Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: graememackay on February 16, 2012, 04:32:31 PM

Title: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: graememackay on February 16, 2012, 04:32:31 PM
If anyone has dealt with the melodeon side of the music room, how was your experience?  Here is mine.

I was asked a favour by a friend of mine who lives in Moscow, to buy a b/c melodeon from the music room, have it delivered to my house so that it could be transported by someone flying to moscow on Monday past.

Sounds easy enough with music rooms free next day delivery service.  Now apart from a small alteration to be made to the bass end this was a pretty straight forward transaction for a music shop.

I ordered it on the Tuesday, gave all the alteration details and spoke of the urgency required and was assured it would be here by the weekend. I had to pop over to ireland for a couple of days and came hem ton find a message in my phone because there was confusion over the alteration. I had to to wait til the next day then spoke to the melodeon chap who wasn't even aware if it was a d/g, b/c or whatever. I made home aware of the urgency and he said he would put it into the workshop ASAP and inform me of the success rate of a Saturday delivery. Having not received any phone call I had to contact them on the Saturday to find out If i was waiting for a delivery or not, he said he would phone me back to let  me know. A few hours later I phoned again to find it was still sitting in the shop. The lack of communication in my direction was upsetting me more than the lack of instrument.

On Monday I thought I'd wait til Tuesday came and the delivery would come, on Wednesday I decided maybe it would take an extra day to get to the highlands. Its Thursday now so I reckon I should call them. Called them at noon, chap knew nothing about it but would investigate and call me back. At 3.30pm my friend in Moscow wanted a Skype call so I phoned the music room again, yet a different chap to speak to knew nothing about the situation. Once again I'm waiting on a call to find out the whereabouts of the melodeon.

Am I alone to be the victim of poor communication? How long does next day delivery take?
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 16, 2012, 04:53:20 PM
I've bought 2 CBAs from them (one went back) and a carry rucksack, also had a couple of tuning jobs.  All went well.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 16, 2012, 05:04:36 PM
My friend has had a melodeon sent down on approval a couple of weeks ago, when he was wondering whether or not to change boxes.
He had it sent down, kept it for some days, found it was good but he really *did* love his old box and returned it.
It's his first time dealing with them, found them helpful, obliging, quick, and didn't have a hissy fit when he declined to buy.
Sounds like in your case they've unfortunately had a 'bad day at the office'.
Fingers crossed it gets sorted.....
Q



Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Hallelujahal on February 16, 2012, 05:10:26 PM
Hi Graeme, I fully empathise with you as there's nothing worse than to be waiting on a delivery and each time you contact the supplier no one appears to know anything. Some of the guys at the musicroom are members here and I'm sure they'll be pretty devastated to hear that someone such as yourself is having a pretty miserable time from them.

But generally they have a pretty good reputation, and a fairly faithful clientèle (a lot who haunt these woods!) - I've had good experiences with them - however, like life, things can and sometimes do go pear-shaped. I think it may be worth dropping Jon Loomes who's a member here a wee note outlining your concerns - I'm sure they'll do all they can to help.
Hope it all works out!
AL
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Sandy Flett on February 16, 2012, 05:24:59 PM
I have bought 2 PAs from them in the last couple of years and all went well, even having one of them made to special order (MMM instead of LMM). Also, felt I got a good deal both times.

I think Al sums it up well, and I agree it would be worth PM'ing John Loomes.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: graememackay on February 16, 2012, 05:45:20 PM
Cheers chaps, I'm not one to complain normally, but this seems to be a bad week at the office really. I was informed on Saturday that management were aware of the situation, which prompted me to assume that I'd be contacted.

I'm happy to admit I'm not always the oracle of communication myself, but so many promised callbacks, not one call.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Christopher K. on February 16, 2012, 07:48:09 PM
That's terrible. Sounds like my communication with the flower shop on Valentine's Day earlier this week, and ten red tulips is a heck of a lot easier than a bass alteration. Good luck with it, though. 
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 17, 2012, 10:33:56 AM
Just to confirm what others have said...

I have been a customer of the Music Room for many years - at their shop at Cleckheaton, at trade stands at festivals and events, and by telephone or online. They have always been courteous and efficient and I would have no hesitation in recommending them to anyone. I'm sorry to learn that Graeme has had a bad experience - I suppose there is always the chance of things going wrong or communications breaking down somehow, and I would hope it is an unfortunate one-off occurrence. I do hope that things are put right for him.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Theo on February 17, 2012, 10:37:25 AM
When dealing with a shop that has many employees its always helps to start any phone conversation by asking for the name of the person you are speaking to, and asking for them by name on subsequent calls.  You then know who you are dealing with and the staff member perhaps feels a bit more personal responsibility to you.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: smiley on February 17, 2012, 10:41:14 AM
I was happy with the service I got from the Music Room (especially Jon and John) when I bought a melodeon last year. They agreed to have the whole treble side redone for 4th button start within about 24 hours because I was due to fly out - and they delivered. I pity the poor tuner who got lumbered with that job!
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Pat. on February 17, 2012, 03:27:23 PM
When John Spiers and Bill Mcinnon ran the music room at oxford a few years ago ,the craic was so good that if I was within 10 miles of Oxford I would pop in and we would have a mini session straight away ,wich was always appreciated by anyone walking in the shop,and the kettle was always on and a great service when ever I bought anything ,however that was some time ago now,sorry to hear of your experience Graham [ I always thought that it was ME that these things always  happend to],hope it was a one off and they get it sorted asap.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Bill Young on February 17, 2012, 04:20:49 PM
<snip>
 I do hope that things are put right for him.
How can they put things right? They've caused the planned transporting to Moscow to be missed by nearly a week. And why suggest that Graeme contact Jon Loomes? He's contacted the Music Room several times. It's their failure to get back to him that he's complaining about.

If this is how they treat a full-time professional accordionist, what can Joe Punter expect? As a friend of Graeme's, I'll certainly think twice about giving any more business to the Music Room, Cleckheaton.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Lester on February 17, 2012, 04:27:00 PM
If this is how they treat a full-time professional accordionist, what can Joe Punter expect?

I would hope they would treat me "Joe Punter" in the exact same way as they treat a "full-time professional accordionist", we are both just customers.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 17, 2012, 05:41:16 PM
<snip>
 I do hope that things are put right for him.
How can they put things right? They've caused the planned transporting to Moscow to be missed by nearly a week. And why suggest that Graeme contact Jon Loomes? He's contacted the Music Room several times. It's their failure to get back to him that he's complaining about.

If this is how they treat a full-time professional accordionist, what can Joe Punter expect? As a friend of Graeme's, I'll certainly think twice about giving any more business to the Music Room, Cleckheaton.
Maybe they could be asked to consider shipping the melodeon to Moscow at their expense (or at least at a reduced fee)?
Obviously things have not gone to plan this time, for whatever reason(s) and I can understand your reluctance to do business with them in the future. However, they are not normally like that, so perhaps don't give up on them completely - think about giving them another chance.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: oread_uk on February 17, 2012, 05:51:23 PM
Having bought 3 melodeons from the Music Room in the past couple of years, two of which have needed alterations of one sort or another, I have always been more than happy with the service I've received - not only when in the shop, but also the communication via phone and email.  They have always been very upfront about how long jobs will take to do, and have normally delivered before the estimated date.  I wouldn't hesitate to buy from them again, and would certainly recommend them to others.

As the general view of their service seems to be quite positive, it seems that maybe this was an unlucky rarity.

Liz  :|||:
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Tufty on February 17, 2012, 06:18:54 PM
I have bought two melodeons from M.R in the last year or so and traded one in. All without any problems.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: graememackay on February 17, 2012, 06:39:28 PM
Well I think the order is now under control. It turns out there was two very similar orders for the same melodeon with similar stories for the purchase which was rolled into one story somehow and only one melodeon was sent... It looks like I will get the melodeon next Tuesday narrowly missing another opportunity to get it escorted to Moscow.

It's very expensive in both shipping and taxes to sent anything to Russia, which is why it's preferred to get a nice chap to take it as hand luggage. I haven't been offered any compensation for the inconvenience and maybe I'm too polite to ask.

I didn't write this post in anger, just a frustrated middle man. I can't say I won't use the shop again, but it might need to be a pretty good deal im getting.
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: Theo on February 17, 2012, 06:49:18 PM
It's very expensive in both shipping and taxes to sent anything to Russia

Last time I tried I found most of the big couriers refuse to deliver to Russia at any price!
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: graememackay on February 17, 2012, 06:57:01 PM
Anyone have James bonds number?
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: mory on February 17, 2012, 07:13:41 PM
I had a Concertina very kindly couriered from Moscow to London as hand luggage by the very nice Bill Dodd, news anchor man for Russia Today the TV station. I had to meet him in a hairdressers felt very KGB I can tell you, it was all arranged through various acquaintances people unknown to either of us personally for a third party who bought the Concertina in Ireland from Noel Hill, who bought it for his son from Chris Algar, it was made by John Connor who lives 12 mile up the road from me, I've met and chatted with John several times and he gave it a quick tweek when it got here, all very Spooky  ;) AtB mory

I enquired after a particuler Banjo from music room and after waiting for a few days for some one to get back to me called again, waited again, finally called again, only to be told it had since been sold wasn't very impressed :o
Title: Re: Music room cleckheaton experience...
Post by: savantuk on February 18, 2012, 12:31:08 AM
I can only speak as I find. 

The Music room has always been my first stop when I want anything.  Always obliging, friendly and ready to do a deal.  I've had jobs done on my melodeons a few times over the years, and the work has always been completed on time, and returned to me within a day or so.

With regard to Russia, I've been there, as a dancer and musician.  I found the Russians to be the most friendly people I have ever met.  The would do anything they could for you, and if they couldn't do exactly what you wanted, they would be bereft!  I was certainly never given any reason to doubt the honesty of the Russians I met, indeed, given their very poor and meagre existence, and the fact that there were £1000s of musical instruments left in various hotels, dance and music sites, nothing was ever stolen.

Give a dog a bad name??  Not everyone is working for the mafya!!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal