Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: gioui on March 22, 2012, 11:58:24 AM
-
WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENCES OF SOUND AND RESPONCE ? WHAT ARE THE PRODUCERS?
-
WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENCES OF SOUND AND RESPONCE ? WHAT ARE THE PRODUCERS?
Just to be clear, the reeds are not brass, but the plates are. Binci makes them.
-
Binci makes them.
[/quote]
inter aliis...
-
Harmonicas have brass reeds, mostly because brass does not corrode as much as steel when soaked in saliva...
-
Binci makes them.
inter aliis...
[/quote]
I provided the info on Binci because he is the only reed supplier from whom I have personally ordered brass-plate reeds. Instead of simply stating (from troll perspective) that there are other suppliers, why don't you provide some actual information and answer the original poster's question? (I recall that one reedmaker who had been supplying brass-plated reeds was, according to one report here on mel.net, in troubled business circumstances.)
-
Harmonicas have brass reeds, mostly because brass does not corrode as much as steel when soaked in saliva...
Yes, and there are other reasons as well. Actual brass reeds (as opposed to reedplates) in accordions would result in some negative effects from work hardening of the brass, resulting at best in issues related to tuning and at worst in broken reeds. Theoretically this could happen in harmonicas as well, but I would speculate that the airflow (and pressure) are different, as well as the amount of actual use. And I can imagine other issues as well, but this is all off topic. The original poster wants to know: who supplies them and what they sound like.
-
Reeds made of brass or bronze were also used in older accordions. I think they're generally said to be quieter/mellower/warmer-sounding than steel reeds.
-
I once drooled over a gorgeous serafini lightweight 3-row melodeon with brass ... - :|bl actually - what is the difference between plates and reeds-? But the wait time was longer than the gestation period of a dinosaur.
-
Ciccarelli was apparently in a bit of a fix, but I recently got another order of brass based reeds from them that are very nice. Hopefully things on his end are on the upswing.
-
I once drooled over a gorgeous serafini lightweight 3-row melodeon with brass ... - :|bl actually - what is the difference between plates and reeds-? But the wait time was longer than the gestation period of a dinosaur.
Yeah, people seem to be talking about two different things. The OP was asking about brass reeds (the bit that's riveted to the plate and wiggles), rather than a brass plate (the oblong bit of metal with a slot in it that the reed is riveted to).
-
I don't guess I know of anyone who still makes brass reeds.
-
Yeah, people seem to be talking about two different things. The OP was asking about brass reeds (the bit that's riveted to the plate and wiggles), rather than a brass plate (the oblong bit of metal with a slot in it that the reed is riveted to).
Since the only kind in production are reeds w brass plates... And the OP asked about prdocers in the present tense...
-
WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENCES OF SOUND AND RESPONCE ? WHAT ARE THE PRODUCERS?
I think it would help to tell us why you want to know. Is this for an old instrument, or other purpose?
There doesn't seem to be anyone making brass reeds for melodions/accordions at present, at least not in quantity.
Reeds in older instruments were often brass, and were said to be a little slower to start, with warmer or more mellow sound (fewer harmonics?) and shorter working life. They are still common in harmonicas, as others have pointed out.
-
Reeds in older instruments were often brass, and were said to be a little slower to start, with warmer or more mellow sound (fewer harmonics?) and shorter working life. They are still common in harmonicas, as others have pointed out.
Several years ago I corresponded with a Cajun who was playing a Falcon accordion with reeds from an antique accordion -- I belive they were brass reeds. Perhaps Wade could fill us in on the details and how these reeds compared?
-
To me the sound didn't quite sound bright enough (compared to my lilly). It made me want to shake the box awake. But it was a lovely box that serafini. I believe it was "limited edition",...
ah I have found it: Les accordéons OTTONE minis luxe. Ces acordéons sont fabriqués uniquement avec des lames binci en laiton. Only made with brass blades. For three rows it is 3500 euros.... :o
-
To me the sound didn't quite sound bright enough (compared to my lilly). It made me want to shake the box awake. But it was a lovely box that serafini. I believe it was "limited edition",...
ah I have found it: Les accordéons OTTONE minis luxe. Ces acordéons sont fabriqués uniquement avec des lames binci en laiton. Only made with brass blades. For three rows it is 3500 euros.... :o
Can someone confirm whether the reeds are actually brass or just the plates -- I have 2 sets of "ottone" Bincis right here in front of me, and the reeds themselves are certainly steel; the plates are brass.
-
Thanks for your replies, I am informed directly from the manufacturers, you are right, the brass reeds are no longer produced but only Reeds steel with brass plates, the producers here in Italy are Binci ciccarelli and cagnoni i think, I would replace the reeds in a Castagnari dony, but do not know if they are equal to other types of reeds from the point of view of the response, from the point of view of sound seem more beautiful and sweet than aluminum but I were not suitable for their weight
-
Several brands of accordions used steel reeds with brass plates of the highest 5 or so piccolo reeds. And a odd varient was a Iron plate reed set in a 1880's Palo Soprani chromatic I restored for a customer. All the reeds were steel except the lowest 5 or 6 which were brass . none of the reeds used weighted tips, the softer brass not needing it for the lower reeds. The response was surprising for a instrument of that age.
A source of brass reeds if you must have one for a replacement , is some of the smaller Chinese childrens instruments. The brass reed works well after you replace the crappy valves. It is pretty much all you can get for vintage instrument replacement. Brass stock is the wrong alloy and is impossible to tune in my experience.
-
Hi Kimric and all,
Pretty good brass-tongued reeds, riveted 2 to a plate for diatonic accordions are often available on ebay in the form of totally wrecked, very early Hohner accordions. When you get to know some of the models you can recognize which ones will have brass reeds* (unless they have the "steel reeds" or "Stahltone" marking externally), and which ones will have them on "individual" plates (2/plate) vs. long plates with 20 or more tongues lined up. Alternatively, if you are willing to fit and rivet tongues yourself to the plates but are seeking good brass, you might try re-purposing the tongues from harmonium / reed organ reeds, again from a wrecked instrument. Or you can work-harden brass stock by hammering it.
I like the sound of brass reedtongues and use brass-reeded concertinas often, brass-reeded accordions occasionally.
PG
edited to add: *for example the model shown below; I often see these in Bb/Eb or A/D. Don't expect these reeds to give you brilliant performance, high volume, immediate response, air-efficiency, or great longevity. But they do have a unique sound of their own and this box might have a good few of them in useful condition, after cleaning, revalving, and tuning:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ANTIQUE-HOHNER-GERMAN-WOOD-ACCORDION-/120869278389
-
Harmonicas have brass reeds, mostly because brass does not corrode as much as steel when soaked in saliva...
Or beer - I always used to soak my blues harps in Tetleys. It swells the wood, which makes the chambers more air-tight so you can bend the notes more easily.
Plus it makes the harmonics taste good on the suck, and produce nice bubbles on the blow!! ;D
Please DON'T try this with melodeons! ;D
-
Does anyone have any sound files so I could compare the sound of brass to tipo a mano reeds?
Thank you!!
-
... used to soak my blues harps in Tetleys.
I always wodered what Tetleys was good for... Actually it was back in the 70s and it was c##p - last time I had it it was greatly improved!
Rob.
-
Actually Tetleys tasted like it had been previously used to soak old Mouthies in :-\ .. EEeeeeeww
-
If you really want brass reeds, get one of those chintzy Chinese toy melodeons that are all over on eBay. They have brass reeds riveted to aluminum plates.
To change the subject - The last time I was in the UK (about 20 years ago), Tetley's beer tasted fine to me. Old Peculiar, however, tasted like cat p***. For a country that brews some truly great stuff, I can't for the life of me understand why anyone there would drink something like that.
Regards,
Paul N. (Brought up on Genesee beers and ales, which may explain a lot)
Tonawanda, NY