Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: TomB-R on February 25, 2012, 01:21:28 PM

Title: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: TomB-R on February 25, 2012, 01:21:28 PM
Okay, I made a stupid mistake, so I'll pass on "the benefit."

When refurbishing a box I've generally taken all the reeds off the blocks, taken off the old valves and cleaned off most of any adhering wax, then dunked the reeds in a jar of meths before a final clean up.

On a recent refurbishment I was called away before the job was done and left and forgot the bass reeds in a jar of meths for two or three weeks.  Bad news - the meths has corroded the reed plates (as online research will confirm) so they have nasty patches looking a bit like light black rust. Happily it doesn't seem to have particularly attacked the corners of the slot and the reeds are tuning up okay, but this set of bass reeds will never look nice again, (unless someone knows a magic method!)

Live and learn!
Cheers all,
Tom
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: george garside on February 25, 2012, 06:08:12 PM
presumably its ok to use meths on steel reeds?

george
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: pete /acorn on February 25, 2012, 06:08:38 PM
hi
My accordion repairer uses a sonic cleaning tank,makes reeds very clean,only problem removes blue from base of reed tongue

Pete
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: TomB-R on February 26, 2012, 09:33:47 AM
presumably its ok to use meths on steel reeds?

george

Seems so, the reed tongues themselves were clearly unaffected.  I don't think a dunk and clean would do any harm to the reed plates either and I may continue doing this.  The problem was leaving them in the meths for so long, which is pretty unlikely to recur.
Tom
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Theo on February 26, 2012, 09:40:36 AM
hi
My accordion repairer uses a sonic cleaning tank,makes reeds very clean,only problem removes blue from base of reed tongue

Pete

I've wondered about doing this.  Do you know waht cleaning solution he uses, and if he uses any anti-corrosion treatment?
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 26, 2012, 10:28:45 AM
I've had good results with ultrasonic cleaning but only in conjunction with normal cleaning.

For what it's worth, the method I settled on for cleaning old reeds is as follows...

1: Remove all visible old wax, glue, etc
2: Clean tongues with PCB polishing block
3: If there's rust present then put them once through the ultrasonic cleaner in undiluted white vinegar, this will remove the blue oxide layer from the foot and underside of the tongue so skip to step 6 if there isn't.
4: Rinse in plain water and dry with kitchen paper and hair dryer
5: Any remaining rust marks will have turned black and should now come straight off with the polishing block
6: Once through the ultrasonic cleaner in plain water, dry immediately when done

If you rinse and dry the reeds straight away then there shouldn't be any problems with corrosion, the old zinc plate Hohner H reeds in my Koch presswood have gone over a year now without any problems. I've tried all sorts of solvents, including neat and diluted meths, expensive commercial cleaning solutions and even coca cola but vinegar has worked best for me.

The best cleaning results I've ever had have been by boiling the reeds in undiluted pickling vinegar, it obliterates any rust and even removes the dull oxide layer on old zinc plates....but....it smells absolutely horrendous, makes your eyes water and the stench permeates and clings to everything in the house. You will require several days of all doors and windows open and routine febrezing before you stop gagging.

If you really want to try it then I can't recommend strongly enough that you do it outside on a camping stove but, (I am actually being serious when I say this), be aware that it might result in complaints from your neighbours.
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Rob2Hook on February 26, 2012, 10:57:25 AM
Just tell the neighbours you're making chutney...?

In a previous occupation I often used ultrasonic cleaning.  For small components the cleaning solution (dependant on what we were cleaning) was put in a beaker and stood in the bath filled with water - rather bain marie style.  If the cleaner is run for any length of time, the medium does get quite warm.  I like the idea of the hair drier, but you could alternatively put the reeds in a warm oven to get them really dry, just like warming plates.  I wonder, does anyone dunk the reed plates in any kind of preservative?  I guess that might prevent the wax from adhering, so I suppose not.

Rob.
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Andy Simpson on February 26, 2012, 11:02:10 AM
I did try camellia oil, which is what I use on my tools and machinery, and that doesn't leave much of a residue at all compared to just about any other treatment but I still needed to clean the plates with meths to get the wax to adhere properly. Not really worth the time IMO.
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Theo on February 26, 2012, 11:17:46 AM
  I wonder, does anyone dunk the reed plates in any kind of preservative? 

I know at least one reed manufacturer does this and I suspect they all do because a completely clean steel surface is prone to develop a fine coating of rust even in a moderately humid atmosphere. 
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: george garside on February 26, 2012, 12:40:00 PM
I was told  some years ago by what I consider a reliable source that the late JImmy Blue,Scottish band leader and Shand Morino player of  some renown, applied a very light coating of WD40  to his reeds ( not the reed plates) after cleaning to prevent rusting . as far as I can gather  it was not sprayed on but applied very sparingly with a cotton bud or small brush and then more or less wiped off so as ato leave a very light covering.  I have never tried this myself  and can't recheck the info as my 'source' is now deceased

george
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: savantuk on March 01, 2012, 10:34:06 AM
I've had good results with ultrasonic cleaning but only in conjunction with normal cleaning.

For what it's worth, the method I settled on for cleaning old reeds is as follows...

1: Remove all visible old wax, glue, etc
2: Clean tongues with PCB polishing block
3: If there's rust present then put them once through the ultrasonic cleaner in undiluted white vinegar, this will remove the blue oxide layer from the foot and underside of the tongue so skip to step 6 if there isn't.
4: Rinse in plain water and dry with kitchen paper and hair dryer
5: Any remaining rust marks will have turned black and should now come straight off with the polishing block
6: Once through the ultrasonic cleaner in plain water, dry immediately when done

If you rinse and dry the reeds straight away then there shouldn't be any problems with corrosion, the old zinc plate Hohner H reeds in my Koch presswood have gone over a year now without any problems. I've tried all sorts of solvents, including neat and diluted meths, expensive commercial cleaning solutions and even coca cola but vinegar has worked best for me.

The best cleaning results I've ever had have been by boiling the reeds in undiluted pickling vinegar, it obliterates any rust and even removes the dull oxide layer on old zinc plates....but....it smells absolutely horrendous, makes your eyes water and the stench permeates and clings to everything in the house. You will require several days of all doors and windows open and routine febrezing before you stop gagging.

If you really want to try it then I can't recommend strongly enough that you do it outside on a camping stove but, (I am actually being serious when I say this), be aware that it might result in complaints from your neighbours.

I feel your pain!! Back in the sixties, my grandma used to cook 'soused herring' every saturday afternoon, which are herrings simmered in pickling vinegar.  The smell was all pervading, and quite disgusting.  I used to get a bad headache within minutes of the vinegar starting to boil.  My memories of saturday afternoons was soused herrings, headaches, and watching Jackie Pallo and Mick McManus beating seven bells out of each other on the TV!!  You have to be as old as me to remember this:).
Title: Re: Warning/Cautionary tale - Reed cleaning
Post by: Lester on March 01, 2012, 10:50:21 AM
My memories of saturday afternoons was soused herrings, headaches, and watching Jackie Pallo and Mick McManus beating seven bells out of each other on the TV!!  You have to be as old as me to remember this:).

Are we twins as I have lived that life  ;D

Les Kellet, Kendo Nagasaki, etc etc
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal