Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: nemethmik on March 16, 2012, 05:09:42 PM
-
Dear Friends,
I am looking for the smallest and lightest 3 row 2-voice diatonic accordion/melodeon model available today.
I'd appreciate your help.
Thank You,
Miklos
-
Castagnari Benny?
-
Castagnari Benny?
Thank You for the hint, Sandy. According to the Castagnari website the Benny has only two voice bass.
http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=31
What is the role of the bass stop on a two-voice bass system?
-
I have a Big-18, the 18 bass version of the Benny, which has a stop to remove the thirds. Maybe the basses have only two voices, the chords three? I've not opened it to look, but Theo did so recently, so maybe he remembers? Whatever it has in voices, it does not lack character!
Cheers John
-
Great box indeed. Here's one of my favourite Benny players:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMjXmdpqo80
-
But playing a Handry!
-
Frans van der Aa's stuff is very light. Particularly the "Compact". He grinds metal off the reed plate to fit them all . His usual 3 row is 3 voice @ 4.4kg, but extrapolating from the other designs ... a 2 voice would weigh about 3.3kg. He's more happy than some to do special commissions.
http://www.accordionmaker.com/compact/!boot.php?taal=uk&muziek=aan
-
Maybe the basses have only two voices, the chords three?
It is possible to have two octaves of bass for the bass button, and for the chord button to play the third, the fifth, plus share the higher of the two bass notes; in which case, the stop would remove the third from the chord.
As to the original question, there are some very small and light 3-row boxes made by Serafini (la-baf) and Peter Hyde -- you might be able to get options not available on the Benny.
-
Andy, that bass/chord solution sound very neat and plausible! It would be interesting to hear if it is done...
-
Andy, that bass/chord solution sound very neat and plausible! It would be interesting to hear if it is done...
Standard set up on a Tommy of the era of the one I had -
(https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Pr8T-CQOR2o/T2OU2djzI9I/AAAAAAAAInI/AbNVLIE3aso/s800/tommy+bass.JPG) (https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Pr8T-CQOR2o/T2OU2djzI9I/AAAAAAAAInI/AbNVLIE3aso/s800/tommy+bass.JPG)
Click for a larger image
Rod 1 - lifts pallets A and C for the three chord reeds
Rod 2 - lifts pallets B and C for the two bass reeds
Thus the reed under C is shared between the bass and the chord.
Ignore the masking tape, it was their to block the low bass and third reeds when I was going through a "sparse bass sound" phase (:)
-
Thanks Lester!
-
Dear Friends,
I am looking for the smallest and lightest 3 row 2-voice diatonic accordion/melodeon model available today.
I'd appreciate your help.
Thank You,
Miklos
What about the Saltarelle Cheviot? Hard to imagine a 3 row smaller than that.
-
Oops ! John A is right, here's the Benny:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGA25E4VSi4
-
Loffet does a 3 row 12 bass at 3.7 kg and an 18 bass at 3.9kg. There is also a 33 button option as well.
http://diato.org/loffet_accordions.htm (http://diato.org/loffet_accordions.htm)
-
This is the smallest three row that I've ever seen: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DpbEWRldUjQ
-
What about this:
http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/steirische-harmonika/#steirische1
-
Loffet does a 3 row 12 bass at 3.7 kg
-
Actually I'm longing for a 1 voice, three row, 18 bass system... Does anyone know if that exists?
-
Didn't Castagnari try a one voice three row 12 bass? I think it was called the Matty and was not a success. Not sure why.
-
That's right. The sound was badly unbalanced between the rows because some reeds were on an upright block and some were flat.
-
I tried a BCC# matti that hobgob had as an unwanted special order and I liked it very much, the only reason I didn't buy it was that it had melodeon push pull bass which were next to useless..Perhaps the balance between rows was not as much a problem on a semitone version (compared to a 4th apart) as a lot of the work is done on the C row and much less on the other 2 rows, depending of course on the key being played in.
george
-
I tried a BCC# matti that hobgob had as an unwanted special order and I liked it very much, the only reason I didn't buy it was that it had melodeon push pull bass which were next to useless..Perhaps the balance between rows was not as much a problem on a semitone version (compared to a 4th apart) as a lot of the work is done on the C row and much less on the other 2 rows, depending of course on the key being played in.
Or perhaps they were not all set up the same way. How many of these have actually been seen?
-
That's right. The sound was badly unbalanced between the rows because some reeds were on an upright block and some were flat.
Why should that make it unbalanced? After all, the same is true of a one row four stop.
-
That's right. The sound was badly unbalanced between the rows because some reeds were on an upright block and some were flat.
Why should that make it unbalanced? After all, the same is true of a one row four stop.
Yes, but on on 4 stop you have two upright and two flat reeds playing at the same time. On the Matty I saw there were two rows which each played a single reed on an upright block, and one row that played a single reed mounted flat. The row with the flat mounted reeds was much louder.
-
Oh, I see. That makes sense. I wonder why they did that, when they could easily have mounted all three in blocks?
-
Thinking again, it may have been two rows flat, one upright. Just a space saving measure I think.
-
has anybody on here got one they are willing to take a peek inside?
george
-
It was two flat and one upright, although it wasn't strictly upright. It was laid flat but mounted on a separate manifold between the two outer flat-mounted blocks. The inner and outer rows sounded loud like a Lilly, but the middle row was much quieter. Shame I don't have a photo.
-
I'd so love a box that sounds like my lilly but with three rows and 18 basses... thanks for the remarks about the matti. It would be so sad to buy something that sounds perfect but then doesn't sound perfect.
-
for me a 12x2 'stradella' arrangement in a matty size box would be great. Could even mange quite well with just 12 thirdlesss major chords same on push & pull.
george
-
As for me, I've got a Benny, and I'm really satisfied with it (only 3 kg ! very responsive, beautiful sound and design, ideal for a woman not really big armed, and not so young either ;D)
I've not opened the box (I'm not really able to do that !), but I've tested its basses (if you play very very slowly, you can hear the notes separetely and very distincly), so I give you hereabove what I found for DO (ut) :
basses : do (2 octaves)
chords : do mi sol
and it was the same pattern for the other left hand basses.
At the same time, I tested a friend's melodeon (Mengascini, a bigger one), and it was strictly identic (but intervals were sometime different, the other way round, but there was exactly the same number of notes : 2 notes for bass, and 3 notes for chords).
So I think the Benny is exactly a "normal" melodeon as far as left hand basses are concerned.
I think what melodeon maker mean when they say "2 voices" for the left hand, is that there is a stop for thirds, don't they ?
-
I haven't tested the Benny properly, but I'm concerned that with two voices on the right hand one loses too much air, especially when accompanying.
-
Hmmm .. more voices .. more air used .. either meticulous air hole technique .. or judicious cross-rowing .. or bigger bellows. You can't buck the Laws of Melodeonism. Good quality reeds will use less, and the other ray of light is that yer third row uses no air at all ... until you play a button :|glug
-
I don't find I have to consciously change the way I play the same tunes with two voices on my Handry and on my Big-18 (ie 18 bass Benny). So, for me at least, air control is not a significant issue. I have not had the Big-18 long, so it is not a question of time and adaptation - it was never a problem. Of course there will be some unconscious minor adjustment.
-
I don't find I have to consciously change the way I play the same tunes with two voices on my Handry and on my Big-18 (ie 18 bass Benny). So, for me at least, air control is not a significant issue. I have not had the Big-18 long, so it is not a question of time and adaptation - it was never a problem. Of course there will be some unconscious minor adjustment.
I didn't notice anything about air control either with the Benny.
I used to have a bigger one before my Benny (Maugein gavott duo, a gorgeous one which I liked so much ... but found too heavy for me, I had really problems playing fast with it).
I think those big melodeons are perfect for young men who want to play loud and who appreciate beautiful profound sound and registers).
As for me, I find it much easier to play on the Benny (weight, much better responsivity, allows easy and best push-pull playing) and I never noticed anything at all concerning air control (on the contrary ;-).
But you know, choosing one's melodeon is a question of feeling ... so other people's experience is rarely useful ! one has to get his own way, hasn't he .. ?
-
air control should be no more difficult with 18 bass than with 8unless somebody wants to use all 18 at the same time! Its jsut the same principle as with stradella which requires no more air on a 120 bass box than on a 48 bass ( assuming same number of voices(reeds) per button. i.e. at any point in a tune only a small number of buttons are used 4 being the absolute maximum as most of us have insufficient digits to press more!
george ;D
-
George - the issue under discussion is one v two voice(s) on RIGHT hand on a small box. Diatosoldo and I are pointing out that we have no problems with air on our Benny/Big - i.e. small boxes can handle two voices. Come to think of it, the Tommy, which is very similar in size, has three - as do some other small boxes and I don't recall hearing folk struggle for air.
-
George - the issue under discussion is one v two voice(s) on RIGHT hand on a small box. Diatosoldo and I are pointing out that we have no problems with air on our Benny/Big - i.e. small boxes can handle two voices. Come to think of it, the Tommy, which is very similar in size, has three - as do some other small boxes and I don't recall hearing folk struggle for air.
The air issue would be highly dependent on what style you are playing I would think. If you are playing french mazurkas at a slow tempo with lots of cross rowing to maintain smoothness then you might have more of a problem with a smaller bellows than if you are playing faster tempo push pull up and down the row.
-
we have no problems with air on our Benny/Big - i.e. small boxes can handle two voices.
I've got a 10-year old Benny of a friend for a week, and I found the air valve too small. When playing some mostly push tunes, I tend to run out of air, unless I do a lot of extra efforts to avoid. Even the Hohner Liliput has bigger/more efficient air valve system. Maybe this "too small air valve" problem has been fixed on newer Bennys ???