Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on March 10, 2012, 04:40:00 PM
-
I am contemplating what layout I might want for an AD melodeon. At first I thought I would want the same relative layout as my DG boxes, but then it occurred to me that playing in A on an AD is in the upper octave of the A row compared with playing in D on a DG, so does this mean any accidentals need to be (relatively) different?
And is 3rd button start okay as the whole thing is in a lower register than DG? And is there any need for reversal-repeat notes?
-
Are you actually talking about a three-row layout? It makes a difference re: 3rd vs. 4th button start on the outer row.
A remark: I understand what you mean about playing in the upper octave (which you will likely do more on an A/D than on your D/G), but the lower octave of an A/D is absolutely lush, especially in MM tuning.
-
I am deliberately going for a 2-row AD because small and light is important to me, and also there are some tunes in D that I would like to be able to play with the extra bass flexibility that you get playing in G on a DG, which the ADG does not allow.
I used to have an ADG and, yes, it is lovely and lush lower down on the A row. I am hoping the AD will also be close enough to substitute for a GC so I can get more out of the GC players repertoire. And AD is also just a semi-tone off Bb/Eb but there is an extra richness that you only get by playing in the flat keys themselves - my theory is that our ears are all too familiar with the likes of A, D and G.
-
I am deliberately going for a 2-row AD because small and light is important to me, and also there are some tunes in D that I would like to be able to play with the extra bass flexibility that you get playing in G on a DG, which the ADG does not allow.
I used to have an ADG and, yes, it is lovely and lush lower down on the A row. I am hoping the AD will also be close enough to substitute for a GC so I can get more out of the GC players repertoire. And AD is also just a semi-tone off Bb/Eb but there is an extra richness that you only get by playing in the flat keys themselves - my theory is that our ears are all too familiar with the likes of A, D and G.
I understood that you weren't talking about ADG, but I thought you might have been talking about A/D/acc because of the mention of "repeats" in the thread title -- which i took to mean "reversals.
The thing to look out for on a fourth button start is the reach down to the accidentals.
-
Personally I would go for a fourth button start, accidentals button 2, reversals button 1.
Steve
-
Personally, I would go for third button start. Low notes F#/A on first button D row, accidentals Eb/F on first button A row.
Dat ma system. Vive la difference.
-
Many thanks for the inputs, all.
I have decided to go for 3rd button start and accidentals the same (relatively) as on my DG: ie D row C/Bb, A row D#/F.
-
'Same layout' accidentals IMHO (and IME) a particularly shrewd move! When you play that prize little minor tune in it's new key .. and reach for the wrong accidental .. ugly :-\
Thanks for that little debate on 3rd start. I learned something there - a 4th start is only needed on D/G, and arguably C/F kit.