Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: nemethmik on March 21, 2012, 08:36:07 AM
-
Here is a short video of my friend's Castagnari Benny: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7e5oSomzYI
It is an LM box with a powerful right hand sound, I found that most of the left hand (fundamental) basses are too weak.
For example, the low G button has G,+G,, reeds, but the G basses have G,+G, or G,+G (I am not sure).
Same problem with D and E. The A, C and F seem to be the same on both sides, but I'd prefer deeper bass reeds on my accordion.
Is this a typical bass arrangement on a 2-reed Castagnari accordion?
If and when I place an order, how can I specify clearly that I need deeper bass reeds on my Benny?
I'd highly appreciate your help.
Miklos
-
If and when I place an order, how can I specify clearly that I need deeper bass reeds on my Benny?
I'd highly appreciate your help.
Miklos
If you want the smallest possible instrument then one of the compromises the builder makes is to use fewer bass reeds (2 instead of the usual 3) and the size of the lowest bass reeds has to be smaller so you can't get the basses as deep as in a bigger box. It is simply a matter of space - lower reeds are bigger. If you do specify lower bass reeds these will be achieved by using more tip weights on the same size reeds and you then run the risk of basses that are slow to respond and unstable in pitch.
If you want a good bass sound you really need big reeds! ;D
-
If you want a good bass sound you really need big reeds
Theo, Thank You for the quick reply. In this particular Benny, the right hand side G button produces deeper/lower note than the G fundamental bass: the size should not be a problem here, unless the right hand reedblocks are bigger than the bass reed blocks.
-
Ah, I've listened to the video now, and in the bass sounds I can hear only one reed playing. Either that or the bass end is tuned much better than the treble! Perhaps there is a lower set of bass reeds that has been blocked off?
-
I recall Bob Ellis saying a while back on melnet that the original Bennys did have very light basses, but Castagnari then moved to a larger bass end and got an improved bass sound. So maybe, Miklos, it depends if your friend's Benny is one of the early ones.
I know that the bigger bass reeds in my fairly compact Dino Baffetti Carnival II have substantial tip weights and they sound much richer than my Tommy basses with no discernable slowness in response - they feature quite prominently in this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJkOXb9UHcs).
-
it depends if your friend's Benny is one of the early ones.
Thank You, Sandy for the comment: the Benny on my video was made in 2000.
I know that the bigger bass reeds in my fairly compact Dino Baffetti Carnival II have substantial tip weights and they sound much richer than my Tommy basses with no discernable slowness in response - they feature quite prominently in this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJkOXb9UHcs).
Exactly this video of yours that I watch every day recently: I want exactly this bass sound in a Benny, if I really decide to order one.
-
Perhaps there is a lower set of bass reeds that has been blocked off?
When playing the A bass on the video I have the impression that can hear two reeds an A,, + A,. Maybe I am wrong.
-
The basses on this YouTube video of a Benny sound fairly good (even within an overall shrill recorded sound): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvDPGNKSGGA
This is just one of several videos offered when I typed "Castagnari Benny" in the YouTube search box - might be worth your having a look at some more.
I am surprised Castagnari do not have sound samples on their website like Saltarelle have.
-
Another thing to watch for is where the deeper bass notes start. I have just checked and on my Castagnari Tommy the lowest bass note is the C, but on the DB Carnival II it is the B. I recall having a lowest bass note on the G on an Oakwood I had years ago - it was a lovely sound if given time to get going, but often hardly sounded at all when playing clipped bass/chord style for dancing.
-
Another thing to watch for is where the deeper bass notes start. I have just checked and on my Castagnari Tommy the lowest bass note is the C, but on the DB Carnival II it is the B. I recall having a lowest bass note on the G on an Oakwood I had years ago - it was a lovely sound if given time to get going, but often hardly sounded at all when playing clipped bass/chord style for dancing.
My Baffetti Binci has C as the lowest note (as do my other D/G boxes, and Jeff's Binci) but Mike A's otherwise identical (but newer) Binci has a B, so either they chenged the design or somebody got confused at manufacture...
-
Sandy has recalled my comments correctly about the earlier Bennys having light basses. I had one of the earlier ones and now have one of the newer Benny's with improved bass end oomph. There is a considerable difference between them, the quality of sound from the newer version being much fuller than from the older one.
The Benny being played in ther clip posted by Miklos was one of the earlier type. You can easily tell them apart because the older model just had plain wood on the front faces containing the name plate and the bass buttons, whereas the new model has a rectangle of marquetry inlay around the name plate and another one around the bass buttons. The newer model is also slightly larger than the old one.
-
The newer model is also slightly larger than the old one.
The height of my friend's Benny is 24 cm; the height of a Benny is 25 cm on the Castagnari website.
-
Larger reeds would more likely lead to an increase in width. Is the new one on the website wider overall than your friend's, or does the bass end of the new one look noticeably wider?
-
Larger reeds would more likely lead to an increase in width. Is the new one on the website wider overall than your friend's, or does the bass end of the new one look noticeably wider?
The only way to find it out is to place an order wait 6 - 9 months, and compare the two instruments side by side.
BTW, Sandy, What is the height of your new Dino Baffetti? According to the specification on the website it is 29 cm, which is 4 cm taller than a Benny. A Benny has 11 a 86GB has 10 buttons on the outside row: does this mean that a Benny has much smaller buttons?
-
Ah, I was looking at the instrument as it is played (ie horizontally), whereas I realise you are talking about height looking at it sitting on its feet. In which case it looks like there are longer reeds in the new Benny.
My DB Carnival II is 29cm high, and has 10 buttons on the outer row.
I believe the Tommy and Benny have the same button spacing, so I measured my Tommy and Carnival II:
Tommy - from top of first button to bottom of 11th button = 18.5cm
Carinval II - from top of first button to bottom of 10th button = 19.5cm
Have to say I have found no real problem in going between the two boxes, but I do notice the longer stretches when playing my Erica (recently acquired).
-
Ah, I was looking at the instrument as it is played (ie horizontally), whereas I realise you are talking about height looking at it sitting on its feet.
Thank You, Sandy!
Height for me is the longest side of the bellows, when fully compressed.
-
Still a bit of confusion then. The 29cm measurement on the DB Carnival II is the distance from the outer edge of the treble keyboard to the outer edge of the bass end, with the bellows shut in the middle.
The measurement for the longest side of the bellows is 24.3cm.
-
The measurement for the longest side of the bellows is 24.3cm.
Oh, my misunderstanding the Dino Baffetti website has for the 86GB "height x length x depths 29 x 24 x 14"
Castagnariy website has for the Benny "dimensions [cm] 25 x 16.5"
Definitely the 86GB (or Carnival II) is smaller then a Benny.
Thank You, Sandy for the help!
-
The measurement for the longest side of the bellows is 24.3cm.
Oh, my misunderstanding the Dino Baffetti website has for the 86GB "height x length x depths 29 x 24 x 14"
Castagnariy website has for the Benny "dimensions [cm] 25 x 16.5"
Definitely the 86GB (or Carnival II) is smaller then a Benny.
Thank You, Sandy for the help!
I am pretty sure the Benny is smaller than the Carnival II, apart from its depth (ie the shorter bellows side) which looks like it is 2.5cm less - presumably since the Carnival only has to fit in two reed blocks, whereas the Benny has three. The 25cm quoted for the Benny dimensions is almost certainly the end-to-end closed-bellows distance from treble to bass - which is 29cm on the Carnival II. And recall the Benny fits in 11 buttons in less distance than the Carnival fits in 10.
-
The 25cm quoted for the Benny dimensions is almost certainly the end-to-end closed-bellows distance from treble to bass
I measured the longest bellows side of my friend's Benny and it was 24 cm.
-
My Tommy's longest bellow's side = 23.5cm. But the treble to bass end to end is just 25cm, so even allowing for the Benny being a bit more to accomodate its 3rd treble row, it is still going to be less than the Carnival II's 29cm. My head is spinning :P .