Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: george garside on February 28, 2012, 10:42:04 AM
-
On my new castagnari lilly the music room have moved all reeds up one exept of course the accidentals at chin end and put in low notes B/E on G row and F#/B on D row. I prefer this layout of low notes as it is effectively the same as on a BC(C#) & maintains the same push note evry 4 buttons & same pull note every 5 buttons.
I would like to carry out a furthur modification with the aim of retaining the F nat & G# accidentalsas standard on the push but instead but replace the pull Eb with a pull low C nad replace the pull Bb with a pull low G, agin maintaining the 4/5 pattern.
The music room can't offer this and the only way I can see of doing it would be to cut two reedplates inhalf ( piano acc plates would be fine for the job so I would have the ' middle octave F pushon one half plate and the low Cpull on another half plate. The two haaf plates would then be glued or otherwise attached to each other to become one reedplate.
has anybody done anything like this? What would be best way of cutting reed plates in half reasonably accurately and woulda two pack epoxy such as araldite work to join them edge to edge etc etc. Any ideas welcome. (if this doesn't work I might shove everything up one more & go for 5th button 'do' with low notes & accidentals.
george
-
So if I understand you correctly you want to end up with F/C on the G row button 1 and G#/G on the D row button 1? where the C is a fourth lower than F, and the G is an octave and a bit lower than the G#?
I may be able to find suitable reed plates, almost certainly for the F/C if I have the right interval.
If not then yes cutting and joining can work, I have see it done. There would be no need for a particularly strong bond between the two halves as long as it is airtight, just wax would probably work.
The only possible problem that you might run into would be that the size of the reed chamber would have to be a compromise between the needs of the high and low reeds, which might mean that one or both reeds would not respond quite as well as usual.
-
You could always partition the chamber and have an insert for the higher reed... but that would involve doubling the height of the chamber as well. Possible, but perhaps not advisable.
-
So if I understand you correctly you want to end up with F/C on the G row button 1 and G#/G on the D row button 1? where the C is a fourth lower than F, and the G is an octave and a bit lower than the G#?
I may be able to find suitable reed plates, almost certainly for the F/C if I have the right interval.
If not then yes cutting and joining can work, I have see it done. There would be no need for a particularly strong bond between the two halves as long as it is airtight, just wax would probably work.
thanks Theo, The C iwant on the first button instead of Bb will be around an octave and a bit lower than the F on that button, i.e. I will have 3 C's available on the G row. I will experiment with two half reedplates using ex piano acc reeds as I have plenty of good ones.
george
-
I have some piano reeds I have been practicing tuning on. Can you tune up/down a piano reed to create a diatonic reed plate or is it best to slice the reed plates in half and join them together to get the diatonic reed plate?
Stephen
-
You are probably better off soldering one tongue down than filing one up.
Gets harder the higher/smaller the plate is.
-
I have some piano reeds I have been practicing tuning on. Can you tune up/down a piano reed to create a diatonic reed plate or is it best to slice the reed plates in half and join them together to get the diatonic reed plate?
Stephen
I've made quite a few bisonoric reedplates from unisonoric PA reeds by tuning one or both sides up or down as required. Generally speaking you can safely go a semitone either way. Intervals of more than a tone can sometimes be achieved by the solder blob method. As far as I am aware it's fairly standard practice.
Graham
-
I have some piano reeds I have been practicing tuning on. Can you tune up/down a piano reed to create a diatonic reed plate or is it best to slice the reed plates in half and join them together to get the diatonic reed plate?
Stephen
I've made quite a few bisonoric reedplates from unisonoric PA reeds by tuning one or both sides up or down as required. Generally speaking you can safely go a semitone either way. As far as I am aware it's fairly standard practice.
Graham
So standard that, when you stop to think about it, that is how Hohner make diatonic plates in the first place. (And why they voice chords the way they do on many instruments.)
-
That's really interesting re: the use of solder. I'm just learning to tune by experimenting on older PA reeds myself. I was wondering if two half reed plates could be joined with silver solder which has a low melting temp, but also has low plasticity, or perhaps 95/5 solder, if the added heat to reach molten state wouldn't affect the reed. I've never tried this myself so on the principle that simpler is better, the previous ideas would seem preferable.
Regarding using solder to adjust tuning, I was not aware of this technique. With so many different types of solder, is one preferred over another (40/60) for greater workability? Does this affect a reed's ability to hold tuning? Is there more detail on this technique anywhere?
Thanks, Terry
http://www.harrisproductsgroup.com/en/Products/Alloys/Soldering.aspx
-
Surely silver solder has a high melting point - higher, I would have thought, then the metal from which the plates are cast. I'd guess if you were going to try it you'd need a 70 deg solder & suitable flux intended for whitemetal & pewter, along with a temperature-controlled iron. Personally I probably wouldn't attempt (though I miight try it on a scrap plate just to see what happens!) Soldering on to the tip of a reed isn't usually a problem because of the air-gap round the reed and the fact the mass of the steel tongue acts as a heat-sink. I have usually done this with ordinary domestic resin-cored solder, but I occasionally use a 188 deg solder with a suitable paste flux.
-
Electrical solder has a lower melting point than plumbing solder, and the acid in some plumbing solder may cause problems. I use a dot of solder rosin on the reed tip, and electrical solder. When you got a pile on the reed, you can add more to build height and weight by letting it harden, and then quickly add more solder to the hardened surface.
Try to keep the solder to the top 3rd of the reed. and use the longest reed you can get away with to improve response.