Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: Lester on February 22, 2012, 07:48:16 PM
-
Early start this year, just had this on email
MELODEONS AT WITNEY
10th – 11th November
Andy Cutting, Christian Maeys, Emmanuel Pariselle & more
For G/D Melodeon
Sounds FAB ;D
-
Sounds goos to me Lester - last year was great! ;D
-
Jolly good :-) Hotel already booked :|||:
-
Me too, at the Witney Hotel again - no parking but I know where it is!!! Not had any notification re the course, so am assuming it will be along soonish and I'll get a place!!.....oh of course I will, just remembered, I didn't book til July or there-abouts last year. Er... I guess Steve will be back in charge of The Meal, eh, Liz???
-
Also booked into the Witney Hotel again this year. Didn't sound as though they had many rooms left when I booked this morning.
-
That's me booked at the Whitney hotel as well.
I have taken a double so I'm open to offers for a couple of days.
After that I will just have to bring the wife - in which case I'll be looking for child
minders on that weekend.Please direct all enquires to my normal address.
Only a month before "Melodeons in Yeovil"
See ya soon
Davied
-
No wonder I always have trouble booking accommodation, if you all book it now! I never do it until I send the course booking in ::)
-
Also booked at the Witney ;D Sorry Ellie - far too much forward planning on my part :D
And yes, Lyn, I reckon Steve should be the man in charge of the meal this time, then Ellie, You and I can put our feet up!
Liz :|||:
-
Also booked at the Witney ;D Sorry Ellie - far too much forward planning on my part :D
And yes, Lyn, I reckon Steve should be the man in charge of the meal this time, then Ellie, You and I can put our feet up!
Liz :|||:
...and just what makes you all think I'll be going to M@W this year anyway? ::)
-
Hurm, never been to this, but have been meaning to. List of tutors looks interesting, and I'd be eligible for the dinner too. Trouble is, I've got no idea what my life is going to be like in November (at a guess - very busy!). Hmmm.
-
[/quote]
...and just what makes you all think I'll be going to M@W this year anyway? ::)
[/quote]
;D :||:
-
Now then Steve no larking about. We want a firm commitment from you. ::) Oh and Ellie .....I see Melodyman has a spare bed.......get in there quick, girl, and you're all set!
Can any one tell me when to expect the booking forms to be out?
Lx
-
August?
-
It was end of July/August last year. If you go onto the website, you can sign up for the email notification- although I think Lester posted that the course details/booking forms were up on Melnet very quickly last year.
Liz :-)
-
I've booked at the Witney Hotel as well - we'll have to have a session there, there's enough of us!!
-
But they might never let us back again, Dunny!
-
Trust Dunny to lower the tone of the place! In previous years, the clientele at the Witney Hotel has been quite refined.
The whole country's going to the dogs...chunter...chunter...mumble...mumble >:E
-
The problem with The Witney Hotel is that it's actually a B&B.
-
Thought you lot might need some help lowering the tone at the Witney Hotel, so I've booked a room there myself. Only 8 months to go. Can't wait!
-
The problem with The Witney Hotel is that it's actually a B&B.
Confusing, I agree, but I can't see why it should be a problem. Most of us will arrive too late for an evening hotel meal on Friday; we will be out all day Saturday and Sunday turning ourselves into virtuoso musicians (one can dream! :||: ::)); and there is the Italian meal and then the concert on Saturday evening. Who needs full board in a 'proper' hotel?
-
Trust Dunny to lower the tone of the place! In previous years, the clientele at the Witney Hotel has been quite refined.
The whole country's going to the dogs...chunter...chunter...mumble...mumble >:E
Cheers Bob, nice to know I'm appreciated ;D
Of course if you got up a bit earlier you'd be down in time for a sesh >:E
-
anyone tried to log on to book? Cannot get onto the page - have tried every which way, direct, indirect, and all roads besides.
-
I can't either Lyn :(
I'll keep trying and let you know..
-
The site says bookings not open yet
-
MMmmmm. Can get onto Concertinas At Witney.It's just that the flyer arrived this morning so I expected the bookings to be open. Ho hum. >:( :o :-\ :- ::)
-
Latest update says bookings available sometime in August once the programme is set (:)
-
Any news anybody?
-
Nope - still looks like they're sorting it out. Bit frustrating.
-
Very, very frustrating. I did ring and have a word but was told the site would be sorted by LAST SATURDAY. Hmmm. I go away tomorrow, not sure I will have access to computer and printer...so if I lose out on the classes I would like to do, I will not be a happy bunny. :-\ Fingers crossed!
-
I bumped into Dave and Mandy Townsend at Whitby folk festival on 24th August. Dave apologised for the lateness of finalising the arrangements for Melodeons at Witney and he hopes to have details ready in the next few days.
-
:Ph
-
As many of the folk world are currently in fields around the country, I hope he leaves it till after the weekend!
-
Right... Considering that for once I've not left this too late to book onto the thing itself, can someone let me know what I need to do? Have I left it too late to find somewhere to stay? PM me by all means so I don't clutter up the thread with witterings...
:|||:
-
Right... Considering that for once I've not left this too late to book onto the thing itself, can someone let me know what I need to do? Have I left it too late to find somewhere to stay? PM me by all means so I don't clutter up the thread with witterings...
:|||:
You don't need to do anything until the booking opens (hopefully in the next few days). Once your booking is accepted you will be sent a confirmation letter along with a comprehensive accommodation list, both in Witney and in the villages nearby. Some people jump the gun and assume they will have a place and so book hotels in advance. The Witney Hotel is a popular choice, but as it is very close to the school where the event is held, it does tend to get booked up early.
-
Excellent! Thanks! I'm setting a reminder to keep checking so I don't miss out! (:)
-
Hmm, yes, I am one of those people wot have jumped the gun! Booked my room at the Witney Hotel a couple of months ago!!! ;) But not so farsighted if I don't get a place on the course. But then, you can have my room! ;D
-
And me Lyn :|bl I suspect we are many though!
-
And me...
-
Booking form is now live - a very nice choice of units ;D
-
Booking form is now live - a very nice choice of units ;D
Thanks for the tip-off Dunny, my application has been sent.
I saw this on the website:
It is also possible for Caravans and Camper-Vans to stay on the parking area behind Henry Box School. There are no camping facilities
Has anyone on here done this? Is it recommended? convenient? does it need booking up or is likely to be full? any thoughts/suggestions gratefully received.
-
Booking form is now live - a very nice choice of units ;D
Thanks for the tip-off Dunny, my application has been sent.
I saw this on the website:
It is also possible for Caravans and Camper-Vans to stay on the parking area behind Henry Box School. There are no camping facilities
Has anyone on here done this? Is it recommended? convenient? does it need booking up or is likely to be full? any thoughts/suggestions gratefully received.
There were three or four campervans on the car-park last year, some quite large, and it's very convenient for the classes. I didn't take mine being as it's November - getting wimpish in my old age!
-
When I go into their website, it still shows the same old message. I wonder why you guys can get the course and booking information but I can't. Very frustrating! ???
-
When I go into their website, it still shows the same old message. I wonder why you guys can get the course and booking information but I can't. Very frustrating! ???
empty your cache....might be that?
-
When I go into their website, it still shows the same old message. I wonder why you guys can get the course and booking information but I can't. Very frustrating! ???
Agree with LDT, it's probably that you're loading an 'old' copy of the page. I have an app that allows me 'save and read later' and I had a similar problem until I reloaded everything.
-
If you're on windows, pressing F5 on your keyboard usually does the trick.
-
Thanks for the help, guys. You were right! I cleared out the cache using the 'Safety' option on my 'Tools' button and it worked fine after that. :Ph
Booking form completed and despatched. Fee paid. Now just the usual anxiety about whether I will get my first choices and whether those will still seem like the best options when the music is published. ::)
-
Thanks! Didn't realise the cache would need emptying :o Anyway, all done - some nice choices :-D
Liz :|||:
-
Has anyone else had any kind of email confirmation that their booking has been received? (Apart from the paypal receipt?) I'm not expecting there to be yet necessarily, but I feel better if I know that other people are in the same boat ;D (Or to chase it up if I haven't received something I ought to have :P)
Liz
-
It only appeared as open this evening to me. So hope I am not too late! Also could find no way of paying online.....or is it just me? My cheque will be in the post in half n hour. Didn't find it terribly easy to download and attach, and I have sent attachments before!
-
Just found that the website has gone live and printed off the booking form. Are we still OK for the Witney Hotel Bob?
Mark
-
I'm a bit stuck... How basic is 'basic'? How intermediate is 'intermediate'?
Selam
-
I'm a bit stuck... How basic is 'basic'? How intermediate is 'intermediate'?
Selam
You are intermediate I would say :)
-
Thanks, Lester! (:)
-
It only appeared as open this evening to me. So hope I am not too late! Also could find no way of paying online.....or is it just me? My cheque will be in the post in half n hour. Didn't find it terribly easy to download and attach, and I have sent attachments before!
It was a bit glichy - took me ages to manage to get the right page up - you should have been offered the opportunity to pay via paypal (I think if you don't have a paypal account you can make a one off payment via paypal using a credit card). Google reader also had the RSS notification dated as August 2nd, which meant the news was right down the list - with this and the fact that my Mac had cached the page- if it hadn't been for Melnet and Mr Dunn, I probably would have missed it!
-
Liz: I haven't received any response yet either, other than the PayPal receipt, but it is probably a bit soon to expect one. Since Dunny was one of the first melnetters to book, he may also be among the first to receive an e-mail.
Mark: Glad you noticed that booking has begun. I was going to ring you this evening to let you know, but clearly there is no need. Our room at the Witney Hotel has been booked for several months, so you can relax on that score.
-
Well, the RSS feed for a disaster - still not showing up on mine. Happily though I just happened to check in here last night, so booked and paid on the spot (cue late-night deliberations over which modules to choose - I've gone french ;D). Not the easiest booking method I've ever used (copy and paste into an email? For heavens sake, surely an online form is not *that* hard? Or even a list of what you need to put in the aforementioned email. I'd've been quite confused if I'd never been before).
-
Well, the RSS feed for a disaster - still not showing up on mine. Happily though I just happened to check in here last night, so booked and paid on the spot (cue late-night deliberations over which modules to choose - I've gone french ;D). Not the easiest booking method I've ever used (copy and paste into an email? For heavens sake, surely an online form is not *that* hard? Or even a list of what you need to put in the aforementioned email. I'd've been quite confused if I'd never been before).
After long deliberations I've also gone for french for Saturday, Dance Music of Brittany with Emmanuel Pariselle, then Music of Morvan with Christian Maes.
Enjoyed french folk dancing at Sidmouth Folk Festival this year so this chance to learn more about the music follows on well.
Looking forward to Witney Melodeons 2012
Barry
-
Well, the RSS feed for a disaster - still not showing up on mine. Happily though I just happened to check in here last night, so booked and paid on the spot (cue late-night deliberations over which modules to choose - I've gone french ;D). Not the easiest booking method I've ever used (copy and paste into an email? For heavens sake, surely an online form is not *that* hard? Or even a list of what you need to put in the aforementioned email. I'd've been quite confused if I'd never been before).
Hi Ellie - I caught up with this last night. Yes, it's a bit of a clunky system and not getting an email confirmation is a little concerning but fingers crossed. Like you, I've gone French, Christian Maes for everything with Emmanuel as back up. Tempted by Andy Cutting, especially as I've spent the last two weeks trying to learn Spaghetti Panic (inspired by a fantastic recording of it on Soundcloud from Ollie of this parish). But listened to a fair bit of Breton stuff this summer - Esquisse from Nantes were fantastic at Towersey - and I like the idea of staying with one tutor/one musical area for a weekend. BTW, is it me or do room bookings seem tighter than last year, Fleece, Witney and I think Corncroft all gone... looking forward to it already...
-
I have sent a printed form and cheque to back up the email booking as I'm sure it didn't work. I thought the whole experience was stressful in the extreme, waiting weeks for the page to come up, worrying `I'd be away when it did, only finding out from melnet that the link was live, finding the uploading downloading attaching thing nigh-on impossible. I managed to book and pay for my Witney Hotel on line with no bother - I'm not totally technically incompetent! :o
Anyway, 'tis done, fingers crossed. I've gone, tentatively, for intermediate though there are a couple of basic ones I had to include as those were the options. I'm assuming we will get an email confirmation shortly? ie, before the music etc is sent?
Then I can really relax and start looking forward to it all. Phew. erm...that's if I've got a place. Otherwise there'll be a room going at the Witney...... :'(
-
Blimey - looks like we've all gone French :o
I haven't yet had email confirmation, I'll let you all know when I do.
-
I've had a email from them this morning saying there's a bit of a 'log jam' with bookings for various reasons, and they're trying to sort this out, so notifications will be on their way in due course. I think the message is "don't panic, it'll all get sorted out soon...."
Cheers,
Guy
-
It seems there may be more pressure on Christian Maes's workshops than on Andy Cutting's! Like several others here, I have booked mainly French workshops. Let's hope there is room for all of us in the workshops of our choice.
Interest in the French workshops prompts me to remind folk about the Festival des Panards at Hebden Bridge on the weekend of 12th-14th October, where Bernard Loffet will be running a workshop on melodeon maintenance and another one on playing 'Melodeon Breton Style'.
-
Bob - I'm going to Hebden but to dance rather than play.... And I also went mainly for the French options! :-)
-
Liz: Come and say hello. I'll be one of the musicians playing for the bal on Friday evening and at the dance and music session on Sunday.
-
I have decided to give it a miss this year despite my favourite Frenchman being a tutor. Might sneak into the Friday night session to see old friends ::)
-
Since nobody else has reported this yet, some of you might like to know that I received an e-mail confirmation of booking at 2.45 this afternoon.
-
Since nobody else has reported this yet, some of you might like to know that I received an e-mail confirmation of booking at 2.45 this afternoon.
I got mine about the same time, look forward to catching up with you again Bob.
Trevor
-
Yep, got mine today. Got my first choices so well pleased! A3 B4 C1 huzzah!!! :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||:
-
Me too. A3, B2, C1. ;D :|||:
-
....so the next thing to consider is the Italian meal. Are those nice ladies organising it again this year or is the equally nice Steve resuming responsibility?
-
A1, B3 and C4... No idea what to expect except everyone tells me I should go... Oooh exciting!
:|||: :D :|||:
-
This *nice >:E* lady is more than happy to do it again if Steve doesn't want to? Although not the 'pre-meal task' as that's just too much like my day job. Steve?
Liz X
-
....so the next thing to consider is the Italian meal. Are those nice ladies organising it again this year or is the equally nice Steve resuming responsibility?
This *nice >:E* lady is more than happy to do it again if Steve doesn't want to? Although not the 'pre-meal task' as that's just too much like my day job. Steve?
Liz X
What makes you all think I'm going to Witney anyway?? ::)
Yes - I'll be there!
Note that there is a possibly a problem this year which hasn't occurred before...
Those of you who have received booking confirmation and the timetable for Saturday will see that the workshop sessions do not end until 5:30 pm. In previous years the afternoon has ended with a showcase playaround, finishing at about 5:00 pm, allowing us to walk down to the pizza house to arrive at about 5:15 pm. That has given us time to have the meal and just about have time to get back for the concert.
Realistically, I can't see us getting to the restaurant before 5:50 pm, which may be pushing the timing somewhat, given that the staff can be a bit slow in getting everyone served.
What do you all think? Do you want to have the usual Saturday evening Italian meal and silly competition, given that it might be a more hurried affair than usual? If so, I am happy to organise it, perhaps with Liz's help (thanks Liz!).
Please note that if the meal goes ahead, the usual participation criteria will be strictly applied: the meal is for the Sheffield melodeon gang only. Definitely no riff-raff allowed. To qualify for a place at the meal, you need to have been Sheffield born and bred, or be currently resident in Sheffield, or else able to demonstrate some valid connection with that estimable city. You will also need to complete a task of some sort (yet to be decided) which will form part of the silly competition, for which prizes will be awarded.
No applications for attendance yet please; just let me know if you would like me and/or Liz to organise it.
-
Right - now that I've had the confirmation... Another newbie question... :-[... Where, other than the Witney Hotel, would be a good place to stay. Also... :-[ :-[ :-[ where *is* Melodeons @ Witney...?* I can't find the address for the thing (I'm probably being blind/stupid/impatient)!
Thanks
:|||:
Selam
*No prizes** for anyone who says 'Witney'. :P
**Not necessarily prizes for people who don't...
-
Right - now that I've had the confirmation... Another newbie question... :-[... Where, other than the Witney Hotel, would be a good place to stay. Also... :-[ :-[ :-[ where *is* Melodeons @ Witney...?* I can't find the address for the thing (I'm probably being blind/stupid/impatient)!
Thanks
:|||:
Selam
*No prizes** for anyone who says 'Witney'. :P
**Not necessarily prizes for people who don't...
As there is no prize for "Whitney" here is the real answer
http://www.henrybox.oxon.sch.uk/page_viewer.asp?page=Home&pid=1 (http://www.henrybox.oxon.sch.uk/page_viewer.asp?page=Home&pid=1)
-
Thanks, Lester (again!)! Such a speedy response, I shall have to think of a prize! ;D
-
Thanks, Lester (again!)! Such a speedy response, I shall have to think of a prize! ;D
As long as it isn't the *snifflecoughwail* ;)
-
I think it would be a shame if the meal didn't take place. It provides an opportunity to socialise that doesn't exist to the same extent elsewhere in the weekend. My vote would be for it go ahead, although it might also be worth pointing out to Dave Townsend that, since the afternoon session is finishing half an hour later than in previous years, it might be worth putting back the start of the concert by a similar amount of time to allow ourselves (and others!) sufficient time to eat.
-
It's a pity that the programme took so long to publish and it's disappointing that Saturday has been split into two separate classes. One of the things that set it apart from Melodeons & More was that you had a full day to really let the techniques sink in.
-
I agree with Bob - I think it would be a shame not to have the meal - I thoroughly enjoyed it last year and it was lovely to get to know people. Will 'Ask' make the food for order at a particular time do you think? Also - last year we were up there pretty promptly and it certainly didn't feel too rushed - perhaps we could say just limit it to mains, rather than having a starter as well - then we can decide if there's time for desert?
I'm happy to help in any way I can Steve - give us a shout if you want it!
Liz (Who is now broken after a fabulous weekend of dance with Eynsham and Gog Magog...)
-
Just returned from a fabulous Bromyard to find my confirmation A3 B4 C1 ;D
I'm up for the meal, although I may have to be creative re the Sheffield connection.........
-
I may have to be creative re the Sheffield connection.........
Don't we all? A load of soft southerners down there in Sheffield! >:E
Oops! I think I may have just got black-balled from the Italian meal. :'(
-
Just returned from a fabulous Bromyard to find my confirmation A3 B4 C1 ;D
Exactly the same as mine! Great minds think alike, obviously ;)
-
It seems that almost all of us here have chosen C1: it could be a very big class! My other choices are A2 and B2, which seem somewhat less popular.
-
A4, B2 and C1 for me. You're right, Bob, it does look like being a large class. Like others, I too feel it would be a great shame to lose the meal. I wonder if the organisers might be prepared to delay the start of the concert. That would certainly be an excellent compromise -it is good to get 'off site' for a while.
-
Not going to make it this year; clashes with (literally) my only gig this year!
Has anyone signed up to B1? :o I wonder what the tune list for that one is?!
-
Not going to make it this year; clashes with (literally) my only gig this year!
Has anyone signed up to B1? :o I wonder what the tune list for that one is?!
Sorry you're not going to make it...looks like it's just me for B1 at the moment.
Cheers,
Guy
-
A3, B2 and C1 for me.
Barry
-
Just received confirmation that I'm on units A1/B4 & C3
My first choices.
Accommodation already booked.
Cant wait to receive the music !
Onwards and upwards
Davied
-
I agree with Bob - I think it would be a shame not to have the meal - I thoroughly enjoyed it last year and it was lovely to get to know people. ... - perhaps we could say just limit it to mains, rather than having a starter as well - then we can decide if there's time for desert?
Sounds like a good plan Liz. I certainly can't help with meal arrangements this year I'm afraid, but limiting courses would certainly be an easy way to speed up the meal (and ease pressure on one's stomach muscles, and perhaps reduce sleepiness in the evening concert - always a problem up on the balcony!).
Got my confirmation through on Friday - A3, B2, C2. Just awaiting the music now!
-
Rumours of my non-appearance would appear to have been false. Now turning too, stewarding and A3, B1 and C2.
-
Not going to make it this year; clashes with (literally) my only gig this year!
Has anyone signed up to B1? :o I wonder what the tune list for that one is?!
Sorry you're not going to make it...looks like it's just me for B1 at the moment.
Cheers,
Guy
Me, you and Andy then (:)
-
Rumours of my non-appearance would appear to have been false. Now turning too, stewarding and A3, B1 and C2.
Hooray! It wouldn't be the same without you there, Lester :D
-
Not going to make it this year; clashes with (literally) my only gig this year!
Has anyone signed up to B1? :o I wonder what the tune list for that one is?!
Sorry you're not going to make it...looks like it's just me for B1 at the moment.
Cheers,
Guy
Me, you and Andy then (:)
Ooh good...people to hide behind....
-
Details of the Sheffield Melodeonists' Meal and Silly Competition are now available in a separate thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,10329.msg127583.html).
-
Just got my confirmation e mail.
Andy's Tunes first, then Waltzes with Paul Scourfield, and songs with Saul Rose to finish with.
Cant wait!
Will e mail Steve about the meal but as someone who is the great grandson of an ex Wednesday cup winning goalkeeper, and was born and bred in the "peoples republic" I feel there should be exemptions from having to use my addled brain to think of something witty!
Mr Ellis can also stop going on about Shefield being in the south - isn't he really from Abersomethingorother?
-
Mr Ellis can also stop going on about Shefield being in the south - isn't he really from Abersomethingorother?
No, 'e is bloody not! Any more talk like that and tha'll be walking to Witney, Shez! >:E ....never been so insulted in my life....mumblemumblemumble
...
For the record, I was born in Harrogate, but married a Wensleydale girl and have lived here for thirty-odd years. The connection with Abergavenny is that I went to school there for five years.
-
I think it would be a shame if the meal didn't take place. It provides an opportunity to socialise that doesn't exist to the same extent elsewhere in the weekend. My vote would be for it go ahead, although it might also be worth pointing out to Dave Townsend that, since the afternoon session is finishing half an hour later than in previous years, it might be worth putting back the start of the concert by a similar amount of time to allow ourselves (and others!) sufficient time to eat.
I did indeed contact Dave Townsend about this and he has replied that he might well delay the start of the concert to 8:15 pm. After all, he and the tutors have got to eat too. But it isn't definite yet, so don't go spreading the word too widely until it's official.
-
Well done, Steve! Let's hope your efforts to persuade Steve to delay the start are successful.
-
??
??
??
Well done, Steve! Let's hope your efforts to persuade Steve Dave, perhaps? ;) to delay the start are successful.
-
I would put it down to a senior moment.....if I wasn't still such a child! :|bl
-
Take it no one's had a link to the music yet? Not that I'm impatient or 'owt...
:|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||:
-
I'm sort of glad we haven't - it's always better if I don't over-practise!
-
I'm sort of glad we haven't - it's always better if I don't over-practise!
Kind of agree, enough time to know the tune in my head and have a few stabs, but too much practice is just stuff to unlearn when you are showed what you should be doing.
-
Yes, but what about those of us who have little time to practice because we work for a living or have family responsibilities that restrict our practice time?
If the music arrived sooner, those of us who have sufficient time to practice can choose not to over-rehearse, but if the music arrives later those of us restricted by other commitments have no choice but to arrive at Witney under-prepared.
-
We could disagree about this all day Bob, but in previous years I've always had to resort to practising at lunchtime in the car park at work because I don't have any other time... I've no doubt that the same will be true this year. The most important thing is listening to the music, not trying to play it (:)
-
Depends I suppose - I was fine with Julian Sutton's tunes last year - but Geert's polkas were tricky for me because they were at the dusty end and I could have done with a bit more time before the weekend on those particular tunes. With three different workshops this year, plus the big squeeze tune, being able to familiarise myself with the tunes with 2-3 weeks to spare would be good... I think Dave said mid October in the email.... kind of just excited to see what the tunes are really!!
-
plus the big squeeze tune
Hehe. In 4? 5? years of attending Witney, I have never once yet learned or been able to play the mass tune ;D I just go by the theory that with a hundred odd other squeezers, no-one has got a hope in hell of being able to hear what I'm playing ::) :|glug
-
Oh Ellie, I DO so agree with you !!
I'm not going to worry too much, but it is nice to have heard them once or twice.
-
That makes me feel better Ellie :P At least it won't just be me miming :-P I should probably put some effort into learning some session tunes that aren't in E minor, so I could at least join in with the session a bit more this year :o In theory anyway ;D
-
plus the big squeeze tune
Hehe. In 4? 5? years of attending Witney, I have never once yet learned or been able to play the mass tune ;D I just go by the theory that with a hundred odd other squeezers, no-one has got a hope in hell of being able to hear what I'm playing ::) :|glug
That air button is very useful isn't it :-)
-
Problem is that now I've admitted it, I'm going to have to give it a proper go this year, lest catch me at it :o
Liz - we can just take over the session with a bit of E minor 8)
-
Problem is that now I've admitted it, I'm going to have to give it a proper go this year, lest catch me at it :o
Liz - we can just take over the session with a bit of E minor 8)
And me ;)
-
Problem is that now I've admitted it, I'm going to have to give it a proper go this year, lest catch me at it :o
Liz - we can just take over the session with a bit of E minor 8)
And me ;)
Don't forget your C boxes either!
I'm always partial to a bit of East Anglian C mellowness.
-
Problem is that now I've admitted it, I'm going to have to give it a proper go this year, lest catch me at it :o
Liz - we can just take over the session with a bit of E minor 8)
And me ;)
Don't forget your C boxes either!
I'm always partial to a bit of East Anglian C mellowness.
Anything like marshmellow? ;)
-
Anything like marshmellow? ;)
Owtch! ;D
-
Problem is that now I've admitted it, I'm going to have to give it a proper go this year, lest catch me at it :o
Liz - we can just take over the session with a bit of E minor 8)
And me ;)
You're all very good at miming then :P I wonder who's actually playing? It must just be Steve ;D
-
I agree with Ellie it doesn't do to learn the pieces perfectly before you go, but in some of the intermediate/higher classes it does REALLY help to be able to basically play the thing at a reasonable tempo. Not sure how you get much out of a workshop about style, dynamics, ornamentation etc if you're spending two hours fumbling for the notes. So it's October 20, there are two more weekends after this one before we start and I would like the music now Chris. Please.
-
So it's October 20, there are two more weekends after this one before we start and I would like the music now Chris. Please.
And I'm busy both those weekends. Argh! :o
-
Just had a reply on Facebook from Hands on music. They're still waiting for some of the pieces. No indication of a timescale as yet.
-
Got my email with the link to the music!!! I'm getting excited now! (Ok - I was already excited!)
-
Can I ask a really ignorant question? I'm going to Witney next weekend despite the fact that I've only been playing for a couple of months - more for inspiration than anything else - and I'm trying to learn the tunes that are avaliable to download this weekend. I can work out a right-hand fingering for the tunes easily enough, but without knowing what's going to happen with the basses, how am I supposed to know if it's the right one? Or does this not matter? (I'm just a bit worried that I'm going to learn the tunes with completely the wrong fingering/push-pull combinations and then be stuffed in the workshops...)
-
Can I ask a really ignorant question? I'm going to Witney next weekend despite the fact that I've only been playing for a couple of months - more for inspiration than anything else - and I'm trying to learn the tunes that are avaliable to download this weekend. I can work out a right-hand fingering for the tunes easily enough, but without knowing what's going to happen with the basses, how am I supposed to know if it's the right one? Or does this not matter? (I'm just a bit worried that I'm going to learn the tunes with completely the wrong fingering/push-pull combinations and then be stuffed in the workshops...)
Don't worry, you are doing the right thing as long as you have the tunes in your head and a basic knowledge of where to play them all will be well. If you leraned it all before you got there there would be no point in going ;)
-
Can I ask a really ignorant question? I'm going to Witney next weekend despite the fact that I've only been playing for a couple of months - more for inspiration than anything else - and I'm trying to learn the tunes that are avaliable to download this weekend. I can work out a right-hand fingering for the tunes easily enough, but without knowing what's going to happen with the basses, how am I supposed to know if it's the right one? Or does this not matter? (I'm just a bit worried that I'm going to learn the tunes with completely the wrong fingering/push-pull combinations and then be stuffed in the workshops...)
Last year I learnt a really difficult (for me) tune in G before going, and when I got there I found lots of the notes were expected to be played on the D row in order to fit in some nice bass end. I got hopelessly confused on the day BUT nobody minded and I still learnt a lot.
Lester is right, just get the tune in your head ;) You will find everybody very supportive. A friend of mine is going who very recently started playing, so you won't be alone.
-
Was that the Julian Sutton tune Dunny? I remember you sitting next to me bemoaning the fact that you'd learn the notes on the wrong row :-D I think I can just about play that tune now - a year later :Ph
I been listening to the tunes in the car all week so I can pretty much sing them and know what the notes should be, and where the tune's going, but I haven't worked on the fingering - as there are no chords indicated on any of my pieces, and being French tunes there will no doubt be a lot of cross rowing, I'll just leave that till the day...
Although I might put a bit more time into B2, as I think that was the Intermediate/higher one and I'm guessing that I'll be in with a lot of people who are way better than me at sightreading/picking up the fingering.
Sooooooo looking forward to it though ;D :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||: :|||:
-
I frightened myself to death , getting a friend to play the Andy Cutting exercise! Need to listen listen listen to them all, though I will take my never-comes-out-of-its-bag music stand and have the music out - gotta LOOK the part. Actually now the sinking feeling is battling with the excited feeling....and winning! :'(
-
I frightened myself to death , getting a friend to play the Andy Cutting exercise! Need to listen listen listen to them all, though I will take my never-comes-out-of-its-bag music stand and have the music out - gotta LOOK the part. Actually now the sinking feeling is battling with the excited feeling....and winning! :'(
Lyn - my boss always says " Just remember wherever you are, there will always be someone more **** than you..." Strangely comforting ;) You and I can sit in C1 looking puzzled and incompetent together ;D
-
my boss always says " Just remember wherever you are, there will always be someone more **** than you..."
Yeah... that'll be me (:) Oh dear. Thanks for the encouragement Lester and Dunny. As I've signed myself up to workshops that are somewhat above my ability I might just have to resign myself to being the dunce of the class, but never mind. Looking forward to it anyway!
-
my boss always says " Just remember wherever you are, there will always be someone more **** than you..."
Yeah... that'll be me (:) Oh dear. Thanks for the encouragement Lester and Dunny. As I've signed myself up to workshops that are somewhat above my ability I might just have to resign myself to being the dunce of the class, but never mind. Looking forward to it anyway!
If it makes you any happier I have today had the first look at my homework for next weekend and I kind of think that 'I've signed myself up to workshops that are somewhat above my ability I might just have to resign myself to being the dunce of the class, but never mind' (:)
-
So basically, none of us really know what we're doing :-). Snaffletaffle - I was totally out my depth last year - even had a 1:1 with the tutor because I was so far behind... But I learnt so much, had a great time, met wonderful people... And I'm going back this year - so don't worry!!
Liz :|||:
-
Yeah, what Liz says. I'm sure even the experienced players are feeling a bit apprehensive (Not that this has ANY bearing at all on my level of anxiety!) But it's true, no-one has any expectations of you other than you show up, with an instrument, act nice and DON'T NOODLE!!!!!! ::) in class. People are very friendly and the tutors are used to teaching mixed ability. Do as I do and utilise the air button a lot ;) no one can hear you over their own noise.
My biggest anxiety is actually getting there and getting parked at the hotel...on Friday I will be WAY too travel-anxious to worry about the workshops!
-
Was that the Julian Sutton tune Dunny? I remember you sitting next to me bemoaning the fact that you'd learn the notes on the wrong row :-D I think I can just about play that tune now - a year later :Ph
That was the one >:( and I still can't play it :-[
-
Lester if you're doing the French classes, I'll be fighting you for the dunce's hat. Some of it is bloody awkward especially if you play it with Emmanuell's bass patterns. Awkward but fabulous obviously.
-
I've had a look at the music, and listened to it :o and am completely flummoxed. Haven't actually had any time yet, and won't have any this week either. Aaarrghhh! Also wishing there weren't 3 different courses, as I'll need every minute I can get with the tutors!!
I'm sure it will all be fine come Friday... eeep!
-
You'll be fine Ellie. You rattled through that Swedish stuff at Mendlesham and that wasn't easy....
-
That was *brilliant*! I had such a great time. It was so friendly and welcoming. I was a little bit scared that I wouldn't know anyone but I soon found I didn't need to! Hello to anyone I met - I didn't think to ask people if they were on here so I don't know if I've randomly chatted to any of you lot!
Thanks to everyone who gave me info etc. I'm off to practice now. Completely inspired! :D
-
It was an absolutely fantastic weekend :-D There were so many amazing things to take away from it... And it was so lovely to catch up with old friends and meet new ones!
(Liz)
-
Fab weekend will all my best chums. The Frenchies were absolutely fabulous as were the other tutors (:)
Christian Maes was a real example of "whole body" melodeon playing, in the concert he seemed to be playing his box from his toes to the top of his head.
-
Lester - agreed about Christian Maes. I've never seen a box player 'rock out' quite like he did... ;) :D
So... Is it always that good?! :D
-
I bought his 'Arabic' CD - it's amazing!!! :o I did mini videos of a lot of his workshop - def made me think about the value of practicing different techniques... I liked Emmanuel's playing of the cutlery during the Saturday evening Fleece session too :-)
-
I had an amazing weekend, it was my first one and I'll definitely be back next year! Everyone I met was so friendly and helpful and all the workshops I did were excellent. Huge thanks to everyone involved (:)
-
I'm very envious of you all! I'd love to go to something like that. Shame there isn't one for GC'ers.
Perhaps I'll just have to get a D/G box aswell! ;)
-
It was indeed as good a MAW as any I can remember (it was my 14th MAW. When do I get my long-service medal? :Ph).
Lovely to see old friends and to make new ones too!
Many thanks to Liz for helping me out with the Italian meal and silly competition, and to everyone who took part. Also a big thanks to Paul who organised the late Friday night session at the Hollybush. It was great!
Tutors inspiring as usual; Emmanuel P and Christian Maes especially so for me. Totally agree with Lester's comments. Great concert on Saturday night. Wonderful stuff from all.
Hope you all had a safe journey home, and hope to see you again next year.
-
As good a Melodeons at Witney as I can remember (and I have been going for many years!)
Lovely to meet so many old friends and to make some new ones. I vowed not to spend any money this year and I got away with it on Saturday, but on Sunday I discovered that Rees (the Welsh melodeon wizard) could put a stop in my Benny to take the thirds out of the basses. Well, some things you just gotta do...
...and then there was Christian's Arabic CD. I return home a poorer but happier man.
Now to try to make sense of Andy's To the Edges, which our group played so badly in the showcase. Our excuse was that we didn't discover that it was in 3/4 time (not the 3/2 into which Dave Townshend had transcribed it) until half an hour before the end of the workshop!
-
Fulsome praise and thanks to organisers, and how great was that week-end? Only my second MAW but I felt I'd been going for years. (Certainly felt like that as I renewed my acquaintanceship with the Northhampton Ring Road). Head buzzing with the music. Didn't get to do a Paul Scourfield workshop but had breakfast with him at the hotel and had a lovely chat...love to do the ceilidh workshop some time. And I bought a cd and played it on repeat all the way home!! Thanks Paul, some new tunes on the to-do list.
Lester, I said exactly the same thing re Christian, to the girls, he was mesmerising to watch, I love musicians who get so involved with their music their whole body becomes an extension of the instrument. I missed the opportunity to buy that cd, darn it. Perhaps he has a website?
So full of happiness after it all finished I nearly booked my hotel room in advance for next year on the spot! Perhaps I will........
Ah well, back to normality, just a little matter of a possible melodeon purchase to cogitate on. So what's new? :|||:
-
After missing the last two, MAW exceeded my already high expectations.
It was great to meet and chat with old friends, and make many new ones. Hopefully our paths will cross again before next November (Mendlesham?). And if you want to link up on Facebook....
As everyone has said, the concert was excellent , closed with a brilliant final set from Messrs Pariselle and Maes.
Special thanks to Steve. Although Dave T runs the weekend, Steve is a tireless worker, making everyone feel welcome. Thanks for your enthusiasm, it is one of the things that makes MAW such a happy, friendly event. (And of course for organising the meal)
I have now worked out that on a good day, home is 3 CDs drive from Witney! Pity I only bought two :(
See you all soon!
-
Echoing what everyone else said - a wonderful weekend. My mind was blown by the crazy frenchmen - plenty to keep me practising for the, oh, next year or so.. ::) Must remember to order a quiet couple of weeks at work beforehand next year so I can manage to stick it out to the end of the sessions!
See y'all again somewhere soon :D
-
A great weekend. As a first-timer and not knowing anyone else there, it was good to find people so friendly.
Highlights for me were the Friday session (lots of great playing going on) and the concert - my new ambition is to sound like Christian Maes!
Workshops were consistenly excellent too of course.
-
I too have had the last two years away from Whitney and it was good to
make a return and this time with Mr's Rowe.
I had Fantastic workshops with Andy and Saul,plus together with a Brilliant Concert.
(Christian seems to have stole the show somewhat) even Kirstie is talking of a return next year.
Oh and of course all you lot,the stewards, the management all making for a memorable weekend.
Even the natives seemed friendlier.
Of course always a down side.
Got rid of a melodeon but wait for it - yes I got a new(secondhand) one.
Thanks everybody see you next time
Davied
-
Really enjoyed the weekend. Fantastic concert - pleasure to be part of it, especially when I finished my spot and could relax and enjoy the wonders of Andy, Emmanuel and Christian.
The sessions were great fun. Thanks to Paul for organising Friday night - should definitely become a regular fixture of the weekend.
The Saturday night session in the Fleece was wonderful, with Emmanuel again stealing the show, playing Cajun "triangle" with three knives and serenading a young French girl who was out on the town with her friends! Was great to see the group of young girls who eyed the throng suspiciously when we came in get won over, joining in with percussion by the end.
Thanks to all for helping make a special weekend.
Cheers
Paul
www.paulscourfield.co.uk (http://www.paulscourfield.co.uk)
-
I was only there on the Sunday but it was so good to meet up with friends old and new.
I'm there every year and the atmosphere this year was the best ever - such merry banter.
Emmanuel had some new french carpenter's trousers with two front zips. I asked him why he had two zips but can't print his naughty French reply. :o
The Sunday showcase was awesome, even yours Bob. Well done everyone. (:)
-
Emmanuel had some new french carpenter's trousers with two front zips. I asked him why he had two zips but can't print his naughty French reply. :o
He told me the same story but did correct the fact that they are in fact German carpenter's trousers.
-
What everyone else has said. I too thought the Saturday night concert was stunning. It was lovely to meet up with you all again - thank you for your excellent company. As ever, I came away refreshed, inspired and feeling very privileged to belong to such a generous and friendly community. It never ceases to amaze me that musicians at the top of their profession are so genuinely interested in helping rank amateurs (I'm speaking for myself here) develop their skills. I can only apologise to Andy Cutting for helping to murder his beautiful tune in the showcase! Thank you to everyone concerned.
-
Fantastic weekend... highlights .... learning the only joke about anacrusis in the history of the world (thanks Emmanuel) ... a wonderful concert .... Steve's Sheffield Melodonistas Meal where I actually got to sit next to a Sheffield Melodeonista (hi Liz) ... playing Andy Cutting's Atherfield in the session on Friday as a duet - with Andy Cutting (where else do you the chance to do that???) ... ten minutes playing Rees's gorgeous, gorgeous Paolo Soprani Jubilee ... and my relief that someone else had probably bought it ... making new friends .... getting a lift from Phil Underwood to Milton Keynes Sunday night when an accident closed the A40 and I couldn't get to Oxford station ... just the pleasure of everyone's company, really... and weren't the tutors a lovely, friendly bunch this year, as well as being brilliant?
They should give Emmanuel his own tv show.
(Incidentally, his trousers are indeed German carpenter's trousers, worn by a Zunft called the Zimmermen (look a bit like Amish) who come from Hamburg. The two zips are designed to operate as a flap which can open independent of the waistband buttons. I have a pair myself and I must say it is an extremely convenient system.)
-
As I mentioned in an earlier post, Andy's tune, To the Edges, had been mis-transcribed into 3/2 time. I have been trying today to rewrite it into 3/4 time so that I can add the bass line and so that I have something to which I can refer when (inevitably) I forget how to play it. I have been having a bit of difficulty writing it out in 3/4 time, so I was wondering whether one of the people I saw rewriting it during the workshop might be willing to send me the fruits of their labour.
Drinks will be purchased next time I meet you for anyone who will furnish me with a copy of their notation.
-
Bob
I'm pretty sure its in the latest Blowzabella tunebook if you have a copy- can't check until I get home.
Simon
-
I did Bob - but it was dead messy... I think Catie had written on the bar lines too but her writing is much neater (I was copying from her - naughty, naughty :-P) Maybe we should have 'To the Edges' as a Tune of the Month sometime.... in 2014? :o
I have put a video of Andy playing it in the workshop on YouTube... Here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRtdwAOErTs
There's also a VERY short snippet from the session on Saturday night in with my uploads... not sure what the tune is.... and it's very dark... But I'm pretty sure it was Emmanuel and Penny singing...
I do have some other short videos of Emmanuel and Christian but will upload them as a private listing - let me know if you were in the workshops (A3, B2) and want the links.
Liz :|||:
-
I'm pretty sure its in the latest Blowzabella tunebook if you have a copy- can't check until I get home.
I have both the "Encyclopaedia Blowzabellica" 2nd Edition and "Blowzabella - New Tunes for Dancing". I can't find it in either of those.
I'd be happy to make a new transcription but it would be a few days before I could get around to it, by which time someone else may well have done it already...
-
What an brilliant weekend -everybody else has said such good things about it to which I thoroughly agree. I especially liked the atmosphere of friendliness and willingness to help each other. What a great bunch, and roll on next year!
-
As I mentioned in an earlier post, Andy's tune, To the Edges, had been mis-transcribed into 3/2 time. I have been trying today to rewrite it into 3/4 time so that I can add the bass line and so that I have something to which I can refer when (inevitably) I forget how to play it. I have been having a bit of difficulty writing it out in 3/4 time, so I was wondering whether one of the people I saw rewriting it during the workshop might be willing to send me the fruits of their labour.
Drinks will be purchased next time I meet you for anyone who will furnish me with a copy of their notation.
Bob, there's a transcription here in 3/4 - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4898.msg62601.html#msg62601
Personally, I 'feel' the tune more in 3/8, but that's probably just me.
Glad everyone had a fantastic weekend. One day, I'll make it down. ::)
-
Ollie: Thanks very much for the link to the transcription of To the Edges.
Liz: Equally heartfelt thanks for the link to the YouTube video of Andy playing it.
Both have proved very helpful, as has a video sent to me by another member of Andy's class on Sunday.
I am now in the process of putting all these things together with my own notes so that I can produce a version that includes Andy's suggested fingering and his bass accompaniment. When I have finished it, I will post a copy here, if anybody would find that useful.
-
Bob, I would be so grateful if you could post a transcription that includes some sort of indication of the bass accompaniment! I'd love to learn this tune but know I'd find working out the chords a bit of a nightmare.
It was my first MAW and I'm really glad I went. Perhaps next time I'll be brave enough to stay for the whole weekend (:) I was particularly pleased to find that with 10 people learning a tune at once no one could hear what any one else was doing, so I could happily play alll the wrong notes I wanted. Brilliant workshop with Andy Cutting - what a legend! - and I also thought Christian Maes was very impressive.
-
I have finished writing out the tune and adding the basses Andy recommended. I have also begun writing out the right-hand fingering (without which the suggested basses are impossible). I will probably finish it in time post it here tomorrow.
-
I played both hands - just the A part, in my lesson today, and those basses really made sense. I was also amazed I remembered the right hand moves-what a pity I went totally blank for the showcase :'( :'( :'( :'( and how embarrassing was that, eh?
-
Just want to say I had a brilliant time. Fourth or fifth Witney I think. Liked the new format. Great kick off session with Mr. Cutting and then Saturday afternoon and Sunday with Paul - what a great tutor. Learned so much. Didn't stay overnight this year (only an hour from home near Milton Keynes) but wished I had after staying at the Witney last year. Next year! Lots of lovely melodeons to play with. Really liked the 2 1/2 row 3 voice Italian made Sandpiper on the Music Room stand. Thanks to all who brought the kit along and managed to not look too worried when dozens descended on their stalls at the breaks. :D
-
Really liked the 2 1/2 row 3 voice Italian made Sandpiper on the Music Room stand. Thanks to all who brought the kit along and managed to not look too worried when dozens descended on their stalls at the breaks. :D
It was quite euphonious at times ::)
-
@lyn - I'm very impressed with you progress with 'that' tune! Don't worry about the showcase, we were all as bad as eachother!
@ Bob - thanks for your offer of posting the corrected dots, esp the right hand. I'll find it really useful as I can play the tune, but only on the D row which of course means I can't fit the basses :(
-
As promised, here is the notation for Andy Cutting's To the Edges. The notation is taken from a recording made of Andy playing the tune during the Sunday workshop at Witney (thanks, Steve). I believe that it is an accurate transcription of the way Andy played the tune when he slowed it down and omitted the basses (although if anyone notices any errors, please let me know). When he played it with the basses and at normal speed certain variations and ornamentations appeared that I have omitted in order to make the tune as straightforward as possible (although it is still not an easy tune).
The bass line is taken from the sheet Andy handed out in the workshop but has been adapted slightly to reflect what he played on the recording. The notation I use for the basses has a lower case letter for a bass fundamental and an upper case letter for a chord (followed by a lower case 'm' if the chord is minor). Pulled notes are underlined, whilst pushed notes are not. Thus, dG on the first line indicates that you should play a pushed D fundamental with a G chord, whilst eEm on the fifth line directs you to play a pulled E fundamental with an E minor chord.
To play the tune with these droned basses, it is essential that whole bars are played with the bellows in the same direction, so I have included the fingering for the right hand above the stave. The letter (D or G) indicates the row on which to play the note and the number (1-4) indicates the finger to use, with 1 representing the index finger and 4 the little finger. Variations are possible but this (I think) is close to what Andy played. Solid arrows represent stretches (e.g. from a pulled A with the first finger to a pulled E with the second finger) whilst dotted arrows represent 'contractions' (e.g from a pulled C# with the third finger to a pulled B with the first finger). Arrows angled downwards indicate a slide of the same finger from a note on the G row to one on the D row. 'U' shaped arrows indicate a change of fingers on the same button.
If there is anything about the notation that is unclear, please let me know.
-
That's great thank you for doing that and passing it on.
A great help
Barry
-
Good stuff, Bob. Well done and thanks!
-
Thank you Bob, and for sharing what must have taken you a lot of time and effort
-
Thanks, Bob. That is so useful.
-
Excellent! Thanks Bob!! xx
-
wow Bob, what a piece of work! (I mean that in the nicest possible way! ;D )
The actual music as music means not a lot to me, but having the chords/basses set out thus is a big help. :-*
-
Thanks for the kind comments. Praise always goes to my head, so I am feeling a bit drunk now! ::)
I include the fingering and the basses on the notation for every tune I play, so there are lots more where that one comes from - several hundred, in fact!
As it happens, I am working today on another beautiful tune that Andy played at the Sunday workshop at Witney, The Abbess, which is also on his solo CD. I am not entirely sure what type of tune it is, possibly a slow schottische? Can anybody enlighten me?
-
Another thank you from me for the notation of Edges. I started learning this a while ago at an Andy Cutting workshop at a Folkbeat weekend (remember them), and this is helping me re-learn it.
Please don't let this spoil your enjoyment of the praise for an excellent piece of work, but I think the key should be A mixolydian, rather than Am Dorian where the Cs would be natural not sharp, and the key signature would have only one sharp.
-
I agree with you, Theo, about To the Edges probably having been written in A mixolydian, although it is not entirely clear because there are no C naturals or C sharps in the main tune. However, I did notice a C# accompanying the A natural in the second bar of the C music when Andy played it with some embellishments, which suggests A mixolydian.
When I began transcribing the tune, I referred to an earlier transcription in Am Dorian by Luca Celano that was included in another melnet thread and I wrote 'Am Dorian' at the top of my transcription because LC's version had only one sharp. However, after discovering several differences between LC's version and the one played by Andy at Witney, I discarded it and produced my own transcription from the recording. This was written with two sharps, as was Dave Townsend's aberrant version in 3/2 time. I meant to change the heading to 'A Mixolydian', but I forgot. Sorry! :|bl
-
Bob, that's an extremely accurate transcription, well done and thank you!
The only tiny detail I would want to change would be the rhythm in the first bar of the B music, where I think Andy plays the same rhythm as at the very first bar of the tune.
Everything else looks to me to be absolutely spot on (:)
-
Thanks for noticing that. I have listened to the recording again and you are absolutely correct. I am surprised that I didn't notice that when I checked through my transcription and I am grateful to you for drawing it to my attention.
I have amended my notation accordingly and have attached a revised version that also takes account of Theo's point about it being in A mixolydian.
-
I have been asked to share my transcription of The Abbess, which Andy Cutting played during his Sunday workshop at Witney, so here it is!
This is one of my personal favourites from among the tunes that Andy has written. While I shall never be able to play it anywhere near as well as Andy does, I hope in time to be able to do justice to it.
-
That's great Bob my favorite Andy cutting tune
Very useful thank you for doing that and passing it on
Barry
-
You're welcome, Barry.
-
I agree with you, Theo, about To the Edges probably having been written in A mixolydian, although it is not entirely clear because there are no C naturals or C sharps in the main tune. However, I did notice a C# accompanying the A natural in the second bar of the C music when Andy played it with some embellishments, which suggests A mixolydian.
When I began transcribing the tune, I referred to an earlier transcription in Am Dorian by Luca Celano that was included in another melnet thread and I wrote 'Am Dorian' at the top of my transcription because LC's version had only one sharp. However, after discovering several differences between LC's version and the one played by Andy at Witney, I discarded it and produced my own transcription from the recording. This was written with two sharps, as was Dave Townsend's aberrant version in 3/2 time. I meant to change the heading to 'A Mixolydian', but I forgot. Sorry! :|bl
Surely the tune is just in D? Just because it doesn't have any C#s doesn't mean it's in a mode. The tonal centre is definitely D. The chords, although often played over a D, are D, A (which of course includes a C#, so there are C#s in the harmony, if not the melody), G, Bm and Em, which are chords I, V, IV, vi and ii of D major, respectively. If it were in A mixolydian, like The Athol Highlanders), then the tonal centre would be A, but this tune is very definitely in D.
-
I assumed the tune was in A mainly because it begins on an A and finishes on one. I know that, as I have written it out, it finishes on a G, but that is because the G leads into an A as it returns to the start. The last time through it resolves on a final A. However, I would not claim to be an expert on keys and modes, so I will leave further discussion of such matters to those more knowledgeable than I am.
-
Thanks for both transcriptions, Bob.
That's my New Year's challenge sorted (:)
(Don't even think about asking about this year's and last :( )
Andy