Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Bryson on March 15, 2012, 06:24:55 PM
-
I learn most of my tunes by ear using the dots only to confirm awkward bits.
I've had a go at learning to read music a couple of times but it has defeated me!
I want to read music to play my DG box. Do I first need to check out the chord then decide that the dot should be played on the push or on another button on the other row as a pull? How do you get your head around that? ... or your fingers for that matter?
Has anyone out there any ideas as to how to make a start? Or any anecdotes about successful techniques used?
cheers
Bryson
-
Learn to read music so that you can hear it in your head (like reading text) and then play what you hear. As for chords, you can hear in you head what chords will fit, just as when playing by ear.
You can try singing the tune as you read it, just as people learning to read start by reading aloud.
It won't be easy, but once you can do it that way the skill is transferable to any other instrument that you play by ear.
-
Take a simple score, and read aloud the notes in order to remember where they are on the staves. This is where ABC comes handy, as it can play the tune as you get familiar with the written notes.
With time you will remember which notes are on which button, and which are on the push and which are on the pull! But it takes some time and practice. Be patient.
In a way similar to what we use for violin, I write little > and < marks over the notes as reminders for push and pull, especially in passages when we need several consecutive and opposite bellows movements.
-
Bryson, Have a look at earlier threads, eg http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5056.0.html.
-
The question you've asked isn't really about reading from music, but how to decide which button to use to play a particular note. This applies whether you are playing by ear or from dots.
This problem isn't confined to melodeon players. The piano keyboard is the only instrument I can immediately think of which has a strict one-to-one relationship between the note and the key. On nearly all other instruments a note can be played in several different ways - even wind instruments use alternative fingerings. And even with the piano, the dots won't tell you which finger to use on the key.
The dots can only tell you what to play, not how to play it. On any instrument, and whether playing from music or by ear, you have to work that out for yourself. Experienced players can do this on the fly, and can choose the appropriate fingering/button/bellows direction as they sight-read (or play by ear). However to learn to play a tune properly you have to work through it and try out alternative ways of playing different phrases until it all comes together.
To play from the dots you first have to learn to relate the note on the stave to the keyboard. Once you've done that, you'll be able to play the tune, but you may not make the best choice of button/bellows direction first time through. If you're expecting to be able to sight-read perfectly right from the start, you're setting yourself a pretty stiff challenge. That comes with practice and experience.
-
(...) If you're expecting to be able to sight-read perfectly right from the start, you're setting yourself a pretty stiff challenge. That comes with practice and experience.
I think the original post was more about learning tunes from reading scores, and about what chord to use.
Some people have a natural ear for chords, others will develop it. The first chord of a tune is usually the one that matches the key signature, but not always. A simple approach could be that as you play a tune, you will find what chords will sound best with the notes being played.
-
When I switched from one row to three row I would frequently get hung on up deciding which button to use. (On the three row there are often three possible choices for the same note.) This, coupled with the choice of which octave to play, made for some considerable confusion. My solution for this was not to think about the note I was going to play, but to consider the note with which it would be followed. This sense of anticipation meant that my hand was always in the correct position for the next phrase.
More recently I have been practicing scales without changing bellows direction. The choice of which one of two buttons to use again became a concern. I would practice for a week or so using one pattern. Then I would try another. Both seemed to work, so which to choose? Eventually I settled on practicing scales playing each note twice (e.g C C D D E E etc.). Where there is a choice of buttons I play the buttons once each. This way I am not putting emphasis on any set pattern, rather I am focusing on the relationship between the notes. Now when I play melodies I find it easy to use whichever button fits best within the context of each melodic phrase. Familiarity, gained through repetition, has allowed me to transcend the awkwardness of indecision.
-
Reading the dots and playing a particular instrument are atwo different skills. Reading the dots is the saame forany instrument as far as t;he melody line goes but the bass where applicable can be written to suite a particular instrument eg a 3 manual organ.
Sometimes guitar bass is shown below the dots by naming the chord, same often goes for piano acc bass/...Concentrate on ;the treble/tune line and as Anahata has said put in what bass you can by ear as often written chords are just not on your box.
The dots will tell you what notes to play in what order & their approx length & timing. What they won't tell you how to do is to play the notes on a particular instrument so the second skill of being able to play the instrument from a mechanical /manual dexterity or whatever angle is absolutely vital and most importantly one must be able to pot the appropriate note as indicated by the dots without having to give any thought whatsoever as to where it is on the box! In other words a thorough knowledge of the keyboard is absolutely essential.
george
-
I found the keyboard layout referenced on the opening page of the site a great asset to help me begin linking (:) (:) the notes as written on the stave with their respective positions on the keyboard. Good luck and stick with it because in my experience there's no mystique about sight reading. Like any new skill it will come with time, if you are able to do a bit most days.
-
I've found the problem is knowing what note I'm playing. Got round this early on by playing scales and saying the name of the note as I was playing it. You sound like a total twit of course (best find somewhere you won't be overheard), but it works like a charm because then you can name all the notes which makes it easier (for me, anyway) to associate said note with the note written in the music, as long as you can also name that. Possibly a slightly long-winded version (I could sight read sheet music pretty fluently before I picked up a melodeon), but just to add the idea to the pool collecting here (:)
-
. Got round this early on by playing scales and saying the name of the note as I was playing it.
Spot on Ellie! This is a learning technque that I have recommended to students for many years as it helps to memorise both the names of each 'dot' and also the button /bellows direction required to produce a note to match the 'dot'
george
-
I think all these different techniques mentioned just show that playing melodeon is a very individual thing, and what works for one person won't work for another.
Like Anahata, I have to get the tune in my head before I can play it. This generally means memorising it, but written notation can be the way I read it in order to memorise it. I read the notes into my head, a bit like sight-singing, and then play what's in my head. It doesn't even have to be in the right key on the page, I just need to see how it goes.
What this means is that I often have no idea of the letter-name of the notes I'm playing, and in most circumstances I wouldn't find it helpful to know. After all, if you can play the same tune on two different rows of your melodeon, you're playing entirely different notes while doing pretty much the same thing with your fingers, so I can't see that it's much help to know the note names.
But as I say, it's a very individual thing. Some people find they need to know how the notes correspond to staff notation, while others, even if they can read music, simply don't play this way. Melodeon is a quirky instrument that in many ways defies logic, and players often respond to it in an intuitive way that isn't easily shared or explained.
-
I was refering to thorough knowledge of the keyboard as being necessary for direct site reading but playing from memory ( however the tune got there!0 is in many ays more akin to humming or whistling in that ity is intuitive
george
-
I was refering to thorough knowledge of the keyboard as being necessary for direct site reading but playing from memory ( however the tune got there!0 is in many ays more akin to humming or whistling in that ity is intuitive
george
George, I hope your knowledge of box keyboards is superior to that of a computer keyboard ;D
-
Indeed , unfortunately my fingers sometimes 'play' single note triiiplets on the comppputor!
george ;D
-
Indeed , unfortunately my fingers sometimes 'play' single note triiiplets on the comppputor!
george ;D
;D
-
Like Anahata, I have to get the tune in my head before I can play it. This generally means memorising it, but written notation can be the way I read it in order to memorise it.
I'm not sure if I'm quite the way you described. I can sight read on the melodeon, but the process involves (to some extent) hearing what I see, and playing what I hear, in real time. I don't have to memorise the tune first to play it; actually I'm quite slow at learning to play tunes from memory. A lot of that ends up being muscle memory, by the time I've learned it properly.
-
Going back to the original post - I first play it using dots and also listening to it if possible via Youtube/cd etc, just to make sure my dot reading is about right.
I then twiddle around different chords and see how they fit, realising there's some notes can only be played on pull, some are push only. That restricts the chord choice for them.
I then look at phrases, and see if I can pull or push a set of notes by using the other row as opposed to push/pull on one row, simply because it's how I think of things. Depending on whether making a run of notes is on the push or pull, that then gives me a hint of the chords. Not the same for those that run up and down the rows, but it works for me.
As I've mentioned before, it's worth printing off the keyboard diagrams found from a link off the home page and simply looking at the notes available. I found it invaluable to help me work out what note was where.
Q
-
When I was first learning to read music with a D/G a made a note diagram that linked each button to it's not and was colour coded to show where the same note could be got on the push or pull. I've attached it to this post.
My advice is just to stick with it. Like all disciplines, the more you do the clearer it becomes.
After a short while you just start to recognise patterns in the written music that relate to patterns in your fingering.
As to the chords, you may have a choice of pull or push but most of the time you only have to exepriment once as the sound of the correct chord is obvious. Hope this helps.
-
Stevec: I did something similar. I used the keyboard diagram and coloured in scales on the push, then repeating for those on the pull. It helped clarify it in my mind at the time.
-
The use of colour is part of current teaching practices. My daughter writes down her revision material using different coloured pens . Colour helps to store info in the long-term memory .
-
Tyker: Yes indeed - and I found it really useful to visualise the keyboard.
-
. Got round this early on by playing scales and saying the name of the note as I was playing it.
Spot on Ellie! This is a learning technque that I have recommended to students for many years as it helps to memorise both the names of each 'dot' and also the button /bellows direction required to produce a note to match the 'dot'
george
Also memorise the sound (pitch) of the note at the same time, it works as a crosscheck later on "that didn't sound like a D" and also with learning tunes by ear.
Steve