Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Gary P Chapin on March 05, 2012, 04:02:31 AM
-
I understand this kind of musing is not for everyone. For me, it's a good time. Thanks to Chris Ryall, Owen, and Vermont Andy,
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2012/03/neil-postman-and-accordion-technopoly.html
-
Kind words and a nice thoughtful article. You might consider Mike Hurst in there following his typically bold post in the Films theme
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8993.msg111881.html#msg111881
I rarely see Mike, but he's been a long term influence on me. Hearing him in Whitby got me to realise :o there were 'blue' notes, and made me wonder how to use them.
I still recall a shouted "stop thinking about it" when I was stumbling in a fast pace 'double step back' in a Chester FF session. The shock of it actually made me stop thinking and I believe my play took a step forward from that instance. Never mind, thanks Mike and Gary, and yes, it is all about attitude.
Any more melodeonistas fancy a 'last cigarette'? :-\
-
Interesting and thought provoking blog, thanks.
I wonder at what point does it come full circle where, as a reaction to the movement to bigger and more complex boxes, folks start going back to simpler boxes and a simpler style of playing? Almost like the punk reaction against prog rock (:)
Steve
-
The design of all instruments is a compromise. Take for example the violin - "perfected" over centuries - yet the most valued is an antique modified to make it more playable. Then someone decided that for convenience a fifth string should be added, giving the extended range of a viola, but with a tone that falls somewhere between the two... Horses for courses.
Various types and quantities of basses have long been available on diatonic boxes and the current trend seems to cater for performers who want the extended possibilities they offer. Some can carry this off, just as the Shand box retains the punch of the diatonic system whilst making the bass capable of the harmonies and counterpoints of the stradella system. Some players can make it work, others just sound like a poorly played PA. There is a risk that with the size and weight of such boxes the typical sound of a diatonic will be lost for the majority of players - it takes physical stature and strength to waggle all that mass around!
I don't say that I dislike the new machines, just that they seem to suit concert performance rather than the mostly dance based origins of the instrument. Bear in mind that there are also musical genres in which players take the bass reeds out to lighten the instrument. We're not too likely to see many of these out playing for Morris or even social dance in the UK at least. Perhsaps this is one of the indicators of what promotes MAD, I bet people who own the new behemoths also have a few small boxes for other applications.
Rob.
-
Another advantage of going 3 row is that you can play in in many more keys (especially if chording in a group) and don't have to lump so much about. Despite this anybox is happiest in home keys - sessioning you need at least 2 rows in the appriopriate keys for the country you are in - so D+G+something in UK, C+G+something in France. Even Pignol says this.
But the ability to wander off and arrange/improvise something off piste, eg fluent interchange of 6th/b6th and 7th/maj7thnotes when in a minor (Grapelli did this all the time) or interjecting of 'blue' #4th and b9s is a whole different way of play. In particular it's very central to the sounds presently floating across from France and Belgium.
You do need to learn yer scales to approach this. Hence my interest and surprise that Mike had explored the same route. Including the third row! He was always a 1 row fella! :|glug
-
In particular it's very central to the sounds presently floating across from France and Belgium.
I agree. It's a movement going on.
-
Speaking for myself, I favour the basic 2-row 8-bass and feel that the compromises necessary to bully tunes into shape to fit onto this are part of the character of the instrument. I recognise that the increased chromaticism and flexibility of the newer designs open the door to all sorts of possibilities, but this doesn't attract me. But it's just a personal point of view.
-
Speaking for myself, I favour the basic 2-row 8-bass and feel that the compromises necessary to bully tunes into shape to fit onto this are part of the character of the instrument. I recognise that the increased chromaticism and flexibility of the newer designs open the door to all sorts of possibilities, but this doesn't attract me. But it's just a personal point of view.
I tend to agree, it's a bit like your attitude towards a relationship between persons:
Option 1: Live it and love it.
Option 2: Live it and hate it.
Option 3: Leave it.
I pick number 1; instead of trying to escape the limitations inherent to the design of a 2-row, one may find more satisfaction in learning how to get along with them!
When I listen to what good players can do on a 1-row, it motivates me to keep working on improving my playing on a "stock" melodeon.
-
I ought to listen to more of the kind of music being made by the people who are driving the trend for these boxes before commenting, I suppose, but a while back I watched some clips from live performances on the website of one of the players you mention on your blog, Gary, and it didn't do much for me I have to say. The guitar-hero postures and dramatic grimaces did nothing to compensate for what struck me as vacuous, meandering melodies. >:E
-
Speaking for myself, I favour the basic 2-row 8-bass and feel that the compromises necessary to bully tunes into shape to fit onto this are part of the character of the instrument. I recognise that the increased chromaticism and flexibility of the newer designs open the door to all sorts of possibilities, but this doesn't attract me. But it's just a personal point of view.
Why does mel.net not have a LIKE button. I really wish I had said this.
-
Seems to me there is approximately a spectrum between pure diatonic(one row) and fully chromatic:
- One row two bass
- One row 4 bass
- two row, no accidentals, 8 bass
- two row, accidentals, 8 bass
- 3 row, no accidentals, 12 bass
- 3 row, accidentals, 12 bass
- two row, accidentals, 12 bass
- two plus half row, 12 bass
- two plus half row, 14 bass
- two plus full row, 12 bass
- two plus full row, 18 bass
- three row stradella bass
- chromatic button stradella bass
- piano key, stradella bass
And the art of happy music making is to decide where on that spectrum suits you.
-
Speaking for myself, I favour the basic 2-row 8-bass and feel that the compromises necessary to bully tunes into shape to fit onto this are part of the character of the instrument. I recognise that the increased chromaticism and flexibility of the newer designs open the door to all sorts of possibilities, but this doesn't attract me. But it's just a personal point of view.
Why does mel.net not have a LIKE button. I really wish I had said this.
seconded! ( or should it be thirded!)
george >:E
-
Interesting and thought provoking blog, thanks.
I wonder at what point does it come full circle where, as a reaction to the movement to bigger and more complex boxes, folks start going back to simpler boxes and a simpler style of playing? Almost like the punk reaction against prog rock (:)
Steve
at one time a 'melodeon' had one or two treble rows and 8 bass at the most. Should the 2-3 row 18 bass jobs be called melodeons or are they something else - button accordions ? but clumsy ones when compared to the 3 row British Chromatic with stradella bass which are much easier to play and have bass scope that cannot be acheived where bass and treble are weddedd to each other in in a' directional battle'. For me the best of both worlds lis enompassed by just two boxes - a simple 2 row 8 bass DG with all its well known advantages of lightness, portability, rhythmic ability, and most bang for your buck and a lightweight 48 bass (casali) British Chromatic which will do mot other things including having all 12 keys readily available with bass to maatach and without any directional battles between treble and bass (MAD in one box)
george ;)
-
I wonder at what point does it come full circle where, as a reaction to the movement to bigger and more complex boxes, folks start going back to simpler boxes and a simpler style of playing? Almost like the punk reaction against prog rock (:)
I wonder if this hasn't already happened. When the original music of Auvergne came to Paris and started being played on chromatic accordions, then became more complicated, and eventually became a whole other thing, Bal Musette? Then the late sixties and seventies and there's a folk revival in France (just like in the US and UK). Suddenly diatos become the weapon of choice, Bal Musette becomes a period piece.
Speaking for myself, I favour the basic 2-row 8-bass and feel that the compromises necessary to bully tunes into shape to fit onto this are part of the character of the instrument. I recognise that the increased chromaticism and flexibility of the newer designs open the door to all sorts of possibilities, but this doesn't attract me. But it's just a personal point of view.
What's interesting is that I enjoy a lot listening to the extended work (I'm a jazz fan from way back), but when I think about what do I want to play ... it's 2 row, 8 bass that is my favorite. Even on the Pastourelle III (2 and a half row, 12 bass), I definitely take more advantage of the extra reed choices than I do the half row and flat basses.
-
(sorry for the typos in this... display fault on my screen makes correction very difficult)
Thanks Gary.
I've found your Postman post and the rest of the discussion very helpful....as I've been infected with the idea that I might want a 3R 18B... and after reading this, I'm slightly recovering. I agree that the invention of the chromatic button giant machines led to amazingly complex playing....just because it COULD be done. The existence of all those buttons must have seemed to call for them to be used. Hence the reaction back to 2R 8B with the folk revival. So then diato-accordionists had the same kind of restriction as the other folk instruments, such as pipes and gurdy... and the restrictions seemed to help the quality of the music, compared with the elaborate (indulgences?) of the chromatics virtuoso.
For Postman's theory, interesting to compare accordions with the violin. The violin stays in its simple basic form, four strings and no frets. It permits musicians at all levels to play simple or amazingly complex and virtuosic music. If you like, you can just play simple tunes in first position. No probs. It does not embody complexity in its structure like a chromatic or 3R 18B does. So I can understand the idea that the existence and growing acceptability of 3R18 does almost call for the built-in complexity to be used to play more complex (chromatic/ multi-key) tunes.
So I'm thinking that 18 bass bisonorics are maybe a step too far for me. Of course there are even further steps, such, as Marc Perrone adding a fourth melody row, to try and make the thing entirely chormatic both ways!!!! Or maybe it's just as crazy playing an accordion almost entrely on the pull, as I'm doing a lot of th time, with those big gulps of air from time to time. I like the discssuion of these points on the Marc Serafini page disssing the DARWIN. If your really want to keep a push-pull keyboard AND play chromatically, its seems to be that the Darwin must be the way to go.
The big counterargument is that quality of playing from Bruon le Tron and others using a 3R 18B. which to me is much more interesting than players on chromatics usuall are. iI'm thinking that if I must learn to play more multi-key chromatic pieces, maybe the chromatic is the way to go. There are also some brilliant players of that, every bit as good as diatonists..(in my opinion) .. such as Herve from Trio DCA, and the chap on the Salterelle website.
Finally. One great benefit of melnt for me has been to hugely increase my respect and appreciation for 2R8B players. Currently for the delicacy shown by Mr Joreema, CLIVE WILLIAMS and Ed Rennie. I never dreamt that hohners could make suchbeautiful music. Another reasons to eschew the escaltlation to more complex booxes.
-
In considering 18-bass stuff, free bass hadn't occurred to me.
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2012/03/free-bass-greensleeves.html
-
In considering 18-bass stuff, free bass hadn't occurred to me.
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2012/03/free-bass-greensleeves.html
I have an 18 bass box that can work like a free bass. There are two stops on the left-hand end:
Stop One - takes out the lower of the two bass reeds
Stop Two - takes out the fundamental of the two voice 'chords' leaving only the third of the 'chord'
I've not had it long enough to get my head fully round it all, but it certainly opens up a number of possibilities.
-
Once upon a time there was a German three row concertina, push/pull like an anglo. Then they started adding buttons, a few here, a few there and added in a drop of "wouldn't be nice if...". Every so often they would branch out, or stop and then someone would do something a bit different.
The up shot was we ended up with anglo/german concertinas, chemnitzers and bandoneons all of which have a pretty unique technique and repertoire. Are melodeons going the same way?
Steve
-
In considering 18-bass stuff, free bass hadn't occurred to me.
http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2012/03/free-bass-greensleeves.html
I have an 18 bass box that can work like a free bass. There are two stops on the left-hand end:
Stop One - takes out the lower of the two bass reeds
Stop Two - takes out the fundamental of the two voice 'chords' leaving only the third of the 'chord'
I've not had it long enough to get my head fully round it all, but it certainly opens up a number of possibilities.
That's a good idea. A very good idea.
-
Stop One - takes out the lower of the two bass reeds
Stop Two - takes out the fundamental of the two voice 'chords' leaving only the third of the 'chord'
Gaillard uses this system. It preserves a basic if sparse 'chord' feel, is ambivalent wrt major/minor, and allows fingering of some tritone pairs. I have to say these can bring on cramp, but the 'dominant' chords are not theoretically possible using our standard cross chord fingerings.
And, if you are called Norbert you can run 2 octave counterpoint on he left hand. :Ph
-
It preserves a basic if sparse 'chord' feel, is ambivalent wrt major/minor, and allows fingering of some tritone pairs.
Not quite. As the 'chords' are made up of the root and third of the chord, then they are not particularly ambivalent wrt major/minor.
-
As said here, it is indeed food for thought.
I have been going through these thought processes, and threads like this are useful to help make choices.
I have been thinking I'd maybe treat myself to a 2.5 row for a birthday in 18months time, inspired by the wonderful sounds of the Banquest of boxes cd.
But.....
I've bumped into a whole new ( to me ) treasure trove of English tunes played on a 2 row which I love - JK's English Choice. Love it. Feels like it's where I'd like to be.
I realise some of the tunes from Mr. Cutting I'm currently learning slowly are achievable on a 2 row. I didn't think they were. The odd chords are mostly do-able by cross chording, subsituting alternative 8 bass options, or simply cheating and leaving them out! I hadn't realised there was so much you could do on a 2r8b.
Not being particularly into the continental repertoire, I'm not sure I need the other basses and at this moment in time can't work out what I'd use them for.
I have come to melodeon late so would prefer to concentrate on one thing - a 2 row - and get it right rather than spread myself too thin on other variants.
I might be tempted by a full sized box, as opposed to the smaller one I play, but.......
apart from stretching my fingers for the occasional accidental, I think I'm heading towards a 2 row choice.
I can start to understand why more experienced players are making the positive choice of sticking with a simpler system, especially if just playing the solid English session tunes that is what I enjoy.
Q
-
As said here, it is indeed food for thought.
I , or simply cheating and leaving them out!
[/quote
I have never considered this to be 'cheating', rather something that you can make a feature of ( less is more & all that)!
george ( who must been cheating for many a year but didn't realise it!!) ;D
-
Thanks Owen - slip up there :|bl My Gaillard came with 1+5 chords and the slide takes out (generally) the tonic
-
Seems to me there is approximately a spectrum between pure diatonic(one row) and fully chromatic:
- One row two bass
- One row 4 bass
- two row, no accidentals, 8 bass
- two row, accidentals, 8 bass
- 3 row, no accidentals, 12 bass
- 3 row, accidentals, 12 bass
- two row, accidentals, 12 bass
- two plus half row, 12 bass
- two plus half row, 14 bass
- two plus full row, 12 bass
- two plus full row, 18 bass
- three row stradella bass
- chromatic button stradella bass
- piano key, stradella bass
And the art of happy music making is to decide where on that spectrum suits you.
You missed out
"two plus half row with 8 basses"
which is a "two row + accidentals 8 bass" with more accidentals and low notes to cover all tunes in the "home" keys, but without the heavier and less ergonomic/comfortable bass end of a 12 bass...
-- and which would probably be my "ideal" box if I had to choose only one... ;-)
-
George: thanks for correcting me - absolutely right. Making more of less.
A much better way of phrasing it :D
Q
-
You missed out
"two plus half row with 8 basses"
I know Ian, :|bl and I missed out a whole load of other configurations as well, :o but I think there were enough in there to illustrate the general point of choosing a comfy spot on the scale.
-
You missed out
"two plus half row with 8 basses"
I know Ian, :|bl and I missed out a whole load of other configurations as well, :o but I think there were enough in there to illustrate the general point of choosing a comfy spot on the scale.
Couldn't agree more -- and the "comfy spot" is completely different for different people depending on personal preference and what type of music they play.
Arguing that one is always "better" than the other is like saying that a Ducati is always better than a Ferrari (or a Routemaster bus)...
-
Couldn't agree more -- and the "comfy spot" is completely different for different people depending on personal preference and what type of music they play.
Arguing that one is always "better" than the other is like saying that a Ducati is always better than a Ferrari (or a Routemaster bus)...
2-row B/C with 12 basses. Then you cover a good 'spectrum' !
-
but only if they are 12 'stadella' as on some double ray de lux's as otherwise they are not much better than 'standard' 8 BC bass.
george ;)
-
Slightly different question:
What is the etiology/reason for the "open" keyboard? (like on a Tommy)
Or maybe the question is, what is the reason for the closed keyboard?
Related Q:
Same for the flat/stepped keyboards. Assume flat came first? If so why?
-
I can't think of any good reason for open or stepped keyboards & personally much prefer flat closed ones. I suppose some think open keyboards look more arty farty or pseudo antique butI am only talking from a practical playing point of view
george
-
I can't think of any good reason for open or stepped keyboards & personally much prefer flat closed ones. I suppose some think open keyboards look more arty farty or pseudo antique butI am only talking from a practical playing point of view
george
Personal preference again, other people prefer stepped/open keyboards because when the inner row buttons are pressed they don't fall below the level of the outer ones, which is better if you play with relatively straight fingers instead of curled-over ones.
-
but only if they are 12 'stadella' as on some double ray de lux's as otherwise they are not much better than 'standard' 8 BC bass.
george ;)
Actually the "modern" bass layout for B/C isn't that bad, but it depends how much bass you want or need to play...
-
To take it back to Gary's idea of philosophy:
It links into a previous post of mine, where I agreed wholeheartedly with JK's musings that the majority of English tunes are dance tunes , so should be played as such. I suggest that if you step too far away from their original meanings and reason for existance, then they loose their meaning and power.
A complex box might tempt you down the road of over engineering and complicating the tune simply because you can, whereas a 2r8b ( or even a 1 row ) lets you play it simply and powerfully as per dance, because the speed and drive required doesn't allow you to over improvise the tune.
Just an idle thought whilst at work today!
Q
-
Oh forgot to say.....
I prefer open stepped ones cos that's what my Tommy's got, and I really like the look of them!
I also wonder if the buttons stick down in closed ones if not properly set up??
George - I think that makes me arty farty..... or as we say down here " Very Totnes"
( where centre of the alternative movement of the Universe seems to exist ;D )
Hope Marje of this parish isn't listening :|bl
ahem!
Q
-
for what its worth both my serenellini and newly aquired Lilly have arty farty open stepped keyboards 'cos I like evrything else about them and they don't make them any other way
george ;)
-
In the education field, the saying is: a kid can never do what they could never have done. If you increase the options available to kids, you increase the probability that those options will emerge.
A complex box might tempt you down the road of over engineering and complicating the tune simply because you can, whereas a 2r8b ( or even a 1 row ) lets you play it simply and powerfully as per dance,
To be fair, 3x18 boxes "let" you play simply and powerfully -- as do ostensibly infinite devices like fiddles, CBAs, and pianos (notice fiddle players aren't having this conversation because Theo's spectrum doesn't exist in their world). What 2x8 boxes do is decrease the probability that you won't play simply and "as per dance" by not offering the option of particular complexities. So you could say that the technology has an ideology that values "simplicity," or you could say the technology is such that it is chosen by people who value such a thing. Are the technology and the user of it an "aesthetic values feedback loop"?
I've never believed that tech is neutral ("melodeons don't kill people, people kill people ..."). My melodeon has a point of view about what sounds good.
And, George: Why are there only 239 beans in a can? Because one more would be too farty! (That may be one of Lester's)
-
Sorry, I'm going to have to dissent on this one.
Put crudely (but I think truthfully) a melodeon has no more opinion on music than a brick does about architecture.
... or a tea leaf about the history of the East India Company ;)
-
(...) A complex box might tempt you down the road of over engineering and complicating the tune simply because you can, whereas a 2r8b ( or even a 1 row ) lets you play it simply and powerfully as per dance, because the speed and drive required doesn't allow you to over improvise the tune.
Agreed! I started on a 2-row, then erred in the 3x12 alley thinking it would be "better"... Not!
-
You haven't put it crudely, Andrew, just literally. Remove the engineer's glasses, put on those of the poet, and you'll find, miraculously, that instruments can indeed have ideas.
For the first 10 years of my fiddle-playing life I laboured with a mediocre instrument. I finally got a good one, a really good one, and when I got it home, for a while, I was awed and mystified. I realized that I had to adapt / relearn the way I played to get the best - or indeed anything much - out of it. I understood this instinctively as needing to learn how the violin wanted to be played.
Occasionally people ask to try it out and they fall into two classes: those that don't know how it wants to be played, and don't like it; and those that do, and really appreciate it.
I think I'd agree with you about the tea leaf though.
-
You haven't put it crudely, Andrew, just literally. Remove the engineer's glasses, put on those of the poet, and you'll find, miraculously, that instruments can indeed have ideas.
For the first 10 years of my fiddle-playing life I laboured with a mediocre instrument. I finally got a good one, a really good one, and when I got it home, for a while, I was awed and mystified. I realized that I had to adapt / relearn the way I played to get the best - or indeed anything much - out of it. I understood this instinctively as needing to learn how the violin wanted to be played.
Occasionally people ask to try it out and they fall into two classes: those that don't know how it wants to be played, and don't like it; and those that do, and really appreciate it.
I think I'd agree with you about the tea leaf though.
Playing a musical instrument with regard to the way that is was designed and constructed by another human, the history of music making, social context and to be pleasing to your own senses is very different to saying that technology itself has agency.
That's what Gary's website article was saying.
... oh, how to refer to people on forums, "Gary" seems a little impertinent to a person I've never met, and "Mr Chapin" seems a bit cold and possibly rude. Ah well :-\
-
Playing a musical instrument with regard to the way that is was designed and constructed by another human, the history of music making, social context and to be pleasing to your own senses is very different to saying that technology itself has agency.
I didn't take Gary's blog post to mean that the melodeon has agency, but rather, that it has an embedded ideology that places parameters on what can be done with it; that once you apply a melodeon with "expanded features" to music that would not have included those features, there is an increased possibility that the variations you will bring to the music will make use of the added features.
I definitely see selective processes at work as well: compose tunes that are playable on the more popular melodeon configurations and they can be repeated by other players; compose for a rarer configuration and either 1. probably of transmission is decreased, 2. probability of simplication (i.e. in playing on 8 or 12 bass/chord buttons rather than 18) will increase OR 3. the tune will simply not get transmitted through very many other players. On the other hand, if 18 bass players are searching for repertoire, and a composition makes use of the 'expanded' features, perhaps those players are more likely to grasp onto the new tune.
-Andy, whose CDs of 18 bass players see very little play...
P.S. Have personally met Gary, so I use his first name; but knowing him, I doubt he would want you to call him Mr. Chapin!
-
... oh, how to refer to people on forums, "Gary" seems a little impertinent to a person I've never met, and "Mr Chapin" seems a bit cold and possibly rude. Ah well :-\
.. how do you like to be addressed, Andrew? Let's face it, we'll meet up in a session or similar soon eventually, and this place is no more formal than there. There's one recent melnet recruit I've only ever known as "Dave" - it took me quite a while to recognise him online!
As a young registrar I was once b0ll'cked by the head of dept for referring to our Prof of Obstetrics as 'Bill'. No matter that "Bill" had co-supervised my student computer project, delivered both my daughters, dammit, even helped leaflet when I stood for council! "Bill" even like the same music. I considered that Head a bit of a dinosaur (and was not alone in that). Times have changed and my own registrars use my first name. Anyway, surnames were only imposed on Britain by the Normans for tax reasons. They didn't feel a need for them amongst themselves ???
FWIW in France everyone on the folk scene uses first names, and merrily tutoyers without a second thought, albeit you are still expected to vouvoyer in a non-social (eg restaurant waiter) relationship. Cheers, Chris
-
Quebecois:
I was thinking particularly of Andy Cutting's version of Old Molly Oxford, on his cd of the same name.
It is one of my favourite tunes, gloroius, powerful and relates to the morris dance i call occasionally that is equally powerful and hard. Though a great fan of his, I really am not keen on his rendition as he makes it more wistful and 'flowery' and I think it really looses the essence of the tune. Far better played at dance speed, simple, emphasis where it needs for the morris dance. Job done!
Gary: ' melodeons don't kill....' thank goodness you didn't hear me when first beginning ::)
Q
-
... oh, how to refer to people on forums, "Gary" seems a little impertinent to a person I've never met, and "Mr Chapin" seems a bit cold and possibly rude. Ah well :-\
.. how do you like to be addressed, Andrew? Let's face it, we'll meet up in a session or similar soon eventually, and this place is no more formal than there. There's one recent melnet recruit I've only ever known as "Dave" - it took me quite a while to recognise him online!
As a young registrar I was once b0ll'cked by the head of dept for referring to our Prof of Obstetrics as 'Bill'. No matter that "Bill" had co-supervised my student computer project, delivered both my daughters, dammit, even helped leaflet when I stood for council! "Bill" even like the same music. I considered that Head a bit of a dinosaur (and was not alone in that). Times have changed and my own registrars use my first name. Anyway, surnames were only imposed on Britain by the Normans for tax reasons. They didn't feel a need for them amongst themselves ???
FWIW in France everyone on the folk scene uses first names, and merrily tutoyers without a second thought, albeit you are still expected to vouvoyer in a non-social (eg restaurant waiter) relationship. Cheers, Chris
Heh, I've rather stumbled into this one without thinking ...
Actually, I rarely use my given name in online discussions. This is because of the places and people I'm usually communicating with over the Internet. This forum is one of a couple of odd exceptions; since it's nothing to do with the world of free software and hacking* I've used my "real name", though in reality my nick is no less "real".
So, "Andrew" on here I think, though I may have to respond to more disparaging terms sometimes :|bl
* no, you're thinking of crackers :P
-
Sorry, I'm going to have to dissent on this one.
That's okay. I was reading Marshall McLuhan -- "the melodeon is the message" -- last night, so it may have been one rhetorical flourish too many. Think of it in the same light as when 2X8 players talk about how the instrument "makes decisions" for them.
I didn't take Gary's blog post to mean that the melodeon has agency, but rather, that it has an embedded ideology that places parameters on what can be done with it; that once you apply a melodeon with "expanded features" to music that would not have included those features, there is an increased possibility that the variations you will bring to the music will make use of the added features.
That would be it, exactly. Especially important is the idea of probability and possibility. The idea isn't necessarily that I -- Gary Chapin -- will get a 3x18 box and suddenly be corrupted into jazzy accidentals, but that the existence of such boxes will increase the probability that someone (or many someones) will be thus influenced, the repertoire will change, the society of the music will alter, the values of players, listeners will alter. Someone can -- and probably does -- play a 3x18 the good old old way, sans the modern flourish, but no one can play the 3x18 way on a 2x8 box. It's the possibilities. Also, this isn't the only thing determining the issue ...
-Andy, whose CDs of 18 bass players see very little play...
Actually, because of this discussion, I've been paying more attention to them. I am so damned suggestible.
... oh, how to refer to people on forums, "Gary" seems a little impertinent to a person I've never met, and "Mr Chapin" seems a bit cold and possibly rude. Ah well :-\
Not rude. Not impertinent. "Mr. Chapin" is out. "Sir," has a ring to it. "Gary" is preferred. On another board I had a user name, "planechant," because I liked the pun between geometry and plainsong, and folks invariably addressed me as "Chant." S'a funny ol' world.
-
[...] but no one can play the 3x18 way on a 2x8 box. It's the possibilities. Also, this isn't the only thing determining the issue ...
And a simple box is a kind of reduction of complexity which can in turn lead to the generation of more complexity (of a different sort). See this video. Note the hat. In this case, the hat is the technology with the ideology that determines the entire performance!
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/03/flash-and-glitz-and-very-simple.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/03/flash-and-glitz-and-very-simple.html)
-
Andy: that's outrageous! I suddenly feel very slow in my playing.
Back to my thought to add. I forgot to mention earlier the cost of a larger more complex box is not only in monetary terms.
Once you add a half or whole row and another set of 4 or 6 bass buttons, the whole size and weight issue arises.
Part of my thinking about 2r8b v's 2.5r 12b is that the weight can go up from half as much to even double the weight.
Do I really want at least a 50% increased lump to carry around for the occasional use of the extra 1/2 row or 4 basses?
I perceive my playing won't head off into the continental repertoire, so am willing to 'get round' obstacles on a 2r 8b simply to keep the size managable for me.
More grist to the mill!
Q
-
Wow. The hat, the one row, and he's having conversations with the keyboard (?) player.
-
...and he uses his thumb *on* the keyboard!
It's....... simply just too much :D
Q
-
...and he uses his thumb *on* the keyboard!
It's....... simply just too much :D
Q
I couldn't see whether the thumb touched the buttons, or if that hand position was necessary to get the flicking motion (of the fingers).
I love how people appear to be casually browsing postcards in the background, numb to what is going on melodeonistically.