are referring to the mechanism, and which reedblock is operated by which row of buttons. The reedblock furthest from the keyboard tends to have a more open sound than the one nearer the keyboard, just because there is less in the way of the sound as it emerges from the reeds into the outside world. Usually the outer row of buttons(B on a B/C box) operates the reedblock furthest from the keyboard.
-
Many Thanks Theo, for a prompt and very informative reply!
What a learned fellow you are ;D
Skipy
-
Does it really make a difference to the sound?
-
Does it really make a difference to the sound?
this could also be part of the reason Jimmy Shand came up with the design that allowed 3 rows of buttons (BCC#) to work only 2 rows of palletes that contained all the reeds for the 3 rows in the Shand Special of 1937/8 and the post war Shand Morino which was a development of it. Prior to this 3 row boxes were very wide and the top row of palletes was obviously much furthur away from the keyboard giving different pallete opening speeds each row whcih must have effected the sound in some way, the 3 row 60 bass hohner organolla of around 1933 used the 3 rows of palletes & looked very clumsy
george
-
Does it really make a difference to the sound?
I reckon it does, but its not a big difference. I think it accounts for the slight difference in tone you can hear on a D/G say when you compare the same notes that occur on both rows. Most people are completely unaware of this I suspect, but when I'm checking a box that I've just tuned I often notice slight differences. The same thing does not happen with a PA where the same notes are on push and pull on the same reedblock.
-
Does it really make a difference to the sound?
I reckon it does, but its not a big difference. I think it accounts for the slight difference in tone you can hear on a D/G say when you compare the same notes that occur on both rows. Most people are completely unaware of this I suspect, but when I'm checking a box that I've just tuned I often notice slight differences. The same thing does not happen with a PA where the same notes are on push and pull on the same reedblock.
I have often wondered whether this slighty uneven pitch between the same note on both rows adds to the rhythm in some subtle way on a Dg . I am fairly sure it does on a BCC# with the vast choice of accidentals & probably does on a 3 row 4th aprt box. This is also complemented by the fact that you can change some notes 'on the button' & some 'on the bellows' again giving an uneven sound. It is virtually impossible to match this on a piano or continetal chromatic box & helps to give the shand morino its unique sound.
george
-
this could also be part of the reason Jimmy Shand came up with the design that allowed 3 rows of buttons (BCC#) to work only 2 rows of palletes that contained all the reeds for the 3 rows in the Shand Special of 1937/8 and the post war Shand Morino which was a development of it. Prior to this 3 row boxes were very wide and the top row of palletes was obviously much furthur away from the keyboard giving different pallete opening speeds each row whcih must have effected the sound in some way, the 3 row 60 bass hohner organolla of around 1933 used the 3 rows of palletes & looked very clumsy
The same thing shows up on some club boxes: a beloved old wooden Club III of mine has 2.5 rows of pallets to match the 2.5 rows of keys, but a (less beloved, but more robust) red post-war Club 3M has only two rows of pallets. I've always assumed that the slight differences in tonality between the three "middle Ds" is because it's impossible to tune the box so that the notes are completely identical.