Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Jack Humphreys on February 17, 2012, 03:24:31 PM

Title: Grilles
Post by: Jack Humphreys on February 17, 2012, 03:24:31 PM
I was interested, but barely grasping,  the technical discussion about reedblocks.  I had always believed that concertina chambers were tuned to their note, so you could tap the tune out without any bellows-air. I'd thought that was a reason for their carrying tone compared with accordeons reeds sharing their space. So that's wrong, right?

I would be interested to understand more about the accoustic effects of  Grilles.
When recording with a close mike and a  single voice or bandoneon voices without the vibrato/tremolo reeds (or whatever their proper name is) I like to take off the grille to get a bigger sound and more immediacy and precision.

But without the grille, the MM or LMM combination with  swing tuning sounds horrible to me, tinny and inconsistent.  Put the grille back on and it sounds OK.

So sometimes I think I need to swap my substantial plywoood grille on my Loffet Pro 2.6 for a more open grille with lots of holespace like Vander Aa does.  That would let the reeds speak clearly for M, or  LM.   But perhaps it wouldn't moderate the tone so nicely for the LMM.

So I'm wondering what melnet wisdom is about wood vs metal grilles, and  grilles vs no grilles.     I'm aware that the Cajun accordeons, , don't even have grilles
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2012, 09:18:06 PM
I've had chats ( via pm ) with Bob Ellis of this parish after he attended a Loffet workshop last autumn and had a good chance to look around and inside them. Bob commented that he didn't like the look of the all aluminium grill of the 3 row Loffet Pro. I knew he plays a Benny, so pointed out that I suspect his has an ali grill on his Castagnari as my Tommy has one but it's cleverly overlaid on the outside with veneer to look like wood. The back is clearly aluminium. He replied that after inspection, his Benny too is similarly constructed though he'd never noticed! I can't be sure after finding out about 2 models, but perhaps all the Castagnari range has aluminium overlaid with veneer to give their individual sound.
Though your 2.5 row Loffet looks like it's plywood, just make sure it hasn't got an aluminium lining, looks are deceiving!
I'd be interested too, having played a nice 2.5 Pro the other week.
cheers
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Ollie on February 17, 2012, 09:32:57 PM
My Beltuna grille is constructed in the same way.

Which will be why it dented, not cracked, when it came sharply into contact with the curb...  :-[
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2012, 10:03:48 PM
Ollie:
A simple equation.
Kerb or other solid object  + Melodeon =  :'(
Learn and repeat after me............
( hope it's only a dent! )
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Ollie on February 17, 2012, 10:05:38 PM
It was 4 days after I bought it.

Outside pub - melodeon (in case, not zipped up) in front of someone's bike. Bike needed to be moved - moved melodeon - hand slipped, case fell open.

The look on my Dad's face...  :-[

Won't do it again!
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2012, 10:18:51 PM
It's easily done.
My first decent concertina was an Edeophone, the 12 sided variety.
It has perfect fretwork, raised ebony ends. I was told by the chap who sold it to me that it was rare to find one like this, as the 12 ( uneven ) sides means they roll if put down.....then topple and the thumb strap or finger hold pushes through the fretwork.
It meant I banged it into my head to either play it or put it in the box and do the lid up
Consequently I always do that. I need to impress my dearest that her beautiful glass buttoned concertina is equally as delicate, but I'm only her Dad.
Please have a word if you ever get the opportunity at a Fools practise ;)
A lesson hard learned, but could have been worse.
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Jack Humphreys on February 18, 2012, 09:33:50 AM
I've had chats ( via pm ) with Bob Ellis of this parish after he attended a Loffet workshop last autumn and had a good chance to look around and inside them. Bob commented that he didn't like the look of the all aluminium grill of the 3 row Loffet Pro. I knew he plays a Benny, so pointed out that I suspect his has an ali grill on his Castagnari as my Tommy has one but it's cleverly overlaid on the outside with veneer to look like wood. The back is clearly aluminium. He replied that after inspection, his Benny too is similarly constructed though he'd never noticed! I can't be sure after finding out about 2 models, but perhaps all the Castagnari range has aluminium overlaid with veneer to give their individual sound.
Though your 2.5 row Loffet looks like it's plywood, just make sure it hasn't got an aluminium lining, looks are deceiving!
I'd be interested too, having played a nice 2.5 Pro the other week.
cheers
Q

My Loffet Pro grille is just a flat piece of veneered ply. I think its the curved ones that could be metal underneath.
If you're interested in the Pro 2.6.... You might like to note that it has the six buttons on the third row, which gives you the great advantage of  D/E  (GD-speak)  reversals in BOTH octaves, with the buttons conveniently assymmetrically set towards the higher notes.  But his Breton-made line only has the usual five.

What about my original question, though?
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2012, 09:57:25 AM
Jack: I'm afraid that's about my limit of observation and experience of grills, as I have only owned one box!
It's interesting though, because we've both mentioned another variable - shape.
i.e. why are flat ones  made from ply, whereas ( some ) curved ones are aluminium?
Perhaps the shape of a curve necessitates it's metal based to allow a smooth bend, but why choose a curved front? Is it aesthetics or has it a role in sound production.
I do not know the answer, merely posing the question - yet another one about grills!
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: rees on February 18, 2012, 10:04:27 AM
The curved Castagnari grilles are indeed aluminium. Within the last five years, the grille on the Tommy, Benny and others has been changed to a more angular shape and are now made of wood.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2012, 10:09:24 AM
Ahhh thanks Rees for the definitive comment.
Bang goes my 'Castagnari grills are aluminium' theory!
If hey are now more angular, and now made of wood, it hints that the curved shape dictates it being made from a bendable metal.
Has the change to wood had any noticable effect on the sound produced from them?
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: oggiesnr on February 18, 2012, 10:58:17 AM
Jack: I'm afraid that's about my limit of observation and experience of grills, as I have only owned one box!
It's interesting though, because we've both mentioned another variable - shape.
i.e. why are flat ones  made from ply, whereas ( some ) curved ones are aluminium?Perhaps the shape of a curve necessitates it's metal based to allow a smooth bend, but why choose a curved front? Is it aesthetics or has it a role in sound production.
I do not know the answer, merely posing the question - yet another one about grills!
Q

It's easier and cheaper to bend aluminium rather than wood so if your box is curvy it will usually have a metal grill. It's also cheaper to stamp out loads of metal grills than cut them (even with a laser cutter) so again it's a cost issue for cheaper boxes.

Steve
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Howard Jones on February 18, 2012, 11:18:21 AM
On concertinas, metal ends are said to give a brigher sound, whereas wooden ends are more mellow.  The type of wood used can apparently make a difference to the sound.

I must admit that when buying my melodeon my choice was entirely aesthetic.  I thought the metal grille it originally came with looked cheap and nasty and of lesser quality than the rest of the box.  Martin Banks, who I was buying it from, offered to make a wooden grille and that clinched the sale.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: rees on February 18, 2012, 11:27:16 AM
Ahhh thanks Rees for the definitive comment.
Bang goes my 'Castagnari grills are aluminium' theory!
If hey are now more angular, and now made of wood, it hints that the curved shape dictates it being made from a bendable metal.
Has the change to wood had any noticable effect on the sound produced from them?
Q

Not in my experience, but two identical Castagnaris will usually sound slightly different anyway.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Andy Next Tune on February 18, 2012, 11:53:46 AM
On concertinas, metal ends are said to give a brigher sound, whereas wooden ends are more mellow.  The type of wood used can apparently make a difference to the sound.

As does the type of metal! I have a C/G Crabb Anglo purchased many years ago with metal ends which has a mellow tone. Enquiries last year on the concertina forum came up with a definitive answer from a member of the Crabb family(!) - that particular model was engineered to a price and so aluminium was used for the metal ends as one of the cost saving elements.

Andy
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 18, 2012, 12:46:56 PM
OK... from the above replies, it makes sense that aluminium is used if you've a curved end to your melodeon.
I too have believed, and also experienced different sounds from concertinas, the brighter tones produced from metal ends.
If we consider Rees's comments about Castagnari's, individual boxes of exactly the same make/model can vary in tone, so perhaps the metal v's wooden ends are not so important in melodeon sounds?
Q
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Anahata on February 18, 2012, 01:07:39 PM
If we consider Rees's comments about Castagnari's, individual boxes of exactly the same make/model can vary in tone, so perhaps the metal v's wooden ends are not so important in melodeon sounds?
Q

On a concertina the end piece has to be strong enough to hold the button bushes and is likely to get stray fingers poked into it. So one reason why metals ends make make a concertina brighter may be because a metal end can have a lot more empty space to let the sound out, whereas a wooden end with lots of hole area might be too fragile. On a melodeon, the grille is purely cosmetic, so a sparse wooden grille like an Oakwood can be used, where I guess it doesn't make much difference whether it's wood or metal because it's mostly air (or grille cloth).
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Theo on February 18, 2012, 01:09:53 PM

If we consider Rees's comments about Castagnari's, individual boxes of exactly the same make/model can vary in tone,

The scientist in me speaking again.  To make a fair test you have to change only one variable, so to discover anything about the grill question you must change only the grill.  So the way forward is to test different grills on one individual instrument.  Fortunately you can do this easily on a melodeon because the grill is usually separate component.  With a concertina it is, if wood, an integral part of the structure.

The grill lining cloth also has an influence on the sound, so there is another variable!
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: rees on February 18, 2012, 01:24:53 PM

If we consider Rees's comments about Castagnari's, individual boxes of exactly the same make/model can vary in tone,

The scientist in me speaking again.  To make a fair test you have to change only one variable, so to discover anything about the grill question you must change only the grill.  So the way forward is to test different grills on one individual instrument.  Fortunately you can do this easily on a melodeon because the grill is usually separate component.  With a concertina it is, if wood, an integral part of the structure.

The grill lining cloth also has an influence on the sound, so there is another variable!

Exactly.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Howard Jones on February 18, 2012, 01:33:56 PM
one reason why metals ends make make a concertina brighter may be because a metal end can have a lot more empty space to let the sound out, whereas a wooden end with lots of hole area might be too fragile.

That may well be true, but many metal ends have no more spaces than wooden ones.  At a glance, I can't see much difference between my metal-ended Crabb and wooden-ended Dipper.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Jack Humphreys on February 18, 2012, 01:43:21 PM
I have the impression that my wooden grille sort of homogenises the swing voicing, makes it sound nicely smooth. Without the grille it sounds (to me) ... can't find the words.... tinny,  a bit  angsty...nasty .  So the grille seems to be doing a good  job. But one I don't want for the single or octave voices.
So I'm still wondering whether to ask someone to make me a very open metal grille, or just to keep taking it on and off, with risks of dust and damage.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: IanD on February 18, 2012, 01:44:08 PM
If we consider Rees's comments about Castagnari's, individual boxes of exactly the same make/model can vary in tone, so perhaps the metal v's wooden ends are not so important in melodeon sounds?
Q

On a concertina the end piece has to be strong enough to hold the button bushes and is likely to get stray fingers poked into it. So one reason why metals ends make make a concertina brighter may be because a metal end can have a lot more empty space to let the sound out, whereas a wooden end with lots of hole area might be too fragile. On a melodeon, the grille is purely cosmetic, so a sparse wooden grille like an Oakwood can be used, where I guess it doesn't make much difference whether it's wood or metal because it's mostly air (or grille cloth).


Thin open wood grilles (to not block any sound) like on the Oakwood are not that strong even if they're made of aircraft play -- many that I've seen (mine included) have minor damage from being bashed accidentally. Veneer over 1mm aluminium (like my Tommy) is much more robust, but more expensive and harder to make which I guess is why Castagnari switched.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: anotherboxplayer on February 21, 2012, 11:57:56 AM
when i spoke to M. Loffet, his view was a metal grille gave the sound a bit more 'bite' than wooden grilles.

surely any cloth lining in the grille is bound to muffle the sound  - how much depends upon the material and desnity of its weave?  so probably best to use acoustically transparent cloth behind the grille to keep dirt out?
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 21, 2012, 01:09:43 PM
Yes, apart from trade suppliers' offerings some people use loudspeaker grille cloth as replacement. It is woven to be accoustically transparent.  I like the look of a metal grille, myself, and the veneered ali type are probably the best of both worlds.  When the string section of our morris band were making it impossible to hear my box, I took the grille off and even the dancers noticed the change in volume and brightness.

Rob.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: waltzman on February 21, 2012, 02:13:23 PM
even the dancers noticed the change in volume and brightness.
Rob.

 ;D
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: Noodle on February 21, 2012, 05:51:09 PM
I've taken the grille off each of my melodeons. I love the open pallet look of my Hohner 1 row 4 stop, but didn't really notice much in the way of sound difference.

My old Double Ray sounds so much more shrill without its grille which suits me, but it does look a bit of a mess.

With my Binci, I noticed a distinct difference between the rows with the D sounding much more 'open' than the G. I'm convinced there's a big difference since taking the grille off even though it's barely got anything to stop the sound coming out. The placement of the pallets make it far more beautiful aesthetically too, in my opinion. I'm aware that it makes it easier to damage the pallets or the wires, but it shouldn't be too big a job to sort it out should anything happen.
Title: Re: Grilles
Post by: TomB on February 21, 2012, 07:20:09 PM
For more in depth info on reeds and tonal quality, see Malcolm Austens link to concertina net on this thread:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8925.msg111040/topicseen.html#new
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal