Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: pperrin on March 23, 2012, 01:28:38 PM

Title: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: pperrin on March 23, 2012, 01:28:38 PM
I have got my ebay bargain air-tight(ish) - and a couple of reeds will need attention but...

I can now knock out a single line melody of Wild Rover fairly fluently (hurrah). The next step is (presumably) to get some chords in on the right and/or bass/chords with the left and give it a bit of a pulse.

I have a chord button and a bass button - where should I start with them (other than having the chord open the whole time!)?

Also for the melody, I am not releasing keys if the next note is just from push to pull - what about duplicate notes? Relax the squeeze or release the key?

Any tips for a new player?

Cheers!
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: Stiamh on March 23, 2012, 02:32:51 PM
Also for the melody, I am not releasing keys if the next note is just from push to pull - what about duplicate notes? Relax the squeeze or release the key?

First, unless I am mistaken there is a strong school of thought among contributors to this forum that you should release the button even when the note changes from push to pull. I think that is completely unnecessary and indeed counterproductive unless you want to play staccato all the time, but: listen to all advice, consider, experiment and adopt what you like.

As for repeated notes, in general you should lift the finger and press again.

But as you progress you may find (depending on the style music you want to play) the bellows playing a role in this too. In Irish music you can get a very nice effect - say, in jigs - on some repeated notes by leaving the finger down and articulating with bellows pressure, particularly where two repeated notes straddle a strong beat.

If you're playing a one-row, you may have your right-hand thumb in a strap. If you don't, it will be easier to explore another option for repeated notes: changing fingers. There are several reasons why you might do this - to get the right feel, to help you move your hand for the next note, for example.

Anything goes, if it gets you the sound you are looking for.

For the bass stuff I'll let others help you.

Good luck!
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: pperrin on March 23, 2012, 03:34:56 PM
As for repeated notes, in general you should lift the finger and press again.

Cheers for all that, it does have a thumb strap, so swapping fingers is out, but letting go should be OK. A bit of finger retraining to do!
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: george garside on March 26, 2012, 10:04:57 AM
I agree with Steves advice   and would add that the sound effect of changing notes  'on the button' or 'with the bellows' are completely different and  either method can be used to great effect as& where chosen. But I wouldn't worry at all about whcih you use in the early stages when the main object is just to get a recognisable tune going!

As to the 2 bass on one row- Just two guidelines

- play them when they sound OK leave them off when they don't

- think of them more as providers of  rhythm  rather than than harmony  & experiment with  getting a range of rh;ythmic effects out of them  ranging from a basic UM _ PA  to perhaps just using the bass note OR the Chord to emphasise a particular treble note or perhaps  holding  a bass note 'across' a few treble notes  as a sort of drone.

george
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: pperrin on April 01, 2012, 02:33:58 PM
Thanks for that - now the right hand has an idea of what it is doing with out too much thinking, I am trying out some patterns with the left - bass bass chord, bass bass chord and that kind of thing - my ears are starting to make some sense out of it!
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: syale on June 17, 2012, 05:06:31 AM
I am learning on a single row too. Hohner HA-114 (4 stop).

The bass notes to me are challenging. kind of like patting your head and rubbing your stomach!

I have been practicing for 6 weeks and can rattle out about 4 tunes with just the melody. I find I am concentrating so much on the melody I am not doing anything with the bass. My father in law (Newfie) is a good single row player and he said it will come in time but I am a little impatient. Is there anything I can do to speed up the process?
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: Anahata on June 17, 2012, 09:23:58 AM
I am a little impatient. Is there anything I can do to speed up the process?

No. You have to learn patience too!  >:E
If you are having problems getting left and right hands to work together at all, I'd guess that you don't already play another musical instrument.

What you are doing is programming what we sometimes call "muscle memory" but is really a subconscious part of the brain, to handle most of the work of playing a tune. It takes a while to get these patterns rewired into your brain, but the whole process becomes quicker the more you do it.

Try playing really slowly - one note at a time, with the basses, so that you can feel the simultaneous hand actions one at a time and get used to them. Repeat this ad nauseam for even just one bar or a short phrase of the tune until it becomes automatic. "automatic" means that muscle memory thing is starting to kick in.

Get used to the fact that a concentrated practice session may not produce great results at the time, but when you come back the next day, you'll find everything's improved overnight.

Don't think you need to play the basses al the time. A quick percussive note on the main beats (and maybe a quick percussive chord on the off-beats) will, when you get up to speed, give the tune lots of rhythm, bass and harmony.

At least with a one row you don't have to think about which bass and chord to play. Also on a one row box there's nothing wrong with learning to play the RH side first, whereas with a two row if you do that you may find when you add basses and chords that you need to relearn the RH side, switching rows to fit in with the right chords.
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: syale on June 17, 2012, 05:36:22 PM
Thanks so much for the info and encouragement!

I did play the descant recorder at junior school but that was 40+ years ago. Amazingly I picked one up recently and was able to rattle off the tune as though it were yesterday...

I will try slowing down the process and also try to listen to the bass more when listening to other players on YouTube etc. The difficult is tuning out the melody as they are catchy for a reason.
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 17, 2012, 06:54:23 PM
My father in law (Newfie)

It took me ages to discover what that means!  ::)

Graham
Title: Re: New player - single row, two bass - advice on repeated notes and rhythm please
Post by: syale on June 18, 2012, 05:21:07 AM
Newf, Newfie = Newfoundlander. Most easterly province in Canada :D

A newlywed Newfie sailor is informed by the navy that he's going to be stationed a long way from home on a remote island in the South Pacific for 2 years. A few weeks after he gets there he really starts to miss his new wife, so he writes her a letter.

"My darling," he writes, "it looks like we're going to be apart for a very long time. Already I'm starting to miss you and we're constantly surrounded by young, attractive native girls. The temptation's terrible. I need some kind of hobby to keep my mind off them."

His wife sends him back an accordion with a note reading, "Why don't you learn to play this?"

Eventually his tour of duty comes to an end and the Newfie sailor rushes back to his wife. "Darling" he says, "I can't wait to get you into bed so that we can make passionate love!"

But she stops him with a wave of her hand. "First, let's see how well you play that accordion."
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal