Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Owen Woods on March 29, 2012, 07:33:33 PM
-
There have been a few topics recently on the effect of expanding the scope of the melodeon. I've posted a few times about this in the past, I've just put together a blog post expanding on this. I'd be interested in knowing what you all think.
http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/03/29/making-the-most-of-your-limitations/
-
I enjoyed reading the blog, there's sufficient core information given to engage interest in the subject and it's presented in a very readable manner. All instruments have limitations as you say, but our beloved melodeon belongs in the group marked "created with more impediments than most - enjoy!" :|glug
Most early keyboard instruments are far more hamstrung than the modern pianoforte btw and some modern performers have developed special techniques to overcome the problem of reaching lots of notes at once (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifKKlhYF53w). >:E
-
Truly great players understand the limitations of their chosen instrument, and play to the limit of those limitations, and can still produce amazing music.
qv one string fiddle players, those strange african instruments with very few twanging metakl keys, brendan powers on diatonic harmonicas, and one of the most amazing irish melodeon players ever, Bobby Gardiner on a Hohner 4-stop 1 row:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOj9vCR0cQ
or this amazing playing on a 1 and a bit row:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDMhFTiBpC0&list=FLKhMCsH6Xs4bOabTueiND2A&index=2&feature=plpp_video
Conversely, you wil find plenty of videos where the limitation is with the player, not the instrument :-) Why have a 3 row, 18 bass box and play 'Jimmy Allen' in one key with no accidentals? ;D
-
Why have a 3 row, 18 bass box and play 'Jimmy Allen' in one key with no accidentals? ;D
Because everyone else in the session is? ;D
-
Conversely, you wil find plenty of videos where the limitation is with the player, not the instrument :-) Why have a 3 row, 18 bass box and play 'Jimmy Allen' in one key with no accidentals? ;D
[/quote]
Because it's a tune that has no accidentals and sounds best without strange chords, and because introducing gratuitous key-changes risks making it sound like an X-factor song? Some tunes sound best if they're not messed with, and respecting this does not necessarily indicate a limitation on the part of the player.
I often think that's a danger with piano accordions - they introduce key changes and fancy chords just because they can. It doesn't always enhance the tune - in fact it can rob a good tune of its strong, simple beauty. Sometimes less is more.
-
Ukebert, yes I agree with what you've written.
The only thing I would add is that the trend (I don't think I'd use the word 'fad' because I doubt it's going to be temporary) is probably the result of improvements in technology, which have meant that heavier boxes can be very responsive, and therefore the benefits of reduced limitations can now be achieved without losing too much playability.
I also have to say that my experience is that (surprisingly) extra weight is something you can actually learn your way round. My rough and ready concept is that broadly speaking, if the reeds sound with half as much air pressure, then doubling the weight of the left hand end will (very roughly speaking) give you a box that is just as easy to play. And the benefits of larger LH ends are not just to be found in having a bigger range of buttons, they also usually bring a bassier tone to the basses.
-
my point, which I didn't make very well, is why purchase a box with lots of notes that you never use? It's a bit like haing a ferrari and never getting out of third gear!
-
my point, which I didn't make very well, is why purchase a box with lots of notes that you never use? It's a bit like haing a ferrari and never getting out of third gear!
This is how I view the D/G. There are a lot of extra buttons, that do nothing to add to the versatility of the instrument. One Row makes sense, one and a half row is more versatile, three Row'll do anything you want, but two row - I just don't get it. ???
-
I agree, pikey.
Although anyone using a big box, but not all of its capabilities, might say they brought it along because it's their main box, or they use it for other more complex tunes, or they're still learning, or they like its tone, or its colour, or whatever, they may not actually be showing off.
-
my point, which I didn't make very well, is why purchase a box with lots of notes that you never use? It's a bit like haing a ferrari and never getting out of third gear!
This is how I view the D/G. There are a lot of extra buttons, that do nothing to add to the versatility of the instrument. One Row makes sense, one and a half row is more versatile, three Row'll do anything you want, but two row - I just don't get it. ???
2 row is so you don't have to lug round 2 one rows ;)
-
2 row is so you don't have to lug round 2 one rows ;)
When I do a show I use only the D one row. I play in three major keys ( G,D,A) and sometimes use Em or Bm. True, there are some tunes which can't be forced onto the instrument, but with a potential repertoire extending into many thousands of reels, jigs and hornpipes I do not feel limited in any way. If I cant play a particular melody there are always a dozen more which will do the job just as well.
In the past I have struggled - loading the van with two or more melodeons (plus PA for those awkward keys), but over the last 10 years I've realised that it is not important. I play one instrument all night. People dance to the music and listen to the songs. They leave with a big smiles on their faces. IMO job well done. ;)
-
This is how I view the D/G. There are a lot of extra buttons, that do nothing to add to the versatility of the instrument. One Row makes sense, one and a half row is more versatile, three Row'll do anything you want, but two row - I just don't get it. ???
Assuming you're being serious, the answer is that a two row does add versatility. It's not just a question of being able to play in more keys - as you say, a one row can do that (up to a point). What a 2-row offers is greater range of chords, and extra buttons you're so dismissive of allow the option to play legato or not, as you choose and not as the instrument dictates. You concede that a one and a half row is more versatile, well a 2 row is even more versatile.
-
It's not just a matter of playing in different keys, whatever the key a diatonic instrument can only play music of a very limited chromatic nature, not the greater variety of melody and decoration available to a chromatic instrument. Don Worral's excellent ' History of the Anglo German Concertina' charts the demise of traditional music at the beginning of the 20th Century, a possibility of history being repeated ?
-
my point, which I didn't make very well, is why purchase a box with lots of notes that you never use? It's a bit like haing a ferrari and never getting out of third gear!
Ah right, I geddit now. I misunderstook your point. Yes, I agree, no point in having a box with lots of fancy features you don't use.
-
As someone whose main boxes are both D/G plus a row of accidentals and reversals (a Castagnari Benny and my self-built 'Ellis Pariselle' with 12 and 14 basses respectively), it makes perfect sense to me to play standard tunes like Jimmy Allen on these boxes without using accidentals, reversals or unusual basses. Such tunes fit nicely within the limitations of a D/G two-row or even a one-row box and showcase well the distinctive 'melodeonicity' of the instrument. However, the extra row and the additional basses provide a level of versatility that also enables one to play complex tunes in unusual keys.
One reason I have the accidentals, reversals and additional basses on my instruments is so that I can play tunes that would be difficult or impossible to play on a standard D/G box (e.g. French tunes in C, Gm and Dm). I don't want to carry around with me several boxes in different keys; it is much more convenient to carry one box that will play in all the keys I desire. This does not mean that I lose the punchy melodeon sound - merely that the fingering patterns to produce that sound in other keys are different from those we are familiar with in D and G. But there are some tunes that sound awful when played in a punchy in-out style (e.g. In Dreams from Lord of the Rings). Reversals help one to play smoothly when it is appropriate, but they do not dictate that you must play that way.
Reversals are also useful when it comes to playing grace notes. For example, some tunes I play sound nicer with E grace notes leading into D notes at certain points in the melody. Since these notes are always in the opposite direction on a D/G box, this is very difficult, but not if you have reversals on a third row, enabling you to flick the E a couple of milliseconds before hitting the D!
Additional basses can also provide a richer palette of sounds from which to select. Some tunes sound better with the standard eight basses, but others are enhanced enormously by employing non-standard basses. For instance, In Dreams, although played predominantly in D, sounds so much more ethereally beautiful with F, B flat and E flat basses at the appropriate places and Jump at the Sun, when played in Dm, is enriched substantially by playing G# basses to enhance the G#s in the melody in bars 1, 2, 5 and 6 of the A music.
One final point: there is an assumption in Owen's otherwise excellent blog and in some of the subsequent posts in this thread that three rows plus 12 or 14 basses automatically equates with excessive weight and size. My Benny and my Ellis Pariselle are both lightweight three-row boxes, one with 12 basses and the other with 14. Anyone who meets me in a session or at a festival is welcome to try them to verify how light and responsive they are.
-
What a 2-row offers is greater range of chords, and extra buttons you're so dismissive of allow the option to play legato or not, as you choose and not as the instrument dictates.
Chinese one row in C.
http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Fields_Of_Athenry_loungecore_remix.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Fields_Of_Athenry_loungecore_remix.mp3)
Not so much legato - more legatissimo!
-
One final point: there is an assumption in Owen's otherwise excellent blog and in some of the subsequent posts in this thread that three rows plus 12 or 14 basses automatically equates with excessive weight and size. My Benny and my Ellis Pariselle are both lightweight three-row boxes, one with 12 basses and the other with 14. Anyone who meets me in a session or at a festival is welcome to try them to verify how light and responsive they are.
There was a slight criticism of large, heavy, 3 row 18 bass boxes, but that wasn't meant as a criticism of 3 row 12-18 bass boxes because they are heavy! Personally I would love a Benny and I am aware of how light and responsive your box is.
-
... but two row - I just don't get it. ???
Two row G/C is exactly the right amount of versatility for me and the repertoire I play.
-
... but two row - I just don't get it. ???
Two row G/C is exactly the right amount of versatility for me and the repertoire I play.
I think the exchange, above, demonstrates really nicely that there is no objective standard for limitation, but rather a relationship between limitation/versatility, on the one hand, and the kind of music one envisions, on the other. I said "envisions" rather than "plays" because I think that once one imagines some aspect of music that is impossible on the system one plays, that will mark the point at which the system seems "limited." This can be as simple as that G# that I don't have on my D one-row, but it can become much more complex than that when one tries to decide whether to cope with the limitation by 1. not playing a given tune or 2. playing it with some change to accommodate the limitation or 3. to play it, on a different box... that one might not yet possess... hence MAD...
-
Chinese one row in C.
http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Fields_Of_Athenry_loungecore_remix.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Fields_Of_Athenry_loungecore_remix.mp3)
Not so much legato - more legatissimo!
Nicely played. However the effect of the changes of bellows direction is still audible - the notes are clearly articulated and start with a bit more attack. I suspect it would be even more noticeable with a faster tune. Nothing wrong with that, if that's an effect you want, but there are situations where something smoother, perhaps even slurring the notes together, might be wanted. The reversals on a 2-row allow you to avoid that - or not, as you choose.
-
Last time I looked on the shelf I seemed to have a 1 row 4 stop, a two row 8 bass, and a 3 row 18 bass. Each has its potentials like bashing out a shanty or a step dance on the one row, trying to imitate Stephane Delicq's amazing bellows control on the two row, and exploring chromatic Slavic gypsy music on the three row.
To me each one represents a different state of perfection in the evolution of the melodeon.
-
Firstly, thanks to ukebert for an interesting and thought provoking blog.
There have been a couple threads recently along similar lines and I find them very useful. Being a relative newbie, chalking up 2 years this Sidmouth, I've reached an interesting stage where I am wondering which direction to take my music and have I the tool for the job. Something adequate but not over tooled...... if you see what I mean :|bl
I think Nick's reply above sums up my rudimentary thoughts on it. At this time in my developement, I don't envisage playing Slavic gypsy music or complicated French/Continental tunes, so see no point in a 3 row monster box that I'd struggle to pick up.
I can see that a box with greater sound or bassier sound might tempt, but that's about it.
I think the limitations for me are imposed by the music I wish to play, essentially 'Wot Nick said' balanced against the most appropriate tool for the job. You can play simple tunes on a 3 row large box, but then suffer a penalty of humping round a large instrument that might have parts of it never played. Therefore in such circumstances a smaller 2r8b might be more apropriate.
Hmmmm ..... thanks for making me think!
Q
-
I may not have this quite straight, but I heard that Tufty Swift used to play a fully chromatic accordion (whether it was B/C/C#, CBA or PA I'm not sure) then moved to D/G melodeon, then finally settled on the one-row as his instrument of choice.
I've always had huge admiration for the way some folk musicians can get so much music out of instruments with so few notes, of which the Hungarian tilinko is possibly the ultimate - a whistle with NO finger holes (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYlB8pOb_5c) using only harmonics.
There must be a reason why the two row 8-bass melodeon is so popular though, and I think it's that it hits a sweet spot on the scale of complexity: it enables a huge range of tunes to be played with enough bass and harmony to be interesting. A fully chromatic box opens up a few more possibilities, but not in proportion to the extra weight and expense, while a one row has too many limitations and you certainly can't play everything on it.
Interesting to compare this discussion with the equivalent in the classical music world. Horns had no valves until around 1815, neither did trumpets until someone invented a valve trumpet and Haydn wrote a concerto to show off its capabilities. There's something undefinably earthy and exciting, though, about early music played with natural trumpets and horns where the players had to really struggle to get the notes.
-
Interesting to compare this discussion with the equivalent in the classical music world. Horns had no valves until around 1815, neither did trumpets until someone invented a valve trumpet and Haydn wrote a concerto to show off its capabilities. There's something undefinably earthy and exciting, though, about early music played with natural trumpets and horns where the players had to really struggle to get the notes.
Actually Hayden's concerto was written for a keyed trumpet, not a valved trumpet /pedant :P
-
There's something undefinably earthy and exciting, though, about early music played with natural trumpets and horns where the players had to really struggle to get the notes.
And the same applies to bands like Blowzabella who concentrate on drone based music, though they are more adventurous with playing outside a single scale. To my ear all the chromatic stuff they add works so well just because it increases the tension as at strains further from the drones and then gloriously falls back with a satisfying sense of pleasure and relief.
-
You can play simple tunes on a 3 row large box, but then suffer a penalty of humping round a large instrument that might have parts of it never played. Therefore in such circumstances a smaller 2r8b might be more appropriate.
I think Owen might have overstated the point -- and he admitted this -- by referring to 3x18 boxes as "enormous," but I certainly take your point. One of the things I'm curious about is how the the CBA became the standard instrument for rural French music and remained so until the 1970s. If you look at the AMTA web site, there's still quite a CBA presence in this area of music ... and it doesn't seem as if their music is overly chromaticized. Many of the tunes they play work wonderfully on the 2x8 box. So, historically, I am curious about the rise of the CBA in France in that era, and why it's history seems to run counter to the idea that more complex tech = more complex music.
-
Here's my take on this topic, with hat tip to Cyril Roche:
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/04/big-boxes-still-distinctively.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2012/04/big-boxes-still-distinctively.html)
-
If you look at the AMTA web site, there's still quite a CBA presence in this area of music ... and it doesn't seem as if their music is overly chromaticized.
This is really interesting -- I'd love to know whether the tunes are played in a range of keys that would be "too much" for the average 2 or 3 row diato player. (For instance, if a large chunk of the repertoire is in typical fiddle keys (A-D-G) and another group of tunes in flatted keys, so the CBA could "handle" it all, with one fingering pattern for all equivalent scales...)
-
Here's my take on this topic, with hat tip to Cyril Roche:
Which suggests an interesting experiment - would someone who has both a big 3-row and a light 2-row like to play the same tune, same fingering, on each, and record the results for us to hear? Although the tone of the sound would probably be very different, would the bounciness and attack sound different?
-
Here's my take on this topic, with hat tip to Cyril Roche:
Which suggests an interesting experiment - would someone who has both a big 3-row and a light 2-row like to play the same tune, same fingering, on each, and record the results for us to hear? Although the tone of the sound would probably be very different, would the bounciness and attack sound different?
I like this suggestion - could also c.p. one row with three row.
-
Here's my take on this topic, with hat tip to Cyril Roche:
Which suggests an interesting experiment - would someone who has both a big 3-row and a light 2-row like to play the same tune, same fingering, on each, and record the results for us to hear? Although the tone of the sound would probably be very different, would the bounciness and attack sound different?
Here are some I prepared earlier:
Bear dance on a very heavy Hohner Morino Club N:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3sRui8_Jza0
The same on a very light Dino Baffetti Binci Special
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=No9c-Hv7mlY
The Sloe on a heavy Hohner Ouverture
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6P2n9Oh-WQ
And the same on a 4-stop one row:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TN_pb7cd-eY
And then on the Dino:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLEY4Jy_Qyw
I find that it's easier to get bounce and attack from the smaller boxes. The large Hohners encourage you to play across the rows more, because it is so much harder work to change bellows direction!
;D
-
Thanks, pikey, and I understand your comments, but in terms of the overall effect I have to say that it's not clear - all your videos are great, but it does sound as if the Morino reeds are rather less responsive than the other boxes, which may be due to the capabilities of that particular box, rather than the general point about box heaviness - it sounds as if the reeds take some time to produce the sound, rather than you having any difficulty throwing it around, but I'm certainly open to persuasion.
-
And also, I have to say it seemed to me that the 1-row seems slower to get going on each note, on the Sloe, than does the Ouverture, which may be a responsiveness issue rather than one of weight, but what's your view?
-
But you've certainly shown me that the Dino is a bloomin' good box!
-
Two recordings:
http://libtrad.eu/mp3/test1.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/test1.mp3)
http://libtrad.eu/mp3/test2.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/test2.mp3)
Both made on the same day (2012-04-03T15:17:31) using the same mic (CAD u37 USB mic approx. 6ft away from instrument). Both accordions use the same LM voicing. Playing is limited to one row with only two chords used. I tried to keep the decorations and dynamics closely matched. One instrument is a light weight Chinese One Row the other is a much heavier Hohner Corona III N.
-
What do you think of this. Mike? It seems to me that the tones are quite different, but the transients are very similar. Personally, I preferred the bigger box in terms of tone quality, but there doesn't seem to be any noticeable lag caused by box weight.
-
What do you think of this. Mike? It seems to me that the tones are quite different, but the transients are very similar. Personally, I preferred the bigger box in terms of tone quality, but there doesn't seem to be any noticeable lag caused by box weight.
Agreed.
Listening to the two recordings I would say that the size of the Corona gives a more resonant tone. I'm not skilled enough to say whether this is the bellows space, soundboard, reed blocks, or some other factor. I will say though that playing the bigger box as a single row is a bugger of a job. Whilst I'm happy to play across the rows 'til the cows come home, all that pumping in and out really takes it out of your forearm and biceps. :Ph
-
And also, I have to say it seemed to me that the 1-row seems slower to get going on each note, on the Sloe, than does the Ouverture, which may be a responsiveness issue rather than one of weight, but what's your view?
That's a good point, I don't notice when I'm actually playing, but you're right - the Dino reed and button response is very fast, the Ouverture/Morino a bit slower, and the 4-stop slower still! I suppose it's to do with the size and number of the reeds that need to get going.
The Hohner Clubs do feel very heavy though, which encourages you to use the Club system and avoid bellows changes, which the Club system does very well when used properly.
The Dino Binci Special (one of the few prototypes where the lower end reeds were swapped/tweaked to make them less dominant), is the most responsive box I've ever played - I'd even say better than most Castagnaris. I'm finding myself playing Irish reels in sessions that I could never manage to play before! ;D
If you want to see the limitations of a Dino Binci and a Sandpiper D/G stretched to the max, look out Tim Edeys youtube videos that he did for the Music Room. Simply awesome!
-
The Dino reed and button response is very fast, the Ouverture/Morino a bit slower, and the 4-stop slower still! I suppose it's to do with the size and number of the reeds that need to get going.
The type/make of reeds too. My Castagnari Max (1 row 4 stop) is much more responsive than my Hohner 1 row 4 stop.
-
The Dino reed and button response is very fast, the Ouverture/Morino a bit slower, and the 4-stop slower still! I suppose it's to do with the size and number of the reeds that need to get going.
The type/make of reeds too. My Castagnari Max (1 row 4 stop) is much more responsive than my Hohner 1 row 4 stop.
It also costs at least three times as much (:)
Steve
-
It's great that people have taken the time and effort to record and post stuff which really adds to the debate. It's always great to hear nicely played tunes too.
Might I also mention the playing of John Kirkpatrick - on his album from the early 80s 'Three in a Row', the final track is played on a pokerwork, then hohner one-row then stradella bass three-row (Find The Lady, I think). Obviously it's not played exactly the same on each box in the way that Mike did above, but it does show the potential (and so perhaps by extension, limitations) of the different boxes. That all three versions sound great just goes to show that the main factor in all of this, as we all know, is the person playing the box, not the box. This could then lead on to questions about how good a melodeon do people actually need... but that's a different debate for a different thread.
-
I don't know if my own experiences add anything to this debate: I have two boxes that I mainly use, both 14 bass Saltarelles, but of slightly different sizes and designs. My brown one is 'Dinoesque', lighter, punchier sound, and more responsive. My orange one is much sweeter in tone, a more balanced sound between bass and treble, slightly heavier, but the reeds are significantly less responsive, and seem to be of a different type. I've found I tend to rehearse using the orange one, and then play the brown one live at dances, because it seems to work best that way. I can't hear the difference in responsiveness between the two if I record them, but the difference is that when I pick up the brown one, it's not so much the sound, it's the fact that it's noticeably easier to play, because of the greater attack - therefore I get a buzz from its responsiveness, because 'it just plays itself'!
I've not really thought this through before, but my suggestion is that what we tend to do is to learn the sound of our own boxes, and without realising it we compensate for any lack of responsiveness by playing the notes a fraction of a second earlier. This probably takes a certain amount of effort to do, and that can come out in terms of slightly uneven rhythm and imprecise sound, but the surprising thing is how much we can learn to compensate. I suppose I'm saying that we must learn by listening to the sound, rather than by thinking, 'I must hit that button .... now!'
I have a slightly analogous situation from playing the bass guitar, which I've done for many years. Because I like a low sound which doesn't interfere much with the sound frequencies being played by the rest of the band, I've until recently always played with the pads of my fingers. (Never liked a plectrum on bass, just not varied enough playing volume for me.) Because that involves a slight delay in producing the attack of each note as the fingertip pad pulls the string, I think I compensated by playing each note a fraction of a second earlier. However in the last few years, because I needed to improve the precision of my rhythm in a band with no percussion, I've changed to using my fingernails, cutting the treble, and this gives noticeably sharper attack to each note, and now that I've got the technique of playing more gently but with greater volume, I've realised it sounds cleaner and more precise overall, but mainly, it's easier.
So going back to the question of box weight, I think there are various reasons why it's not quite such a problem in the long run as people imagine when they first pick a heavy box up. Reed responsiveness is the main factor, and we do actually learn our way round the difficulties, I now think to quite a large extent. I don't have particularly beefy arms, but I don't really find I ever get worn out from throwing the box around, any tiredness comes from concentrating on tight rhythmic playing all evening.
-
tiredness comes from concentrating on tight rhythmic playing
Very true. When I go busking I never take a break. One tune often flows into another if I stop between tunes it is rarely for more than 30secs. Tunes are never repeated. I can keep this going for 4 hrs max. At the end of that time I am mentally drained. The fingers still work, but the brain is somewhere else. I can't remember tunes, I forget what I'm playing and ultimately the money dries up.
what we tend to do is to learn the sound of our own boxes
This too is true. When asked which is my favourite accordion, the honest answer is always the one in my hand. Often when I take out a box I have not played for some time I am surprised at how good it sounds. I'll play that instrument for four or five months. Milking it for every last nuance, enjoying it's quirks and avoiding the weaknesses. Then one day I'll discover a new ''old friend'. With each different instrument there is an adjustment. We articulate the same melody in very different ways when playing different boxes.
I recall making the switch from G one row to C. I couldn't get over the way it changed my playing. Similarly the switch from C to D brings out different qualities. This is not related to size, weight, reeds, repeat buttons, or accidentals. It's purely about the sound.
-
Well put Mike!
-
I recall making the switch from G one row to C. I couldn't get over the way it changed my playing. Similarly the switch from C to D brings out different qualities. This is not related to size, weight, reeds, repeat buttons, or accidentals. It's purely about the sound.
Actually, it seems that we tend to play different tunes with different boxes!
Or, should I say, the box tells you which tunes to play...
-
I recall making the switch from G one row to C. I couldn't get over the way it changed my playing. Similarly the switch from C to D brings out different qualities. This is not related to size, weight, reeds, repeat buttons, or accidentals. It's purely about the sound.
Actually, it seems that we tend to play different tunes with different boxes!
Or, should I say, the box tells you which tunes to play...
Great quote - I have tunes that the 1 row 4-stop likes, but the big Hohner clubs hate, and vice-versa. (Clubs like tunes you can play with no change of bellows direction)
The Dino Bafetti Binci special wins hands down though -it loves the 1 row tunes played on one row, and it loves tunes with the run of notes using the same bellows direction crossing rows too!
Which leads me to think that the limitations of a melodeon are really down to the following:
- quality of reeds : how fast can they speak
- quality of reed valves - how fast can they respond, to make a reed sound, or close when you change bellows direction
- weight of the left hand end : how fast can you change bellows direction
- quality of reeds and valves and how airtight the box is: how much air you need to get it going
- keyboard action - how fast can you get the reeds to speak, and how fast does the button come back up again,and how far down do you need to press it
- keyboard layout - does it suit your hand and your fingers?
and last, but definitely not least, your own capability to explore the limitations of your chosen beast, and selecting tunes and styles that suit what it is good at playing ;D
-
If you want to play out though Pikey, there is another point to consider - "What key is everybody else playing?". This is why my "C" boxes seldom leave the house. :'(
-
If you want to play out though Pikey, there is another point to consider - "What key is everybody else playing?". This is why my "C" boxes seldom leave the house. :'(
To qoute from Tufty Swift's seminal "Hints On Playing One Row Melodeon" (pub. Jack Youngers, Belper; 1980).
"To play in a country dance band will probably put you under pressure to get melodeons in D and G to make it convenient to play with others used to playing in those keys. Do so if you wish, but most instruments can accommodate C very well - particularly Concertina, Banjo, Dulcimer and all Brass instruments."
-
If you want to play out though Pikey, there is another point to consider - "What key is everybody else playing?". This is why my "C" boxes seldom leave the house. :'(
let's both bring our c boxes out at the same time, and start a trend!
-
Getting back to limitations, here is a superb example of a complex tune played on a standard 2-row, really showing what you can do with a 2 row box.
Enjoy! (and look at her other Youtube videos, it's made me think again about what you can play a 2 row)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OMGzgRx6ow&feature=g-vrec&context=G249b953RVAAAAAAAADg
-
Getting back to limitations, here is a superb example of a complex tune played on a standard 2-row, really showing what you can do with a 2 row box.
Enjoy! (and look at her other Youtube videos, it's made me think again about what you can play a 2 row)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OMGzgRx6ow&feature=g-vrec&context=G249b953RVAAAAAAAADg
Quick transcription of the above.
X:1
T:Le Revenant
C:Trad.
R:Valse
S:http://youtu.be/4OMGzgRx6ow
Z:Mike Hirst 2012-04-05T09:14:35
M:3/4
L:1/8
Q:1/4=180
K:C
|: "Am"e4 e2 | "F"f2 e2 d2 | "Am"c4 c2 | "Dm"d2 c2 B2 | "Am"A4 A2 |
[1 "G"B2 c2 d2 | "C"e6 | "Em"d6 :|[2 "G"B2 c2 B2 | "Am"A6 |AB c2 d2 ||
|: "Am" eA ce ce | "F"fe df ed | "Am"cE Ac Ac |"Dm"dc Bd cB |
"Am"A2 EA EA |[1 "G"B2 c2 d2 | "C"ec Ge cG | "Em"dB Gd BG :| [2 "G"B2 c2 B2 | "Am"A6 | AB cd ef |]
-
Enjoy! (and look at her other Youtube videos, it's made me think again about what you can play a 2 row)
And what nice music can come out of a Pokerwork, especially a G/C Pokerwork.
Also you must watch that one right to the end...
-
She is a superb player! I'm going to have to sit down and learn the tune......
-
Getting back to limitations, here is a superb example of a complex tune played on a standard 2-row, really showing what you can do with a 2 row box.
Enjoy! (and look at her other Youtube videos, it's made me think again about what you can play a 2 row)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OMGzgRx6ow&feature=g-vrec&context=G249b953RVAAAAAAAADg
She is GREAT! I first discovered this clip about a year ago and it has taken me that long to be able to play even a very simplified version of the tune. Who is she? I cannot believe that she is not well known.
-
I've just emailed her on Youtube to ask her if she wants to join us on Melnet ;D
-
Who is she? I cannot believe that she is not well known.
She appears to be Claire Pinet (https://profiles.google.com/clai.pinet/about)
-
I've just emailed her on Youtube to ask her if she wants to join us on Melnet ;D
I subscribed to her channel a couple of years ago and have waited in vain ever since for something new from this great player, I wish you well with your invitation but I suspect she's moved on to something else which is a great loss to diatonic squeezers everywhere.