Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andy in Vermont on February 28, 2012, 07:52:45 PM
-
Has anyone spotted a "Brio" in the wild?
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/02/castagnari-for-beginners.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/02/castagnari-for-beginners.html)
-
I wonder what the "beginners" price would look like...
-
The Studio, a comparable model, is 900 euros direct from Castagnari (according to a price list that I got several months back) and the Nik is a higher quality level (with better reeds) for 1150 euros, so it stands to reason that the Brio will be somewhere between.
In the past, there have been discussions about reasonable price ranges for student instruments.
I imagine everyone has a different standard of what a good box for a beginner would be, and what kind of price a beginner should play. I started on a 2 row, used Czech box that cost about half the price of a new Pokerwork. It was a terrible box, with springs constantly breaking, terrible reed lags, extra wide button spacing -- I learned about 2 tunes and then promptly upgraded. The thing was in no condition to sell and was basically worthless when I was done with it.
Some people might find that what I had was a good box for a beginner. I personally think that it was a waste. I wasted time fixing the thing several times, and in the end it isn't even a reasonable back-up box. If I hadn't switched to a different box, I would have given up.
A Pokerwork could be a great box for a beginner and should last more than several tunes (indeed, some keep playing them if they like the sound and feel of these classic boxes); should the player decide to move on to a fancier box, the Pokerwork should be useful for the next person as well. The newer line of Hohner boxes (Merlin etc) seem like a great choice, too.
The same can certainly be said for a Castagnari Studio (and likely, the Brio as well, if it meets the standards of quality that one expects from Castagnari). I think that a box like this could easily be an heirloom, passed on to the next generation, or from one child in the family to the next.
At some level, there are some consumer choices that some will agree or disagree with. The current production of Hohner Pokerworks and the new wooden Hohners are made in China; as far as I know, the Studio and Brio are made by Castagnari in Italy.
-
I played a Studio a few months back and was not really impressed; with Dural reeds it sounded like a bunch of other, less expensive boxes. The casework was very plain, seemed like ply.
However, what it did have: it was in tune and had good action set up.
Right there, that is worth the difference in price with some of the cheaper stuff.
By the time you buy a Merlin or PW and get it tuned and "fettled", you are at the Studio price point.
Plus the re-sale has got to be better, I would think.
-
It's a bit like buying a "entry-level" BMW instead of a fully-loaded Chevy...
-
Hmmm... looking at the Brio pictures, I'm wondering why it's not Irish style flat keyboard - arguably, this would have been marginally cheaper to produce, easier to maintain... and opened this entry model to a much wider market...
Ed J
-
I'm wondering about the availability. One of the great advantages of a Pokerwork is that they are stocked by so many places that one can arrive by mail order within a few days, complete with bag, book and CD. If however there is a waiting list, the beginner might, just might, lose interest and take up the hammered dulcimer (joke!) or other instrument instead.
-
I'm wondering about the availability. One of the great advantages of a Pokerwork is that they are stocked by so many places that one can arrive by mail order within a few days, complete with bag, book and CD. If however there is a waiting list, the beginner might, just might, lose interest and take up the hammered dulcimer (joke!) or other instrument instead.
My feeling is that unless a beginner would have done some research before buying, the Castagnari name wouldn't necessarily prompt the purchase of a "entry-level" box.
Nice from them to offer lower-priced models though. Their marketing people must be at work!
-
It's a bit like buying a "entry-level" BMW instead of a fully-loaded Chevy...
I don't know, I'd say the comparison between a Morgane & a Castagnari Studio or Brio might be the equivalent of a Ford Focus vs. a BMW 135i, with the Pokerwork as a less-than-fully-loaded "Chevy".
I haven't had the opportunity to try to try a low-end Castagnari, so maybe it is actually superior to the Hohner "ligne naturel", but the Morgane & the Merlin I've owned did not need tuning or "fettling" & seem like very well designed boxes for the money.