Melodeon.net Forums
Forum and website admin => Wish lists => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on February 20, 2012, 05:47:27 PM
-
First a bit of background: I am a great lover of the melodeon and the different folk/dance styles it can be used for. I have been playing melodeon for many, many years, but this past 6 months I have had to stop as it seemed to be aggravating tendonitis in my right forearm. However, playing piano accordion (my first instrument) does not have any bad effect on my arm, and I find that having (willingly enough) to do everything on that I do feel my standard of PA playing has improved. And as I have written in melnet posts over the past couple of years I am very keen to get as much melodeon-style influences/expression into my PA playing as possible.
What I am leading up to: I have discovered so many wonderful tunes and styles of playing through melnet, many of which I have learned, and many on a long list of to-be-learned. I often think "Oh, I would have liked to have submitted something for this TOTM or that ThOTH" but felt it may not go down well to submit a PA rendition. I have also recently learned how to do videos and post on YouTube, so am all ready to go, playing melodeon tunes, hopefully in a rhythmic style that melodeonists would recognise/appreciate, but on a PA. So which board should I post on - directly onto TOTM and ThOTM, or on Other Free Reed Instruments, or on Recordings/Videos, or not at all? I know Theo is not keen on cross-referencing posts, so it would have to be just one of these at a time.
As most folk accordionists will tell you, there is no equivalent to melnet for us. I know I am very grateful for the Other Free Reed Instruments board, and was wondering if there are enough PA and CBA players lurking around in melnet (like me) who would appreciate a thread for accordion recordings/videos of tunes "from the melodeon repertoire". Or would this be pushing things too far? [Edited to add: BCC# accordion players would obviously be very welcome to contribute as well, especially perhaps if focusing on some particular way they get "extra expression" that might help PA/CBA players, or indeed if offering nice Stradella bass effects.]
-
Sandy, this is a great shame - I was worried about similar tendonitis issues once, but they seemed to disappear once I'd managed to sort out my box positioning, and surprisingly, how I was using my PC mouse. Are you absolutely sure nothing can be done to allow you to continue playing? I now actually find the box to be very physically unstressful to play - Finger movements need not be large at all. My mouse-related forearm problem was a bent back wrist - astonishingly easy to correct!
-
As most folk accordionists will tell you, there is no equivalent to melnet for us. I know I am very grateful for the Other Free Reed Instruments board, and was wondering if there are enough PA and CBA players lurking around in melnet (like me) who would appreciate a thread for accordion recordings/videos of tunes "from the melodeon repertoire".
I do a lot of lurking here myself looking for ways to improve my CBA playing. I would love to hear more of your efforts on the PA. If they are not appropriate for posting here maybe there would be another way like a facebook or another blog for melnet followers using alternative instruments. Or even simply adding a keyword to a youtube posting that would bring up PA version of TOTM with a search.
-
Sandy, this is a great shame - I was worried about similar tendonitis issues once, but they seemed to disappear once I'd managed to sort out my box positioning, and surprisingly, how I was using my PC mouse. Are you absolutely sure nothing can be done to allow you to continue playing? I now actually find the box to be very physically unstressful to play - Finger movements need not be large at all. My mouse-related forearm problem was a bent back wrist - astonishingly easy to correct!
Chris, many thanks for your concerned input. I am certainly hoping to ease back into playing the melodeon in due course. My local NHS hospital physiotherapy people said in November that the arm has not responded to what they have tried over many weeks and I have an appointment to see an orthopaedic specialist in March - I plan to take my melodeon with me to show him the positioning of the thumb/fingers/arm that seems to cause the problem. After I have seen him I will actively explore more relaxed ways of holding/playing. What do you do with your thumb on the treble side -edge horizontal or vertical, or behind?
I went over to left hand mouse full-time some months ago.
My ideal would be to have this new PA strand working and be back to also playing/contributing on melodeon.
-
..... I would love to hear more of your efforts on the PA. ........
Afraid my YouTube channel is all band videos at the moment, which I actually fancied submitting to the "collaborations" ThOTM some while back - http://www.youtube.com/user/sfmus1/videos
But there is some solo accordion stuff on my ONMVOICE - http://www.onmvoice.com/sfmus
I would like to try to stay in the melnet community but if they prefer not then you have some good alternatives to explore there. Thanks.
-
Dear Sandy
I feel your pain! I've suffered similar problems playing the fiddle and had to stop a few months ago, so I do understand your predicament.
I really would prefer to keep melnet as melnet. If TOTM or ThoTH become a general instrument tune learning platforms then we could I fear loose something that makes melnet special. So for the present if you want to post PA videos please put them in the "Other Free-reed" section
I don't really understand why PA players can't get something like this off the ground, there are plenty of people interested in PA and it just takes a couple of people willing to put some time in to set the ball rolling. I'm more than happy to share what I've learned. I could even help you set up a separate forum for accordion.net and have some prominent links from here if that would help.
Theo
Edited to add:
There is Accordionist.org (http://accordionist.org/) which just need a few more people to post there!
-
Sandy, this is of great concern - (there but for the grace of God go I!) All I can say is that the PA looks to me much more tendonitis-prone, because the finger movements seem much greater - with a box you've got smaller buttons, and the benefits of two notes per button, so I would have thought it should in theory be easier.
My thumb is placed on the fluted edge, for positional reasons only - the straps hold the box firmly in place. I feel that my fingers fall naturally onto the buttons, with very little movement necessary (with a little re-thinking).
My guru Lionel the violinist used to suffer badly from arthritis - he took so many painkiller drugs to continue playing onstage that he ended up in hospital with stomach problems, and I fondly remember him and I amusing the ward with a few tunes on my hospital visit once (thanks to some condescending and smiling nurses!). I too have worried about continuing playing into my 'dotage', but so far it's been OK!
I see you're in Surrey - not too far away from Essex, for me to come down to a meet-up?
Chris Ryall also seems to have many useful medical things to say about these body things.
-
Theo, nice post.
-
Theo, nice post.
:|bl
-
I really would prefer to keep melnet as melnet. If TOTM or ThoTH become a general instrument tune learning platforms then we could I fear loose something that makes melnet special. So for the present if you want to post PA videos please put them in the "Other Free-reed" section
I agree with you and will follow that route. Thanks.
-
..... All I can say is that the PA looks to me much more tendonitis-prone, because the finger movements seem much greater - with a box you've got smaller buttons, and the benefits of two notes per button, so I would have thought it should in theory be easier.
You would think so, but it seems (to me) to be the very fact that the arm stays so still playing the melodeon, with all the activity being centred on the hand/wrist/fingers, that leads to muscle tension then fatigue that ends up as stinging pain [Edit: also the elbow angle seems to matter as I think it helps to get the box further away from my right hand, instead of cramped up with elbow at less than 90deg]. By contrast, the PA makes my whole forearm leap about which, presumably keeps fresh blood coming in to the muscles. In fact, I think I may be mis-naming my problem as tendonitis as this time it seems to be more in the muscles (I have a history of tendonitis, but this does seem slightly different, and one physio even thought it could be coming from an old shoulder injury - hopefully the specialist in March will shed more light on it all).
I see you're in Surrey - not too far away from Essex, for me to come down to a meet-up?
I always enjoy a get together with like-minded musicians and you would be very welcome. It would be most fun if I was getting back into playing melodeon, so lets see what the specialist says in March then think about it again. Your concern for my problem is much appreciated.
-
That's great, Sandy, just send me a PM in due course.
-
Hmm, I hadn't noticed the elbow cramp issue until you said it, but I see what you mean. This seems to be caused by the continual tension necessary at the elbow to keep the right forearm up, isn't it? I've just tried out a few ideas: 1) holding the box at more of an angle dropped to the left allows the right thumb to exert more pressure on the angled edge, to support the forearm; and 2) a fairly flexible sling around the top strap or your neck, supporting your right wrist at about mid-fingerboard height? This really seemed to work for me! Or maybe: 3) a thumb-strap? (Can't try this, I don't have one.)
-
I don't really understand why PA players can't get something like this off the ground, there are plenty of people interested in PA and it just takes a couple of people willing to put some time in to set the ball rolling. I'm more than happy to share what I've learned. I could even help you set up a separate forum for accordion.net and have some prominent links from here if that would help
As a PA player in the UK, and interested in British folk music and dance, I have long wanted to see just such a forum for accordionists of all types and varieties. I think it could be very valuable - however, I'd hate to lose the craic and fun of this place. However, I understand the need for this place to remain rooted to melodeons. I have a website that I might be able to make available for such a project. What else would be needed? I'm a bit of a numpty when it comes to these sort of things??? Wonder how much interest there'd be.
AL
-
Well, I'd hang out there a bit. I need one more thing to keep be glued to the computer!
Bob
-
Worth PA enthusiasts having a look at where we got to last time - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3976.msg49579.html#msg49579
-
Yes Sandy - I signed up to Karen Tweed's mailing list in order to listen out for anything on the PA forum front. Sadly, all I've ever received is a series of blog messages telling me what, where and when Karen is up to! Not sure holding out is doing much good at the mo?
AL
-
Right - I've got the website sorted, and am in the process of installing the web forum software - will post with details later. THEO I need some help and advice please!
Best regards, AL
-
What do you need help with?
-
Will pm - but basically have created website and have just installed the SMF software - but would like some further advice before going live.
Regards
AL
-
Hmm, I hadn't noticed the elbow cramp issue until you said it, but I see what you mean. This seems to be caused by the continual tension necessary at the elbow to keep the right forearm up, isn't it? I've just tried out a few ideas: 1) holding the box at more of an angle dropped to the left allows the right thumb to exert more pressure on the angled edge, to support the forearm; and 2) a fairly flexible sling around the top strap or your neck, supporting your right wrist at about mid-fingerboard height? This really seemed to work for me! Or maybe: 3) a thumb-strap? (Can't try this, I don't have one.)
Chris - your thoughtful suggestions about trying different ways of holding/playing got me thinking. Up till now I had been thinking "but I have been playing the melodeon my way without trouble for years, so why should it be hurting me now". But it looks likely that I originally hurt my forearm by some other repetitive activity, and it just happens the melodeon playing now aggravates that. Anyway, I decided to get an extension for my right hand strap (dog collar as suggested by Lester elsewhere) to get the box slightly further away so my right elbow is less cramped up, started using the thumb strap and just tried to be as relaxed as possible. I have now played several 15 minute sessions in the last 24 hours and was getting on so well I took the chance to record some schottisches for ThOTM. And the resulting ache in my forearm is much milder than at any time of trying the melodeon in the last 6 months; hopefully this means the enforced rest is helping the weak spot to heal - but I have decided to rest it for a day or two now. Lets hope this is a new beginning, and thank you so much for your suggestions and encouragement.
With Al also now all fired up with his accordion forum this has certainly been one of my most productive posts to melnet.
-
With Al also now all fired up with his accordion forum this has certainly been one of my most productive posts to melnet.
Ay - all fired up is about right. Still a little more tweaking, then it'll be ready to roll out. Thanks for all your help Sandy & Theo!
AL
-
Well you certainly look pretty relaxed in that video, Sandy - nice playing!